Chair (roy): We will now begin formal session.

If all delegates will please take their seats, the rapporteur will begin roll call. Rapporteur (syarief): Before we begin roll call, allow me to clarify between the two possible and appropriate responses when your State is called: present and present and voting. Delegates who identify their status as present and voting are not permitted to abstain on any substantive vote while in this session of the committee. Instead, these delegates must vote strictly in favor of or in opposition to any motion before the committee. Timor leste : (angkat plakat) present and vote. Singapore : (angkat plakat) present and vote. Indonesia : (angkat plakat) present and vote. Rapporteur (syarief): For those delegates who may have arrived while the roll call was being taken, and whose attendance has not yet been recorded, please send a note forward to the dais to let us know of your arrival and voting status. Please be certain your States attendance has been recorded. Chairman (roy) : Are there any motions on the floor at this time? (tidak ada) Chairman (roy) : we will open the speakers list to begin deliberations upon setting the agenda. All those who would like to be placed on the speakers list, please raise your placards until your State has been recognized. (Chair recognizes States while rapporteur records their order) Chairman: If any additional members of the committee wish to be placed upon the speakers list, please send a note forward to the dais with an explanation in this regard. (belum ada respon) Chairman: Are there any motions on the floor at this time. (Singapore angkat plakat) Chairman : Singapore, do you have a poin or a motion? Singapore (bolor) : Thank you Mr. chairman We think that it might better we set up the list for the topics that were going to discuss today. Singapore was thought the problem of human resources is a topic that is ideal for being our first discussion in this forum.

Chairman : thank you delegate.. are there any other suggestions on what topics should we cover first? Timor leste : With respect to economic progress during this be the main reason that impedes us to go into membership of asean, we suggested that economic issues should be a top priority should discussion today. Chairman : thank you delegate.. decisions in order. are there any other suggestions on what topics should we cover first? (tidak ada) Chairman : Reporter going to read an arrangement of events at a meeting today and also the rules in this forum. Reppourter : This meeting will be divided into 4 motion, In the first motion we ' ve heard a speech as well as drawing up an agenda of our meeting of the wishes of east timor to join with asean. Before entering the next motion, I will read out the order of the issues we discuss in several phases, And details are as follows : After this we will be entering a second motion whereby this second motion, each delegation shall be given the opportunity to convey the main reasons and interests related to the theme of the meeting. And than we will go on the third motion, the third motion will be grouped into 3 sub_motion. each motion are the issues being the major problem that inhibits membership of East timor's status in asean. It is : The first we will discuss economic issues The second we will talk about progress east timor in security matter and the third is about the quality of human resources in east timor

After that the last motion we will formulate a draft containing the results of the meeting today. Chairman : we will begin debate by hearing general statement from each delegates. (first speaker on list is delegate from East Timor) The chair recognizes the delegate from the East Timor. You have two minutes to speak on this matter. Timor leste : Thank you Mr. chairman, Our desire to join ASEAN is a long-standing one and in the last 10 years we have shown unequivocal determination to join the organisation. Geographically, we are very much part of Southeast Asia. Indonesia has shown statesmanship, vision and a real sense of history by being among those who are most strongly advocating for Timor-Lestes early membership as early as this year. Malaysia, Thailand, Cambodia, Brunei, The Philippines, Cambodia and Myanmar have expressed public support. When I visited Cambodia a few weeks ago, we were told by Prime Minister Hun Sen that in preparation for Cambodias 2012 chairmanship of ASEAN, they are already making additional arrangements to accommodate Timor-Leste as the 11th member. Prime Minister Hun Sen

