Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
ARCHOLOGICA
2005
Opvscvla 29.indb 3
21.8.2006 11:56:38
F I L O Z O F S K I FA K U LT E T
SVEUILITA U ZAGREBU
FACULTY OF PHILOSOPHY,
UNIVERSITY OF ZAGREB
RADOVI ARHEOLOKOG ZAVODA
PA P E R S O F T H E D E PA RT M E N T
O F
A R C H A E O L O G Y
UDK 902-904
ISSN 0473-0992
IV
Opvscvla 29.indb 4
21.8.2006 11:56:39
SADRAJ
CONTENTS
Stao FORENBAHER
& Timothy KAISER
Jacqueline BALEN
Domagoj PERKI
& Daria LONJAK DIZDAR KASNOBRONANODOBNA OSTAVA SIA/LUICA
THE SIA/LUICA LATE BRONZE AGE HOARD
Izvorni znanstveni lanak / Original scientic paper ________________________ 41
Tomislav BILI
Marija MARI
Marko SINOBAD
Kristina GLICKSMAN
Marija IA-VIVEK,
Tino LELEKOVI
& Hrvoje KALAFATI
Opvscvla 29.indb 5
21.8.2006 11:56:39
Adnan BUSULADI
Mirja JARAK
Tajana PLEE
& Ana AZINOVI-BEBEK
Kreimir RAGU
Dinko RADI
Tihomila TEAK-GREGL
Tihomila TEAK-GREGL
Urednici / Editors
Opvscvla 29.indb 6
21.8.2006 11:56:39
Stao Forenbaher
Institut za antropologiju
Amrueva 8
HR-10000 Zagreb
staso.forenbaher@zg.htnet.hr
Timothy Kaiser
Royal Ontario Museum
Toronto, Kanada
tim.kaiser@utoronto.ca
Due to its strategic position at the very centre of the Adriatic Sea, the islet of Palagrua played a vital role during
one of the crucial transitional episodes of European prehistory the spread of farming. The earliest evidence of
human presence on this islet dates to the Early Neolithic.
This article presents an overview of Palagruas Early Neolithic sites and nds, as well as an interpretation of those
nds in the context of comprehensive changes that aected
the Adriatic region during the rst half of the sixth millennium BC. These nds indicate the existence of seafaring skills and technology that allowed circulation of goods,
ideas, and people in rapid fashion over long stretches of
open water. Thanks to these skills, a new way of life based
on food production spread and stabilised relatively quickly throughout the Adriatic region.
Key words: Adriatic, Impressed Ware, island, migration,
navigation, Neolithic, Palagrua
Introduction
Uvod
Pojedini otoci odigrali su u odreenim razdobljima prolosti osobito vanu ulogu. Njihov povijesni
Opvscvla 29.indb 1
21.8.2006 11:56:39
Opvscvla 29.indb 2
to their size, depended on a variety of dierent factors. This paper investigates the role of one of the
smallest Adriatic islands in one of the crucial transitional episodes of European prehistory the spread
of farming.
Palagrua is not an ordinary Adriatic island. While
virtually every other Adriatic island was formed
when the Holocene marine transgression separated
the westernmost ranges of the Dinaric Mountains
from the mainland by drowning the valleys between them, Palagrua has always been an island.
Today, seas are 130 m deep at their shallowest and
much deeper for the most part elsewhere surround
Palagrua. Thus Palagrua must have been an island even during the Last Glacial Maximum, when
the sea was at its lowest, c. 120 m below its current
level. Only Suac and Jabuka share with Palagrua
the distinction of not having been connected to
the mainland at that time (Van Andel 1989; 1990;
Forenbaher 2002: g. 1). It is therefore somewhat
meaningless to talk about the rst occupation of
the Adriatic islands. Since all of them used to be
part of the mainland on several occasions during
the Pleistocene, presumably they were inhabited as
early as the rest of Southern Europe. Judging from
their archeological records (e.g., Ganey et al. 1997;
Stani et al. 1999), at least some of them continued
to be occupied as they gradually became detached
from the mainland between c. 15000 and 5000 BC
(Forenbaher 2002: g. 2).
