Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
IiFC 2010
_____________________________________________________________________
Abstract
This is 21st century, the world is more liberal and open which promotes people move
around and hence getting economic benefits, saving, investing and doing businesses
where Muslim are not different in frequently using conventional banking system
which is ‘Riba’ (interest) imbedded. The ‘Riba’, whatever the modes or types, is a
matter of prolonging debate between different schools of Islamic thought. This
research apprises critically the issue- whether the interest earning from banks
rendering services in non-Muslim countries is acceptable or not. In this contention the
paper analyses the fact from the views of different Islamic scholars and finds
ambiguous result. The content analysis between views reveals that the concept of
liberal orthodoxy is refutable where as fundamentalism is grounded on the light of
Quran and Sunnah.
1. Introduction
The monetary transaction and ‘Riba’ (interest) are persistence to each other and retain
interactive relationship in any prevailing financial system in this deceptive world.
Among others, Muslims are also readily engaged in this traditional conventional
system whether intensionally or of ignorance or of fallacy as a result of religious
hazard. Though the fact of Riba, any types of, whether it is acceptable, disputable or
rejectiable has drawn numerous attentions in Islamic research, but from different
points of views (e.g. Fiqh) it demands further enquires that is the contention of this
♣
Corresponding Author: Master’s Student, Academy of Islamic Studies, Department of Fiqh and Usul,
University of Malaya, Malaysia, Email: shahaalam83@yahoo.com
Khan, Abd Rahman and Golam Rabby
research. Specifically, the main objective of this study is “Riba from the conventional
banks of non-Muslim country and Islamic stand in views of Fiqh” which codify the
Muslim stakeholders definitively in having that Riba.
The fundamental thesis of this research is grounded on the Sura Al-Baqarah, among
others, in the Holy Quran. Admissible income has been encouraged and the effects of
yields have also been manifested by Allah Almighty.
2. Methodology
In broad view, a qualitative method is followed in this research. For the great concern
of in-depth analysis, specifically content analysis approach has been adopted and for
relevant information- non-Muslim country, lawful and unlawful Riba, different
Fatawas, personal opinion etc- various books have been studied, different articles
have also been reviewed and above all the Holy Quran and Sunnah have been
followed throughout the analysis.
In content analysis, three different trends of thoughts, concerning around the research
topic, - generous (more adoptive), robust (strict and straight into principle) and in
between has been identified. In analysis equal importance has been given on these
thoughts but differentiated on the basis of the Quran and Sunnah and Fatawa as
always since these are together instructive to the Islamic way of life.
436
Proceedings of International Islamic Finance Conference 2010
3. Analytical framework
Information Flows
Refinement
Personal Opinion
Barrier
Fatawa
Information Prong
The figure (1) illustrates the analytical framework of this research. As this research
follows the content analysis approach hence the sources of information are logically
secondary in character. Collecting and designating those information presses to
recognize the whole model into two parts which are unidirectional one-sided. The
upper part of the model is the engine of information demand mechanism working in
accumulating resources where as the lower part is the domain of supply mechanism
helping in disseminating information into three categories- adoptive, in principle and
in between. The process of dissemination is conditional in prong and subject to a
refinement barrier which is based on the instructions of Islamic way of life. The
information passes through this sorting boundary and is heading towards individual
line of thought. The two part of the model together unveil the understanding of three
different contemplations in which the analysis is round about.
4. Analysis
In analysis, the framework developed in the preceding section is followed strictly.
Three streams of ideologies have been recognized so far in this part of research. In
testing the hypothesis in question- whether having interest from non-Muslim
country’s conventional bank is lawful or not- attempt has taken into the
epistemological enquires to unveil the rations of those ideological jurisprudences.
For the philosophical understanding of hypothesis in question, the grounded theory
has also been considered in judgment of the following three stems of thought.