said in his usual straightforward way: If Indonesia is so supportive of Timor-Leste joining ASEAN now, why should any of us object? Even Myanmar has expressed support for an early membership in spite of our criticisms of the regimes human rights record. But Singapore, while agreeing with Timor-Lestes ASEAN membership, objects to early membership as, it argues, Timor-Leste is not yet ready to absorb the many challenges and complexities of ASEAN membership. Below I argue why Timor-Leste is ready to join ASEAN. Chairman : So general statement of delegates east timor. And then also i give chance for delegates singapore to convey general statement of their point of view. You have two minutes to speak on this matter. Singapore : Thank you Mr. Chairman.. As we know that East timor as the new country is still faced with various problems in his land, as state revenue from crude oil and gas the chief source of financing government expenditures timor-leste, poverty problem, financial, to limited human resources and still any disturbance resulting from horizontal conflicts. Various related the problem above, of course timor leste will face the challenges is that related confession ( consensus ) by asean, referring to the asean charter, article 6, paragraph 3, stating that the new members compulsory decided on consensus conference by high levels of asean, based on the recommendation asean coordinating council. Now therefore hindrance membership east timor in asean volatility caused by political security and economic problems and human resources east timor. Chairman : So general statement of delegates east timor. And then also i give chance for delegates singapore to convey general statement of their point of view. You have two minutes to speak on this matter. Indonesia : Thank you honorable chair.. Indonesia is also concerned with maintaining stability in the region include encourage acceptable. Indonesia think it is very important, because east timor is geographically adjacent to Indonesia so that the application of the various collaboration patterns, habits, and practices of intersate relations between ASEAN and east timor concering also. Was also right for the safe of regional stability as well. So it is something that is Indonesia is of interest to east timor in order to be part of the big family of ASEAN. Chairman : we will begin debate on the adoption of the agenda. According to general statement of delegations. The reporter has noted the points from exposure on this session. Before we are entering a motion next, expected to the delegations to discuss issues to be more specific. Chairman : As has been described by reporters in first motion, in this third motion will be more focused on against three sub-motion which is the major issues related to the theme of a discussion today. Every delegation will more be given a quota as many as 2 statement in any sub-motion. Chairman : we are now entering the 3rd motion with our 1st sub_motion that talking about economic issues. there any motions on the floor at this time? (Singapore angkat plakat)

Chairman : delegate from Singapore, you have 1st chance to speak on this matter. Singapore : Thank you Mr. Chairman.. economically, based on research conducted government and companies estimates for east timor annual revenues, petroleum the average state budget, a year from 2010-2049 timor leste has been pegged only by $ 1.25 billion course a year, already includes of total revenue in 2010-2049, oil and gas petroleum fund, and the possibility of income other existing ( and if any ) that compares with dipa province of ntt, which in 2010 has reached $ 1.2 billion. and in 2011 the number increases to $ 1.5 billion. Indonesia is lucky has a lot of income that is not depends only to oil and gas, that ' s why a fund for development countries will continue to rose precipitously from year to year. Try to imagine what 2049 in years to come? when the state budget of timor leste has been pegged only $ 1.25 billion. And the funds dipa 2021 nusa tenggara timur (ntt) for the year it will be estimated to reach $ 4 billion -- $ 5 billion more. It ' s just the comparison between nusa tenggara timur in 2021 and timor leste in 2049. Try to imagine what again, how things are timor leste and nusa tenggara timur (ntt) in the 2049? In the government timor leste who uses funds the construction of $ 1 billion ' ' for the year it has been right. And I think the plan timor leste to build the refinery in southern east timor, that ' s very hard to be realized considering up to hundreds of billions needed tens of billions of dollars for realizing an ambition that, unless the government timor leste bold tased, but ... the question ... what timor leste unable to pay the debt? Oil reserves course the year it will be reduced in number. Chairman : thank you delegate of Singapore, are there any respons according to this statement? (Timor leste dan Indonesia angkat plakat tapi timor leste yg dipilih) Chairman : delegate from Timor leste, you have the chance to respons this matter. Timor leste : Thank you Mr. Chairman, speaking about research in economics of Timor leste, we also have a scientific evidence can show that the economic growth of East timor. according to the latest UNDP report on 2011, timor leste's economic growth GNP/GNI per capita increased by 228 percent with close to US $ 5000. Timor-Leste has no foreign debt, and according to the 2010 pocket book from The Economist, Timor-Leste has the highest surplus in the world more than 280% as a percentage of GDP. Our economy continues to show strong growth for four consecutive years, and according to The Economist, Timor-Leste, including one among nine of the fastest growing economies in the world in 2011. Thank you. Chairman : thank you delegate of timor leste, is there any other motions on the floor? (semua angkat plakat, tp kesempatan jatuh ke Singapore) Chairman : delegate of Singapore, the floor is yours. Singapore : East Timor expect to exploit petroleum in the Timor Gap, but it seems difficult to get foreign exchange revenues in the Timor Gap because Australia had promised to East Timor with the authority of the management and the exploitation of Australia getting the 80% and the rest given to East Timor. Australia has also been opposing East Timor to be able to master the Timor gap in full, by way of stalling settlement of the border of the two countries. Although independent, East Timor is still very dependent