Human presence on Palagrua seems to be a relatively more recent phenomenon. Archaeological
research on the island, which has included intensive surface survey, test- and area-excavations, has
yet to encounter any evidence of human presence
on Palagrua during the Late Upper Pleistocene
or Early Holocene. It may be that archaeological
sites of those periods once existed at some lower
elevation(s) of what was then a much larger island,
and were drowned by rising Holocene seas. The
rocks that remain above water today would have
been that islands least productive and least attractive part. The earliest archaeological nds recovered from Palagrua to date are Early Neolithic
Impressed Ware potsherds, and they may well be
evidence for the rst occupation of the island.
Located virtually at the centre of Adriatic, Palagrua
is that seas most remote island (Fig. 1). The closest landfalls in any direction are about 45 km away:
the small island of Suac to the north-northeast,
and the tiny islet of Pianosa to the southwest, while
mainland Italy (Monte Gargano) lies 57 km to the
south. Palagruas narrow, rocky ridge, 1390 m long
and 270 m wide, is made up of bedded limestone
and limestone breccias (Fig. 2). There are two small
21.8.2006 11:56:39
Stao FORENBAHER & Timothy KAISER PALAGRUA AND THE SPREAD OF FARMING IN THE ADRIATIC
Slika 1. Karta Jadrana s Palagruom i drugim odabranim nalazitima impresso-lonarije (autor: Stao Forenbaher).
Figure 1. Map of the Adriatic showing Palagrua and other selected Impressed Ware sites (by Stao Forenbaher).
Opvscvla 29.indb 3
21.8.2006 11:56:42
Slika 2. Palagrua s vrha Male Palagrue (pogled prema zapadusjeverozapadu); ranoneolitiko nalazite Jonkova njiva nalazi se
na zaravni neposredno nad morem (autor Stao Forenbaher).
Figure 2. View of Palagrua from the summit of Mala Palagrua
(looking towards WNW); the Early Neolithic site of Jonkova njiva
is on the plateau immediately overlooking the channel (by Stao
Forenbaher).
Kasnije generacije arheologa nisu meutim njihovim otkriima pridavale posebnu panju (primjerice Petri 1975), sve do jednodnevnoga posjeta 1992.
godine koji je pokazao da je Marchesetti bio posve
u pravu kad je primijetio da je prolost otoka neobino bogata. Arheoloka istraivanja koja su nakon toga zapoeta jo uvijek traju (Kaiser & Kirigin
1994; Kirigin & ae 1998; Forenbaher & Kaiser
1997; Kaiser & Forenbaher 1999; Kirigin & Katunari 2002). Do sada su provedeni sustavni pregled
povrine obaju otoka, pregled podmorja do dubine
Opvscula Archaeologica Vol. 29 (2005)
Opvscvla 29.indb 4
10
21.8.2006 11:56:45
Stao FORENBAHER & Timothy KAISER PALAGRUA AND THE SPREAD OF FARMING IN THE ADRIATIC
od 25 m, niz probnih sondiranja te podzemni pregled radarom i vee sustavno iskopavanje (oko 150
m2) na sredinjoj zaravni zvanoj Salamandrija. Prikupljeni su ranoneolitiki, kasnobakrenodobni/ranobronanodobni, klasini grki, helenistiki, ranorimski, kasnoantiki i postsrednjovjekovni nalazi.
Slika 4. Ulomci impresso-lonarije s Palagrue: 13 Jonkova njiva, 4 sjeverna padina nad Starom vlakom (autor: Stao Forenbaher).
Figure 4. Impressed Ware potsherds from Palagrua: 13 Jonkova njiva, 4 north slope above Stara vlaka (by Stao Forenbaher).
Taking into account the unquestionable Early Neolithic nds from Jonkova njiva, however, the fth
impressed sherd probably also should be attributed
to the Early Neolithic.
Jonkova njiva (Jonkos Field) is the second largest
parcel of level terrain on the island. This 0.12 ha plateau is located at its eastern tip and is connected to
the rest of the island by a knife-edge saddle called
11
Opvscvla 29.indb 5
21.8.2006 11:56:47
Opvscvla 29.indb 6
These may have been missed during the systematic surface collection due to the fact that it was carried out in the late spring,
when relatively lush vegetation reduces ground visibility; subsequent visits took place in the late summer, when most of the
vegetation is dry. Alternatively, progressive erosion may have
exposed more artifacts.
