Problema de Verificacin No.

1
TIPO:

Clculo de reacciones de una estructura.

REFERENCIA :'Resistencia de Materiales Parte-1 de S.

Timoshenko, pgina 346, problema No. 3.
PROBLEMA: Determine la reaccin X del sistema como se
muestra en la figura.

50"

50"
X

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Reaccin X, kip
8.77 *
8.77
Ninguna

* La respuesta real en la referencia es 0.877 P. En el ejemplo, P se

toma como 10. Por eso X = 8.77

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.

STAAD TRUSS PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO. 1

*
* REFERENCE `STRENGTH OF MATERIALS' PART-1 BY S. TIMOSHENKO
* PAGE 346 PROBLEM NO. 3. THE ANSWER IS REACTION = 0.877P.
* THEREFORE IF P=10, REACTION = 8.77
*
UNITS INCH KIP
JOINT COORD
1 0. 0. ; 2 150. 100. ; 3 150. 50. ; 4 300. 0.
MEMBER INCI
1 1 2 ; 2 1 3 ; 3 2 3 ; 4 2 4 ; 5 3 4
MEMB PROP
1 4 PRIS AX 5.0 ; 2 5 PRIS AX 3.0 ; 3 PRIS AX 2
CONSTANT ; E 30000. ALL
SUPPORT ; 1 4 PINNED
LOADING 1
JOINT LOAD ; 2 FY -10.
PERFORM ANALYSIS
PRINT REACTION

SUPPORT REACTIONS -UNIT KIP INCH

----------------JOINT LOAD
1
4

1
1

FORCE-X
8.77
-8.77

FORCE-Y
5.00
5.00

STRUCTURE TYPE = TRUSS

FORCE-Z
0.00
0.00

MOM-X
0.00
0.00

MOM-Y
0.00
0.00

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

20. FINISH

MOM Z
0.00
0.00

Problema de Verificacin No. 2

TIPO:

Clculo de Frecuencia Natural.

REFERENCIA :'Problemas de Vibracin en Ingeniera de

Timoshenko, Young & Weaver (4th edicin,
pgina 11, problema 1.1-3).
PROBLEMA: Una viga simple es soportada por dos resortes tal
como se muestra en la figura. Despreciando la
masa distribuida de la viga, calcule el periodo de
vibracin libre de la viga sujeta a una carga de W.

Y
W = 1000 lbs

1
L

2
A

DANDO:

EI = 30E6 lb-sq. in., A = 7 ft, B = 3 ft.

Constante Elstica K = 300 lb/in.

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Periodo t
0.533
0.533
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.

STAAD PLANE PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO 2

*
* REFERENCE 'VIBRATION PROBLEMS IN ENGINEERING' BY
* TIMOSHENKO,YOUNG,WEAVER. (4TH EDITION, PAGE 11, PROB 1.1-3)
* THE ANSWER IN THE BOOK IS T = 0.533 SEC., VIZ., F = 1.876 CPS
*
UNIT POUND FEET
JOINT COORD ; 1 0. 0. ; 2 7. 0. ; 3 10. 0.
MEMB INCI ; 1 1 2 2
UNIT INCH
SUPPORT
1 3 FIXED BUT MZ KFY 300.
MEMB PROP ; 1 2 PRIS AX 1. IZ 1.
CONSTANT ; E 30E6 ALL
CUT OFF MODE SHAPE 1
LOADING 1 1000 LB LOAD AT JOINT 2
JOINT LOAD ; 2 FY -1000.
* FOLLOWING VERY SMALL MEMBER LOAD IS PROVIDED
* TO ACCOUNT FOR ADDITIONAL MASSES NECESSARY TO
* SOLVE EIGEN PROBLEM NUMERICALLY. THIS SMALL
* VALUE OF THE LOAD HAS ALMOST NO EFFECT IN THE
* ACTUAL RESULTS.
MEMBER LOAD
1 2 UNI Y 0.01
MODAL CALCULATION
PERFORM ANALYS

CALCULATED FREQUENCIES FOR LOAD CASE

MODE

27. FINISH

FREQUENCY(CYCLES/SEC)

1.877

1
PERIOD(SEC)

0.53284

Problema de Verificacin No. 3

TIPO:

Deflexin y momentos para elemento finito con

flexin de placas.

REFERENCIA :Simple clculo hecho a mano considerando toda

la estructura como una viga en voladizo.
PROBLEM:

Una simple placa en voladizo es dividida en 12

elementos finitos de 4-nodos. Una presin
uniforme es aplicada y la mxima deflexin en el
extremo del voladizo y la flexin mxima en el
apoyo son calculadas.
Y

50 mm

6 @ 50 mm

DANDO:

Espesor de placa = 25mm,

Presin uniforme = 5N/sq.mm

CLCULO A MANO:
3

Max. Deflex. = WL /8EI, donde

3

WL =(5x300x100) x (300) = 405x10

3

10

8EI=8x(210x10 N/sq.mm)x(100x25 /12)

7

= 21875x10
Deflexin = 18.51mm
Max. momento = WL/2 = (5x300x100)x300/2
6

= 22.5x10 N.mm = 22.5KN.m

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

Clculo manual
STAAD-III

Max. Defl.
18.51 mm
18.32 mm

Max Momento
22.50 kNm
22.50 kNm

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.

STAAD SPACE FINITE ELEMENT VERIFICATION

UNIT MM KN
JOINT COORDINATES
1 0 0 0 7 300 0 0
REPEAT 2 0 50 0
ELEMENT INCIDENCES
1 1 2 9 8 TO 6
REPEAT 1 6 7
ELEMENT PROP
1 TO 12 THICK 25.0
CONSTANT
E 210.0 ALL
SUPPORT
1 8 15 FIXED
UNIT NEWTON
LOAD 1 5N/SQ.MM UNIFORM LOAD
ELEMENT LOAD
1 TO 12 PRESSURE 5.0
PERFORM ANALYSIS

20. PRINT DISPLACEMENT LIST 14

JOINT DISPLACEMENT (CM
-----------------JOINT LOAD
14

X-TRANS
0.00000

RADIANS)

Y-TRANS
0.00000

STRUCTURE TYPE = SPACE

Z-TRANS
1.83226

X-ROTAN

Y-ROTAN

0.00000 -0.08186

Z-ROTAN
0.00000

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

21. UNIT KN METER
22. PRINT REACTION
SUPPORT REACTIONS -UNIT KN
----------------JOINT LOAD
1
8
15

1
1
1

FORCE-X
0.00
0.00
0.00

METE

FORCE-Y
0.00
0.00
0.00

STRUCTURE TYPE = SPACE

FORCE-Z
-22.40
-105.19
-22.40

MOM-X
-1.37
0.00
1.37

MOM-Y
5.50
11.50
5.50

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

23. FINISH

MOM Z
0.00
0.00
0.00

Problema de Verificacin No. 4

TIPO:

Calcular reaccin en apoyos para un marco

simple.