with the supply of goods from Indonesia starting from basic food to fuel (BBM) mainly through the East Nusa Tenggara province. Australia had tried to control the distribution of items of daily needs but failed because it was too expensive and less well-known people of Timor-Leste. In addition to the very subject politically to former colonist Portugal, Timor-Leste adopted the United States dollar as the currency that resulted in people's purchasing power is much decreased compared to when it was still a province of Indonesia. And this situation quite prove the unpreparedness of timor leste to face toward the dynamics of ASEAN community in 2015. Thank you.. (Indonesia angkat plakat) Chairman : delegate of Indonesia, you have a motion? Indonesia : yes honorable chair, thank you very much.. There is hope that such a big that project lng will excites economic activity in timor-leste overall, especially in areas surrounding facilities lng are. Any device to local administration elected leaders and traditional who is interviewed for manufacture this report express our hopes. On top of that, the people think that this project will create jobs for the local, either directly in facility development and kompleks port, or indirectly via high demand for goods and services that may be fervid presence project. Considering jobs is the main concern the people, we will discuss this topic on chapter following, including how many and job types probably invented. This proposition will be mengkaji-ulang akibat-akibat possible for some local economy and national. The potential of the mainspring for national economy come from stages of construction. Construction of pipelines gas liquefaction facilities and will absorb the cost of unusually large until billions of dollars. How big that can be entered in the economy timor-leste and provides a livelihood for its citizens? Considering the condition of development in timor-leste now, and almost able to be ascertained that all the materials and components needed for construction to be produced in foreign affairs and regional projects, are shipped into so that each a request for the activities of the local economy must not derived from work manufacturing, but from the process of construction itself, which is quite open of employment for the inhabitants of timor-leste. Timor Leste: However poor we are, but we have to provide humanitarian aid to countries rich and poor are affected by natural disaster. We have been providing cash assistance to victims of natural disaster in Indonesia, Myanmar, China, Madeira Island in Portugal, Haiti, brazil, and Australia, with a total of nearly $5 million in the last three years. During the last decade, unprecedented diplomatic incident or security issues with our neighbours. Relations with Indonesia, our nearest neighbor, with whom we directly borders both on land and sea, is an exemplary example. Chairman: Chairman thinks statements given already quite explain about our first sub _ motion. Decision in order. Raise your placard to give approvement. (placard diangkat semua) Chairman : we are now entering the second sub-motion of this meeting. in this sub-motion every delegate will discuss about the politics and security issues in timor leste. Are there any motion on this floor?

