Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
ON
SUBMITTED TO:
Prof. S. Panda
SUBMITTED BY:
Roshan Kanoo (08DM076)
SL.
NO. HEADINGS PAGE NO.
1 Introduction 1
2 Terminologies 1
3 Project Objectives 1
5 Methodology 3
6 Analysis 3-6
9 Challenges 8
10 The Opportunities 8
11 Consumer Churn 9
1. BSNL.
2. Idea
3. Reliance
4. Vodafone
5. Aircel
6. Airtel
And that is why we say that the current telecom market is a matured one. When we say that this
market is matured one it basically implies that it has got two essential parameters
Now when a new telecom operator (player) wants to enter this kind of matured market he faces a
lot of challenges in grabbing the already held market share by the existing players. So with the help
of this project I tried to gather as much information and strategies which will help a new player to
enter this market and for that reason a detailed plan of action has been put forth.
TERMINOLOGIES:
• Evolved/matured market: Market penetration to the tune of 60% - 70% and
presence of multiple operators that is more than 6 -7 operators.
• Green field/land grab market: Comparatively a new market where the penetration is
only about 15% – 20%.
• Competition churn: Switch over of customer from one operator to another operator
due to competition and basically loss of clients and customer.
• ARPU: (Average revenue Per Unit), it is a measure used by customer communication
and net working companies. It is total revenue divided by number of subscribers.
• AVCV: Address verification and credit verification.
• COAI: Cellular Operators Association of India is the main telecom lobby group of
India.
• CUG: Closed User Group.
• VAS: Value Added Services.
PROJECT OBJECTIVE:
By this project what we are trying to find out are the challenges for a new player to establish itself in
the market and gain market share. The basic challenges it is likely to face are regarding:-
Segmentation
Target Customers
Positioning
Distribution channel
Marketing and sales strategy
Product and services
Pricing strategies
Value (creation, capturing and sustaining)
Customers(acquisition, satisfaction and retention)
There is 60%-70% market penetration already done by the existing players. Any sort of
penetration by a new player is pretty difficult, because majority of the market share is held
by existing players.
Another important feature of a matured market is the presence of multiple operators i.e. 8 to 9
players.
High industry standards or use of advance technology. Nowadays cutting edge advance
technologies are used by telecom operators which gives various advantages to the
subscribers as well as it is a source of additional revenue for the operators. Various value
added services (VAS) are being provided to the customers like MMS, E-Mail, GPRS, and 3G
etc.
A matured market is also classified by the fact that there are well established brands like
Vodafone, Airtel, BSNL, Idea, BPL, Reliance etc.
Moreover customers in a matured market are very literate, educated and smart. They know
the ins and outs of the various products being offered to them.
Consumers in a matured market are very cost sensitive also, as in a matured market there is
much competition, so every firm offers the best it can to the customers at the cheapest
possible terms as competition forces it to happen. So customers become more and more
price sensitive. As there is every possibility that a slightest of change will force the customers
to churn away or to switch over from one operator to another, as because they have lot of
options with them.
In a matured market, price war also prevails a matured market may be very price sensitive as
each operator tries to maintain the lowest price possible in order to attract the customers
and get a chunk of market share from the rivals. So a new player needs to play in the pricing
strategies as well.
In a matured telecom industry, there is much consumer churn also, which means as the
customer has got many options with him, he hardly remains loyal to any brand and there is
every possibility that he may shift from one operator to another whichever seems attractive.
So, these are the various conditions of a matured market, but any telecom operator who can control
the above mentioned conditions and forces can penetrate into a matured market. Whenever a
telecom operator tries to get new customers, there are basically two groups of customers to be
attracted. One is the new customers i.e. those who are graduating to a mobile like students entering
colleges. These are first time users .second group are the shifting customers i.e. those who are
planning to switch over from one operator to another i.e. by the way of customer churning. But it is
fact that it is very difficult to gain customers in a matured telecom market due to the penetration
already made by existing players of telecom industry.
Once the target customers are determined, the company can move ahead with
preparing their own strategic plans to enter the market.
METHODOLOGY:
For the purpose of the project, I have taken Orissa as the market place and the following
methodology is taken into account:-
STEP 1:
PEST ANALYSIS
STEP 2:
Before entering into a matured market, the vision should be very well established and what value
can the new entrant can introduce to the customers, and how it will be introducing it in the 4 p’ s
tactics.
