Revista Servico Publico

$*
441 5 6
7! 689:
3 88;<=>6<8

!" # $
$%& %'

(
) ) #* +
, ++ -+

%'
)
' -

.
!"
/ ,
0 + -

1 #
/2 /
RSP Revisitada: 3 ( " ++

'
, #
Braslia 2015
Misso da Revista do Servio Pblico

E F G' 1 ++ +1
%' F1 F
' +*
,3 , 3 %'
Presidente # )

/ )
Diretor de Desenvolvimento Gerencial /2
Diretor de Comunicao e Pesquisa: / ) #&
Diretor de Gesto Interna # +
Conselho Editorial
Conselheiros nacionais H " I J K+ I LKIMN / J K+
I - LKIMN # J I %' !' LI!MN I # J K+ '
LKMN I J I %' $7 LI$=MN I J FO K+ #P
/ LK#7/MN !" # $ J K+ ' LKMN / " #+ #Q J K+
I ) LKI)MN / ) #& J , 3 %' L,3M
/ " / J K+ I LKI,MN / E J K+ ' LKMN
/ ) J I %' $7 LI$=MN # E # J K+ LKMN
# #+ J K+ LKMN ) #. J K+ LKMN RS
J K+ I LKI,M*
Conselheiros internacionais I J , P T EP , L,E,MN T
J K+T ( U L
RRMN 3 # J K+ E LK 0MN / I- )U J K+
LKM*
Periodicidade
)+ +% " %' , 3 %' *
Comisso Editorial
#
U1 # +1 # # # I1 # #F / 1 , I
1 ! # / 1 /- /U '1 / ) #&*
Expediente
, -+ / ) #&* , / V1 /- W
I* , F+ I+ V * # # # )* )+' ) I / '1
) # )* / I* -X %' H / / )*
$* )+' -X # #* # * L+ ,M
)+ +% * 9>;Y = 7 , 3 %' * ,31 9>;Y = *
+* *N 6:1: *
, E +* 9>;Y ) ! " 9>:>* +
%'1 2 F F + S L9>>Z7688YM*
9>Y:79>Z8 9>>879>>;*
388;<=>6<8
9* %' J P*
* , 3 %' *
#EK ;: L8:9M
# ( 2 ) J ,3
,31 689:
R 9*888
)[ <8188 L2 M
, + )[ 96188
0 ) )+ +% '
+ F ,3
\\\**+*
I %' , 3 %'

J ] 6=
Y8498=>88 J 1 EI
R( L49M 6868 ;8>47;8>6
\\\**+*
^*+*
& F 2 ' ' 1 1
)*
%' " F 2 (*
Sumrio
Contents

F F F
F
F F ( T (

!
9Y9
$%& %'

(
$F \ + F

( (
Roberto Rocha C. Pires e Alexandre de Avila Gomide
, ++ -+
%'
,T +
F

" #$
' - F .
+\ (

%
& '

0 F+ -
F1 #
R F+_ F+ T (
F1 #

&($ &!
9>:
66Y
6:Y
6Z9
;99
RSP Revisitada: 3 ( " ++

' F
'
$ %

Editorial
#LM LM1
0 )+ +% F "
1 %' ) )+1 F 9>Z:* 0
F 1 +%1 ++
-+1 ' 1 ( F+*
0 F1 %) *+$#
,+# -#/
!

+
#
) +$# #0 11 + .
F%' F
(%& F %' F * 0
2 " 2 ( ` 2 &
F%' 1 %' ( +%
` & . F%' * 0
(%' 1 2 1 (
1 +1 1 . 2
F%' ++*
0 F1 2 3 ) +$# ##

,+# 4
1 -F .
%' F S*
1 +% F
F - + I (%
% +% F* E +
P' ( ++ F 1 (F "
1 % (2
+ F%' %& +*
'
22 $52 1 # #
" F * F+ 1
(% %'
=* 0 2 1 2 1
1 %' + %' %'
1 ( X %&
"F 2 ++ 1 1 F
X. +*
0 2 F1 F #/ $ 5 #,+#
06#
brasileiras1 F+ + 2 F+ '
' X%& P 1 (
I RP1 F R E EF+
b* 2 ' 1 (
X1 &
+ %' -F1 2 ' + *
0 F 7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3
1 + 2 .
2 * 1 F
F+ F1 #*
% (% F (
. 1 S F %&
X%' %' . accountability (
*
8$ 4 22 ,+# " F
%' ) )+* 0 F ( ) 9>Z:
1 (1 2 F%' 1 F
` ( F+* 0
1 1 + %'
+%' (+ 1 2 1
(% -2 F+* ,
" +% ' H 2
2 F F +* 1 X
S 2 1 (1 F%&
+1 X F c+
d1 ' F ( + %'
"*
*
# )
,