(timor leste dan singapore angkat plakat, chairman memilih Timor leste) Chairman : delegate of Timor leste, this your call for speak. Timor leste : thank you Mr. Chairman..We are proud of what we accomplished in the brief years since independence in 2002. We have a multi-party democracy with nine political parties who each have representatives in the national Parliament. Nearly 30 percent of elected members of Parliament are women, and some of the women of Timor-Leste has occupied several key positions in the Ministry portfolio. Timor-Leste was featured with a very liberal Constitution and humanist who banned the death penalty. We have ratified all major international agreements on human rights and the obligations we have reported about it. Timor-Leste, according to Reporters Without Borders, has one of the most free media for the Asia-Pacific region. We are very sensitive to the views of our neighbors on issues of regional and global, and always strive to make every step we do not deviate from the ASEAN view whenever there is aconcensus with regard to the situation of certain member states or thematic issues into the limelight with ASEAN. Our wriendly and pro-active with all the new force to be reckoned with, such as China, India, South Africa, and Brazil while maintaining a special relationship with Australia, New Zealand, Japan, Republic of Korea, the European Union and the United States, where Timor-Leste has always enjoyed supporta strong bi-partisan. Our main partners in the sustainable security is Indonesia, Australia, New Zealand, the U.S., Japan and Portugal. Australian and Portuguese instructors train our soldiers and officers; increase our Junior officers are all achieved through training in Australia, Indonesia, Japan, and Portugal. The Timor-Lestes police officers has helped and today there are still assigned to assist the UN in the Balkans and Africa. Within this close, a number of military engineers Timor-Leste will be deployed to Lebanon as part of an engineering unit army Portuguese. Dozens of our volunteers will assist the UN in Sierra Leone, Congo and Afghanistan. Thank you. Chairman: Thank you delegate. Are there any other country wants to give a response? (Singapore angkat plakat) Chairman: Singapore, you are allowed to speak. Singapore : Thank you Mr. Chairman.. Regional cooperation between asean now toward new phase more integratif fore and vision on by will formation of the asean community in 2015. In an outline, the asean 2015 community divides into three pillars, namely ASEAN political- security community. The vision of ASEAN is ASEAN as a concert of Southeast Asian Nations, outward looking, living in peace, stability and prosperity, bonded together in partnership in dynamic development and in a community of caring society. The establishment of an ASEAN community 2015 is based one of its pillars, namely the ASEAN Political Security Community aims at accelerating the political security in ASEAN cooperation to bring about peace in the region, including by the international community. In the plan of action of the ASEAN Political Security Community, has set out a plan of activities for the realization of the ASEAN Political Security Community which consists of six components: Political Development, Shaping and Sharing of Norms, Conflict Prevention, Conflict Resolution, Post Conflict Peace-Building, and Implementing Mechanism.

Chairman: Every delegate who wants to response, please raise your placard. (Timor leste dan Indonesia angkat plakat, yang dipilih timor leste..) Chairman: Yes, the chance given to Timor Leste. You are allowed to speak. Timor Leste: Thank you very much Mr.Chair, Since the upright standing as an independent and sovereign country in 2002, we have made every effort to harmonize the foreign policy and security with our ASEAN neighbours. For example, we support every ASEAN member countries in national nomination for the various positions in the United Nations and specialized agencies, including special programs, etc. We also include support in Singapore. We are very sensitive to the views of our neighbors on issues of regional and global issues, and always try to make every step we do not deviate from the ASEAN perspective whenever there is consensus as it relates to the situation of certain Member States or thematic issues are the center of attention along with the ASEAN. We are very friendly and proactive with all new force to be reckoned as china, india, south africa, and brazil while maintain special relations with australia, new zealand, japan, the republic of korea, the european union and the united states, where timor-leste always enjoy support bi-partisan strong. Our main partners sustainable in security is indonesia, australia, new zealand, us japan and portugal. Instructor portuguese australia and trains soldiers and his officers we; increase in officer young we all traveled through training in australia, indonesia japan and portugal. The police officer timor-leste has also help and currently, there are still on duty help united nation in the balkans and africa. Within this, near a number of engineers military timorleste will be deployed to lebanon as part of a unit of engineering Portuguese soldiers. Dozens of volunteers we are helping pbb in sierra leone, liberia, congo and afghanistan. Anywise poverty of us, but we have to provide humanitarian aid to the rich countries as well as poor affected by a natural disaster. We have given cash aid to the victims of natural disasters in indonesia myanmar, china, ( portugal ), the madeira islands haiti, brazil and australia with the equivalent of almost us $ 5 million in the last three years. This last decade, for 1 it has ever occurred incident diplomatic or security issues with our neighbors. Relations with indonesia our neighbors with whom we is directly adjacent both on land and the sea is an example worth diteladani. See a state treasury timor-leste and evidence about the ability of timor-leste in doing activity which regional and international, to reverberate timor-leste is ready to join the asean this year or next year. Seraiah admit that we are also still has many weaknesses and limitations. But asean can admit timor-leste now and offer the opportunity to us for five to ten years or so in the period of transition, where we will expand an attempt to catch up us from other asean that has been go up first. It is plausible, in line with asean practice in the past in relation to the new members and in line with european union practices in recognition of similar things, especially in favor of new members until the state concerned able to fulfill obligations in organization. A fellow member of asean nothing to worry about the cost of financial where timor-leste will never burdensome by asking economic or financial support, Thank you. Chairman: Thank you delegate of East Timor. Are there any other points or motions? (Singapore dan Indonesia angkat plakat, yang dipilih Singapore) Chairman: Singapore, your motion please.