Marketing strategies
STEP 3:
STEP 4:
ANALYSIS:
Now for the purpose of the project I took into account the PEST analysis, Porter’s five forces
analysis, Competitive SWOT analysis and Competitive Value Chain analysis and tried to find out as to
what are the challenges and opportunities lying ahead.
Political Environment:
Orissa is a politically stable state in India. Govt. of Orissa is also trying its level best to
invite various telecom companies to invest in the state. Cheap as well as professional labor is
available here.
Economic environment:
On an average, 4 % growth in the subscriber base every month. Total revenue growth
is also satisfactory.
Social Environment:
Out of the total population of Orissa, people between age group of 18-45 are about 30%.
A lot of demand is coming from rural area as 80 % of people live in rural area.
Growing middle class and youth with an increasing fascination and need for mobile.
Technological environment:
Growing awareness for advanced mobile technology and services like MMS, GPRS, 3G,
EDGE, Mobile TV and other VAS.
In the project, I have also tried to make use of the Porter’s five forces analysis which include three
forces from horizontal competition, i.e. threat of substitute products, threat of established rivals,
and threat of new entrants and two forces from vertical competition i.e. the bargaining power of
suppliers and bargaining power of customers.
BUSINESS ANALYSIS
We have tried to entail and enlist this analysis in our plan of action.
A new entrant should take into account the various strength and weakness, opportunity and threat
of itself and as well as that of competitor also. Now taking into account the market of Orissa it can
be said that the strength of Airtel is its network and billing, but its weakness is its tariff plan which
is not suitable to most user. Similarly if we take into account Reliance its weakness is its network
which is not at all reliable. For Vodafone its strength is its billing procedure and tariff plan. Again if
we take BSNL its strength is its network all over Orissa and in other states for those who frequently
use roaming but its weakness is its customer care and selling and distribution channel. Regarding
AIRCEL its weakness is its network in both home circle and in case of roaming also.
So a new entrant should thoroughly check what are its strength like-
-what are the new technologies that are in demand and the competitors are not able to
provide ?
With the help of value chain analysis a new entrant should analyse the competitive strength of the
business. To do this the activities of a business could be divided into two heads-
-primary activities
-support activities
PRIMARY ACTIVITIES
It relates to those activities which are associated with getting the finished goods and services to
buyers, informing buyers and consumers about the product and services its benefits ,price etc, and
essentially all those activities which are associated with maintaining product performance after the
product has been sold.
SUPPORT ACTIVITIES
These activities are not directly related to the production of services but these support activities
increase the effectiveness and efficiency of the primary activities such as the human resource
management. So value chain analysis help a new entrant to identify which activities are best
undertaken by a business and which are those activities which can be outsourced.
Now if the new entrant wish to go for differentiation then it will have to perform its value
chain activities better than the competitors, in contrast if the new entrant wants to achieve cost
leadership, then its required to reduce its cost associated with the value chain activities or in other
words a reduction in the total amount of resources used.
While moving ahead with the project all these analysis have been taken into account and an action
plan has been derived .
AIRTEL:
AIRCEL:
RELIANCE:
Male- 2911600
Female- 2605638
Male- 15748970
Female- 15538452
Orissa has a teledensity of 20.3% compared to the national average of over 35%.
A vast potential lies to tap this segment i.e.. Youth, students, urban middle class, low income earners
etc. keeping in view the demand of various segments. As such consumer need analysis has been
taken care in the plan of action.
CHALLENGES
Various researches indicates that first entrants are also market leaders in most markets Pioneers in
cellular service establish a presence in the marketplace, build brand equity and create an excellent
distribution network. Also, a peculiarity of this industry is that the quality of service is primarily
determined by coverage. Having evolved over time, the first entrant's network usually has much
better coverage. The customers become used to enhance coverage over time. So, new entrants have
to invest significantly to achieve this same coverage -- an effort that is capital intensive and time
consuming. All new networks have initial bugs that take time to fix. Subscribers are just not willing to
go through another learning curve, when there is already a robust supplier of service. Another
frequent constraint is access to property to build the towers, since the first entrants have already
seized the ideal sites for coverage. This, in turn, may require the later entrant to invest larger
amounts in network infrastructure to gain similar coverage.
