Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Proti
Te Serbian Radical Movement
A Historical Aspect
Following thc ScrboTurkish war (+868) an outburst ol dynamic po
litical cvcnts culminatcd in thc carly +88os with thc lormation ol modcrn
political partics in Scrbia. Tis phcnomcnon rcsultcd lrom scvcral impor
tant lactors. Although thc promulgation ol thc Constitution in +86 had
not yct cstablishcd lull parliamcntary dcmocracy, it had sccurcd a political
cnvironmcnt in which largcr scgmcnts ol socicty could takc an activc part
in political dccision making.
+
Tis political documcnt cxprcsscd a compro
misc bctwccn thc Crown and thc National Asscmbly by dividing lcgislativc
authority, climinating thc prcvious oligarchic political tradition and almost
unlimitcd powcr ol thc rulcr. Sccondly, altcr thc assassination ol Princc
Mihailo brcnovi in +868, Scrbia was rulcd by his minor ncphcw Princc
Milan brcnovi who was rcprcscntcd by thc Rcgcncy. Tc Rcgcncy was
dominatcd by a strong political pcrsonality, latcr loundcr ol thc Libcral
Party, uropcancducatcd Jovan Risti.
:
Tc ruling circlcs lclt a nccd to
introducc ccrtain rclorms bascd on Vcstcrn political cxpcricncc. Tirdly,
as a conscqucncc ol thc ScrboTurkish war and thc Congrcss ol 8crlin in
+88, Scrbia bccamc an indcpcndcnt statc with all thc prcrogativcs ol powcr
and importancc that such a position acquircs. Fourthly, during this pcriod
a numbcr ol young Scrbian studcnts wcrc scnt to uropcan univcrsitics
to rcccivc highcr cducation. xposurc to uropcan political dcvclopmcnts,
movcmcnts, and idcas accompanicd thcm back to Scrbia. Finally, Scrbian
socicty politically maturcd and cntcrcd thc partisan strugglc.
Scrbian socicty, dominatcd by thc pcasantry, passcd through scvcral
stagcs ol national consciousncss. Tcy bcgan by opposing thc ttoman rulc
and laying thc loundations lor a nationstatc at thc bcginning ol thc ninc
tccnth ccntury, progrcsscd through opposing thc vcry samc Statcs cstab
+
Slobodan Jovanovi, !lada Milana Obreno.ia, vol. ! (8clgradc, +), :o+, scc also
Usta.ni ra..itak Srbije u XIX .eku, cd. Miroslav jordjcvi (Lcskovac, +o).
:
Ibid.
8alcanica XXX\! 130
lishmcnt by bcginning pcasant rcvolts throughout thc +8os and +8os,
to nally waging war against thc ttomans in +86 (joincd by Russia in
+8) and winning indcpcndcncc in +88. Tc Scrbian pcasantry maturcd
during thcsc ycars, publicly articulating its own opinions and intcrcsts.
8y thc +88os Scrbian socicty dcvclopcd a thin, but cxisting laycr ol urban
bourgcoisic who gcncrally originatcd lrom thc villagc, with a pcasant con
sciousncss couplcd with rudimcntary capitalist commcrcial mcntality. At
thc samc timc, a third social laycr grcw within thc Scrbian socicty consisting
ol local intclligcntsia (tcachcrs, physicians, pricsts, local statc authoritics)
who sharcd thc social dcstiny ol pcasantry, but had lairly dcvclopcd political
awarcncss. Hcadcd by 8clgradc intcllcctuals, this was basically thc structurc
ol thc Scrbian socicty in thc +88os.
Scc imitrijc jordjcvi, Tc Scrbian Socicty in thc +88os: A Cross Scction ol thc
rigins ol thc Radical Party (in manuscript).
ivan ivanovi, Politika istorija Srbije, vol. !! (8clgradc, +::), +6+. Scc also
Jovanovi, !lada Milana Obreno.ia, !!, +, ivan Mitrovi, Srpske politike stranke
(8clgradc, +), +, Michacl 8oro Pctrovich, History of Modern Serbia :c,-:,:
(Ncw York: Harcourt 8raca Jovanovich, +6), ++.
