Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Warnar
Kari
K
Veblen
Music
1800
December
12,
2015
Abeles, H. (2009). Are musical instrument gender associations changing? Journal of Research in
Music Education, 57(2), 127-139. doi:10.1177/0022429409335878
Throughout this article, Abeles discusses how musical instrument gender associations
are
changing
over
time.
Through
a
series
of
conducted
experiments,
Abeles
also
analyses
what
instruments
are
considered
to
be
more
masculine/feminine.
Abeles
then
concludes
that
gender
associations
with
musical
instruments
may
be
influential
in
the
lives
of
male
and
female
musicians
as
they
pursue
a
musical
career.
I was interested by the statistical analysis presented by Abeles. Once I saw the results, I
realized
that
I
had
never
asked
myself
why
these
musical
stereotypes
were
the
case.
Why
are
there
more
male
percussionists
than
female,
and
why
more
female
flute
players
than
male?
It
surprised
me
to
know
that
there
was
little
change
in
instrument
gender
associations
between
the
1970s
and
2000s.
Even
in
my
high
school
music
class,
the
instrument
gender
associations
were
not
as
closely
linked
with
these
statistics.
For
example,
there
were
usually
a
balance
of
male/female
trombonists
and
saxophone
players.
In
contrast
to
the
statistics
presented,
the
tuba
players
were
only
female
and
the
trumpet
players
were
mostly
female
musicians.
The
instrument
gender
associations
that
do
correspond
however
are
the
large
amount
of
male
percussionists,
female
flautists,
and
female
clarinet
players.
I was frustrated with the concluding results presented by Abeles through the
investigation.
It
was
noted
that
The
results
indicated
that
the
instrument
played
by
the
candidate
was
an
important
predictor
of
being
hired
for
an
instrumental
music
position
(Abeles).
I
have
seen
various
instrumentalists
that
do
not
correspond
to
this
criteria
who
have
been
hired
over
other
people
not
for
their
choice
of
instrument
but
for
their
level
of
skill
and
technique.
This
is
what
I
believe
to
be
the
deciding
factor
in
such
positions.
In
another,
more
recent
study,
Cramer,
Million,
and
Perreault
(2002)
surveyed
college
students
to
examine
how
gender
associations
with
musical
instruments
affected
their
perceptions
of
musicians.
They
found
that
the
perceptions
of
male
and
female
musicians
depended
on
the
instrument
on
which
the
performers
played.
For
example,
males
who
played
feminine
instruments
were
perceived
as
less
dominant
and
active
and
had
less
leadership
skills
than
females
playing
the
identical
instruments.
(Abeles).
I
believe
that
this
is
purely
a
stereotype,
if
a
musician
truly
has
the
skills
to
lead
other
musicians,
their
ability
will
not
be
limited
by
their
instrument
choice.
As
a
comment
to
the
author,
I
would
have
liked
more
statistical
analysis
revolving
around
the
impact
of
instrument
gender
associations.
What
are
the
results,
and
how
would
the
music
program
of
today
be
different
if
instrument
gender
associations
did
not
exist?