Singapore : Thank you Mr.Chair.. We do agree with the last East Timors motion. Nevertheless, security political stability in the long run be the main agendas that remain questionable. Besides, the perception associated political instability and security will participate affect national economic development. It is related to the historical record indicating for ten years after independence in 2002, timor leste as new state diterpa internal problems continue to threaten the security and destructive image as a democratic. Examine political dynamics security in east timor was currently still young and fragile in government institutions and very prone to conflict, could hinder efforts and potentially retargets embodiment 2015, the community especially on pillars security political community that aims to accelerate asean political security cooperation in asean countries in the region to make peace in the world peace and widely democratic, in the environment fair, and harmonious surely be serious consideration for asean member states to receive membership timor leste today, Thank you. (Indonesia angkat plakat) Chairman: Yes Indonesia, your motion allowed to be offered. Indonesia : Thank you honorable Chair. In General, political security situation in East Timor is currently experiencing relative conditions more conducive and stable. There is a growing consensus on what is needed for the settlement of the political crisis, including the reform of the security sector. The meeting is living I and II, spearheaded by the Bishop of the Diocese of Baucau, Dom Basilio do Nascimento and. President Ramos Horta, by involving the leaders of the political parties aimed at finding solutions together for the creation of peace and stability to meet the presidential and parliamentary elections in 2012. This indicates a positive progress for the creation of a democratic and secure atmosphere in East Timor, Thank you. Chairman: motion from indonesia just close our second sub-motion session. Now the decision is in order. Raise your placard to move to next section. Chairman : now were going to talk about the final issues about human resource and development and this is our last section in this third motion. Every delegates who wants to be the first speaker please raise your placard. (Singapore and Timor leste angkat plakat, timor leste dipilih) Timor Leste: in 2011, the human development index in Timor-Leste for the year 2010 is 0.502, this means fall into the category of medium in human development. In 2005, the human development index was 0.428 and early independence in 2002 is 0.375. We have moved ahead of several old members of ASEAN, such as Cambodia, Laos and Myanmar, and Viet Nam were behind only to human development. From 169 countries, Timor-Leste is in the ranking of 120 over Laos (122), Cambodia (124) and Myanmar (132). Timor-Leste is also ranked higher than Papua New Guinea (137) and most of the countries of subSaharan Africa; especially Kenya (128), Nigeria (142), Angola (146) and Mozambique (165). School enrollment jumped sharply from 63 percent in 2006 to 82,7 percent by 2009. Some areas, such as oecusse densely populated areas manatuto and atauro in the past two years has been free illiterate. In short, timor-leste would be exempt from illiteracy in the year 2015. Child mortality and the death of

