Está en la página 1de 52

Investment Strategy Group

A slow and fragile healing process to safeguard


Samy Chaar, PhD & Stephanie de Torquat Investment Strategy Group November 2013

Global leading economic indicator firming


Mid year economic soft patch is abating
Global economic conditions are improving, a sign that the risk of global recession is currently low.

GLOBAL LEADING ECONOMIC INDICATOR (PROXY FOR GLOBAL GROWTH)


OECD COUNTRIES PLUS 6 LARGEST NON MEMBERS, YOY%

Economy improving

Economy slowing

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Global manufacturing PMI improve


Developed markets firming, emerging markets less of a drag
PMIs are picking up implying little risk of contraction ahead, despite some regional divergences.

LEADING ECONOMIC INDICATORS - PMI


LEVEL (X-AXIS, CONTRACTING LINE IS 50) VS RATE OF CHANGE (Y-AXIS)
Bottoming Expansion

Contraction

Maturing

Note: DM in blue / GEMs in brown; Source: Bloomberg, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Global growth imbalanced


New normal equilibrium still prevails
Global growth still well below trend suggesting economies to reach escape velocity is premature. .

NOMINAL GROWTH CONSTITUENTS (INFLATION + REAL GDP GROWTH)


IN YOY % CHANGE

Note: DM in blue / GEMs in brown; Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Recovery set to remain mediocre and imbalanced


With weak employment growth over the long run
An impressive set of stimuli - Auto Bail-Out - Cash for Clunkers - Homebuyer Tax credit - TARP - Tax cuts - Extended unemployment benefits - Massive Fed balance sheet expansion (QEs, Operation Twist) for one of the slowest US recoveries ever!
Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation
Please see important information at the end of the document

US REAL GDP ANNUALIZED GROWTH


OVER THE 5 YEARS FOLLOWING THE END OF RECESSIONS, IN %

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Global imbalances adjusting


Deleveraging implies a reduction in the western deficit, and a turn to surplus, and a corresponding decline in the emerging surplus as EM growth models will evolve toward more domestic demand.

EMERGING VERSUS DEVELOPED ECONOMIES CURRENT ACCOUNTS


USD BN
Major Turning Point in 2008 Global Imbalances Global rebalancing

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Re-balancing global growth


The Emerging Market Growth Miracle is, in fact, a simple reflection of the willingness of the advanced countries to run deficits to provide the demand for emerging overinvestment: the gap between advanced and emerging country GDP growth is easily explained by the growth in western private sector leverage / current account deficits.

EMERGING MINUS ADVANCED ECONOMIES REAL GDP GROWTH (%Y/Y) VS ADVANCED ECONOMIES CURRENT ACCOUNT BALANCE (USD BN, 3Y MMA)

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Macro conclusions
A slow and gradual healing process, but not one without risks
! The global environment remains fragile. An escape route for the world economy lies ahead if, and only if, a number of conditions are met:
1.

Keep the cost of capital under control


Western economies are still burdened by unsustainable levels of total debts and deficits. The world is not yet ready to support higher rates - the US housing recovery also depends on contained mortgage rates

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

US Interest Rate Risk: the great divergence

1/2

Long-term rates close to fair-value, short term rates widely disconnected


Too rapidly rising LT yields would be unsustainable and detrimental to the economic and financial environment due to excess leverage. However, ST yields, especially when adjusted to QE3, are not consistent with low but stable inflation, and declining unemployment. .

US YIELD CURVE MATURITIES


IN %
Short-end of the yield curve is widely disconnected to fundamentals: relatively stable inflation (no deflation) and declining unemployment. No value distortion on the long-end of the yield curve. In line with sub-trend nominal growth and excess leverage.

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

US Housing
Rising rates starting to weigh on housing recovery
US NEW HOME SALES VS MORTGAGE RATES
RISING RATES TO WEIGHT ON HOUSING RECOVERY

US HOUSING STARTS VS MORTGAGE RATES


RISING RATES TO WEIGHT ON HOUSING RECOVERY

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

US Interest Rate Risk: the great divergence

2/2

Long-term rates close to fair-value, short term rates widely disconnected


FED FUNDS RATE VERSUS TAYLOR RULE
IN %
US Fed Funds disconnected from fundamentals especially when taking QE financed LSAP into account

US 10Y YIELDS VERSUS FAIR-VALUE


LEVEL IN % & TRAILING Z-SCORE

US 10Y close to fair-value

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Monetary involvement 101


Quantitative versus qualitative/credit easing
The debt burden is still too large to be only tackled by conventional measures such as austerity and growth policies. Monetary support remains the main workable tooI in the absence of debt restructuring and banking sector recapitalizations. However, Central Banks also need to be consistent with their mandates.