In addition to coverage and related quality of service, another huge barrier to entry for new entrants
is the issue of number portability. Customers would have to get a new cellular number when they
switch carriers since they cannot take the same phone number with them as is done in land line
networks. In general customers do not like to change their phone number. Thus, we see the inherent
advantages to being first in the market in the wireless industry: control of ideal sites; freedom to
evolve and fine-tune network coverage; building of brand loyalty by offering superior customer
service; locking in customers by subsidizing equipment for an extended period under fixed-service
contracts, and gaining control of key channels of distribution.
THE OPPURTUNITIES
Rural Orissa
Mobile affordability not really an issue anymore.
Lifetime prepaid a great success.
Rural customers waiting to be connected.
Greenfield market now outside urban Orissa.
New entrant should emphasize in ‘Rural Chalo’ mobile scheme to attract
majority of new rural subscribers.
8|Page “H ow to g et n e w cu sto m er s in a m atu r ed t el ec o m ma rk et”
CONSUMER CHURN:
As there is competition in the market consumer churn is a very visible in this kind of market. So a
new entrant must make use of this churn in its favour to the full extent. The action plan contain as
to how to do this.
MARKETING STRATEGY:
ACTION PLAN
Now taking into various analysis into account a detailed plan of action has been formulated which
enlist in itself as to how a new entrant should penetrate into a matured market where already the
existing players are there who are having a large chunk of market share. These action plan details as
to how a new entrant will be able to get new customers or will be able to do consumer churn in its
favour so as to enter and penetrate into the mature market and get customers .In this action plan I
have listed various probable steps that a new entrant should take, keeping in view the condition of
Orissa.
ADDITIONAL SERVICES
PROVIDING LOW COST ROMING
HOME CIRCLE ISD FACILITY
INCREASING WORKFORCE
MODERN TRADE
EDUCATING ROI (return on investment) FACTOR
CORPORATE STRATEGY
PENETRATING INTO GOVT SECTOR
PREPAID CUG
SHOWING BENEFITS TO RETAILERS
EFFICIENT ADVERTISING
The first step for a new entrant should be to find out approximately as to how many retailers are
there in the market who sell the sim card, recharge vouchers of other competitors .The new
operator should convince these retailers with lucrative business proposal so that they sell the sim
card and recharge voucher for the new entrant too. The new entrant should make a full proof plan
to tap these retailers because they are the one who has got direct contact with the customers and
they in fact be willing to convince the customer on the behalf of the new entrant .This is the first way
to penetrate into the Market. The new entrant should come up with profitable schemes and build a
good relationship with them.
The next step would be to create a total set of new retailers totally devoted to this new entrant.
Earlier in the telecom market it was not possible to create new retailers and the sim cards and
recharge vouchers were sold only by those retailers who were dealing in telecommunication
product, mobile handset and accessories only. But now a day’s even small retailers can deal in these
products, as because there is no such regulation. So the new entrant should try to educate these
new retailers who will push its product. As because the initial investment is very low even small
retailers dealing in any sort of business can sell this sim cards and recharge vouchers to earn a
handsome amount of revenue as a secondary source of income in their existing setup. The new
entrant should try to build good relationship with these new retailers. Today starting from a barber
shop, to a tyre repairing shop, to a medicine shop can deal in these products. These new retailers
will do a good business for the new entrant because they will be dealing with the products of this
new entrant only.
The new entrant should try to churn consumers in its favour by working on the weakness of the
other competitors. As if we take the case of Reliance and Aircel in Orissa, there is always a problem
related to their network which is always congested. If we take the case of BSNL in Orissa, they lack in
selling and distribution of their recharge vouchers. Moreover the billing process of Reliance is not
trusted by a lot of customers. So the new entrant should try to churn these set of dissatisfied
customers in its favour by educating them on this factors. The new retailers will also help in churning
out to a great extent.
The new entrant should develop and introduce new services which the competitors have ignored
and which are demanded by the customers. They should also try to work out on the niches that the
competitors are missing or any beneficial trend that are still not introduced by the competitors. Now
in case of Orissa value added services are still left untouched by the competitors. So the new entrant
should try to come up with various value added services (VAS) like 3G, email on the go, GPRS,
internet etc.
