Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Hydrophilic polymers that bind to mucin or epithelial surfaces are becoming valu-
able in drug delivery as they can reduce bioavailability problems resulting from a too
short residence time of the dosage form at the action or absorption site (1). These poly-
mers, by localizing the dosage form at a specific site where mucus is present, like buccal
or nasal cavity, stomach and intestine, bladder or vagina and by decreasing the release
rate of the drug, will also ensure patient compliance by reducing dose, frequency of ad-
ministration and ultimately drug-side effects (1). In this respect, monolithic matrix for-
* This paper has been presented at Alexandria Second International Conference of Pharmaceutical Sciences and
Technology, October 25–27, 2000.
** Correspondence, e-mail: amalelkamel@yahoo.com
171
A. H. El-Kamel et al.: Bioadhesive controlled release metronidazole vaginal tablets, Acta Pharm. 52 (2002) 171–179.
mulations are of particular interest, since if rigid enough, their structural integrity will
not be disrupted by the swelling and hydration that normally occurs to the mucus adhe-
sive component (2).
Metronidazole is an important active substance that has been widely and success-
fully used for over 37 years in the treatment of some protozoal and anaerobic bacterial
infections. For cases that persist after oral treatment and where resistant trichomonads
are suspected, a combination of oral and topical therapy may be effective. Moreover, in
clinical circumstances where low systemic levels would be desirable, e.g. in pregnancy,
topical treatment might be indicated. On the other hand, mucoadhesive vaginal tablets
are easily used and may stay day and night, compared to other conventional forms like
vaginal creams (3). A mucoadhesive tablet of metronidazole intended for local applica-
tion in the vagina has been previously developed using Carbopol 934 and HPMC K4M
mixture (4). Bouckaert et al. (5) reported that there was no significant difference in clini-
cal efficacy after application of a single vaginal metronidazole bioadhesive tablet com-
pared to a standardized oral treatment. The bioadhesive matrix consisted of modified
starch/polyacrylic acid mixture.
In a continuing investigation, this work aims to formulate metronidazole tablets to
adhere to the vagina for an adequate time and to maintain sustained drug release by an
easy, simple, nonexpensive method.
EXPERIMENTAL
Materials
Metronidazole powder (Pharco Pharm. Ind., Egypt), sodium caboxymethylcellulose
(NaCMC), hydroxypropylmethylcellulose (HPMC) and methylcellulose (MC) (BDH
Chemicals Ltd, UK), Carbopol 934 (The BF Goodrich Company, USA) and N-acetyl-L-
cysteine (AC) (Duncan, UK) were used. All other chemicals are of analytical or pharma-
ceutical grade.
Methods
Preparation of tablets. – All powders were sieved and fractions corresponding to par-
ticle size range 100–315 mm were used for tablets preparation. Tablets containing 20%
metronidazole were prepared by direct compression of powder mixture using flat face 9
or 12 mm punch (Erweka single punch tablet machine, Germany).
In vitro release studies. – The drug release rate was determined using USP dissolu-
tion apparatus II (6) (Hanson Research Corp., USA). A tablet was glued in the center of 9
cm diameter glass disc. Dissolution medium was 650 mL of either distilled water or ci-
trate buffer pH 4.8 maintained at 37 ± 0.1 °C and stirred at 25 rpm. Sample (5 mL) was
withdrawn at suitable time intervals, compensated with fresh dissolution medium and
assayed spectrometrically (Ultrospec III, Pharmacia LKB Biochrom, UK) at 319 nm. No
interference occurred due to tablet excipients or to cyanoacrylate glue at this wave-
length. Samples were assayed in triplicate.
172
A. H. El-Kamel et al.: Bioadhesive controlled release metronidazole vaginal tablets, Acta Pharm. 52 (2002) 171–179.
Swelling study. – The swelling index for placebo and medicated tablets was deter-
mined in buffer pH 4.8 at 37 ± 0.1 °C after 0.25, 0.5, 1, 2 and 4 hours (7).