EXPANSION & DETERIORATION OF CENTRAL BANKS BALANCE SHEETS


SIZE & COMPOSITION OF THE FEDS BALANCE SHEET, IN USD BN
Others MBS UST and Fed agency debt QE2 (+600 bn) QE1 (+1400 bn) QE3 (+85 bn MBS & UST per mo) Operation Twist (400 bn)

QE3 Tapering starting Jan. 2014 (-10 bn/mo)

Shaded area: projection of Fed holdings

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Divergences in monetary activity to be reversed


Taper debate in the US versus low inflation in the Eurozone
The USD suffered while the EUR benefited from relative monetary policies. The gap should somewhat normalize starting early 2014 as EUR strength is undermining the Eurozone's competitiveness and pressing downward inflation figures.

EURUSD SPOT PRICE VS FED/ECB BALANCE SHEET RATIO


LEVELS

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

The ECB in a vicious cycle?


Contracting balance sheet leads to stronger EUR and accelerating disinflation
EUROZONE HEADLINE & CORE CONSUMER PRICE INFLATION - IN % ECB RATE VERSUS TAYLOR RULE
IN %
The ECB should be forced to reverse ongoing trends thanks to conventional (rate cut) and/or unorthodox (VLTRO) monetary policy tools EZ Inflation figures are very low when compared to official ECB target rate

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Macro conclusions
A slow and gradual healing process, but not one without risks
! The global environment remains fragile. An escape route for the world economy lies ahead if, and only if, a number of conditions are met:
1.

Keep the cost of capital under control


Western economies are still burdened by unsustainable levels of total debts and deficits. The world is not yet ready to support higher rates - the US housing recovery also depends on contained mortgage rates

2.

Stabilisation of fiscal deficits, not too high, not too low


especially in the US and Japan. Growing deficits (unrestrained addition of new debt) would be as counterproductive as rapidly shrinking deficits (public austerity during private deleveraging prevents any economic recovery)

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

US debt ceiling and budget balance


Remarkable but worrying - politically driven - improvement on the flow side
US TOTAL PUBLIC DEBT & STATUTORY LIMIT
IN USD MN; 53 INCREASE SINCE 1972

US GOVERNMENT SURPLUS/DEFICIT
AS % GDP; 18 GOV. SHUTDOWNS SINCE 1970S

Only 3 defaults in US history (1790, 1934, 1979). Only once because of a debt-limit crisis; the US accidentally defaulted on a small number of bills in 1979.

18 shutdowns since 1970s; Average length 6.5 days; Cost 0.1% GDP per week. - Oct. 31: USD 6 bn in interest on Treasury securities - Nov. 15: USD 29 bn in interest on Treasury securities

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Macro conclusions
A slow and gradual healing process, but not one without risks
! The global environment remains fragile. An escape route for the world economy lies ahead if, and only if, a number of conditions are met:
1.

Keep the cost of capital under control


Western economies are still burdened by unsustainable levels of total debts and deficits. The world is not yet ready to support higher rates - the US housing recovery also depends on contained mortgage rates

2.

Stabilisation of fiscal deficits, not too high, not too low


especially in the US and Japan. Growing deficits (unrestrained addition of new debt) would be as counterproductive as rapidly shrinking deficits (public austerity during private deleveraging prevents any economic recovery)

3.

Support the global rebalancing of emerging surpluses and western deficits


Western economies are gaining internal (declining ULC) and external (FX devaluation) competitiveness pushing emerging economies to change their growth model towards more consumption. Productive capacity in the West responding to EM demand should allow world growth to very gradually recover

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Looking to go onshore!
Fighting for a larger share of investment thanks to competitive gains
REAL EFFECTIVE EXCHANGE RATE
LOCAL CURRENCY, INDEXED TO Q111 = 100

TOTAL ECONOMY UNIT LABOR COSTS


LOCAL CURRENCY, INDEXED TO Q208 = 100
China; 50%

UK.; 16% Ger.;11% EZ; 8% US.; 4% Port.; -3% Spain; -6% Japan; -7% Ireland; -11%

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Looking to go onshore: Is the competitive story working?


