Sr No A)

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

ELECTRICAL
30mA ELCBs are preferred normally in locations like Spa where human body is wet and body resistance is very low. However in dry condition human body resistance is about 20 M-Ohm and as general practice 100 mA ELCB is I ) Instead of 100 mA sensitivity for ELCB it will be 30 mA for all prefered in event to restrict the malfunctioning of ELCB sub-circuits. due to small leakage current. ii ) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Noted. The same Drawings Will be incorporated in As Built

Electrical Service General Notes & Legend Drawing No. E-400 [5]

Lighting Layout i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings

Will be incorporated in As Built

a)

Drawing No. E-401 [5]- Basement Level. Lighting layout

b)

Drawing No. E-402 [5]- Level Ground Lighting Layout

i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings

Will be incorporated in As Built

c)

Drawing No. E-403 [5]- Level-1 Lighting Layout

i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings

Will be incorporated in As Built

d)

Drawing No. E-404 [5]- Level-2 Lighting

i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings

Will be incorporated in As Built

Page 1 of 20

Sr No

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

e)

Drawing No. E-405 [5]- Typical Level-3, 4, 6 & 8 Lighting Layout

i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings

Will be incorporated in As Built

f)

Drawing No. E-406 [5]- Typical Level 5, 13 & 21 Lighting Layout

i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings i) In legend the layers for emergency lighting and normal lights are shown as different but in layout all lights are in same layer. ii) The quantity will be strictly as per layout. Noted. The same iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. Drawings

Will be incorporated in As Built

Will be incorporated in As Built

g)

Drawing No. E-407 [5]- Typical Level 9, 17 & 25 Lighting Layout

Will be incorporated in As Built

h)

Drawing No. E-408 [5]- Typical Level 27 & 28

Will be incorporated in As Built

i)

Drawing No. E-409 [5]- Roof Level Lighting Layout

Will be incorporated in As Built

j)

Drawing No. E-410 [5]- Machine Room Lighting Layout

Page 2 of 20

Sr No 3 Power Layout

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

a)

Drawing No. E-413 [5]- Basement Level Power Layout

i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray and bus duct used should be as per technical i) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings specification & BOQ. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray, bus duct & GI trunking used should be as per technical specification & BOQ i) & iii) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. ii) Noted & Confirmed. i) Title block and legends are missing. ii) Cable tray, bus duct & GI trunking used should be as per technical specification & BOQ i) & iii) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. ii) Noted & Confirmed.

b)

Drawing No. E-414 [5]- Level Ground Power Layout

c)

Drawing No. E-415 [5]- Level-1 Power Layout

d)

Drawing No. E-416 [5]- Level-2 Power Layout

e)

Drawing No. E-417 [5]- Typical Level-3, 4, 6 & 8 Power Layout

f)

Drawing No. E-418 [5]- Typical Level-5, 13 & 21 Power Layout

g)

Drawing No. E-419 [5]- Typical Level-9, 17 & 25 Power Layout

h)

Drawing No. E-420 [5]- Typical Level-27 & 28 Power Layout

i)

Drawing No. E-421 [5]- Roof Level Power Layout

j)

Drawing No. E-422 [5]- Machine Room Power Layout

k)

Drawing No. E-423 [5]- Level Upper Roof Power Layout

Page 3 of 20

Sr No 4 Single Line Diagram

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

a)

Drawing No. E-440 [4]- Single Line Diagram (Sh 1 of 5)

i) Breaker selected one size higher as it was coming nearer to the rating suggested. However the limiting settings will be carried out accordingly at site. i) Capacitor breaker seems to be on higher side. 630 A breaker is Ii) Please note that the supplied cable is as per IS 7098 sufficient. I & II only. Test Certificates of the same can be ii) Types of cables not as per IS standards. provided if require any time. iii) Voltage drop should be provided. iii) Attached as ready reference iv) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. iv) Noted. Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings i) Please note that the supplied cable is as per IS 7098 I & II only. Test Certificates of the same can be provided if require any time. ii) Attached as ready reference iii) Noted. Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings i) Breaker selected one size higher as it was coming nearer to the rating suggested. However the limiting settings will be carried out accordingly at site. Ii) Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawings iii) Attached as ready reference iv) Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawings

b)