Swelling index of MC tablets could not be measured due to complete dissolution of
the tablets. Each experiment was performed in triplicate.
Bioadhesion study. – The balance method (7) was adopted to measure bioadhesion
properties with some modifications. A rabbit intestine was dissected and placed in nor-
mal saline after being washed from all food debris. The intestine was cut into 5 cm
length parts and adhered to a moving platform with cyanoacrylic glue; placebo and me-
dicated tablets were glued to different weights (1, 2, 5 and 10 g). This was followed by
taring the balance. A volume (0.1 mL) of either buffer pH 4.8 or 0.1 mol L–1 N-acetyl-
cysteine in water was slowly added by means of plastic syringe over the mucus mem-
brane. The platform was slowly raised till the tablet touched the mucosa and left in con-
tact for 15 minutes, after which the balance was retared and corresponding weights were
added on the pan. The addition stopped upon the detachment of the tablet from mu-
cosa. The equivalent adhesion force was then calculated in g cm–2. Each adhesion experi-
ment was repeated six times.
Dissolution rate
Results of the release study of metronidazole in water and in buffer pH 4.8, from the
various polymeric matrices containing a single polymer, are shown in Fig. 1.
In general, the release rate was higher in water than in buffer pH 4.8, except for tab-
lets containing MC. Based on dissolution efficiency calculated for all formulations after
7 h (DE, %), the release rank order in water was as follows: MC (63.5%) > NaCMC
(45.4%) > Carbopol (37.8%) > HPMC (18.6%), while in buffer pH 4.8 it was: MC (78.8%)
> Carbopol (34.1%) > NaCMC (27.8%) > HPMC (19.7%). Concerning the nonionic poly-
a) b)
100 100
80 80
Drug released (%)
60 60
40 40
20 20
0 0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Time (h) Time (h)
Fig. 1. Metronidazole release profile from different tablet formulations containing single polymer
in: a) distilled water b) buffer pH 4.8. HPMC (D), NaCMC (£), MC (×) and Carbopol (¯). Error
bars represent SD (n = 3).
173
A. H. El-Kamel et al.: Bioadhesive controlled release metronidazole vaginal tablets, Acta Pharm. 52 (2002) 171–179.
mer, methylcellulose, the release pattern in both media studied was high. This may be
due to the inability of the polymer to surround the drug particles under the compression
conditions used. In water, nearly 40% release of the drug was observed in the first 2
hours (Fig. 1a). Methylcellulose hydrates on contact with water forming a gel layer at
the surface of the tablet, causing the tablet to expand. It has been observed that the gel-
lified layer formed after hydration of this polymer does not adhere well to the tablet but
is detached rapidly even with a moderate agitation (8). This is followed by the formation
of fresh surface and subsequent removal of gel barrier. On the other hand, in acidic me-
dium, owing to some protonation of ether linkages, a decrease in tortuosity of the hy-
drated film leads to a more rapid drug release than in water (9).
The lowest drug release rate was obtained with HPMC in both media. HPMC
builds up, after its dissolution, an excessively viscous gel around the tablet. This is more
resistant to water penetration and erosion. Dissolved drug is released by diffusion
through the viscous gel. Since the erosion rate of the swollen gel is slow compared with
the rate of advance of the swelling front into the glassy tablet core, the diffusional path-
length for the drug might increase with time, thus causing the release rate to decrease
(10).
Being a polyelectrolyte, NaCMC is very sensitive to the presence of ions. It has been
reported that NaCMC network structure is looser in distilled water than in presence of
salts. Also, at pH 4.8 ionization of carboxylic group of NaCMC decreases – pKa @ 3 (8).
This affects polymer chain conformation and polymer network structure becomes tight-
er. Therefore, the release rate in buffer pH 4.8 is expected to be slower than in water.
