Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Why consolidation may not add value but may increase cost
By LAWRENCE P, CAFASSO When New York-area and other hospitals faced severe revenue shortfalls even as their expenses climbed precipitously, many responded with mergers and acquisitions. But as New York institutions combined their operations and centralized administrative and other functions under a single, corporate structure, a question has arisen: Has the corporate office really added value, or has it simply added more overhead? As part of cost-cutting strategies, newly merged hospitals tend to remove core functions including treasury, billing, insurance, finance, budget and reimbursement, managed care, internal audit, human resources and IT from the local institutions, and instead centralize them at the corporate level. When carefully planned, this approach may be effective for many industries. But before implementing a strategy of consolidation, top management should consider .what the benefits would be, if any, to the individual institutions as well as to the hospital system as a whole. If core functions are consolidated at the corporate level, will they bring true savings, or merely reallocate costs, possibly burdening individual hospitals with additional overhead? The case for maintaining billing at the local level is pretty straight forward: cash is king. It is obvious that a hospital needs to have control of, and timely access to, billing and revenue collection, especially in light of the cutbacks that have accompanied the migration to managed care. When the billing/receivables function is centralized, follow-up and other collections activities may take longer, star\'ing institutions of the cash they need to stay alloat while burdening them with additional overhead costs. To speed the process, hospitals may wish to' consider standardizing policies and procedures for (he svstem as a whole, while maintaining implementation and selected. accountability at the local level. Process - To achieve merger-related The case for maintaining IT functions at cost reductions and process improvethe local level may appear to be less con- ments, the post-merger integration should vincing, especially in today's networked focus on the detailed processes of the cenenvironment. But in fact it's not so sim- tralization. It may also be important to ple. If all of local IT systems were com- ensure that people with expertise in pletely integrated, then it might make process mapping and reengineering are available. However, in many health care sen.se to centralize the function. Similarly, while efficiencies may be business combinations, these skills are not realized by centralizing an IT system. But resident. in most cases, it should be noted that each Technology - Moving to a common hospital has might have its own unique hardware and software platform is essenlegacy system. Attempting to use software tial tp maximizing the value of functional and other "patches" to mold disparate sys- integration. Such a strategy facilitates tems into one holistic network may actu- process change and increases the cross ally result in greater inefficiency, since utilization of staff. precious labor hours are u.sed up trying to Measurement and Goal Setting - Even link them together. Instead, a uniform when effective centralized decisions are standard should be established and imple- made in the "people, process and technolmented across the system. ogy"' segments, accountability must be Some areas, however, do lend them- established between the local business selves to con.solidation. While some of the owners and the corporate administration. benefits of consolidation such as a reducEstablishing appropriate goals or servtion in redundant tasks are obvious, other ice line agreements, measuring against examples of significant savings may not those goals, and rewarding accordingly be quite as obvious. can achieve this. Leveraging costs by centralizing the .As hospital administrations are presinternal atidit function, for example, may sured to improve iheir financial returns, it help to attract lop talent, and bring value is imporlanl to consider all the issues and to local institutions. ramifications of a particular approach, to However, there are additional chal- help ensure that any gains realized al the lenges to achieving true post-merger inte- "corporate level will not come at the gration value. The failures usually fall expense of individual insiiiutions. inio one of the following four areas: Lawrence P. Ccifasso is Senior Vice People - Often, administrative and other President and Chief Operating Officer of appoinlmenis are intluenced by politics Catskill Regional Medical Center and forinsiead of bringing in a qualified outsider mer Senior Partner in Charge & to run a large ci)mple\ centralized service .Assurance Business Development Leader. I'unction. a "connected"" individual who Morthcdsi Health Care and Public Sector mav not have ihe needed skills is instead Practice. KPMGLLC
What is Stress? Is stress tlie resiili ot some mechanical force or strain to be measured, for example, by a scientist or engineer'.' Or is stress sometliing less concrete, say a feeling or state of mind thai we ex[x.'rience in various situations? Having experienced life for yourself yt)u know that stress is tx)(h of tliese tilings. Stress is both physical iind mental or emotional. Wliether physical stress results from ihe pull of gravity (hence the weight of our Ixxly) or from the presstire of the surrounding atmosphere, as F^irtli dwellers our ixxJies Doctor are always under some form ol' stress, strain, tension or pressure. L'nder enough physical stress we bend. Too much physical stress and we breaki Altliough physical stress is certainly interesting lo studs. the crux of this article centers about mental and emotional suvss and some of tlie useful methods for managing or coping witli sta'ss in the workplace and elsewhere in our lives. Ciood or "Positive" stress versus bad or "Negative" stress Dr. Hiuis Selye, a pioneer in stress research noted, "Witliout su"ess. there would be no life." Selye