infants under the age of five years likewise, the mortality rate after childbirth has been reduced by half. Malarial disease, scarlatina and poverty has declined significantly in the past four years. According to the who timor-leste, with 1 case per 10,000 people, the disease of leprosy now been declared free of disease that has been berbilang this century. 2005-2010, undp report shows life expectancy of any human child birth in timor-leste have increased in the past two years with an average 62,1 years. In the same period of the gnp / pnb per capita increased by 228 percent with the achievement of us $ 5,000. Singapore: Previously we want to suggest a research results in the form of the following table (tunggu tabel di bukakan oleh sekertaris di proyektor)... As we see, The essence of development at virtually is the effort to improve the quality of man sees of various dimensions. Based on human development index on a table by way of meant that the rating welfare of timor leste is at an order of 147 of 187 countries. Compared with asean member countries, Timor Leste ranks far behind and being with Myanmar on the Low Human Development, Thank you. Indonesia: ASEAN as a regional organisation entity Southeast Asia collectively have achieved significant progress in their cooperation in a number of areas of political, economic, socio-culture that developed and transformed into one of the most successful regional organization in the world. For East Timor, ASEAN has an important meaning and becomes a strategic potential in regional cooperation. TimorLeste's desire to join ASEAN ASEAN position indicates that the more solid in playing its action through regional cooperation. By being part of ASEAN, Timor-Leste will have ample opportunity for its contribution to regional and world peace as well as good a chance in its international relations. We draw conclusions regarding barriers to East Timor obtain the status of full membership of ASEAN is based on political and security issues, economic issues and human resources of East Timor. Political issues related to security, the new State of East Timor is considered particularly vulnerable to conflict and violence due to disagreements on the national political elite. History notes that since its independence in 2002, the escalation of conflicts in East Timor continued to rise until the attacks against national leaders of East Timor's Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao and the shooting of Timor Leste's President Jose Ramos-Horta on February 11, 2008 incident. In addition, Timor-Leste is also still facing economic problems and its human resources. This concept based on economic development east timor appertain low and the readiness of human resources at the moment is still be limited, so regarded can retard the launching of the formation of asean economic community 2015. This is one attention and consideration for asean member states to give confession ( consensus ) related the desire of east timor joined asean. Nevertheless, considering geographically, strategic and economy, membership east timor in asean is one important part in southeast asia. Efforts its trade with asean member not just to give economic profit timor leste merely, but also contributed in asean. Volatility political security and economic timor leste will affect negatively towards a goal launched by asean, namely peace, stability and prosperity in south east asia. Therefore, we are optimistic the domestic political problems of security, economic development and human resources, would not become barriers that impede konsensusnya. This argument is based on the fact that ASEAN has a similar experience when receiving ASEAN member countries (CLMV) are vulnerable to political security and economic problems in the country are classified as the poorest countries in the world.thank you..

Chairman : honorable delegates, we have put an end to the third motion, and now we are entering the last motion of this conference by listening to the reading of a draft resolution on the status of East timor's membership in ASEAN by the Secretary. (Chairman pura-pura berbisik menanyakan kesiapan draft resolusi dengan sekretaris) Secretary : Recognizing the importance for east timor to boost progress in the field of economic, political, security and human resources before deciding to join the asean members, as well as see the experience of East timor is facing the international dynamics with the status as a country that belongs to the young, then felt the need to put forward a number of recommendations as to the solution, including : 1. It is reasonably necessary for east timor to increase their intensity in world level activities to improve the experience in facing challenges and dynamics of international. 2. in order to face the asean community 2015, felt the important for east timor to review and increase their national security and economic before deciding to join ASEAN. 3. Decision on membership status of east timor still needs to review and will be studied and discussed in a meeting between all the Member States that will be decided at the next meeting. Chairman : According to the draft resolution which had been read out, does anyone like to demur or give their input? . If no one wants delivered again, every delegate is expected to forward their willingness to sign the draft resolution on the dais as a sign of agreement of each country. (tiap-tiap delegasi maju untuk tanda tangan draft resolusi) Chairman : Thanks to all delegations for your participation in this meeting. in the spirit of ASEAN integration, this Conference is officially closed (chairman ketok palu 3 kali)

I THINK!!! ITS DONE .