Drawing No. E-441 [3]- Single Line Diagram (Sh 2 of 5)

i) Types of cables not as per IS standards. ii) Voltage drop should be provided. iii) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout.

c)

Drawing No. E-442 [4]- Single Line Diagram (Sh 3 of 5)

i) Some breaker rating seems to be on higher side. ii) Also mention M.D. along with CL iii) Voltage drop to be provided for selected cables. iv) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout. i) In SMDB-UR instead of 300 mA the sensitivity will be set at 100 mA for ELBC ii) Also mention MD along with CL. iii) Voltage drop to be provided of the selected cables. iv) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout

d)

Drawing No. E-443 [4]- Single Line Diagram (Sh 4 of 5)

i) Noted. Ii) Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawings iii) Attached as ready reference iv) Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawings. i) Breaker selected one size higher as it was coming nearer to the rating suggested. However the limiting settings will be carried out accordingly at site. Ii) Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawings iii) Attached as ready reference iv) Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawings

e)

Drawing No. E-444 [4]- Single Line Diagram (Sh 5 of 5)

i) Some breaker rating seems to be on higher side. ii) Also mention M.D. along with CL iii) Voltage drop to be provided for selected cables. iv) Title block is missing and drawing is not set in proper layout.

Page 4 of 20

Sr No

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

B
1.0 a)

Plumbing Works Water Supply

Drawing No. P-415 (5) Basement water supply a) PPR pipes are used . 20 mm is the least size available with ID as 13.2 mm Above Pipes suffice design a) 20 mm dia pipe size is considered for single tap instead of 15 requirement mm dia. Water supply pipe sizes are over sized. Revise the water b) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load motioned in NBC c) Will be incorporated in AS Built Drawings b) Levels of the water supply pipes are not mentioned in the drawing. c) Levels of the AV, AV for urinal, ST etc. are not mentioned on the drawing only the bib tap and wash basin connection detail are provided on the general notes details and legend water supply drawing. a) PPR pipes are used . 20 mm is the least size available with ID as 13.2 mm Above Pipes suffice design a) 20 mm dia pipe size is considered for single tap instead of 15 requirement mm dia. Water supply pipe sizes are over sized. Revise the water b) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load motioned in NBC c) Will be incorporated in AS Built Drawings b) Levels of the water supply pipes are not mentioned in the drawing. c) Levels of the AV, AV for urinal, ST etc. are not mentioned on the drawing only the bib tap and wash basin connection detail are provided on the general notes details and legend water supply drawing. a) PPR pipes are used . 20 mm is the least size available with ID as 13.2 mm Above Pipes suffice design a) 20 mm dia pipe size is considered for single tap instead of 15 requirement mm dia. Water supply pipe sizes are over sized. Revise the water b) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load motioned in NBC c) Will be incorporated in AS Built Drawings b) Levels of the water supply pipes are not mentioned in the drawing. c) Levels of the AV, AV for urinal, ST etc. are not mentioned on the drawing only the bib tap and wash basin connection detail are provided on the general notes details and legend water supply drawing.

b)

Drawing No. P-416

c)

Drawing No. P-417

Page 5 of 20

Sr No d) Drawing No .P -418

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

a) PPR pipes are used . 20 mm is the least size available with ID as 13.2 mm Above Pipes suffice design a) 20 mm dia pipe size is considered for single tap instead of 15 requirement mm dia. Water supply pipe sizes are over sized. Revise the water b) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load motioned in NBC c) Will be incorporated in AS Built Drawings b) Levels of the water supply pipes are not mentioned in the drawing. c) Levels of the AV, AV for urinal, ST etc. are not mentioned on the drawing only the bib tap and wash basin connection detail are provided on the general notes details and legend water supply drawing. a) PPR pipes are used . 20 mm is the least size available with ID as 13.2 mm Above Pipes suffice design a) 20 mm dia pipe size is considered for single tap instead of 15 requirement mm dia. Water supply pipe sizes are over sized. Revise the water b) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load motioned in NBC c) Will be incorporated in AS Built Drawings b) Levels of the water supply pipes are not mentioned in the drawing. c) Levels of the AV, AV for urinal, ST etc. are not mentioned on the drawing only the bib tap and wash basin connection detail are provided on the general notes details and legend water supply drawing. a) PPR pipes are used . 20 mm is the least size available with ID as 13.2 mm Above Pipes suffice design a) 20 mm dia pipe size is considered for single tap instead of 15 requirement mm dia. Water supply pipe sizes are over sized. Revise the water b) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load motioned in NBC c) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings b) Levels of the water supply pipes are not mentioned in the d) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings drawing. c) Levels of the AV, AV for urinal, ST etc. are not mentioned on the drawing only the bib tap and wash basin connection detail are provided on the general notes details and legend water supply drawing. d) Level of PRV are not mentioned on the drawing.