REFERENCIA :'Resistencia de Materiales' Parte-1 S.

Timoshenko, pgina 346, problema No. 2.
PROBLEMA: Determine la reaccin X del sistema que se
muestra en el figura.

10"
3

4
3

10"

2
10"

X
1

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Reaccin X, kip
1.5
1.5
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.

STAAD PLANE PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO. 4

*
* REFERENCE 'STRENGTH OF MATERIALS' PART-1 BY S. TIMOSHENKO
* PAGE 346 PROBLEM NO. 2. THE ANSWER IN THE BOOK AFTER
* RECALCULATION = 1.5
*
UNIT INCH KIP
JOINT COORD
1 0. 0. ; 2 0. 10. ; 3 0. 20. ; 4 10. 20.
SUPPORT
1 FIXED ; 2 FIXED BUT FY MZ
MEMB INCI
1 1 2 3
MEMB PROP ; 1 2 3 PRIS AX 10. IZ 100.
CONSTANT ; E 3000. ALL
LOADING 1
JOINT LOAD ; 4 FY -1.
PERFORM ANALYS
PRINT REACTION

SUPPORT REACTIONS -UNIT KIP INCH

----------------JOINT LOAD
1
2

1
1

FORCE-X
1.50
-1.50

FORCE-Y
1.00
0.00

STRUCTURE TYPE = PLANE

FORCE-Z
0.00
0.00

MOM-X
0.00
0.00

MOM-Y
0.00
0.00

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

20. FINI

MOM Z
-5.00
0.00

Problema de Verificacin No. 5

TIPO:

Deflexin y esfuerzo en una estructura de una viga

sencilla.

REFERENCIA :'Resistencia de Materiales' Parte-1 de S.

Timoshenko, pgina 97, problema No. 1 y 2.
PROBLEMA: Determine el esfuerzo mximo en el eje motriz
(como se muestra en la figura) y tambin la
deflexin en la mitad del eje.

4
3

13.5"

DANDO:

59"

13.5"

Dimetro = 10 in, P = 26000 lb, E = 30E6

lb/sq.in.

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA
El valor es recalculado.

Esfuerzo
psi
3575 *
3575
Ninguna

Deflexin
in
0.0104
0.01037
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.

STAAD PLANE PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO. 5

*
* REFERENCE 'STRENGTH OF MATERIALS' PART-1 BY S. TIMOSHENKO
* PAGE 97 PROBLEM NO. 1 AND 2. ANSWERS ARE 3580 FOR MAX. STRESS
* AND 0.104 INCH FOR MAX. DEFLECTION.
*
UNIT INCH POUND
JOINT COORD
1 0. 0. ; 2 13.5 0. ; 3 43. 0. ; 4 72.5 0. ; 5 86. 0.
SUPPORT ; 2 4 PINNED
MEMB INCI ; 1 1 2 4
MEMB PROP ; 1 TO 4 TABLE ST PIPE OD 10. ID 0.
CONSTANT ; E 30E6 ALL
LOADING 1
JOINT LOAD ; 1 5 FY -26000.
PERFORM ANALYSIS
PRINT MEMBER STRESSES

MEMBER STRESSES
--------------ALL UNITS ARE POUN/SQ INCH
MEMB

LD SECT

AXIAL

BEND-Y

BEND-Z

COMBINED SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

.0
1.00

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

0.0
3575.3

0.0
3575.3

551.7
551.7

0.0
0.0

.0
1.00

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

3575.3
3575.3

3575.3
3575.3

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

.0
1.00

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

3575.3
3575.3

3575.3
3575.3

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

.0
1.00

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

3575.3
0.0

3575.3
0.0

551.7
551.7

0.0
0.0

18. PRINT DISPLACEMENTS

JOINT DISPLACEMENT (INCH RADIANS)
-----------------JOINT LOAD
1
2
3
4
5

1
1
1
1
1

19. FINISH

X-TRANS

Y-TRANS

0.00000 -0.01144
0.00000 0.00000
0.00000 0.01037
0.00000 0.00000
0.00000 -0.01144

STRUCTURE TYPE = PLANE

Z-TRANS
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

X-ROTAN
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

Y-ROTAN

Z-ROTAN

0.00000 0.00086
0.00000 0.00070
0.00000 0.00000
0.00000 -0.00070
0.00000 -0.00086

Problema de Verificacin No. 6

TIPO:

Marco plano sin desnivel.

REFERENCE: 'Anlisis Estructural' de Jack C. Mcormack,

pgina 383, Ejemplo 22-5.
PROBLEM:

Determine las fuerzas en los miembros del marco

que se muestra en la figura.

2 k / ft
2

20'

20'

DANDO:

E e I son iguales para todos los miembros.

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Momento Max. ft-kip

44.4
44.44
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.

STAAD PLANE PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO. 6

*
* REFERENCE 'STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS' BY JACK C. MCCORMACK,
* PAGE 383 EXAMPLE 22-5, PLANE FRAME WITH NO SIDESWAY
* ANSWER - MAX BENDING = 44.4 FT-KIP
*
UNIT FT KIP
JOINT COORD
1 0. 0. ; 2 0. 20. ; 3 20. 20. ; 4 20. 0.
MEMB INCI ; 1 1 2 3
MEMB PROP ; 1 2 3 PRIS AX 1. IZ 0.05
CONSTANT ; E 4132E3 ALL
SUPPORT ; 1 4 FIXED
LOADING 1 ; MEMB LOAD ; 2 UNI Y -2.0
PERFORM ANAL
PRINT FORCES

MEMBER END FORCES

STRUCTURE TYPE = PLANE
----------------ALL UNITS ARE -- KIP FEET
MEMB LOAD JT

AXIAL

SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

TORSION

MOM-Y

MOM-Z

1
2

20.00
-20.00

-3.33
3.33

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

-22.21
-44.44

2
3

3.33
-3.33

20.00
20.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

44.44
-44.44

3
4

20.00
-20.00

3.33
-3.33

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

44.44
22.21

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

17. FINISH

Problema de Verificacin No. 7

TIPO:

Deflexin de estructura plana

REFERENCIA :'Anlisis Estructural' de Jack C. Mccormack,

pgina 271, Ejemplo 18-2.
PROBLEMA: Determine la deflexin vertical en el punto A de la
estructura de armadura plana tal como se muestra
en el figura.