Recognized steams of thought are-
• Liberal line of thought
• Conservative line of thought
437
Khan, Abd Rahman and Golam Rabby
* ‘Mudarabah’ is a special kind of partnership where one partner gives money to another for investing it
438
Proceedings of International Islamic Finance Conference 2010
other three Imams- Malik, Shafi and Ahmed Ibn Hanbal. The proponent
elucidate that whichever and whatever lawful it should be admissible
everywhere whether the country is Muslim or non-Muslim and in case of
unlawful contention the same suggestion have to be followed. Sharia law is, in
all respect, equally applicable to all Muslim and accordingly as interest is
prohibited and unlawful in Islamic Muslim country so that interest should
similarly be unlawful in non-Muslim country (Al-Zarqa 2004; Kassani 1982).
c. According to the jurisprudence of Imam Abu Hanifa and Imam Mohammad as
having interest from traditional bank of non-Muslim country is lawful so it
must not be immoral to take hold of that interest (Al-Zarqa 2004; Jaddi 2001).
(Rahim 2004). The aim of reformists is- (1) to bring Islam out of fundamentals in a
rational and liberal manner and emphasis on the basic ideals of Islamic brotherhood,
and (2) to utilize the dynamic character of Islam within the context of the intellectual
and scientific progress of the modern world (Smith 1966 in Rahim 2004).
In contrary the fundamentalist concept is based on the firm belief that the commands
given by the divine revelations through the Prophet Mohammad (SM) are to be
followed in letter and spirit and cannot be violated or ignored on the basis of one’s
rational arguments or his inner desires (Usmani 2008).
The analysis of content reveals that first two views are analogous to modernist school
of Islamic thought. The scholar views expose easy-going character of Islamic
orthodoxy and extensive liberal capacity of Islam in adopting contemporary demand
of daily life.
The third view strongly supports the rigidity of Islamic unorthodoxy in question of
fundamental principles and hold stand against of rational incarnation and is
unanimous to traditionalist school of Islamic thought.
Since the articulated analysis does not augment any rigid result (direction) hence in
the proceeding paragraphs attempt has taken to testify the argument (hypothesis in
question) of this research from the light of the Holy Quran and Sunnah and at end the
gleaned up results have been arranged in the following table-2 and lined up with
appropriate contentions.
• There has not been any supporting document found for the first line of
thought. These views are based on personal opinion and Fatawa which is not
legitimately acceptable.
• Though second line of thought is also based on personal opinion and Fatawa
as well but having somewhat a stretch of support from a hadith-
‘if Muslim do transaction with non-Muslim of non-Muslim country
then the incurred riba is admissible’ (Kibbi 2002, p. 157; Al-Misri 2001, p;
183).
As it is a Mursal (posted) and Dowaif (weak) hadith (Nabobi n.d.), so this
view fails to establish the ground of acceptability.
• On behalf of third line of thought, there are numerous supportive documents
has been found in the Holy Quran and Sunnah, such as-
o In the Quran a thick devine commands like- Al-Baqarah (verse-
275,276,278,279), Al-Imran (verse-130), An-Nisâ has been found to
support the Islamic fundamentalism.
440
Proceedings of International Islamic Finance Conference 2010
o Insight of various hadiths reveals that riba is unlawful and one of the
worst from seven great vices sin. Example of some hadith are- (Zia-Ur-
Rahman 2001, Vol. 5, p.2 6), (Al-Hamidi in Ali Hussain Al-Bawwab
2002, Vol. 3, p.83), (Al-Tirmizi in Ahmed Mohammad Shaker and
Associates, Vol. 5, P. 273), (Ishaq in Mostafa Al-Adhami 1970, Vol. 4,
p. 251), (Abdullah in Mustafa Abdul Kader Atta 1990, Vol. 2, p. 43)
etc.
Thus, clearly, the above mentioned documents recognized the common truth that
‘Riba’ (interest) is not admissible at all.
6. Conclusioin
The very nature of life induces people to accumulate wealth which conduces to satisfy
latent desires of human being. With the progress of civilization different institutions
have been emerged and established to exchange different forms of wealth securely.
Bank is such a secure institution which does not only keep wealth intake but also
increase which is generated under man-made provision. If such increase mounts up as
interest (Riba) from any conventional bank which is rendering services in non-
Muslim country then it is lawful or not- is the quest of this research. This research
reveals that on the above contention, though, Islamic scholars are diverted but the
actual fact is that all are working for the great benefit of humanity. Three different
divergent lines are oriented towards two particular concepts- Reformist and
Fundamentalist. The former conceptualists are generous to adopt ‘Riba’ incurred from
conventional bank of non-Muslim country whereas the latter group is rigidly denied
the distortion of fundamental principles of Islam. The research concludes that ‘Riba’,
whatever the modes or types, is not refutable only but rejectable also.