ADDITIONAL SERVICES:
The new entrant in order to attract and grab the existing customer of other operator should come
up new additional services. As there are lot of customers of other operators mostly businessman or
high end users who are not satisfied with the services of the existing operators and are willing to
shift to other network but because of certain constraints are not able to do the same. Example a
businessman whose existing no. is circulated to a lot of other people so as because the mobile no.
will change may not be willing to do so. In this case the new entrant can offer him that the previous
last five digit of the number will remain same and can ask customer to use the services of the new
entrant simultaneously with the old number. In this case when the customer simultaneously uses
both the number in the mean time will distribute the new number to other people in a span of 3-4
month and then can shift to the new entrant (operator). After 3-4 month that customer can stop
using the services of the old operator. For this the new entrant can even offer him low rental for this
period so that the customer can use it in a trial basis and ultimately when satisfied the sale take
place.
The new entrant can also increase the credit limit of a new customer so as to provide them with the
opportunity to use their services and earn more revenue. In case of prepaid the question of credit
limit does not arise, but in case of post paid most services provider provides credit limit to the
extent of security deposit taken, and at times some what more than the security deposit, as a
method of avoiding risk. But the new entrant by way of strict compliance to AVCV can increase the
There are number of customers who use roaming facility to a large extent, and depend on roaming
facility for most of their business purposes. As for roaming facility from home network to other
network, the service provider charge a lot from customers and ask to pay more security deposit.
Moreover when roaming is not activated even takes 24 hours to get activated. So the new extent
can works on this factor and introduces roaming as a facility without taking any additional security
deposit. Mostly service provider charges Rs. 1000 as security deposit, but the new entrant can
provide roaming without any additional security deposit. They can ask to the customer to use
roaming to the extent of the initial security deposit and as when the amount of security deposit is
exhausted can be directed to pay the amount in roaming where it is possible and regain the facility.
This will also attract new customers to shift to the services of the new entrant.
The new entrant can also bring innovative products to attract new customers. As for now in Orissa in
order to get ISD facility activated most of the service providers charge Rs.2000 as security deposit.
But the new entrant can provide ISD facility in home circle without taking any additional security
deposit. By doing so the new entrant will not incur any risk because he can provide the service at
initial security deposit. Though the customer will not be able to make more calls but then also he can
make use of ISD facility without incurring any additional cost. In this way the new entrant can both
attract new customers at the same time without incurring any additional risk.
INCREASED WORKFORCE
As discussed earlier, that by tapping the existing retailer and creating new retailers the new entrant
can increase its workforce to a large extent. As for example by tapping the existing retailers the new
entrant can penetrate into the existing set of sales and distribution channels moreover by creating
new retailer who are dedicated to the new entrant only can increase the total workforce more than
what competitors do have. If the existing retailers are 1000 and new retailers created are 300 then
the total retailers for the new entrant would be 1300 whereas for competitor it will be only 1000.
MODERN TRADE
This is a innovative idea of entering into a matured market where competitors have got an edge in
selling and distribution channels. The new entrant can make strategic tie-ups with big shopping malls
,showrooms and chain retailers so that they can open dedicated stores which will help fetch new
customers as well as promote the brand too. For example in Orissa, the new entrant can make
strategic tie-ups with Mobile store or Reliance Fresh, who have got chains of store in and around big
towns which can help get new customers and promote the brand.
The new entrant can also create more dedicated retailers by educating the retailers about the return
on investment factor and convincing them. The new entrant can convince the new retailer by
explaining him as to how to make maximum utility of his existing setup and earn more revenue by
explaining him how he can get more return from a very small initial investment. Another advantage
of telecom product is that it is non perishable in nature. The ROI can be explained to the retailer in
this way: Suppose a small retailer invests RS 1000, which he can sell in a particular day similarly the
next day he will again purchase the recharge voucher with that RS 1000 so, in a month his total
turnover would be RS 30000. If the margin is 4% then he makes a profit of RS 1200 in a month,
where as his initial investment was only RS 1000, so the total return on investment was 120% which
is extremely high, and not possible in any other business, because even the bank do not provides
such a high interest rate. So most retailer find it a very lucrative business option. Moreover in
addition to this the retailer also earns additional revenue by selling new connections. So in this way
the new entrant can create more retailers who in turn convince customer and get them for the new
entrant.