Y
7
12

2
20k

DANDO:

15'
11

1
5

8
8

10

13
9

3
2

k
4 @ 15' = 60' 20

20k

AX de miembros 1 al 4 = 1, 5 6 = 2, 7 8 = 1.5,
9 10 11 = 3., 12 13 = 4., E = 30E3 ksi

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Deflexin, inch
2.63
2.63
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.

STAAD TRUSS PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO. 7

*
* REFERENCE 'STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS' BY JACK MCCORMACK, PAGE
* 271 EXAMPLE 18-2. ANSWER - Y-DISP AT JOINT 5 = 2.63 INCH
*
UNIT FT KIP
JOINT COORD
1 0 0 0 5 60 0 0
6 15. 7.5 ; 7 30. 15. ; 8 45. 7.5
SUPPORT
1 PINNED ; 3 FIXED BUT FX MZ
MEMB INCI
1 2 6 ; 2 3 4 ; 3 4 8 ; 4 4 5 ; 5 1 2
6 2 3 ; 7 3 6 ; 8 3 8 ; 9 3 7
10 1 6 ; 11 5 8 ; 12 6 7 13
UNIT INCH
MEMB PROP
1 TO 4 PRI AX 1.0
5 6 PRIS AX 2.
7 8 PRI AX 1.5
9 10 11 PRI AX 3.
12 13 PRI AX 4.
CONSTANT ; E 30E3 ALL
LOAD 1 VERTICAL LOAD
JOINT LOAD
2 4 5 FY -20.0
PERFORM ANALYSIS
PRINT DISPLACEMENTS

JOINT DISPLACEMENT (INCH RADIANS)

-----------------JOINT LOAD
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

29. FINISH

X-TRANS

Y-TRANS

0.00000
-0.12000
-0.24000
-0.48000
-0.72000
-0.00820
0.29758
0.06578

0.00000
0.18000
0.00000
-0.89516
-2.63033
0.24000
-0.12000
-0.83516

STRUCTURE TYPE = TRUSS

Z-TRANS
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

X-ROTAN
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

Y-ROTAN
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

Z-ROTAN
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

Problema de Verificacin No. 8

TIPO:

Marco plano con desnivel.

REFERENCIA :'Anlisis Estructural de Jack C. Mccormack,

pgina 385, prob. 22-6.
PROBLEMA: Determine los momentos en la estructura que se
muestra en la figura.

Y
k

30

20'

1
3

30'

4
10'

DANDO:

20'

E e I son los mismos para todos los miembros.

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Max. Momento ft-kip

69.4
69.47
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.

STAAD PLANE PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO. 8

*
* PLANE FRAME WITH SIDESWAY. REFERENCE 'STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS'
* BY JACK MCCORMACK. PAGE 385 PROB 22-6.
* ANSWER - MAX BENDING IN MEMB 1 = 69.4 KIP-FT
*
UNIT FT KIP
JOINT COORD
1 0. 10. ; 2 0 30 ; 3 30 30 ; 4 30 0
SUPPORT ; 1 4 FIXED
MEMB INCI
1 1 2 3
MEMB PROP ; 1 2 3 TAB ST W12X26
CONSTANT ; E 4176E3
LOAD 1 VERTICAL LOAD
MEMBER LOAD
2 CON Y -30. 10.
PERFORM ANALYSIS
PRINT FORCES

MEMBER END FORCES

STRUCTURE TYPE = PLANE
----------------ALL UNITS ARE -- KIP FEET
MEMB LOAD JT

AXIAL

SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

TORSION

MOM-Y

MOM-Z

1
2

20.09
-20.09

-3.75
3.75

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

-5.51
-69.47

2
3

3.75
-3.75

20.09
9.91

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

69.47
-66.79

3
4

9.91
-9.91

3.75
-3.75

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

66.79
45.68

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

20. FINISH

Problema de Verificacin No. 9

TIPO:

Marco Plano de niveles mltiples con cargas

horizontales.

REFERENCIA :'Anlisis Estructural' de Jack C. Mccormack,

pgina 388, ejemplo 22-7.
PROBLEMA: Determine los momentos en el marco que se
muestra en la figura.

10

6
6

5
3

20

20

3
1

20k

2
k

20

DANDO:

E e I son los mismos para todos los miembros.

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Max. Momento ft-kip

176.4
178.01
0.91%

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.

STAAD PLANE VERIFICATION PROB NO. 9

*
* MULTIPLE LEVEL PLANE FRAME WITH HORIZONTAL LOAD.
* REFERENCE 'STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS' BY JACK MCCORMACK,
* PAGE 388, PROB 22-7. ANSWER - MAX MOM IN MEMB 1 = 176.4 K-F
*
UNIT FT KIP
JOINT COORD
1 0 0 0 5 0 40 0 2 ; 2 20 0 0 6 20 40 0 2
SUPPORT ; 1 2 FIXED
MEMB INCI
1 1 3 2 ; 3 3 5 4 ; 5 3 4 ; 6 5 6
MEMB PROP
1 TO 6 PRI AX .2 IZ .1
CONSTANT ; E 4176E3
LOAD 1 HORIZONTAL LOAD
JOINT LOAD
3 FX 20 ; 5 FX 10
PERFORM ANALYS
PRINT FORCES

MEMBER END FORCES

STRUCTURE TYPE = PLANE
----------------ALL UNITS ARE -- KIP FEET
MEMB LOAD JT

AXIAL

SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

TORSION

MOM-Y

MOM-Z

1
3

-22.26
22.26

15.06
-15.06

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

178.01
123.16

2
4

22.26
-22.26

14.94
-14.94

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

176.73
122.10

3
5

-6.51
6.51

4.97
-4.97

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

34.49
64.93

4
6

6.51
-6.51

5.03
-5.03

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

35.34
65.24

3
4

9.91
-9.91

-15.75
15.75

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

-157.65
-157.44

5
6

5.03
-5.03

-6.51
6.51

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

-64.93
-65.24

21. FINISH

Problema de Verificacin No. 10

TIPO:

Estructura de marco espacial.