Since the aim of the work is to obtain adequate release of the drug, it is thought to
prepare formulae containing mixture of NaCMC (fast drug release) and HPMC (slow
drug release) in different ratios. Taking DE % as a parameter, the following sequence
was observed in water for NaCMC to HPMC ratios: 4:1 (38.1%) ³ 2:1 (38.2%) > 1:1 (23.4%),
whereas in buffer pH 4.8, the sequence was: 1:1 (29.4%) > 2:1 (27.5%) > 4:1 (20.3%).
It has been reported that there is interaction between NaCMC and HPMC due to
formation of hydrogen bond that will hinder the swelling of CMC (11). Also, the relax-
ation of NaCMC chain will be restricted in presence of another polymer (HPMC). This
will decrease erosion of NaCMC and at the same time prevent the increase in the dif-
fusional pathlength of HPMC. Intermediate drug release between either HPMC or
NaCMC-metronidazole tablets, was observed from the matrix containing 2:1 NaCMC
and HPMC in both media.
Drug release from Carbopol 934 was higher at pH 4.8 than that from NaCMC ma-
trix (Fig. 1b). At pH 4.8 Carbopol will be less ionized than NaCMC. So, the opportunity
of formation of hydrogen bond with the drug will be less than in case of NaCMC, lead-
ing to higher release of the former. Conversely, in water drug release from Carbopol was
lower than that from NaCMC (Fig. 1a). It was reported for Carbopol that there are acid
weakening inductive effects of ionized carboxylate residues that affect the ionization po-
tential of neighbouring groups (12). This may lead to high coiling and proximity of
carboxylic groups leading to intramolecular hydrogen bonding. The cross linking of
Carbopol affects also elasticity of the chains as water penetrates inside the polymer net-
work and this leads to entrapment of the drug inside the cross linked network of the
polymer (12).
174
A. H. El-Kamel et al.: Bioadhesive controlled release metronidazole vaginal tablets, Acta Pharm. 52 (2002) 171–179.
The mode of drug release from the prepared tablets was calculated using the fol-
lowing equation: Mt/M¥ = k tn (13), where Mt/M¥ is the fraction of the solute release
into dissolution medium, k is a constant which is related to the properties of the polymer
and drug, n is the diffusional exponent. The values of n for all the formulations tested in
both dissolution media were calculated (Table I). In general, the release behavior was
non-Fickian with values of n varying from 0.633 to 0.984 for buffer pH 4.8, while they
ranged from 0.665 to 0.868 in case of water. Values of 0.5 < n < 1.0 indicate an anomalous
(non-Fickian or coupled diffusion-relaxation) drug release (13). Correlation coefficients
calculated according to zero-order or Higuchi square root of time equation, indicated
that the in general release approximated more probably the zero-order than the Higuchi
model.
Table I. Estimated values of k and n obtained by regression of log Mt/M¥ vs. log ta,b
n k
Formula
Buffer pH 4.8 Water Buffer pH 4.8 Water
CP934 0.702 ± 0.017 0.810 ± 0.020 0.733 ± 0.005 0.365 ± 0.030
NaCMC 0.714 ± 0.015 0.840 ± 0.008 0.530 ± 0.040 0.270 ± 0.008
HPMC 0.633 ± 0.015 0.665 ± 0.010 0.783 ±0.015 0.590 ± 0.090
MC 0.984 ± 0.030 0.832 ± 0.020 0.935 ± 0.080 0.609 ± 0.039
NaCMC : HPMC (1:1) 0.738 ± 0.020 0.792 ± 0.015 0.494 ± 0.020 0.251 ± 0.010
NaCMC : HPMC (2:1) 0.707 ± 0.018 0.868 ± 0.025 0.550 ± 0.010 0.267 ± 0.010
NaCMC : HPMC (4:1) 0.725 ± 0.015 0.846 ± 0.030 0.352 ± 0.008 0.208 ± 0.010
a From the relation: Mt/M¥ = k tn
(ref. 13).
b Results are expressed as mean ± SD (n = 3).