e)

Drawing No. 419

f)

Drawing No. 420

Page 6 of 20

Sr No g) Drawing No. 421

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

a) PPR pipes are used . 20 mm is the least size available with ID as 13.2 mm Above Pipes suffice design a) 20 mm dia pipe size is considered for single tap instead of 15 requirement mm dia. Water supply pipe sizes are over sized. Revise the water b) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load motioned in NBC c) Will be incorporated in AS Built Drawings b) Levels of the water supply pipes are not mentioned in the drawing. c) Levels of the AV, AV for urinal, ST etc. are not mentioned on the drawing only the bib tap and wash basin connection detail are provided on the general notes details and legend water supply drawing. a) PPR pipes are used . 20 mm is the least size available with ID as 13.2 mm Above Pipes suffice design a) 20 mm dia pipe size is considered for single tap instead of 15 requirement mm dia. Water supply pipe sizes are over sized. Revise the water b) Will be incorporated in As Built Drawings supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load motioned in NBC c) Will be incorporated in AS Built Drawings b) Levels of the water supply pipes are not mentioned in the drawing. c) Levels of the AV, AV for urinal, ST etc. are not mentioned on the drawing only the bib tap and wash basin connection detail are provided on the general notes details and legend water supply drawing. Typical connection detail for the hydropneumatic system are not shown on the drawing. will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Pipe support detail is not mentioned on the drawing. will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Fire tank is isolated and hence the water in the overhead fire tank would become stangnants. Overflow arrangement from the fire tank to domestic tank should be provided to maintained circulation of water connection in the fire overhead tank. Domestic water filling line from the basement should be connected in the fire tank whereas domestic tank shall Noted & necessary arrangements will be made as per be filled from the overflow from the fire tank. requirement

h)

Drawing No. 422

i)

Drawing No. P-423

Page 7 of 20

Sr No j) Drawing No. P-425

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

a) Design calculation of Fixture Unit Load will be submitted a) Revise the water supply pipe sizes as per the fixture unit load b) Noted & necessary arrangements will be made as per mentioned in the NBC. Considered pipe sizes are oversized. requirement. b) As per the schematic, the fire overhead tank and domestic overhead are filled through separate inlet. There is no connection between fire and domestic to maintain the circulation of water in fire tank. Fire tank water shall be used only in case of fire otherwise fire water would be stagnant. So we recommend to provide inlet connection to the fire tank only and the domestic overhead tank would get its supply from the overflow of the fire tank. In this way circulation of water can be maintained in the fire tank. Same scheme should be considered for overhead storage tanks as considered for fire and domestic underground storage tank. Invert level at the pipes connection FD, FT and FCO are not mentioned on the drawing. Invert levels are to be marked on the drawings. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Typical sections are to be developed to clear the invert levels of the pipe at pipe crossing, FT, FD etc. Invert level are to be marked at each connection of FT, FD, CO and pipe bends & connections. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Typical sections are to be developed to clear the invert levels of the pipe at pipe crossing, FT, FD etc. Invert level are to be marked at each connection of FT, FD, CO and pipe bends & connections. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Invert level at the pipes connection FD, FT and FCO are not mentioned on the drawing. Invert levels are to be marked on the drawings. BOP of each pipe are not marked on the drawing. It has to be marked on all pipes running at ceiling level. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Typical sections are to be developed to clear the invert levels of the pipe at pipe crossing, FT, FD etc. Invert level are to be marked at each connection of FT, FD, CO and pipe bends & connections. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Typical sections are to be developed to clear the invert levels of the pipe at pipe crossing, FT, FD etc. Invert level are to be marked at each connection of FT, FD, CO and pipe bends & connections. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing

Drawing No. P 403 k) Drawing No. P 404

l) Drawing No. P 405

m) Drawing No. P 406

n) Drawing No. P 407

o) Drawing No. P 408

p)