REFERENCIA :'Programas de Computadora para Anlisis

Estructural de William Weaver Jr., pgina 146,
estructura No. 8.
PROBLEMA: Determine las fuerzas y momentos en la estructura
espacial que se muestra en la figura.

120" k - inch

120"

X
120"
240"

DANDO:

120"

E = 30E3 ksi, AX=11, IX=83, IY=56,

IZ=56 inch.

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Max Axial
kip
1.47
1.47
Ninguna

Max Mom-y
kip-inch
84.04
84.04
Ninguna

Max Mom-z
kip-inch
95.319
95.32
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.

STAAD SPACE VERIFICATION PROB NO. 10

*
* REFERENCE 'COMPUTER PROGRAMS FOR STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS'
* BY WILLIAM WEAVER JR. PAGE 146 STRUCTURE NO. 8.
* ANSWER - MAX AXIAL FORCE= 1.47 (MEMB 3)
* MAX BEND-Y= 84.04, MAX BEND-Z= 95.319 (BOTH MEMB 3)
*
UNIT INCH KIP
JOINT COORD
1 0 120 0 ; 2 240 120 0
3 0 0 0 ; 4 360 0 120
SUPPORT
3 4 FIXED
MEMB INCI
1 1 2 ; 2 3 1 ; 3 2 4
MEMB PROP
1 2 3 PRIS AX 11. IX 83. IY 56. IZ 56
CONSTANT ; E 30000. ALL
POISS .25 ALL
LOAD 1 JOINT LOAD
JOINT LOAD
1 FX 2. ; 2 FY -1. ; 2 MZ -120.
PERFORM ANAL
PRINT ANALYSIS RESULT

JOINT DISPLACEMENT (INCH RADIANS)

-----------------JOINT LOAD
1
2
3
4

1
1
1
1

X-TRANS

Y-TRANS

STRUCTURE TYPE = SPACE

Z-TRANS

X-ROTAN

0.22267 0.00016 -0.17182 -0.00255

0.22202 -0.48119 -0.70161 -0.00802
0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000
0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

Y-ROTAN

Z-ROTAN

0.00217 -0.00213
0.00101 -0.00435
0.00000 0.00000
0.00000 0.00000

SUPPORT REACTIONS -UNIT KIP INCH

----------------JOINT LOAD
3
4

FORCE-X

1
1

FORCE-Y

-1.10
-0.90

STRUCTURE TYPE = SPACE

FORCE-Z

-0.43
1.43

0.22
-0.22

MOM-X

MOM-Y

MOM Z

48.78
123.08

-17.97
47.25

96.12
-11.72

MEMBER END FORCES

STRUCTURE TYPE = SPACE
----------------ALL UNITS ARE -- KIP INCH
MEMB LOAD JT

AXIAL

SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

TORSION

MOM-Y

MOM-Z

1
2

0.90
-0.90

-0.43
0.43

0.22
-0.22

22.71
-22.71

-17.97
-34.18

-36.37
-67.36

3
1

-0.43
0.43

1.10
-1.10

0.22
-0.22

-17.97
17.97

-48.78
22.71

96.12
36.37

2
4

1.47
-1.47

-0.71
0.71

-0.48
0.48

-37.02
37.02

15.69
84.04

-53.28
-95.32

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

25. FINISH

Problema de Verificacin No. 11

TIPO:

Carga de temperatura en diferentes materiales.

REFERENCIA :'Resistencia de Materiales' Parte-1, de

Timoshenko, pgina 30, prob. 9.
PROBLEMA: Asumiendo el miembro horizontal (como en la
figura) muy rgido, determine el esfuerzo en los
cables de cobre y acero si la temperatura se
incrementa 10 F.
Y

1
C

2
2

S
5

3
C

4000 lb

DANDO:

E = 30E6 psi para acero, 16E6 psi para cobre,

coef. de dilatacin term. - 70E-7 del acero, 92E-7
del cobre,
AX = 0.1 sq., in. Para los cables.
RECOMENDACIN PARA EL MODELADO:
Asuma un alto momento de inercia para el
elemento rgido horizontal y distribuya la carga
concentrada como uniforme.
COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:
Esfuerzo Acero
psi
TEORA
19700
STAAD-III
19698
DIFERENCIA
Ninguna
* Valor recalculado.

Esfuerzo cobre
psi
10150 *
10151
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.

STAAD PLANE VERIFICATION PROB NO 11

*
* THIS EXAMPLE IS TAKEN FROM 'STRENGTH OF MATERIALS' BY
* TIMOSHENKO (PART 1), PAGE 30, PROB 9.
* THE ANSWERS ARE 19700 PSI AND 10200 PSI.
*
UNIT INCH POUND
JOINT COORD
1 0. 20. ; 2 5. 20. ; 3 10. 20.
4 0. 0. ; 5 5. 0. ; 6 10. 0.
MEMB INCI
1 1 4 3 ; 4 4 5 5
MEMB PROP
1 2 3 PRI AX 0.1 ; 4 5 PRI AX 1. IZ 100.
CONSTANT ; E 30E6 MEMB 2 4 5
E 16E6 MEMB 1 3
ALPHA 92E-7 MEMB 1 3 ; ALPHA 70E-7 MEMB 2
MEMB TRUSS ; 1 2 3
SUPPORT ; 1 2 3 PINNED
LOADING 1 VERT LOAD + TEMP LOAD
MEMB LOAD ;4 5 UNI Y -400.
TEMP LOAD ; 1 2 3 TEMP 10.
PERFORM ANALYSIS
PRINT STRESSES

MEMBER STRESSES
--------------ALL UNITS ARE POUN/SQ INCH
MEMB

LD SECT

AXIAL

BEND-Y

BEND-Z

COMBINED SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

.0 10150.8 T
1.00 10150.8 T

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

10150.8
10150.8

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

.0 19698.3 T
1.00 19698.3 T

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

19698.3
19698.3

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

.0 10150.8 T
1.00 10150.8 T

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

10150.8
10150.8

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

.0
1.00

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

0.0
3.7

0.0
3.7

1014.9
985.1

0.0
0.0

.0
1.00

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

3.8
0.0

3.8
0.0

984.8
1015.2

0.0
0.0

25. FINISH

Problema de Verificacin No. 12

TIPO:

Deflexin y esfuerzo de un sistema de armadura.