Fighting for a larger share of investment thanks to competitive gains
TOTAL ECONOMY UNIT LABOR COSTS
LOCAL CURRENCY, INDEXED TO Q208 = 100

FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT NET INFLOWS


AS % GDP

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Rebalancing Industrialization between emerging & developed markets


TOTAL FIXED INVESTMENT SHARE
AS % GDP

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

The Macro View


A slow and gradual healing process, but not one without risks
! Still a long way to normalcy for the world economy but giving the benefit of the doubt to a long and progressive journey to recovery.

Growth: Positive but below trend (adjusting from past excesses). Inflation: Low (little income growth, subdued aggregate demand and still ample supply). Interest Rate Risk: Keep cost of capital under control (Monetary support main workable tool) Fiscal Risk: Further deterioration endangers solvency whilst austerity jeopardizes growth. Competitive Risk: Support global rebalancing of emerging surpluses and western deficits.
Int. Rate Risk US Eurozone Japan Emerging (BRICs) Fiscal Risk Comp. Risk

! Following risks should be monitored to prevent a relapse:


1. 2. 3.

! Macro Risk Barometer:

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Eurozone recovery: fragile but encouraging

Interest rate risk: fiscal unsustainability in the periphery


Interest rates have normalized but adverse funding gap remains
10-YEAR GOVERNMENT BOND YIELDS
IN % 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 12/07 05/08 10/08 03/09 08/09 01/10 06/10 11/10 04/11 09/11 02/12 07/12 12/12 05/13 Portugal Italy Spain Ireland France Germany

REAL POTENTIAL GDP GROWTH VS. REAL GVT BOND YIELDS IN %


8.0 7.0 6.0 5.0 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0 -1.0 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014
Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation
Please see important information at the end of the document

Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Spain real long-term interest rates, GDP-weighted

PIIS real potential output growth, GDP-weighted

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Fiscal risk: too much austerity detrimental to the recovery


The pace of fiscal adjustments should be controlled
Even after the efforts of the last few years, many governments still need substantial fiscal swings However, as households are deleveraging, they cannot offset sharp cuts in government spending, creating potentially a negative impact on growth 2012 and 2013 show less fiscal pressure in the EZ than in the US

CHANGES IN GOVERNMENT BUDGET BALANCE


% GDP, ANNUAL DATA 7.0 6.0 5.0 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0 -1.0 -2.0 -3.0 US Spain UK Ireland France Italy Germany 2012 2013 2012 & 2013

Japan
-8.9 to -10.3

From Dec. 2011 to Dec. 2013:

-13.3 to -7.5

-10.2 to -5.4

-9.4 to -6.9

-5.3 to -4.0

-7.9 to -13.3 to -7.1 -7.5

-0.8 to -0.2

-4.4 to -6.4

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Portugal

Competitiveness risk: looking to go onshore !


Fighting for a larger share of investment thanks to competitive gains
REAL EFFECTIVE EXCHANGE RATE
LOCAL CURRENCY, INDEXED TO DEC 09= 100 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 12/09 03/10 06/10 09/10 12/10 03/11 06/11 09/11 12/11 03/12 06/12 09/12 12/12 03/13 06/13 09/13 Switzerland UK US Portugal Spain Italy France Germany Ireland Japan China

RELATIVE UNIT LABOR COSTS


LOCAL CURRENCY, INDEXED TO Q409 = 100 135 125 115 105 95 85 75 France Germany Portugal Italy US Ireland Japan Spain UK Q4 2009 Q1 2010 Q2 2010 Q3 2010 Q4 2010 Q1 2011 Q2 2011 Q3 2011 Q4 2011 Q1 2012 Q2 2012 Q3 2012 Q4 2012 Q1 2013 Q2 2013 Q3 2013 Q4 2013
Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation
Please see important information at the end of the document

China

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Fiscal risks in Spain & Italy: stock issues, flow improvements

Spanish private debt is still far too large


Private deleveraging is not over
Private sector debt is slightly down (NOT banks!), but the pace of deleveraging is muted, and debt remains too high. This will keep consumption " and growth " subpar The government has more than offset private deleveraging. Total debt has kept increasing as a result