M. St. Proti, Tc Scrbian Radical Movcmcnt 18811903 131
Tc pcriod altcr +o could bc justiably namcd Tc Goldcn Agc. Altcr
thc assassination ol thc last brcnovi on : May +o,
Scrbia cntcrcd a
pcriod ol lull parliamcntary dcmocracy bascd on thc rcviscd Constitution
ol +888. From +o to ++, thc Radicals wcrc in powcr most ol thc timc,
lcading thc Scrbian Statc towards complctc cmancipation. Tc movcmcnt
had maturcd through twcnty ycars ol political strugglc, cxpcricnccd numcr
ous challcngcs and tcmptations, claricd and modicd its idcological and
structural loundations, and bccamc capablc ol playing an instrumcntal rolc
in thc proccss ol Scrbias dcvclopmcnt into a uropcan statc in thc cultural
scnsc.
Altcr thc First Vorld Var and thc crcation ol Yugoslavia, thc Radi
cal Party continucd to cxist and act as a political movcmcnt until ++.
Howcvcr, gcncral political, social, and cultural circumstanccs bccamc so dil
lcrcnt that it sccms vcry dicult, il not impossiblc, to look at it as thc samc
movcmcnt bclorc and altcr ++8.
Tc group ol Svctozar Markovi appcarcd in Scrbian politics in thc latc
+86os, and rcmaincd activc until +8.
6
Svctozar Markovi was a young
political thcorctician and activist who had studicd in Scrbia, Russia, and
Switzcrland in thc latc +86os. Hc dcvclopcd a political doctrinc bascd on
idcas ol Russian socialism, cxpcricnccs ol narodniki movcmcnt and anar
chism, and latcr Vcsturopcan socialism.
Soja Skoric, Tc Populism ol Nikola Pasic: thc Zurich Pcriod, East European Quar-
terly X!\/ (Vintcr +8o).
8
McClcllan, S.eto.ar Marko.ic, 68.
8alcanica XXX\! 132
Markovis tcaching could bc dividcd in thrcc major scctions: his political
conccpt, his sociocconomic doctrinc, and his national programmc.
!n his
political programmc, Svctozar Markovi strcsscd scvcral points. His con
ccpts includcd a vcry strong antiburcaucratic scntimcnt. Hc argucd in la
vour ol thc abolition ol a prolcssional administration, which hc rcgardcd
as thc main obstaclc on thc road to cconomic and cultural cmancipation
ol thc Scrbian population: ! considcr thc dcstruction ol thc burcaucratic
systcm as thc rst ncccssity in Scrbia.
+o
Markovi also strcsscd thc intro
duction ol communal and rcgional scllgovcrnmcntal organization in placc
ol thc prolcssional administrativc apparatus. Hc lavourcd clcctcd collcctivc
bodics in communcs and rcgions to bc suprcmc authoritics in thosc arcas.
Communal asscmblics would bc thc oncs to incorporatc all clcctcd ocials
in thc communc not only thc administrators, thc chicl ol policc, and thc
judgc, but also thc doctor and thc tcachcr.
++
Tc wholc structurc ol thc Statc
cstablishmcnt was to dcrivc lrom thc slogan that thc qucstion ol brcad is
thc qucstion ol local scllgovcrnmcnt.
+:
Tc last ol Markovis political objcctivcs, thc suprcmc authority ol
thc National Asscmbly, logically lollowcd thc principlc ol local scllgovcrn
mcnt. Markovi argucd that thc National Asscmbly, complctcly clcctivc on
thc rcgional basis, constitutcd thc suprcmc lcgislativc body. Conscqucntly,
this linc ol thought lcd him to thc Convcnt systcm ol govcrnmcnt and
lurthcr on, to rcpublicanism.
+
Tc sociocconomic scgmcnt ol Svctozar
Markovis tcaching suggcstcd thc abolition ol privatc owncrship and thc
introduction ol communal propcrty. His cconomic conccpt was bascd on
thc traditional patriarchal lamily coopcrativc, thc socallcd .adruga.
+
Fas
cinatcd by its dcmocratic organization and spirit, Markovi put it in thc
ccntrc ol his sociocconomic tcaching: Tc modcrn cconomic idcal is vcry
closc to thc cconomic mcchanism ol thc Scrbian .adruga.
+
!n his opin
ion, it rcprcscntcd thc most advanccd communism ol owncrship, work and
plcasurc.
+6
Markovi was hcavily inucnccd by Nikolai Chcrnyshcvsky.
Tis Russian socialist lound thc idcal pattcrn lor his cconomic systcm in a
Slobodan Jovanovi, !lada leksandra Obreno.ia, !!!, ++, scc also Milivojc Popovi,
Borbe .a parlamentarni reim u Srbiji (8clgradc, +), .
Jovanovi, !lada leksandra Obreno.ia, !!!, +:, scc also Galc Stokcs, Legitimacy
through Liberalism: !ladimir Jo.ano.ic and the Transformation of Serbian Politics (Scattlc:
Univcrsity ol Vashington Prcss, +).