REFERENCIA :'Resistencia de Materiales' Parte-1, de

Timoshenko, pgina 10, prob. 2.
PROBLEMA: Determine la deflexin vertical en el punto A
(como se muestra en la figura) y tambin el
esfuerzo en las barras de la estructura.

DANDO:

AX = 0.5 sq., in., E = 30E6 psi

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

TEORA
STAAD-III
DIFERENCIA

Esfuerzo
psi
100000
100000
Ninguna

Deflexin
inch
0.12
0.12
Ninguna

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.

STAAD TRUSS PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO 12

*
* THIS EXAMPLE IS TAKEN FROM 'STRENGTH OF MATERIALS'
* (PART 1) BY TIMOSHENKO, PAGE 10 PROB 2.
* THE ANSWER IN THE BOOK , DEFLECTION = 0.12 INCH
* AND STRESS =10000 PSI
*
UNIT INCH POUND
JOINT COORD
1 0. 0. ; 2 155.88457 -90. ; 3 311.76914 0.
SUPPORT ; 1 3 PINNED
MEMB INCI ; 1 1 2 2
MEMB PROP
1 2 PRIS AX 0.5
CONSTANT ; E 30E6
LOAD 1 VERT LOAD
JOINT LOAD ; 2 FY -5000.
PERFORM ANALYSIS
PRINT DISPLACEMENTS

JOINT DISPLACEMENT (INCH RADIANS)

-----------------JOINT LOAD
1
2
3

X-TRANS

1
1
1

Y-TRANS

STRUCTURE TYPE = TRUSS

Z-TRANS

0.00000 0.00000
0.00000 -0.12000
0.00000 0.00000

X-ROTAN

0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

Y-ROTAN

Z-ROTAN

0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

0.00000
0.00000
0.00000

20. PRINT STRESSES

MEMBER STRESSES
--------------ALL UNITS ARE POUN/SQ INCH
MEMB

LD SECT

AXIAL

BEND-Y

BEND-Z

COMBINED SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

.0 10000.0 T
1.00 10000.0 T

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

10000.0
10000.0

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

.0 10000.0 T
1.00 10000.0 T

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

10000.0
10000.0

0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0

21. FINISH

Problema de Verificacin No. 13

TIPO:

Diseo de Acero.

REFERENCIA :Clculo manual anexo paso a paso conforme el

AISC 1989. Novena Edicin
PROBLEMA: Determine los esfuerzos permisibles (conforme el
cdigo AISC 1989) de los miembros de las
estructura tal como se muestra en la figura.
Tambin realiza una verificacin conforme el
cdigo de estos miembros basados en los
resultados del anlisis.
Y

15 k
(WL)

2k/ft (DL + LL)

5
5
5'

8
9

4'

16'

11'

10'

Miembros 1, 2 = W12X26, Miembros 3, 4 = W14X43

Miembros 5, 6, 7 = W16X36, Miembros 8= L40404,
Miembros 9 = L50506
COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:
Tasas Gobernantes para los miembros
Miembro #

Clculo
Manual

1.161 .916

1.119 0.942 .577

1.046 .674

1.03

.844

STAAD

1.162 .916

1.119 0.942 .577

1.047 .675

1.04

.845

PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN 13 CLCULO MANUAL

Manual se refiere al Manual de Construccin en Acero AISC,
Diseo por Esfuerzo Permisible, novena edicin.
Diseo de Acero Miembro 1, Tamao W 12X26, L = 10 ft., a = 7.65 in 2 , Sz = 33.4
in 3
De la clusula F1-2, pgina 5-45 del Manual, L c = 6.85 ft.
Por Observacin el caso de carga 1 gobernar,
Fx = 25.0 kip (Compresin), Mz = 56.74 k-ft
Esfuerzo Permisible de Flexin = F b = 12. x 1000 x 1.0 = 20.2 ksi[Claus. F1-8
10 x 12 x 4.95

pgina 5-47
del Manual]

kl/r = 120/1.51 = 79.47, entonces Fa = 15.41 ksi

(Tabla C-36
pgina 3-16 del manual)
fa = 25./7.65 = 3.268, fb = 56.75 x 12/33.4 = 20.389 ksi
Trate frmula H1-1, pgina 5-54 del Manual
3.268

0.85 x 20.389

15.41

= 0.212 + 0.868 = 1.08

(1-3.268/277.45) x 20.2

Trate frmula H1-2, pgina 5-54 del Manual.

3.268
0.6 x 36

20.389 = 1.161
20.2

Por eso la frmula H1-2 rige y tasa = 1.161

Miembro 2, Tamao W12X26, L = 5 ft., a = 7.65 in 2 , Sz = 33.4

in 3
Por observacin el caso de carga 1 gobernar,
Fx = 8.48 kip (compresin), Mz = 56.74 k-ft
Debido a que L es menor que L c (6.9ft)

[Clusula F1-2
pgina 5-45 del Manual]

Fb = 0.66x36 = 23.76 ksi

(Clusula F1-1
pgina 5-45 del Manual)

kl/r = 60/1.51 = 39.74, entonces Fa = 19.21 ksi

Tabla C-36
pgina 3-16 del Manual
fa = 8.48/7.65 = 1.108, fb = 56.74 x 12/33.4 = 20.386 ksi
Debido a que fa/Fa es menor que 0.15, aplique frmula H1-3,
pgina 5-54 del Manual
1.108 + 20.386 = .0577 + .858 = 0.9157
19.21
23.76
Miembro 3, Tamao W14X43, L = 11ft., a = 12.6 in 2 , Sz = 62.7
in 3
Por observacin el caso de carga 3 gobernar,
Fx = 25.5 kip (compresin), Mz = 112.38 k-ft
Refirindose a la clusula F1-2, pgina 5-45 del Manual.
L c = 8.4 ft.
Por eso,
Fb = 0.6 x 36 = 21.6 ksi
kl/r = 132/1.89 = 69.84, entonces Fa = 16.46 ksi