DEBT BROKEN DOWN BY ECONOMIC AGENTS


% OF GDP 250 200 150 100 66 50 0 101 109 117 93 86 Q2 2010 (HH peak) Q4 2013 (projections) 197 176

Gross government Financial Household sector liabilities corporations debt liabilities

Non-financial corporations liabilities


Please see important information at the end of the document

Source: Oxford Economics (Q4 2013 projections), DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Fiscal dilemma
Deficit improving, but keeping this tightening pace would kill the recovery
Fiscal risk remains significant in Spain: the primary budget deficit is large at -4.0%, but if the government tightens too much, that could hinder the nascent recovery The good news is that lots of it is cyclical. On a cyclically adjusted basis, the government runs a primary surplus

GOVERNMENT BUDGET DEFICIT AND PRIMARY BALANCE*


% OF GDP 6.0 4.0 2.0 0.0 -2.0 -4.0 -6.0 -8.0 -10.0 -12.0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 -11.2 2008 2009 2010 -10.6 2012 2013
Please see important information at the end of the document

+0.2 -2.4 -4.0 -6.9

Primary balance, cyclically adjusted Budget deficit, cyclically adjusted Primary balance Budget deficit

*The government primary balance is the government net borrowing or net lending excluding interest payments on government liabilities. Source: OECD, DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

2011

Italys debt: a public issue


Italys private debt is smaller than that of Spain The issue in Italy is on the public side: with government debt topping 130% of GDP, the country is vulnerable to any rise in rates and the cost of servicing the debt is significant

DEBT BROKEN DOWN BY ECONOMIC AGENTS


% OF GDP, Q4 2013 (PROJECTIONS) 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Gross government Financial liabilities corporations debt Household sector liabilities Non-financial corporations liabilities
Please see important information at the end of the document

Spain

Italy

176

130 117 101 107 86 57 116

Source: Oxford Economics (Q4 2013 projections), DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

But the primary balance is in surplus


Contrarily to Spain, Italy runs a primary surplus, which helps limiting the growth in public debt But debt servicing alone adds -5.3% to the deficit !

GOVERNMENT BUDGET DEFICIT AND PRIMARY BALANCE*


% OF GDP, DASHED LINES ARE OECD PROJECTIONS 8.0 6.0 4.0 2.0 0.0 -2.0 -4.0 -6.0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 -2.3 2.9 Primary balance, cyclically adjusted Primary balance Budget deficit, cyclically adjusted Budget deficit

*The government primary balance is the government net borrowing or net lending excluding interest payments on government liabilities. Source: OECD, DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations
Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Household saving rate has collapsed


The margin of safety for the consumer is at historical lows
With incomes down, high unemployment, and balance sheets in need of repair, households have been using their savings to keep up consumption " but there is no cushion left The fact that consumption expenditures have started to decline in Q1 2012 is for the moment obsucred by recent government spending

HOUSEHOLD SECTOR NET SAVING RATE


% OF NET DISPOSABLE INCOME 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2012 2011 Spain Italy France

Germany

Source: DG ECFIN AMECO, DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations.

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Competitiveness risks in Spain & Italy: diverging trends

Remarkable improvements in Spain, Italy deteriorates


Spains export market share is growing
UNIT LABOR COSTS 2005 = 100
125 120 115 Germany 110 105 100 95 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2012 2013 2011 Spain Italy France

EXPORTS AS A % OF GDP
CHANGE SINCE 2009, IN %

16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0

14.3 11.7 8.4 6.9 3.9 3.4

Portugal Spain Germany Italy

France

UK

Source: OECD Economic Outlook, Eurostat, DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Better competitiveness helps spanish foreign direct investment


Whilst Italy does not attract foreign inflows
Competitiveness improvement in Spain, resp. deterioration in Italy, has led to higher spanish FDI, resp. lower italian FDI Maintaining/growing the ability to attract foreign investment, and gain exports market share is crucial to the recovery, and should be closely monitored

FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT


NET INFLOWS, % OF GDP 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2 Portugal Spain France UK Germany Italy Q2 2012 Change since 2009

Source: World Bank, DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Italys low competitiveness is the countrys achilles heel