Ibid.
6
Jovanovi, !lada Milana Obreno.ia, !!, ++.
M. St. Proti, Tc Scrbian Radical Movcmcnt 18811903 137
bascd on similar idcological grounds, but rathcr on a common intcrcst in
opposing thc govcrnmcnt. As a rcsult ol thcir joint cort, thc Radicals and
thc Young Conscrvativcs wcrc ablc to lorcc thc Libcral govcrnmcnt to rc
sign. Tc Young Conscrvativcs lormcd thcir rst cabinct undcr thc prcsi
dcncy ol Milan Piroanac at thc cnd ol +88o.
ivanovi, Politika istorija, !!, +6+, scc also Jovanovi, !lada Milana Obreno.ia, !!,
+, ivan Mitrovi, Srpske politike stranke (8clgradc, +), +, Pctrovich, History,
+o++.
o
Jovanovi, !lada Milana Obreno.ia, !!, +8:o.
+
Scc Mitrovi, Politike stranke, +, Alcx ragnich, Serbia, Nikola Pasic, Yugosla.ia
(Ncw Jcrscy: Rutgcrs Univcrsity Prcss, +6), +6, Pctrovich, History, ++.
:
Ibid.
Nikola
Pai bccamc thc rst Prcsidcnt ol thc Radical Main Committcc, and Pcra
Todorovi was clcctcd \icc Prcsidcnt.
Ibid.
6
isarmamcnt ol thc Popular Army, Samoupra.a, o July +88, How to Gct Rid ol
!llcgal lcctions, Samoupra.a, o August +88.
For morc dctails, scc Milocvi, Timoka buna, ragutin !li, Zajearska buna (8cl
gradc, +o), Momilo \cljkovi, O Timokoj buni : godine (8clgradc, +6), im
itrijc jordjcvi, Tc +88 Pcasant Uprising in Scrbia, Balkan Studies :o,: (Tcs
saloniki, +).
8
!li, Zajearska buna, 8.
!n a lcttcr to Nikola Pai scnt lrom 8clgradc in Fcbruary +88, onc ol thc
Radical lcadcrs also cmphasizcd thc importancc ol an armcd rcbcllion:
but ! know that our strugglc through parliamcnt has to bc
mcrcly lormal, or at lcast sccond in importancc, our main goal has to
bc thc uprising.
Tc othcr opinion within thc Radical movcmcnt during thosc crucial ycars
in thc wakc ol thc Timok rcbcllion argucd in lavour ol a gradual and silcnt
rccovcry ol thc Party structurc, and thc movcmcnts conccntration on politi
cal issucs, avoiding sharp conlrontations and attacks on thc King pcrsonally.
Somc ol thc Radical lcadcrs lrom 8clgradc criticizcd thcir comradcs in
cmigration lor such statcmcnts. Stojan Proti wrotc to Nikola Pai:
! cannot undcrstand that you, Aca |Stanojcvi| and ika
|Milcnovi|, but you cspccially, can makc such mistakcs. Vhy and
how comc that you camc out so opcnly against thc King: ! can, but
only partially, cxplain thc loolishncss ol your action by your dcspcr
atc situation and by your psychological condition.
(Probably Andra Nikoli) to Nikola Pai, 8clgradc, + April +88, privatc collcc
tion.
(Probably Stojan Proti) to Nikola Pai, 8clgradc, Fcbruary +88, privatc collcc
tion.
6
Ibid.
M. St. Proti, Tc Scrbian Radical Movcmcnt 18811903 141
oncc and lor all: do thcy think that our Party could accomplish its
programmc undcr thc rulc ol King Milan without an uprising. A
lot would dcpcnd upon this. Accordingly, our luturc work should bc
organizcd with thcm or without thcm.
Two othcr lcgal documcnts wcrc passcd during Radical rulc and
shcd a grcatcr undcrstanding ol thc Radical intcrprctation ol dcmocracy.
Tc law on ministcrial rcsponsibility datcd January +8+, gavc thc right ol
qucstioning to both thc National Asscmbly and to thc King. Tc ministc
rial rcsponsibility was both political and criminal.
Tc law on communcs,
cnlorccd in Novcmbcr +88, was dcsigncd to introducc thc conccpt ol local
scllgovcrnmcnt as thc most important political systcm in thc country. Tc
application ol this systcm csscntially mcant thc rcalization ol thc Radical
programmc.
Upon his rcturn to Scrbia, Nikola Pai was clcctcd prcsidcnt ol thc
National Asscmbly in +88 and promptly lormcd his rst Radical cabinct.