noticed that noi all stress is bad. that there ;ire gtx)d or "posiiive" stresses lor "stressors" a word he coined), which promoted wellness along with bad or "negative"' stresses thai caused distress and thai also might encourage illness. Selye alsn roali/ecl thai individuals dii'fered in their ca|xicii\ ic endure siress. We all know of |x.'o|ilc uho ap|X\ir 10 thrive tinder stress and al le\ eK IIKII would Ivnd or break many of us. W'hal miis Iv a bad or negali\e siressur for one |vrsoM nia\ bo a gixxJ or |iusiii\e sire.ssor Idi anoiher |X'rson. Ttierefore, il reall\ boils doun ic ihe |x:rson. ihe iy(v of stress (siiossor) and ilklevel of siress ihai ihe person feels conifunahle wiih thai dictates whether iho suvss is giH>d or bad. Whai is giHid for the gixisc is noi ncccssai ily also gcKxl for ihe gaiidei. This slighi alihough |K)ignani nKHlillcaiion nl a laniiliai proverb leads me to mention ihat woniun b\ mosi accounts appear lo handle siress lieiier ilian do men. Lcnik al an\ actuarial table on moiialilN rales Iviween men and WHIIICM and il is tuuispiuent tliat women, un average, oui-
li\e men. Studies conducted by Professor Shelley E. Taylor ai UCLA suggest that siressed-out women are more likely to seek ihe s(x:ial support of ottiei>i than ;ire stresseduut men when it comes lo dealing witli stress. It appears that most men have yei to "see Ihe light" on this issue luid continue lo indulge in typical "Tighi-or-night'" behavior when confronled with stress. It is the .'\merican physiologist Walter Bradford Cannon "(1871-1945) who is credited wilh the idea of the "tight or night"' response. Bones Stress can be $tre$$
Employers are becoming painfully aware of the many ways in which iiH) much negative su-ess or "StreSS" in the workplace is becoming more and more costly ($S) to business: S-accidents, $-absenleeism, S-employee tumover, S-reduced productivity, .S-medical insurance costs, $-legal bills, .S-workers' compensation. Stress management in the workplace not only makes good sense from a health pers(x;clive il makes good business Sensel Managing or coping with negative stress IX.niling wiih stress is clearly a [Tersonal issue Ixnh in tlie lype of sire.ss and the level of stress. For example, a negalive siressor for one |x."rson may be a posiiive siressor for another person. Levels of stress tlial would ovenvhelm one |X"rson may in fact Ix.* quite uilenible for another |vr.son. .Although u e caniioi eliminate negative stress from our life we cenainlv c;ui find useful ways of managing il lo acceptable levels. What works for one person may or may lml work for another |x.'rson. Hxercise - is a trieil and irtie w ay lo get iicgaiive or "bad"' stress under control. Build up your body, not your fiiisiraiions. Keep a regular schedule of exercise so thai ii is somelhing thai \ou can coiini on as well as look forward to. Nothing complicaled hero. You don'l need to join a heallh club I unless you wani lo). Jtisi llnd a caloriehuniing acii\it\ ihat gels you nKning and cnjoNing life. Tr\ to keep il fun. Remember III warm up and cool down.
A N T
health a n d housing solutions Providing a full range of services for older adults and chronically ill people of all ages throughout the Hudson 'Valley.
Nursing Homes Short-term Rehabilitation Services Adult Day Services Adult Homes Assistive Living Retirement Community Living AlTordable Housing At-Homc Serv ices
"Thanks to Elant. mv wife and I can ,i,v) to work with the peace of mind that Pop is enjoyinii his day - safely."
1-800-501-3936
See MANAGING STRESS page 33-
WEEKLY Planmr
Defensive Driving Course Mav 7 MIDDLETOWN - The six-hour dclcnsivc driving course which offers participatus a lO'i liiscouni on ihcir auto insurance liahilli> imJ colMsion premiums for 36 nu)nlh> ami also removes up to 4 points from drivint: recortls will he offered at Orange Counts Comnnmit> College at the main campus in MiddleiovMi from 9 a.m. to 3:.1O p.m. in ihe Bio-Tech Building, Room 203. For more information ov register electronically, visit www.sunyorange.edu/cape. To register in person: Registration Ofllce on the third floor of the College Commons at the Middletown campus at 1 LS South Street, or call 845-.341-4892. Cardiac Screening May 7 Vassar Brothers Medical Center along with The Hudson Valley Heart Center are offering free cardiac screenings on from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.. in Vassar's Cardiac Catheterization Laboratory Holding Area. Poughkeepsic. Open to the public, the screenings are tor Peripheral Arterial Disease (PAD) and Blood Pressure/Hypertension. For more information or to schedule an appointment, call 483-644 L "Walk- in'.s" are aLso welcome. Electronic Document Management Mav 10 Business professionals can learn how to reduce a coinpany's organizational costs while increasing operating elTiciency u.sing electronic document tiianagcment. The seminar. "Sharpening Your Company's Competitive Edge.' will be held from 9:.30-l l;30 a.m. and again from 1-3 p.m. at ALOS headquarters in Montgotnery. For more infortnation call Joe Manglass at 800-431-710.-i X664 or email ALOS at dwsetiiinars<0'alosusa.cotn. The seminar is tree. Family Medical Leave Act May 12 The Northern Hudson Valley Job Service Employer Cotiimittee in collaboration with the Chamber of Comtnerce Ulster County will present "Family Medical Leave AciAVorker's Compensation Update" with guest speaker. Joel J. Greenwald. Esq. of Greenwald & Associates PC. from 8:45-11:00 a.tn. at the Business Resource Center. One Development Court. Room 114. Ulster Avenue. Kingston. The cost is $10 per person for JSEC members and .SI5 for non-metnbers. For more infortnation visit www.ulsterjsec.org or call Ron Stonitsch at NYS DOL at 845-331-8920 Ext. 3004.
T I I I I T T T T
Managing stress
I I I I I
Tnusted Choice"
We serve you first.
PERMACOAT
Spray on Siding
LIMITED LIFETIME GUARANTEE
For your free in home demonstration call:
(845) 334-8O94
Mid-Hudson Permacoat, LLC The Future of Low Maintenance Home Exteriors
Spray on Siding is a newly developed Technology that gives consumers an alternative to vinyl siding or constant painting.
n rni 11111
rnnrrTn