175
A. H. El-Kamel et al.: Bioadhesive controlled release metronidazole vaginal tablets, Acta Pharm. 52 (2002) 171–179.
which was formed soon as the polymer swelled and opposed the fluid entrance via blo-
cking the existing pores (16). In the case of tablets prepared from mixtures of NaCMC
and HPMC there was no significant difference in swelling index neither between the
prepared mixture formulations nor between the mixture formulations and each polymer
alone.
Modified balance method was used to measure the bioadhesion of the prepared for-
mulae (7). The obtained rank order for the bioadhesive force measured at room tempera-
ture was as follows: NaCMC > Carbopol > HPMC > MC for both medicated and placebo
tablets. Generally, the adhesion force was directly proportional to the applied weight
(Fig. 2). This could be due to establishment of an intimate contact between the muco-
adhesive polymer and the mucus gel (17). Sodium carboxymethylcellulose can increase
surface charge density of the tablet. Moreover, the carboxylic group can form hydrogen
bonds with tissue. In addition, NaCMC tablet has initial faster hydration rate that pro-
motes interpenetration of the polymer chain with the tissue (18). All these factors have
no doubt contributed to higher bioadhesive strength of NaCMC tablets. Carbopol being
mostly unionized at pH 4.8 and containing numerous proton-donating carboxylic groups,
can form hydrogen bonds with the negatively charged mucus gel following the forma-
tion of physical entanglements (19). Mortazavi and Smart (20) have reported the forma-
tion of intermolecular complexes between the glycoprotein and Carbopol 934 molecules.
It has been reported that even the ionized part of Carbopol has bioadhesion force. Ion-
ization of Carbopol results in diminishing the intramolecular hydrogen bonds and gen-
erates a stretched cylindrical shape, which is then more able to penetrate a mucin net-
work than the coil form of unionized Carbopol (21). The adhesion force of HPMC was
found to be less than that of NaCMC and Carbopol. This could be due to formation of
thick and viscous-swollen gel. This gel is not continuous, forming localized pockets of
polymer (22).
100
80
Adhesion force (g cm–2)
60
40
20
Fig. 2. Adhesion force measured for
medicated tablets containing single
0 polymer: HPMC (¯), NaCMC (£),
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 MC (D) and Carbopol (×). Error bars
Applied mass (g) rapresent SD (n = 6).
Methylcellulose tablets exhibited the least adhesion force. This may be due to dis-
ruption of structural integrity of the matrix (2). The results of measurement of adhesion
force are in agreement with those of Ch’ng et al. (23) and Rao and Buri (24), who re-
176
A. H. El-Kamel et al.: Bioadhesive controlled release metronidazole vaginal tablets, Acta Pharm. 52 (2002) 171–179.
ported that the polyanions like Carbopol 934 and NaCMC adhere strongly to the mucus
compared to the nonionic polymers like MC and HPMC. Generally, the adhesion force
of medicated tablets was higher than that of placebo ones. This may be due to possible
formation of hydrogen bond between drug and mucus. Fig. 3 showed the adhesion force
measured for tablets prepared from HPMC and NaCMC either alone or in mixture of
different ratios and at applied weight of one gram. The adhesion force increased with in-
crease of NaCMC content. The formulation which contains NaCMC : HPMC 2:1 showed
reasonable adhesion properties relative to that of NaCMC tablets while it is much supe-
rior to that of HPMC tablets.
12
10
Adhesion force (g cm )
–2
Table II. Adhesion force of medicated HPMC tablets in the presence and in the absence of
N-acetylcysteine (AC)
177
A. H. El-Kamel et al.: Bioadhesive controlled release metronidazole vaginal tablets, Acta Pharm. 52 (2002) 171–179.
CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES
1. A. Ahuja, K. Khar and J. Ali, Mucoadhesive drug delivery systems, Drug Dev. Ind. Pharm. 23
(1997) 489–515.