12
21.8.2006 11:56:50
Stao FORENBAHER & Timothy KAISER PALAGRUA AND THE SPREAD OF FARMING IN THE ADRIATIC
Nakon to smo 1993. godine kartirali nalazite i podijelili ga na kvadrate sa stranicama od 10 m, pristupili smo intenzivnu prikupljanju povrinskih nalaza.
Ustanovili smo nisku gustou (0,1/m2) ulomaka neolitike lonarije i kamenih izraevina. Jo nekoliko
nalaza prikupili smo za naknadnih neformalnih posjeta.1 Kako bismo provjerili postoje li ispod povrine nalazi i tvorevine, iskopali smo est nasumce
postavljenih probnih sondi veliine 1 x 1 m. Rezultat je bio razoaravajui jer smo u njima pronali tek
pokoji nedijagnostiki ulomak lonarije ili kremeni
odbojak. Iskopana taloina sastojala se od 4060 cm
debela sloja tla koje je lealo na ivcu. Nismo naili
ni na kakve tvorevine (osim potpornoga suhozida
uz sondu 40/41, koji je bio vidljiv ve na povrini) ni
na bilo kakav organski materijal pogodan za izravno
datiranje. Namee se zakljuak da su malobrojni
pokretni nalazi sve to je preostalo od ranoneolitikoga koritenja ovoga prostora. Zbog toga naa
rasprava najranijega zaposjedanja Palagrue polazi
od aice ulomaka lonarije.
etiri ulomka Cardium-impresso-lonarije (od
kojih se dva meusobno spajaju) potjeu od dvije
posude. Jedna od njih (sl. 4/12) bila je razmjerno
na i tankih stijenki te vjerojatno manja od druge
(sl. 4/3), od koje imamo samo jedan ulomak. Ukras
je u obama sluajevima izveden viestrukim utiskivanjem ruba koljke anice i ini se da je zahvaao
velike dijelove povrine, a u prvome primjeru otisci
se niu priblino usporedno. Takva arhetipska stilska obiljeja omoguuju nam da spomenute ulomke
okvirno datiramo u prvu polovicu estoga tisuljea
pr. Kr. (kalibrirano) (Forenbaher 1999; Forenbaher
& Miracle 2005). Prema Mlleru (1994: 152153)
jednostavno ukraavanje utiskivanjem ruba koljke
naroito je karakteristino za ranu fazu istonojadranske impresso-lonarije.
Izraevine od cijepanoga kamena s Jonkove njive
znatno su manje vremenski osjetljive. Dvadesetak
izraevina od cijepanoga kamena potjee iz nesigurnih konteksta (s povrine ili iz neuslojenih naslaga), no budui da nema nikakvih dijagnostikih
nalaza koji bi upuivali na kasnija pretpovijesna razdoblja, pretpostavljamo da i one pripadaju ranomu
neolitiku. iroko sjeivo i sjeivo s grebenom (sl.
6), oba napravljena od ronjaka, openito odgovaraju slinim primjercima iz drugih jadranskih neolitikih nalazita (usp. Bass 2004: sl. 4; Forenbaher
2006; Martinelli 1990).
Spomenuti predmeti vjerojatno su proizvedeni na
samoj Palagrui. Na susjednoj Maloj Palagrui postoje obilati izvori ronjaka u obliku nodula i oblutaka, a rupe u matinoj vapnenakoj stijeni naznauju mjesta gdje je ronjak bio izvaen. Eksploatacija ronjaka zapoela je vjerojatno ve za neolitika.
Kamene izraevine s Jonkove njive, za koje pretpo-
13
Opvscvla 29.indb 7
21.8.2006 11:56:54
Opvscvla 29.indb 8
14
21.8.2006 11:56:55
Stao FORENBAHER & Timothy KAISER PALAGRUA AND THE SPREAD OF FARMING IN THE ADRIATIC
15
Opvscvla 29.indb 9
21.8.2006 11:56:56
Opvscvla 29.indb 10
16
21.8.2006 11:56:56
Stao FORENBAHER & Timothy KAISER PALAGRUA AND THE SPREAD OF FARMING IN THE ADRIATIC
17
Opvscvla 29.indb 11
21.8.2006 11:56:56
Opvscvla 29.indb 12
18
21.8.2006 11:56:56
Stao FORENBAHER & Timothy KAISER PALAGRUA AND THE SPREAD OF FARMING IN THE ADRIATIC
la jug Istre tek oko 5750. pr. Kr. (kalibrirano). Stotinjak godina poslije, kad se zemljoradnja konano
pojavljuje u sjevernoj Istri i u susjednim podrujima
Slovenije i Transkog Krasa, uz nju je ve vezana
srednjoneolitika danilsko-vlaka lonarija (Forenbaher et al. 2004).