[Tabla C-36

pgina 3-16 del Manual]

fa = 25.5/12.6 = 2.024, fb = 112.38 x 12/62.7 = 21.51 ksi
debido a que fa/Fa es menor que 0.15, usar frmula H1-3, pgina
5-54 del Manual
2.024 + 21.51 = 0.123 + 0.996 = 1.119
16.46
21.6
Miembro 4, Tamao W14X43, L = 4ft, a = 12.6 in 2 , Sz = 62.7 in 3
Por observacin, el caso de carga 3 gobernar,
Fx = 9.73 kip (tensin), Mz = 112.38 k-ft
L c = 8.4 ft
Debido a que L es menor que L c
Fb = 0.66 x 36 = 23.76 ksi

[Clusula F1-1
pgina 5-45 del Manual]

fa = 9.73/12.6 = 0.772, f b = 112.38x12/62.7 = 21.51 ksi

Tensin y Flexin combinada, use frmula H 2-1, pgina 5-55 del
Manual.
0.772
0.6 x 36

21.51 = 0.036 + 0.906 = 0.942

23.76

Miembro 5, Tamao W16X36, L = 5ft, a = 10.6 in 2 , Sz = 56.5 in 3

L c =7.37 ft,

[Clusula F1-2
pgina 5-45 del Manual.

Por observacin, el caso de carga 3 gobernar.

Fx = 14.17 kip (compresin), Mz =56.76 k-ft

Debido a que L es menor que L c ,

Fb = 0.66 x 36 = 23.76 ksi
kl/r = 60./1.52 = 39.47, entonces Fa = 19.23 ksi
[Tabla C-36
pgina 3-16 del Manual]
fa = 14.17/10.6 = 1.337, fb = 56.76 x 12/56.5 = 12.055 ksi
Debido a que fa/Fa es menor que 0.15, use frmula H1-3, pgina
5-54 del Manual
1.337 + 12.055 = 0.07 + 0.507 = 0.577
19.23
23.76
Miembro 6, Tamao W16X36, L = 16ft, a = 10.6 in 2 , Sz = 56.5
in 3
Por observacin, el caso de carga 3 gobernar
Fx = 10.22 kip (compresin), Mz = 63.24 k-ft
L/r T = 192/1.79 = 107.26 es menor que 51,000C b /F y =119.02
Por eso F b (conforme F1-6, pgina 5-47 del Manual) = 14.24 ksi
Kl/r = 192/1.52 = 126.31, entonces Fa = 9.35
[Tabla C-36
pgina 3-16 del Manual]
fa = 10.22/10.6 = 0.964, fb = 63.24x12/56.5 = 13.43 ksi
Debido a que fa/Fa menor que 0.15 use frmula [H1-3, pgina 554 del Manual]
0.964/9.35 + 13.43/14.24 = 0.103 + 0.943 = 1.046
Miembro 7, Tamao W16X36, L =4ft, a = 10.6in 2 , Sz =56.5in 3
Lc = 7.37ft (Clusula F1-2 pgina 5-45 del Manual)

Por observacin el caso de carga 3 gobernar, Fx = 25.03 kip

(tensin), M z = 63.25 k-ft
De la clusula F1-1, Fb = 0.66 Fy = 23.76 ksi = esfuerzo
permisible de compresin.
Debido a que la seccin est en seccin, Fb = 0.60X36 = 21.60 Ksi
[Clusula F1-5, pgina 5-45 del Manual].
Seleccionando el mayor de los 2 valores anteriores, Fb = 23.76 Ksi
fa = 25.03/10.6 = 2.361, fb = 63.25X12/56.5 = 13.43
Debido a que la combinacin de tensin y flexin, use frmula H
2-1, pgina 5-55 del Manual.
2.361 + 13.43 = 0.109 + 0.565 = 0.674
0.6 x 36
23.76
Miembro 8, Tamao L4x4x1/4, L = 7.071 ft, a = 1.94 in 2
Por observacin el caso de carga 1 gobernar, Fx = 23.37 kip
(compresin), b/t=16
excede 76/F y (Tabla B5-1, pgina 5-36), Apndice B gobernar.
Kl/r = 7.071 x 12 = 106.73, entonces F a = 11.61
0.795
Q s=1.34-0.00447 (16) (6)=0.91 (A-B5-1, pgina 5-98)
C c =132.18 (A-B5-11, pgina 5-100)
(Kl/r)/Cc=0.8074 (Tabla 3, pgina 5-119)
C a =0.354, F a =0.354 * 0.91*36= 11.61
fa = 23.37/1.94 = 12.046
Por eso la tasa = fa/Fa = 12.046/11.61 = 1.03

Miembro 9, Tamao L5x5x3/8, L = 5.657 ft, a = 3.61 in 2

Por observacin el caso de carga 1 gobernar, Fx = 49.82 kip
(compresin), b/t=13.33 excede 76/!F y , Apndice B gobierna.
kl/r = 5.657 x 12 = 68.57, so F a = 16.35 utilizando Tabla 3, pgina
5-119.
0.99
fa = 49.82/3.61 = 13.8
Por eso la tasa = fa/Fa = 13.8/16.35 = 0.844

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
RESEARCH ENGINEERS, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.