441
Khan, Abd Rahman and Golam Rabby
References
Abdullah, M. B. (n.d.). Mustadrek Al-Hakem. Mustafa Abdul Kader Atta edited
(1990), V.2, P. 43.
Al-Hamidi, M. B. F. (n.d.). Al-Zamu, Baina Al-Sahihainai Al Bukhari wah Muslim.
Ali Hussein Al-Bawwab edited (2nd edition, 2002), Vol. 3, P. 83, Beirut: Dar
Ibn Hazim.
Al-Ishbili, A. M. A. H. (n.d.). Al-Ahakamu Sharia Al-Kubra. Abu Abdullah Bin
Hussain Okasha edited (2001), Vol. 1, P. 164, Riyadh: Maktabatu Al-Rusdth.
Al-Khalizi, A. B. H. (2003). Fatawa Muwamilath. Vol. 3, P.24, Oman: Tabya Sharika
Matbayah.
Al-Misri, R. U. (2001). Al-Jamyee Fih Usual Al-Riba. Damascus: Dar-Al-Kalam.
Al-Qaradawi, Y. (1993). Fatawa Muwasarah. 2nd edition, Vol. 2, PP. 110-111, Dar
Al-Wofa.
Al-Qaradawi, Y. (1994). Fawaed Al-Bunuk Hiya Al-Riba Al-Haram. 2nd edition,
Cairo: Daral Sahwa.
Al-Tirmidhi, M. B. I. (n.d.). Sunan Al-Trimidhi. Ahmed Mohammad Shaker and
Associates edited, Vol. 5, P. 273, Beirut: Daru Yahyah Al-Turas Al-Arabi.
Al-Zarqa, M. (2004). Fatawa Mustafa Zarqa. 3rd edition, Damascus: Dar Al-Qalam.
Hossain, M. S. (1996). Islami Banking: Akty Unnatarar Bank Babostha(Islami
Banking: A Superior Banking System). Dhaka: Public Relation Department,
Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited.
Ishaq, M.I. (n.d.). Sahi Ibn Khuzaimah. Mustafa Al-Adhami edited (1970), Vol. 4, P.
251, Al-Maktab Al-Islami.
Kassani, A. (1982). Badaai Al- Sanai. Beirut: Dar-Al-Kitab Al-Arabi.
Kibbi, S. M. (2006). Al-Muamilat Al-Malia Al-Muasarah Fih Dawee Al-Islam. P.
270, Beirut-Damascua-Amman: Al-Maktaba Al-Islam.
Nabobi, I. A. J. M. B. S. (n.d.). Al-Majmu Sharh Al-Muhajwab Lil Shiraji.
Mohammad Nazib Al-Motiee edited, Vol. 9, P. 488, Jeddah: Maktabatu Al-
Ersad.
Rahim, R. A.A. (2004). The Concept of Taqlid in the Reformist’s point of view.
Journal of Fiqh, Issue No. 1, PP. 1-28, University of Malaya, Malaysia.
Rahman, M. H. (Hizri 1423†). Shud Dhonsho O Shoshoner Hateyar. Dhaka: Shikhul
Islam Prokashani.
Saad, A. B. (2006). Khulasa Al-Kalam Fih Ahkame Ulam Al-Balad Al-Haram. P.
376, Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyah.
Suyed, A. J. and Susi, M. A. (2006). Fiqh Al-Muamilat Al-Maliyah. 2nd edition.
Usmani, M. T. (2008). An Introduction to Islamic Finance. Karachi: Quranic Studies
Publishers.
Usmani, M. T. (1998). Bahusun Fi Kadayah Fiqhiyah Muasara. Damascus: Dar-Al-
Qalam.
Zahrah, M. A. (n.d.). Fatawa Al-Sheikh Mohammad Abu Zahrah. Mohammad Usman
Shabir edited (2006), P. 386, Damescus: Dar Al-Kalam.
Zia-ur-Rahman, M. A. (2001). Al-Minah Al-Kubrah. Riyadh: Makataba-Al-Rusdth.
†
2002 BC
442