Page 8 of 20

Sr No Drawing No. P 409

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

q) Drawing No. P 410

Typical sections are to be developed to clear the invert levels of the pipe at pipe crossing, FT, FD etc. Invert level are to be marked at each connection of FT, FD, CO and pipe bends & connections. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Typical sections are to be developed to clear the invert levels of the pipe at pipe crossing, FT, FD etc. Invert level are to be marked at each connection of FT, FD, CO and pipe bends & connections. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Invert level at the pipes connection RWO, FT, and FD are not mentioned on the drawings. BOP and invert level are to be marked on the drawing Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Invert level at pipe connection FT & FD are to be marked on the drawing. BOP are not marked on the drawing BOP are to be marked on the drawing. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing Invert level at the pipe connection and RWO are not marked on the drawing BOP and invert levels are to marked on the drawing. Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing

r) Drawing No. P 411 s) Drawing No. P 412

t) Drawing No. P 413 u) Drawing No. P 414 v) C a) Fire Fighting Drawings Drawing No. M-418

Sizes of the sump vent pipe considered are oversized. It should be Noted. However, 100 Mm Pipe Dia also siffices the 65mm dia instead of 100 mm dia considered. Design requirement

i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing

Noted. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing.

b)

Drawing No. M-419

i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing i) & ii) will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Sprinklers are not shwon in the exit corridor (Grid-6). It has to iii) Sprinkler System is being provided as per Local Fire be sprinkled. Authority Requirement. i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing i) & ii) will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Sprinklers are not shwon in the exit corridor (Grid-6). It has to iii) Sprinkler System is being provided as per Local Fire be sprinkled. Authority Requirement. i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing i) & ii) will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Sprinklers are not shwon in the exit corridor (Grid-6). It has to iii) Sprinkler System is being provided as per Local Fire be sprinkled. Authority Requirement.

c)

Drawing No. M-420

d)

Drawing No. M-421

Page 9 of 20

Sr No

Description

Comments

Reply from ETA

e)

Drawing No. M-422

i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing i) & ii) will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Sprinklers are not shwon in the exit corridor (Grid-6). It has to iii) Sprinkler System is being provided as per Local Fire be sprinkled. Authority Requirement. i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing i) & ii) will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Sprinklers are not shwon in the exit corridor (Grid-6). It has to iii) Sprinkler System is being provided as per Local Fire be sprinkled. Authority Requirement. i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing i) & ii) will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Sprinklers are not shwon in the exit corridor (Grid-6). It has to iii) Sprinkler System is being provided as per Local Fire be sprinkled. Authority Requirement. i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing i) & ii) will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Sprinklers are not shwon in the exit corridor (Grid-6). It has to iii) Sprinkler System is being provided as per Local Fire be sprinkled. Authority Requirement. i) Levels of the fire pipes are not mentioned on the drawing. ii) Drop connection of fire pipe are not shown in the drawing i) & ii) will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Sprinklers are not shwon in the exit corridor (Grid-6). It has to iii) Sprinkler System is being provided as per Local Fire be sprinkled. Authority Requirement. i) Ecentric reducer should be used at fire pump suction. Replace the concentric reducer at the pump suction with ecentric. Noted & Confirmed ii) Orifice plates are not shown in the schematic drawing. It will be incorporated in As Built Drawing iii) Single headed hydrant valve are shown in the drawing. Double SHL are being provided as per Local Fire Authority headed hydrant valves shall be used as per NBC. requirements iv) Make up line from the overhead fire tank is connected to the sprinkler line. It has to be connected to both hydrant and sprinkler line. Noted & Confirmed v) Separate sprinkler and hydrant pumps are to used as per NBC. Common Pump is accepted by Local Fire Authority & Consider separate pump for sprinkler and hydrant system. hence the same is considered in our FF Design Sprinklers above False ceiling is not required as Distance is less than 800 mm between slab bottom & top of False Ceiling Shall be included in next submission

f)

Drawing No. M-424

g)

Drawing No. M-425

h)

Drawing No. M-426

i)

Drawing No. M-427

j)

Drawing No. M-428

k) l)

Drawing No. M-429 Drawing No. M-430

i) Details of sprinklers above false ceiling are not provided. i) Design criteria is not mentioned on the general notes.

Page 10 of 20