STAAD PLANE PROBLEMA DE VERIFICACIN NO 13

*
* THIS DESIGN EXAMPLE IS VERIFIED BY HAND CALCULATION
* FOLLOWING AISC-89 CODE.
*
UNIT FEET KIP
JOINT COORD
1 0 0 ; 2 25 0 ; 3 0 10 ; 4 25 11
5 0 15 ; 6 25 15 ; 7 5 15 ; 8 21 15
MEMB INCI
1 1 3 ; 2 3 5 ; 3 2 4 ; 4 4 6
5 5 7 ; 6 7 8 ; 7 8 6 ; 8 3 7 ; 9 4 8
MEMB PROP
1 2 TA ST W12X26 ; 3 4 TA ST W14X43
5 6 7 TA ST W16X36 ; 8 TA ST L40404 ; 9 TA ST L50506
MEMB TRUSS ; 8 9
CONSTANT ; E 4176E3
SUPPORT ; 1 2 PINNED
LOADING 1 DL + LL
MEMB LOAD ; 5 6 7 UNI Y -2.0
LOADING 2 WIND FROM LEFT
JOINT LOAD ; 5 FX 15.
LOAD COMB 3 ; 1 0.75 2 0.75
PERFORM ANALYSIS
LOAD LIST 1 3
PRINT FORCES

MEMBER END FORCES

STRUCTURE TYPE = PLANE
----------------ALL UNITS ARE -- KIP FEET
MEMB LOAD JT

1
3

1
3

1
3

1
3

1
3

1
3

1
3

1
3

1
3

AXIAL

SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

TORSION

MOM-Y

MOM-Z

1
3
1
3

25.00
-25.00
12.00
-12.00

-5.67
5.67
1.03
-1.03

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
-56.75
0.00
10.33

3
5
3
5

8.47
-8.47
15.95
-15.95

10.85
-10.85
-2.92
2.92

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

56.75
-2.47
-10.33
-4.27

2
4
2
4

25.00
-25.00
25.50
-25.50

5.67
-5.67
10.22
-10.22

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
62.42
0.00
112.38

4
6
4
6

6.13
-6.13
-9.75
9.75

-13.20
13.20
-25.03
25.03

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

-62.42
9.63
-112.38
12.26

5
7
5
7

-10.85
10.85
14.17
-14.17

8.47
1.53
15.95
-8.45

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

2.47
14.88
4.27
56.75

7
8
7
8

5.67
-5.67
10.22
-10.22

15.00
17.00
4.50
19.50

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

-14.88
-1.12
-56.75
-63.25

8
6
8
6

-13.20
13.20
-25.03
25.03

1.87
6.13
15.75
-9.75

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

1.12
-9.63
63.25
-12.26

3
7
3
7

23.38
-23.38
-5.59
5.59

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

4
8
4
8

26.69
-26.69
49.85
-49.85

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

27. PARAMETER ; TRACK 1.0 ALL

28. CHECK CODE ALL

STAAD-III CODE CHECKING - (AISC)

***********************

ALL UNITS ARE - KIP FEET (UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED)

MEMBER

TABLE
RESULT/ CRITICAL COND/
RATIO/
LOADING/
FX
MY
MZ
LOCATION
=======================================================================
*

1 ST W12 X26

FAIL
AISC- H1-2
1.162
1
25.00 C
0.00
-56.75
10.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
1, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 120.0 AX= 7.65 SZ= 33.4 SY= 5.3 |
| KL/R-Y= 79.8 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 20.18 |
| FTZ= 21.60 FCY= 27.00 FTY= 27.00 FA= 15.38 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
2 ST W12 X26
PASS
AISC- H1-3
0.916
1
8.47 C
0.00
56.75
0.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
2, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 60.0 AX= 7.65 SZ= 33.4 SY= 5.3 |
| KL/R-Y= 39.9 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 23.76 |
| FTZ= 23.76 FCY= 27.00 FTY= 27.00 FA= 19.19 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
*
3 ST W14 X43
FAIL
AISC- H1-3
1.119
3
25.50 C
0.00
112.38
11.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
3, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 132.0 AX= 12.60 SZ= 62.7 SY= 11.3 |
| KL/R-Y= 69.7 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 21.60 |
| FTZ= 21.60 FCY= 27.00 FTY= 27.00 FA= 16.46 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
4 ST W14 X43
PASS
AISC- H2-1
0.942
3
9.75 T
0.00
-112.38
0.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
4, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 48.0 AX= 12.60 SZ= 62.7 SY= 11.3 |
| KL/R-Y= 25.3 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 23.76 |
| FTZ= 23.76 FCY= 27.00 FTY= 27.00 FA= 20.26 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
5 ST W16 X36
PASS
AISC- H1-3
0.577
3
14.17 C
0.00
56.75
5.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
5, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 60.0 AX= 10.60 SZ= 56.5 SY= 7.0 |
| KL/R-Y= 39.5 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 23.76 |
| FTZ= 23.76 FCY= 27.00 FTY= 27.00 FA= 19.23 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
*
6 ST W16 X36
FAIL
AISC- H1-3
1.047
3
10.22 C
0.00
-63.25
16.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
6, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 192.0 AX= 10.60 SZ= 56.5 SY= 7.0 |
| KL/R-Y= 126.3 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 14.23 |
| FTZ= 21.60 FCY= 27.00 FTY= 27.00 FA= 9.36 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
7 ST W16 X36
PASS
AISC- H2-1
0.675
3
25.03 T
0.00
63.25
0.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
7, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 48.0 AX= 10.60 SZ= 56.5 SY= 7.0 |
| KL/R-Y= 31.6 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 23.76 |
| FTZ= 23.76 FCY= 27.00 FTY= 27.00 FA= 19.83 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|

ALL UNITS ARE - KIP FEET (UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED)

MEMBER

RESULT/ CRITICAL COND/

RATIO/
LOADING/
FX
MY
MZ
LOCATION
=======================================================================
*

TABLE

8 ST L40 404

FAIL
COMPRESSION
1.040
1
23.38 C
0.00
0.00
0.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
8, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 84.9 AX= 1.94 SZ= 0.8 SY= 1.7 |
| KL/R-Z= 106.7 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 0.00 |
| FTZ= 0.00 FCY= 0.00 FTY= 0.00 FA= 11.60 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
9 ST L50 506
PASS
COMPRESSION
0.845
3
49.85 C
0.00
0.00
0.00
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|
| MEM=
9, UNIT KIP-INCH, L= 67.9 AX= 3.61 SZ= 1.8 SY= 3.9 |
| KL/R-Z= 68.6 CB= 1.00 YLD= 36.00 ALLOWABLE STRESSES: FCZ= 0.00 |
| FTZ= 0.00 FCY= 0.00 FTY= 0.00 FA= 16.34 FT= 21.60 FV= 14.40 |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------|

************** END OF TABULATED RESULT OF DESIGN **************

29. FINISH

Problema de Verificacin No. 14

TIPO:

Diseo de concreto conforme el cdigo ACI.