2. J. D. Smart, Some formulation factors influencing the rate of drug release from bioadhesive ma-
trices, Drug Dev. Ind. Pharm. 18 (1992) 223–232.
3. C. Dollery, Therapeutic drugs, Churchill Livingstone, Edinburg 1999, pp. M146–M151.
4. F. Lejoyeux, G. Ponchel, D. Wouessidjewe, N. A. Peppas and D. Duchêne, Bioadhesive tablets:
influence of the testing medium composition on bioadhesion, Drug Dev. Ind. Pharm. 15 (1989)
2037–2048.
5. S. Bouckaert, M. Temmerman, J. Voorspoels, H. Vankets, J. P. Remon and M. Dhont, Preliminary
efficacy study of a bioadhesive vaginal metronidazole tablets in the treatment of bacterial va-
ginosis, J. Pharm. Pharmacol. 47 (1995) 970–971.
6. USP XXIII, The United States Pharmacopeial Convention, Rockville 1995.
7. B. Parodi, E. Russo, G. Caviglioli, S. Cafaggi and G. Bignardi, Development and characteriza-
tion of a buccoadhesive dosage form of oxycodone hydrochloride, Drug Dev. Ind. Pharm. 22
(1996) 445–450.
8. P. P. Buri and E. Doelker, Formulation des comprimés à libération prolongée II. Matrices hydro-
philes, Pharm. Acta Helv. 55 (1980) 189–196.
9. H. Lapidus and N. G. Lordi, Some factors affecting the release of a water-soluble drug from a
compressed hydrophilic matrix, J. Pharm. Sci. 55 (1966) 840–843.
10. S. K. Baveja, K. V. R. Rao and K. P. Devi, Zero-order release hydrophilic matrix tablets of b-adre-
nergic blockers, Int. J. Pharm. 39 (1987) 39–45.
11. C. V. Walker and J. I. Wells, Rheological synergism between ionic and non-ionic cellulose gums,
Int. J. Pharm. 11 (1982) 309–322.
12. W. N. Charman, D. P. Christy, E. P. Geunin and D. C. Monkhous, Interaction between calcium, a
model divalent cation, and range of polyacrylic acid resins as a function of solution pH, Drug
Dev. Ind. Pharm. 17 (1991) 271–280.
13. N. A. Peppas, Analysis of Fickian and non Fickian drug release from polymers, Pharm. Acta
Helv. 60 (1985) 110–111.
14. H. Kurahashi, H. Kami and H. Sunada, Influence of physicochemical properties on drug release
rate from hydroxypropylmethylcellulose matrix tablets, Chem. Pharm. Bull. 44 (1996) 829–832.
15. R. Shrivastava, S. R. Jain and S. G. Frank, Dissolution dialysis studies of metronidazole-mont-
morillonite adsorbate, J. Pharm. Sci. 74 (1985) 214–216.
16. L. S. C. Wan, P. W. S. Heng and L. F. Wong, The effect of hydroxypropyl-methylcellulose on wa-
ter penetration into a matrix system, Int. J. Pharm. 73 (1991) 111–116.
17. D. Duchêne, F. Touchard and N. A. Peppas, Pharmaceutical and medicinal aspects of bioadhe-
sive systems for drug administration, Drug Dev. Ind. Pharm. 14 (1988) 283–318.
18. K. K. Peh and C. F. Wong, Polymeric films as vehicle for buccal delivery: swelling, mechanical,
and bioadhesive properties, J. Pharm. Pharmceut. Sci. 2 (1999) 53–61.
178
A. H. El-Kamel et al.: Bioadhesive controlled release metronidazole vaginal tablets, Acta Pharm. 52 (2002) 171–179.
S A @ E TA K
179