Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
I mp l e me n t i n g t h e c a r e e r
management system was one of the
main challenges in terms of hierarchy.
Tradi ti onal l y, the Chi nese vi ewed
f unct i onal depar t ment s as mor e
important than supporting functions such
as IT and personnel. Thus, some functional
managers insisted, I have the say about
where my people go, and it was difficult
for them to listen to a third party-the
career manager-who was not their direct
boss. Jugier commented:
Chinese employees respect functional
managers a lot. They think that
personnel people are closer to the
general manager and feel that the
career manager is another guy
watching them.
Jugier hoped that employees would
be happy to find someone other than
their direct boss to discuss their career
opt i ons wi t h. However , Chi nes e
employees did not quite see it in this light.
Finding qualified career managers in
Chi na was anot her chal l enge,
according to Jugier:
Career managers must have the
necessary character and competence to
do the job. They have to discuss with
managers and convince them. That's
why most career managers are from
business functions. We should do the
same in China. We have to develop
competent career managers and
recruiters here. We are here to develop
people and enable them to take more
important positions and make more
contributions. It is one of my tasks.
We have many positions to fill in
China and we need people from other
countries. We are in the starting stage.
THE IMPORTANCE OF FACE
The Chinese placed much significance
on the concept of face. They went to
great lengths to avoid calling attention
to errors, indiscretions or emotions that
would cause themselves or others to lose
face, particularly in front of other people.
Good relationships were maintained by
conflict avoidance and helping each
other to save face. Causing other people
to l ose f ace coul d be seen as a
chal l enge to thei r posi ti on i n the
hierarchy, which could threaten group
harmony and the social order.
In keeping with the value of face,
Chinese businesspeople tended not to
be confrontational. They would not point
out a mistake for fear of causing loss of
face. It was also considered disrespectful
for a junior person to interrupt or correct
a senior. A testing engineer in Michelin
reported that some of his colleagues
were not happy with the management
style of an expatriate manager who
provi ded them wi th the di rect and
instantaneous feedback, causing many
peopl e to l ose face, wi thout the
expatriate even realizing it.
GUANXI
There is no exact translation for the
Chinese concept of guanxi-a mutually
beneficial relationship providing an
ongoing link between individuals-which
CAREER MANAGEMENT PROCEDURE Exhibit 4
Business Plan
Company, entity, department, team
objectives
Activity objectives Progress Objectives
INDIVIDUAL OBJECTIVES
Personal Development Objectives
Execute Plan Coaching
Analyze Results
Annual Performance Review
32
THELINK 2005 Fall
CASESTUDY
was the foundation on which most things
were built in China. One person would
do a f avor f or another , wi th the
expectati on that the person bei ng
helped would provide some type of
unspecified future assistance in return.
Such relationships might exist between
neighbors, with the clerk in a local store,
with government officials or with business
associates. Expatriate managers often
spent less time cultivating personal
relationships, and from the Chinese point
of view, such inadequate attention to
managi ng per sonal r el at i onshi ps
undermined managerial effectiveness.
Jugier explained:
We had to make employees learn the
way we approach our business and
understand Michelin. Chinese people
emphasized guanxi rather than
teamwork. We had to teach them how
to work together in an organization.
Many employees could not even
understand why it was necessary to
sign a new labor contract with SMW.
COMMUNICATION AND
DECISION STYLES
The Chinese had a high-context and
non-verbal style of communication. It
was high context in the sense that certain
knowledge was already assumed, as
opposed to a low-context culture, where
more information was exchanged during
each communi cati on. Non-verbal
communi cati on i ncl uded i mpl i ed
meanings, non-verbal cues, indirect
statements and symbolic language. In
addition, the Chinese were comfortable
with silences or pauses in conversation.
The i ndi r ect nat ur e of Chi nese
communication came from a long history
of cl ose fami l i es and i nterpersonal
r el at i ons . I t as s umed a s har ed
understanding between communicants.
For instance, Chinese businesspeople
would rarely say no directly in response
to a suggestion. Instead they would often
propose that the matter be studied
further. Similarly, open-ended questions
were common, avoiding the possibility of
forci ng someone i nto a cor ner by
requiring a yes or no answer. Rather
than valuing directness, the Chinese
were more likely to be polite but vague.
Michelin's management placed more
emphasis on processes and structures,
allowing people to delegate more.
Chinese managers were concerned that
the rigid structure was an obstacle to
speed in the decision-making process.
Mi chel i n r equi r ed them to fol l ow
procedures to solve problems in a step-by-
step manner as opposed to finding short
cuts and quick fixes to solve problems.
PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT
In China, being technically solid was a
prerequi si te i n order to become a
manager. Wi thout sound techni cal
knowledge and skills, it was difficult to
earn respect from staff. Interpersonal skills
in the managerial selection process
played a secondary role in China.
Expatriates at Michelin noticed that the
individual qualities of some of the Chinese
staff were excellent. However, they often
l acked t he expect ed t eamwor k
capabi l i ty and responsi bi l i ty i n the
decision-making process. The Chinese
education system placed far greater
emphasis on testing individual technical
skills than on leadership and teamwork.
Because of the fast growth in foreign
direct investment in China, companies
were competing for talents, and talent
retention and development were major
issues. The lack of management talent in
China was often referred as famine in the
midst of abundance. People who had
managed to acquire good management
skills were in short supply, which led to salary
escalation, high staff turnover and less
commitment from the company to invest
in training and development. Chinese
managers at Michelin were frequently
approached by headhunters or other
companies. Retention of experienced
l ocal managers was al ways a key
challenge for multinational companies in
China, and Michelin was no exception.
SUMMARY
These cultural differences created the
need to stri ke a bal ance between
seemingly opposing values. To Jugier it
seemed a daunting task. Indeed, cultural
differences could significantly affect the
common set of Mi chel i n' s val ues
wor l dwi de. Wi t h s ome 125, 000
empl oyees around the worl d, the
company had always tried to ensure
cons i s t ent under s t andi ng of i t s
management pri nci pl es, and these
common principles had to be shared by
its employees in China. THELINKS