REFERENCIA: Manual CRSI y notas del ACI-318 del ACI

PROBLEMA: Un marco plano es creado con una carga tal que
provoca un momento en la viga de 138 Kip-Ft y
una carga axial de 574 Kip junto con el momento
anterior en la columna.

521.32 k

521.32 k
5.268 k / ft

15'

4
20'

DANDO:

Tamao de vigas es 10 x 16 inch, columna 14 x 16

inch.

COMPARACIN DE SOLUCIONES:

Notas ACI
Manual CRSI
STAAD-III

rea de acero
de viga
2.78 sq.in.
X
2.82 sq.in

rea de Acero
de columna
X
4.01%
4.13% requerido
4.23%propor.

**************************************************
*
*
*
S T A A D - III
*
*
Revision
*
*
Proprietary Program of
*
*
Research Engineers, Inc.
*
*
Date=
*
*
Time=
*
*
*
*
USER ID:
*
**************************************************

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.

STAAD PLANE VERIFICATION FOR CONCRETE DESIGN

UNIT KIP FEET
JOINT COORDINATES
1 0. 0. ; 2 0. 15. ; 3 20. 15. ; 4 20. 0.
MEMBER INCIDENCE
1 1 2 ; 2 2 3 ; 3 3 4
UNIT INCH
MEMBER PROPERTY
1 3 PRISMATIC YD 16. ZD 14.
2 PRISM YD 16. ZD 10.
CONSTANTS
E CONCRETE ALL
SUPPORT
1 4 FIXED
UNIT FT
LOADING 1 DEAD + LIVE
JOINT LOAD
2 3 FY -521.32
MEMBER LOAD
2 UNI GY -5.268
PERFORM ANALYSIS
PRINT MEMBER FORCES

MEMBER END FORCES

STRUCTURE TYPE = PLANE
----------------ALL UNITS ARE -- KIP FEET
MEMBER LOAD JT

AXIAL

SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z

TORSION

MOM-Y

MOM-Z

1
2

574.00
-574.00

-13.72
13.72

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

-67.81
-138.00

2
3

13.72
-13.72

52.68
52.68

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

138.00
-138.00

3
4

574.00
-574.00

13.72
-13.72

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00

138.00
67.81

************** END OF LATEST ANALYSIS RESULT **************

23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.

UNIT INCH
START CONC DESIGN
TRACK 1.0 MEMB 2
FYLD 60.0 ALL
FC 4.0 ALL
CL 1.4375 ALL
DESIGN BEAM 2

====================================================================
B E A M N O.

2 D E S I G N R E S U L T S - FLEXURE

LEN - 20.00FT. FY - 60000. FC - 4000. SIZE - 10.00 X 16.00 INCHES

LEVEL

HEIGHT
BAR INFO
FROM
TO
ANCHOR
FT.
IN.
FT.
IN.
FT.
IN. STA END
--------------------------------------------------------------------1
0 + 2-5/8
2-NUM.10
0 + 0-0/0
20 + 0-0/0
YES YES
|----------------------------------------------------------------|
| CRITICAL POS MOMENT=
125.40 KIP-FT AT 10.00 FT, LOAD 1 |
| REQD STEEL= 2.48 IN2, ROW=0.0185, ROWMX=0.0214 ROWMN=0.0033 |
| MAX/MIN/ACTUAL BAR SPACING= 4.73/ 2.54/ 4.73 INCH
|
| BASIC/REQD. DEVELOPMENT LENGTH = 48.19/ 65.86 INCH
|
|----------------------------------------------------------------|
*** BAR SIZE CAN NOT BE MATCHED TO MEET ALL REQUIREMENTS.
REQD. STEEL = 2.795 IN2, MAX. STEEL PERMISSIBLE = 2.873 IN2
MAX NEG MOMENT =
138.00 KIP-FT, LOADING
1
*** BAR SIZE CAN NOT BE MATCHED TO MEET ALL REQUIREMENTS.
REQD. STEEL = 2.795 IN2, MAX. STEEL PERMISSIBLE = 2.873 IN2
MAX NEG MOMENT =
138.00 KIP-FT, LOADING
1
B E A M N O.

2 D E S I G N R E S U L T S - SHEAR

AT START SUPPORT - Vu= 46.75 KIP

PROVIDE NUM. 4
AT END SUPPORT - Vu= 46.75 KIP
PROVIDE NUM. 4

Vc= 17.08
BARS AT 3.4
Vc= 17.08
BARS AT 3.4

KIP
IN.
KIP
IN.

Vs= 37.93 KIP

C/C FOR 110. IN.
Vs= 37.93 KIP
C/C FOR 110. IN.

********************END OF BEAM DESIGN**************************

30. DESIGN COLUMN 1
====================================================================
C O L U M N

N O.

D E S I G N

R E S U L T S

FY - 60000 FC - 4000 PSI, RECT SIZE - 14.00 X 16.00 INCHES, TIED

AREA OF STEEL REQUIRED =

9.032 SQ. IN.

BAR CONFIGURATION
REINF PCT. LOAD LOCATION PHI
---------------------------------------------------------12 - NUMBER 8
4.232
1
(PROVIDE EQUAL NUMBER OF BARS ON EACH FACE)

END

0.700

********************END OF COLUMN DESIGN RESULTS********************

31. END CONC DESIGN

32. FINISH

NOTAS
STAAD-III reporta que no es capaz de encontrar un arreglo de varillas
conveniente que satisfaga los requerimientos de refuerzo para el momento
negativo en los dos extremos de la viga 2. Sin embargo, esto no significa
que sea imposible llegar a un arreglo de varillas. Cuando STAAD-III
busca un arreglo de varillas, utiliza solamente varillas del mismo tamao.
Empieza con el dimetro de varilla correspondiente al parmetro
MINMAIN. Si no es posible un arreglo con esa varilla, trata con el
siguiente dimetro mayor. Si se trata con todos los dimetros permisibles,
el programa reporta que no pudo llegar a un arreglo de varillas. Sin
embargo el usuario puede ser capaz de satisfacer los requerimientos si
mezcla varillas de diferentes dimetros. Por ejemplo, 3 # 11 varillas y 2 #
10 varillas pueden satisfacer los requerimientos. El programa no est
equipado con opciones para llegar a tales combinaciones de varillas.