But exports hold up for now
ULC VS. CPI-BASED COMPETITIVENESS
OECD COMPETITIVENESS INDICATORS 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 Q4 1999 Q4 2001 Q4 2003 Q4 2005 Q4 2007 Q4 2009 Q4 2011 Q4 2013

EXPORTS VS IMPORTS OF GOOD & SERVICES


% OF GDP 32 31 30 29 28 27 26 25 24 23 22

Exports

Italy - ULC Italy - CPI Germany - CPI Germany - ULC

Imports

Source: DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations, OECD

Q4 2000 Q3 2001 Q2 2002 Q1 2003 Q4 2003 Q3 2004 Q2 2005 Q1 2006 Q4 2006 Q3 2007 Q2 2008 Q1 2009 Q4 2009 Q3 2010 Q2 2011 Q1 2012 Q4 2012
Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

The French conundrum: fiscal and interest rate risks are contained but fundamentals are poor and worsening

Debt stabilizing (at high levels)


But current account still deteriorating
TOTAL ECONOMY DEBT
% OF GDP, BREAKDOWN BY SECTOR, FRANCE 600 500 Financial 400 300 200 100 0 Q4 1995 Q4 1997 Q4 1999 Q4 2001 Q4 2003 Q4 2005 Q4 2007 Q4 2009 Q4 2011 Government corporations Households Non-financial corporations 0 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006 2010
Please see important information at the end of the document

BUDGET DEFICIT AND CURRENT ACCOUNT %


OF GDP, FRANCE 4 2

Primary balance Current account Budget deficit

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation, Oxford economics, OECD (2013 projections)

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

French yields spread with Germany at odd with current account


Unfair but sustained mispricing
CURRENT ACCOUNT VERSUS BOND YIELDS
FRANCE, ITALY & SPAIN DIFFERENTIAL WITH GERMANY 14.0 12.0 10.0 8.0 6.0 4.0 2.0 0.0 Q1 2002 Q1 2003 Q1 2004 Q1 2005 Q1 2006 Q1 2007 Q1 2008 Q1 2009 Q1 2010 Q1 2012 Q1 2013 Q1 2011 German MINUS Spain & Italy current account; Q3 2013 = 5.0% Spain & Italy vs. German 10-year yield spread; Q3 2013 = 2.6% French vs.German 10-year yield spread; Q3 2013 = 0.6% German MINUS French current account; Q3 2013 = 8.9% 14%

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation, OECD

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

French competitiveness risks prevail

Competitiveness eroded in absolute AND versus peers


UNIT LABOUR COSTS AND PRODUCTIVITY
FRANCE & GERMANY, INDICES 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 France productivity Germany ULC Germany productivity France ULC

UNIT LABOUR COSTS IN TOTAL ECONOMY


RECENT EVOLUTION 125 Italy 120 115 110 105 100 95 Q2 2005 Q2 2006 Q2 2007 Q2 2008 Q2 2009 Q2 2010 Q2 2012 Q2 2013 Q2 2011 France OECD total Germany Spain Ireland Greece

Source: INSEE, OECD

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

De-industrialization AND low industrialization


FRANCE VALUE-ADDED BY SECTOR
% OF TOTAL 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%

INDUSTRY SECTOR SHARE


IN TOTAL DOMESTIC ECONOMY VALUE ADDED, % 30 25.8 25 21.9 19.619.3 18.618.5 18.317.8 16.816.216.1 12.8

Services

20 15 10

Agriculture

Industry

5 0 Finland Sweden Spain Italy Belgium Austria Germany Portugal Netherlands

Q1 1980 Q1 1982 Q1 1984 Q1 1986 Q1 1988 Q1 1990 Q1 1992 Q1 1994 Q1 1996 Q1 1998 Q1 2000 Q1 2002 Q1 2004 Q1 2006 Q1 2008 Q1 2010 Q1 2012

Eurozone 17

Source: INSEE, Eurostat (May 2013)

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Denmark

France

France is one of the lowest industrialized countries in the world!


VALUE ADDED IN INDUSTRY, INCLUDING ENERGY
AS A PERCENTAGE OF TOTAL VALUE ADDED, OECD 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 LUX FRA GRC ESP GBR USA ISR BEL PRT DNK NLD NZL EA17 ITA AUS JPN ISL OECD CHE SWE TUR AUT FIN EST DEU SVN CAN POL SVK IRL MEX HUN ZAF RUS CZE KOR CHL NOR IDN CHN
Source: OECD
Please see important information at the end of the document

2010 or latest available year

2000

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Conclusion
Eurozone recovery fragile but encouraging
! Following risks should be monitored to prevent a relapse:
1. 2. 3.