6
Tc cabinct rcsigncd in August +8: and was succccdcd by thc Libcral
govcrnmcnt ol Jovan Avakumovi.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
6
Ibid., :::.
Scc Raa Milocvi, Dra.ni udar odo.go i Pr.i april :,; s.rgnue krujeg kralje.skog
namesnit.a (8clgradc, +6).
M. St. Proti, Tc Scrbian Radical Movcmcnt 18811903 145
was rcportcd that thc Radicals accompanicd thc King all ovcr Scrbia chccr
ing and calling him thc rst Radical and Alcxandcr thc Grcat.
8o
Vith thc
cxccption ol thc Ministry ol thc Military, thc cabinct ol Lazar oki was
purcly Radical.
8+
ncc again, thc collaboration was shortlivcd. Tc Radical
cabinct was lorccd to rcsign and, morcovcr, thc Radicals and thc King cn
tcrcd into an opcn conlrontation. Radical public mcctings wcrc banncd and
thc Radicals dcscribcd as just a mob gathcrcd to disturb public pcacc and
ordcr.
8:
Tc Kings nal stcp was his dccision to abolish thc Constitution
ol +888 in May +8.
8
ncc again, thc Scrbian Statc was pushcd into a
pcriod dominatcd by thc rulcr and his camarilla. Tc Radical achicvcmcnts
in political aairs wcrc supprcsscd and thcir collaboration with thc King
provcd to bc dctrimcntal and misjudgcd. Tc pcriod ol pragmatic Radical
ism sccms to havc bccn crucial in many ways. Tc Radical Party progrcsscd
in thc altcrmath ol thc Timok rcbcllion, passing through thc painlul proccss
ol political rcoricntation, nally succccding in cntcring thc govcrnmcnt and
bccoming an important political lactor. Tis pcriod was charactcrizcd by
scvcral signicant achicvcmcnts ol thc Radical Party in thc implcmcntation
ol parliamcntarism and modcrn dcmocracy. 8cginning with thc Constitu
tion ol +888, lollowcd by a scrics ol lcgal documcnts which had spccicd
thc principlcs cstablishcd by thc Constitution, thc Radicals rcalizcd much
ol thcir political programmc.
8
Finally, thcy collaboratcd with thc Libcrals
and with thc King. Tis mcant that thcir partisan cxclusivcncss, which still
cxistcd among ccrtain circlcs in thc Party, had bccn gcncrally climinatcd.
Tcy cntcrcd thc phasc in which thcy undcrstood and acccptcd thc rulcs ol
thc political gamc, thcy wcrc not as innoccnt and clcan as thcy had bccn in
+88+. !nstcad, thcy bccamc succcsslul and powcrlul.
Tc phasc ol Scrbian Radicalism lrom +8 to +o was markcd chicy
by pcacclulncss and unsucccsslul attcmpts to rcturn to powcr, bccoming
known as thc pcriod ol ovcrpowcrcd Radicalism. Tc political work ol thc
Radical lcadcrs was mainly conccntratcd on journalistic activitics. Trough
thcir lcading political organ Odjek, thc ncwlystartcd Narod (Tc Pcoplc)
and thc litcrarypolitical magazinc Delo (Tc ccd), thc Radicals wcrc ablc
8o
Avakumovi, Mcmoirs, +:.
8l
Ibid.
8:
Avakumovi, Mcmoirs, no. :8/!!!, +.
8
Jovanovi, !lada leksandra Obreno.ia, !!, :o::+.
8
Milivojc Popovi, Poreklo i postanak usta.a od :. godine (8clgradc, +), o+.
8alcanica XXX\! 146
to rcmain a prcscncc in daily politics. 8csidcs cvcryday issucs, thcir attcn
tion turncd to qucstions ol uropcan political thcory. uring this pcriod,
thc Radicals acccptcd thc thcory ol 8ritish parliamcntarism, rclying on
thc work ol two ol thcir political writcrs: Stojan Proti and Milovan j.
Milovanovi.
8
ncc again, thc major Radical objcctivc was thc dcmand lor a ne.
constitution. Tc govcrnmcnts attcmpts to lorm a constitutional commit
tcc ol all thrcc political partics dcnitcly lailcd in +86 as a rcsult ol thc
Radicals vigorous opposition to collaboration with thc Progrcssivist gov
crnmcnt ol Stojan Novakovi couplcd with thcir prcssurc to rcinlorcc thc
Constitution ol +888.