Kakav je odnos opisanoga razvoja dogaaja prema
istodobnoj situaciji du zapadne obale Jadrana?
Najraniji pouzdani datumi za zapadnojadransku
impresso-lonariju kreu se oko 6000. pr. Kr. (kalibrirano) i potjeu iz nalazita na otvorenome, s
podruja Tavolierea i iz njegova susjedstva (Skeates
2000: 163166). Najkraa veza izmeu Krfa i Tavolierea vodi preko Otrantskih vrata i dalje uz obalu
Apulije, no datumi koji nam stoje na raspolaganju
ne podravaju pretpostavku da su naseljenici pristigli
tim putom. Obrnuto od oekivanja s udaljavanjem
od Tavolierea du obale, kako prema sjeveru tako i
prema jugu, datumi za najraniju lonariju postupno
su sve mlai (Skeates 2003: 169171).
To navodi na zanimljivu mogunost da je impresso-lonarija do zapadne jadranske obale dospjela
okolnim putem, du obala Albanije i Crne Gore,
preko junodalmatinskih otoka, dalje preko Suca
i Palagrue do Gargana te napokon do Tavolierea,
njegova neposredna zalea. Postojei radiokarbonski datumi ne protuslove ovoj hipotezi jer najraniji datumi za impresso-lonariju u junoj Dalmaciji
nisu nita kasniji od datuma iz Tavolierea (Forenbaher 1999; Forenbaher & Miracle 2005). S druge
strane ne mogu je ni izravno podrati, jer nedostaju datumi za impresso-lonariju du kljunog
odsjeka istonoga Jadrana izmeu sjeverne Grke
i june Dalmacije. Drugim rijeima, datumi kojima
raspolaemo ne doputaju nam da zakljuimo je li
impresso-keramika stigla u Italiju iz Dalmacije ili je
bilo obrnuto.
Postoji i mogunost (koju smatramo manje vjerojatnom) da je jadranska impresso-lonarija nastala na
srednjem Jadranu, na podruju koje obuhvaa Tavoliere i junu Dalmaciju, odakle bi se bila proirila
na sjeverozapad i na jugoistok du obiju jadranskih
obala. U tom bismo sluaju morali odbaciti rane
datume za impresso-lonariju iz nalazita Sidari,
kao i predloeni model njezina irenja u dvije faze s
otoka Krfa (Forenbaher & Miracle 2005; 2006). Kronometrijsko datiranje najranije lonarije s obalnih
nalazita Crne Gore i Albanije moglo bi se pokazati
odluujuim za provjeru spomenute hipoteze. Bez
obzira na to koji e se od predloenih scenarija u
konanici pokazati najvjerojatnijim, jedna je stvar
sigurna: maleni otoi Palagrua morao je u svima
njima odigrati kljunu ulogu.
Nalazi s Palagrue svjedoe da su (neki) ljudi u ranome neolitiku posjedovali pomorska znanja i tehnologije
19
Opvscvla 29.indb 13
21.8.2006 11:56:57
Opvscvla 29.indb 14
20
21.8.2006 11:56:57
Stao FORENBAHER & Timothy KAISER PALAGRUA AND THE SPREAD OF FARMING IN THE ADRIATIC
LITERATURA / BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ammerman &
Cavalli-Sforza 1984
Bass 1998
Bass 2004
Broodbank 1999
Budja 1999
Burton 1879
Casson 1995
Chapman & Mller 1990
Demoule 1993
Forenbaher 1999
Forenbaher 2002
Forenbaher 2006
Fumo 1980
Ganey et al. 1997
Gilman 1981
A.J. Ammerman & L.L. Cavalli-Sforza: The Neolithic Transition and the
Genetics of Populations in Europe, Princeton, 1984.
B. Bass: Early Neolithic Oshore Accounts: Remote Islands, Maritime
Exploitations, and the Trans-Adriatic Cultural Network, Journal of
Mediterranean Archaeology 11/2, London, 1998, 165190.