Interest Rate Risk: Keep the cost of capital under control Fiscal Risk: A subtle fine-tuning in the pace of deficits reduction Competitive Risk: To support reindustrialization, exports and foreign direct investments

! Macro Risk Barometer:


Int. Rate Risk Eurozone Spain Italy France Fiscal Risk Comp. Risk

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Impact on asset classes

Pushed further along the return curve


Corporate risk (credit & equities) offers relative appeal
The early stages of QE were very successful in boosting credit & equity markets, owing to the wide implied real return differential between equities, credit, government bonds (TIPS) and cash. Within Equities favour Europe and EM over the US Within Bonds, favour the US and EM$ over EU debt

REAL IMPLIED RETURNS FOR CASH VS BONDS, CREDIT & EQUITIES


IN %

Source: DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations. See list of underlying indices by region in following slides of the document.

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Asset Classes Preferences

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Market drivers: Multiple expansion


MSCI WORLD : PRICE, EPS & PE RATIO
LEVELS

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Europe versus the US


Current levels of PMIs are already supportive of positive EPS growth. Earnings revisions will start to be really positive when PMIs reach 55 (EMU 51.1 in Sept., UK 56.7). The forward looking PMI components (new orders) look encouraging.

MSCI EMU YOY REPORTED EPS GROWTH VERSUS EMU PMI


%YOY 12M LAG & LEVEL

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Currencies

Strategically favour fundamentally strong FX (NOK, SEK, CHF); Some EM FX will benefit from the global rebalancing (MYR, CNY, KRW)
Strategically favour the fundamentally strong currencies (low debt levels, current account & public balance surpluses), such as the NOK, the SEK and the CHF. Some EM FX will benefit from the global rebalancing (i.e. the debasement of western currencies for competitive purposes); focus on quality (fiscally sound EM FX).

PROXY FOR FX QUALITY-ADJUSTED YIELDS*


CURRENT ACCOUNT DEFICIT (AS % GDP) & 12M REAL DEPOSIT RATES (IN %)

* Current account balance as a proxy for external assets / liabilities, Real rates as a proxy for the average return on capital. Source: DataStream, Lombard Odier calculations.

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Gold
Gold is a hedge against systemic risk; but systemic risk is abating
Gold has a strong correlation with CDS spreads on European peripherals. The narrowing in PIIS (ex-Greece) CDS spreads a sign of lower systemic risk successfully contained by central banks has been followed by much lower gold prices and reducing investment demand for hedging purposes

GOLD PRICES VERSUS GDP WEIGHTED AVERAGE OF 5 YEAR CDS SPREADS FOR PORTUGAL, SPAIN, IRELAND AND ITALY
2100 1900 1700 1500 1300 1100 900 700 01.08 03.08 06.08 09.08 12.08 03.09 06.09 09.09 12.09 03.10 06.10 09.10 12.10 03.12 05.12 08.12 02.13 05.13 08.13 02.14 05.14 08.14 03.11 06.11 09.11 12.11 11.12 11.13 11.14 GDP weighted average of 5y CDS for Portugal, Spain, Ireland and Italy (in bps)-> <- Gold price (in USD oz) July 26, 2012 Draghi speech believe me, it will be enough 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0

Source: Datastream, Lombard Odier calculation


Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Cross Asset Review


A balanced risk exposure with strong regional preferences
! Balanced positioning in terms of risk exposure with a medium term preference for equity risk over interest rate risk.

Looking to benefit from the important long term implied real return differential between equities, government bonds and cash.

! Within Equities favour Europe over the US, while Emerging markets are stabilising:

European markets could outperform thanks to a pick up in earnings growth following Eurozones exit from recession, especially against US equities which remain expensive and where equity investor sentiment is stretched. Emerging markets could benefit from a valuation discount as world growth is recovering.

! Within Bonds favor US and Emerging debt over core Europe (Germany):

US yields are now relatively attractive compared to its European pears. EM debt cheapest versus High Yield since 2005; price dynamics and flows have stabilised.

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

Please see important information at the end of the document

Investment Strategy ! October 2013 !

También podría gustarte