CORPORATE STRATEGY:
Another avenue for the new entrant is to chalk out innovative corporative strategy. This is basically
institutional sale for the new entrant. They can customize a suitable CUG plan with customised
tariff and can approach private sector companies and can materialize the deal, which will fetch them
bulk customers. As in case of most of the service providers, in case of post-paid connection 20% of
those are institutional customers. Such institutional sale provides bulk revenue and moreover it is
very easy to materialize such deal in a short span of time with lucrative proposals. Orissa as state is
developing very fast and most companies are setting up their regional head office here, so the scope
of institutional sales via CUG plan is very high, which in turn will help a new entrant to get more
customers.
PREPAID CUG
The new entrant can also bring an another very innovative product in the form of CUG. It will be a
very unique innovation in its own, because till now CUG is available only in post-paid connection.
The main target audience (customer) for this product will be the small scale industries or likewise. In
order to penetrate into the rural sector this can prove to be very ideal product in Orissa. The key
feature of this product is that it can be given free of cost, because in order to fetch new rural or low
earning customer, an initial free of cost distribution will prove very helpful, because ones the habit
of use of telecom product is installed in the customers, they will surely use it more and in turn more
revenue will be generated. Competitor firm provide a validity of 1 month at the cost of Rs 200, which
provides validity of 1 month and talk time of Rs. 50, but the new entrant can provide 3 month
validity at Rs. 250 and talk time of Rs. 100. So now at Rs. 150 the user can use it for 3 month .The
new entrant can provide subsequent validity of 1 month at Rs. 10, so that even the low earning
customers can make most use of it. And this will definitely churn no. of customer from competitor
firm. Moreover the prepaid CUG call rates can be put to as low as 10 paisa /min, this will be very
innovative product which the low earning group or people working in SSI can use at affordable cost
as a result of which the customer can afford connectivity at as low as Rs. 10 whereas earlier he used
to spend Rs. 150 for the same.
The new entrant can also make a strategic planning so as to penetrate into the govt sector offices by
providing free of cost connection to the Govt. employees as there is low amount of risk in case of
Govt. sector employees and getting the deal materialized from govt sector office is also not that
tough. So the new entrant can fetch bulk amount of customers from this sector. The new entrant
can introduce customized CUG tariff for Govt. employees moreover regarding the AVCV it would not
be a very risky proposition because of job security of Govt. employees. It will act as a source of
institutional sales which will consists of 20% of post-paid business for the new entrant
As all the existing retailers will be having target from the existing competitors so the new entrant in
order to penetrate into the already existing sales and distribution channel i.e. the existing retailers
must show the monetary benefits and return on instrument to these existing chain of retailers .If a
particular retailer is getting Rs. 50 per connection from an existing competitors the new entrant can
offer him Rs 80 per connection provided he fulfils a target of getting 100 new customers and once
the dealer is convinced then he should be provided with enough stock. It is possible that other
competitors will again try to attract him with more lucrative offer but then retailers wouldn’t be
having enough capacity to invest .And the new entrant should try to modify the scheme for the
existing retailers more profitable and lucrative.
EFFICIENT ADVERTISING
As advertising plays vital driving force behind any buying decision of buyers, so the new entrant
should try to do cost effective yet efficient advertising and promotion. Making prospect aware of
brand and promoting the brand is very essential so the new entrant should try to select place wise
advertising strategy. As in case of cities and towns the advertising strategy should be tailor made
accordingly and similarly for rural areas a tailor made advertising and promotion strategy should be
used.
Reduce price to penetrate an existing market. By introducing a product at a lower price than the
pioneer's, a latecomer can attract new customers who would not have otherwise purchased such a
product in effect expanding the total market. Reduced price can also induce the pioneer's current
customers to switch. Still, this strategy is likely to result in reduced margins for the new entrant
compared with other players in the market, unless the new entrant's cost of production is relatively
cheaper. Improve a product or service, with focus on a niche market. Companies can compete by
being innovative in the marketplace. The innovation may be radical or incremental. One example of
incremental innovation is an enhanced version of an existing product. The enhanced product can
compete directly with existing products, or it can be positioned to attract a smaller segment of the
-0XXX0-
WEBLIOGRAPHY:
• www.google.com
• www.wikipedia.org
• www.orissa.gov.in
• www.coai.com
• www.cnetnews.com
• www.airtel.in
• www.scribd.com
REFERENCES:
• VISHAL KUMAR SHAH
SENIOR SALES EXECUTIVE,
VODAFONE., ASSAM REGION