B. Bass: The Maritime Expansion of Early Neolithic Agro-pastoralism in
the Eastern Adriatic Sea, Atti della Societ per la Preistoria e Protostoria
della regione Friuli-Venezia Giulia 14, Trieste, 2004, 4560.
C. Broodbank: Colonization and conguration in the insular Neolithic of the
Aegean, in P. Halstead (ed.), Neolithic society in Greece, Sheeld, 1999, 1541.
M. Budja: The Transition to Farming in Mediterranean Europe and
Indigenous Response, Documenta Praehistorica 26, Ljubljana, 1999, 119141.
R.F. Burton: A Visit to Lissa and Pelagosa, Journal of the Royal Geographical
Society 44, London, 1879, 151190.
L. Casson: Ships and Seamanship in the Ancient World, Baltimore, 1995.
J.C. Chapman & J. Mller: Early Farmers in the Mediterranean Basin: the
Dalmatian Evidence, Antiquity 64, 1990, York, 127134.
J-P. Demoule: Anatolie et Balkans: la logique volutive du nolithique
gen, in J. Roodenberg (ed.), Anatolia and the Balkans (Anatolica 19),
Leiden, 1993, 113.
S. Forenbaher: The Earliest Islanders of the Eastern Adriatic, Collegium
Antropologicum 23, Zagreb, 1999, 521530.
S. Forenbaher: Prehistoric Populations of the Island of Hvar: An Overview
of Archaeological Evidence, Collegium Antropologicum 36, Zagreb, 2002,
361378.
S. Forenbaher: Flaked Stone Artifacts / Izraevine od cijepanog kamena, in
P. T. Miracle & S. Forenbaher (eds.), Prehistoric Herders of Northern Istria,
the Archaeology of Pupiina Cave, Volume 1 / Pretpovijesni stoari sjeverne
Istre, arheologija Pupiine pei, 1. svezak, Pula, 2006, 225258.
S. Forenbaher & T. Kaiser: Palagrua, jadranski moreplovci i njihova
kamena industrija na prijelazu iz bakrenog u bronano doba, Opuscula
archaeologica 21, Zagreb, 1997, 1528.
S. Forenbaher & P. T. Miracle: The Spread of Farming in the Eastern
Adriatic, Antiquity 79, York, 2005, 514528.
S. Forenbaher & P. T. Miracle: Pupiina Cave and the Spread of Farming
in the Eastern Adriatic / Pupiina pe i irenje zemljoradnje na istonom
Jadranu, in P. T. Miracle & S. Forenbaher (eds.), Prehistoric Herders of
Northern Istria, the Archaeology of Pupiina Cave, Volume 1 / Pretpovijesni
stoari sjeverne Istre, arheologija Pupiine pei, 1. svezak, Pula, 2006, 483
530.
S. Forenbaher, T. Kaiser & P. T. Miracle: Pupiina Cave Pottery and the
Neolithic Sequence in Northeastern Adriatic, Atti della Societ per la
Preistoria e Protostoria della regione Friuli-Venezia Giulia 14, Trieste, 2004,
61102.
P. Fumo: La Preistoria delle Isole Tremiti, Campobasso, 1980.
V. Ganey, B. Kirigin, M. Petri, N. Vujnovi. & S. ae: Arheoloka batina
otoka Hvara, Hrvatska / The Archaeological Heritage of Hvar, Croatia (BAR
International Series 660), Oxford, 1997.
A. Gilman: The Development of Social Stratication in Bronze Age Europe,
Current Anthropology 22, Chicago, 1981, 123.
21
Opvscvla 29.indb 15
21.8.2006 11:56:57
Harding 2000
Kaiser & Forenbaher 1999
Kaiser & Kirigin 1994
Kirigin & ae 1998
Kirigin & Katunari 2002
Kovai 1997
Marchesetti 1876
Martinelli 1990
Mller 1994
Perls 2001
Petri 1975
Richards et al. 2002
Rowley-Conwy 2003
Skeates 2000
Skeates 2003
Sordinas 1969
Stani et al. 1999
Tringham 2000
Van Andel 1989
Van Andel 1990
Zohary & Hopf 1993
Opvscvla 29.indb 16
22
21.8.2006 11:56:57
Stao FORENBAHER & Timothy KAISER PALAGRUA AND THE SPREAD OF FARMING IN THE ADRIATIC
Zvelebil 2002
23
Opvscvla 29.indb 17
21.8.2006 11:56:58