86
Tc summcr ol +86 was markcd by a massivc Radical mccting hcld
in 8clgradc on :8 July. According to Odjek, bctwccn and o thousand
pcoplc wcrc prcscnt.
8
Most ol thcm wcrc pcasants who camc lrom all ovcr
Scrbia.
88
ivan ivanovi, a promincnt Libcral, claimcd that this had bccn
thc most massivc political mccting cvcr organizcd in Scrbia.
8
At thc cnd ol +86 thc Radicals cntcrcd thc cabinct again. Altcr an
arrangcmcnt with thc King, jordjc Simi, onc ol thc lcss important Radi
cals in thc party hicrarchy and a mcmbcr ol its lcast militant wing, lormcd a
govcrnmcnt consisting ol ncutrals and compromising Radicals. Tc Radical
ministcrs wcrc Mihailo \uji, Pcra \climirovi, Andra Nikoli and Milovan
Milovanovi.
o
8chind this group stood Nikola Pai as a sccrct advisor ol
thc govcrnmcnt.
+
As a part ol thc dcal with thc King, thc Radicals agrccd
to postponc constitutional rclorm lor onc wholc ycar. Radical pragmatism
bccamc morc than obvious. !ntcnt to rcmain in powcr, thcy tcmporarily
bctraycd thcir most important political objcctivc and principlc: thc dcmand
lor thc rcinstitution ol thc +888 Constitution. Tis cabinct was lorccd to
rcsign in thc lall ol +8, largcly bccausc cxKing Milan brcnovi rc
turncd to Scrbia. Tc ncxt ycars markcd thc timc ol thc pcrsonal rcgimc ol
King Alcxandcr supportcd and adviscd by his lathcr Milan. Tc govcrn
mcnt was hcadcd by Milans intimatc old lricnd \ladan jordjcvi. cspitc
all thcir prcvious attcmpts to collaboratc with thc Crown, thc Radicals wcrc
again out ol powcr, and morc importantly, out ol thc political mainstrcam.
8
Slobodan Jovanovi, Moji sa.remenici (Vindsor, Canada, +), +:8.
86
Scc Novakovi, Usta.na borba.
8
Odjek, o July +86.
88
Ibid.
8
ivanovi, Politika istorija, !!!, o+o.
o
Jovanovi, !lada leksandra Obreno.ia, !!!, +8++.
+
Ibid.
M. St. Proti, Tc Scrbian Radical Movcmcnt 18811903 147
Tc majority ol thc laws passcd undcr Radical rulc wcrc changcd or sup
prcsscd.
Tc nal attack on thc Radical Party camc in +8. An abortivc at
tcmpt on thc cxKing Milans lilc madc by a youngstcr lrom 8osnia was
uscd by thc govcrnmcnt as a prctcxt to arrcst thc Partys most outspokcn
lcadcrs, accusing thcm ol inspiring and organizing thc attcmptcd assassina
tion. Tc Radicals imprisoncd wcrc Nikola Pai, Kosta Taunovi, Stojan
Proti, Ljuba ivkovi and thc pricst Milan juri.
:
Tc prosccution pa
pcrs statcd that during thc mccting ol thc Radical Main Committcc Nikola
Pai opcnly thrcatcncd cxKing Milan, that Ljuba ivkovi was thc author
ol Tc cmon ol Scrbia, which alludcd to cxMilan, and praiscd Karad
jordjc, thc lcadcr ol thc First Scrbian !nsurrcction, and that thc cntirc public
lilc ol Stojan Proti was thc lilc ol a rcvolutionary.
Ibid.
Ibid. Scc also Kosta Jczdi, I.andanski atentat i Nikola Pai (8clgradc, +:6).
Ibid.
8
Ibid.
Ibid., +.
+oo
Ibid.
+o+
For morc dctails, scc \asi, :,c.
M. St. Proti, Tc Scrbian Radical Movcmcnt 18811903 149
dynasty rcplaccd thc brcnovis Pctcr Karadjordjcvi, thc grandson ol
Karadjordjc, bccamc King ol Scrbia. Tc Radical Party cntcrcd its Goldcn
Agc. Altcr ovcr twcnty ycars ol strugglc, rcbcllion, crisis, compromisc and
succcss, it bccamc powcrlul and maturc cnough to dominatc Scrbian poli
tics and dccisivcly contributc to Scrbias cmcrgcncc as a dcmocratic uro
pcan statc.
Institute for Balkan Studies UDC :,.:.:(-:&.,:)(c,:)!:::,c
Serbian cademy of Sciences and rt ,,(,,.::)::,
Belgrade