92

%1 ;9%1<
Jos Carlos Vaz

92

$ ;9<
, F F+ F 1
1 2 . + ( %' %'
F1 + ++ %' L
FM1 +F L (F+M %&
% (F+ F * P " 2 1
' 1 . + +
% 2 ( ' +' 2 1
( 1 +1 1 .1
F%' +- ++ + ` (F+*
F 1 %' F+1 +1
+%'1 '1 ' 1 %& +1
F

, e F F+ F
1 2 + f ( P
P F1 2 + FP T =
P L FM1 +F L F (M T
gF % 689<* $' X 689<*h

171
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
X F * P

2 1 2 + 1 +
+ 2 (2 FP =
-2 T ( 1 F T "1
FP F + T X*
F 1 P F+1 1
+P1 FP1 FP 1 1
P F
! "

#
"

R T F F T
+ + ( ( F F ( 1
Q F L\ T M1 +F F
L\ ( FFM \ F T + F+
( * R T 1 T 1
( \ + (
( F =1 T 1 \ (
FF ( + ++ ( F+*
$#% T1 F+ F1 +T1 +F1
1 1 + F1 F F

172
Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015
!
Introduo
3 F " " 681 1 (%&
1 + " c%'d
, X + ' * 3 "
F 1 F%' + F
* R. (% =
F%' 1 %'
( +% & . F%'
L$1 6884M* , + ` , X%'
1 " ( %& =
* R" 2 +
' +% X. *
%' F " (
( ,1 =
, ' F ` *
3 1 2 %' +
2 F1 2
2 . '
e+ -= L1 68961 6898M* ,
" 1 F +
I1 6Y + :*:48 1
+ * " 1 %' 1
2 . 1 '
( + I1
%'
1 2
%' +%' F+*
3 F1 + %' +
2 F+ (F+1 . ++ %&
F 2 ++
* # 1 = + ++
P1 %' +%' F 1 2
F(P ( *
0 F '
S X X ( %'
F ++ XF+ .
+1 ( F *
E 1 c2 - F
173
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
1 F+ ( %'

d L 1 689;1 * ZM*
0 ( F " F
1 2 . +%& ( %'
%' F* , + ++
%' L FM1 +F L
(F+M %& % (F+
F * P " 2 1 ' 1
. + + % 2
( ' +' 2 1 (
+1 1 .1
F%' +- ++ + ` (F+*
, F - 2 1 " %'*
( + + %' ++
F #F %' I 9>ZZ 2 .* 3
1 = + . ++
2 . %' (F+
* , +1 1 %'
+ +* 3 1 +=
+ P F 1
+%& 2 '
( %'1 %'1 +%' F *
X1 = X +
F *
&

'( ) '( "

0 ++ 1 9>4< 9>Z:1 +
%' + I ` %'1 X. .
F%' P L1 9>>4M*
0 + F%' ` %'
F %& , '
1 1 * #F %' I -F1
9>ZZ1 ( + %& .
%' + +1 *
1 9>>81 %' ( F1
1 " F+ %& 2
. %' +% *
174
!
I 1 1 %'1 2 +'
+% L1 6886M*
3 +1 F+ =
%' F 2 F +
* , 1 1 ' (
%' X " 2
+ *
E+ 2 1 F %'1
F +
1 +1 2 " %'* #+
L9>>>M1 GF (
X1 " F 2 1 +1
` *
+
. %' + I1 1
1 %' *
1 1 2 1 #F %' 9>ZZ
( " . %' F 1
P #F %' " F + I
%' 2 - F 1 (
P G F +
L1 68961 * 9YM*
, F %' P + I ' " `
%'1 1 2 %'
' + %' %' +
I1 1 1 X%' " +
(F+*
g***h (F+ 2 ( %' F
F 2
(.1 " + %'
* 1 1 "
P F+ + -
%' %& L1 68981 * :>;M*
3 F1 + 2 F X
9>>8 + + % 1 X %'
+ I * , .
%& F + L%' %'M1
. " ( + I
F 1
175
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
P & %' +

F+ %&1 - + P #F %' I 9>ZZ
L1 N 1 688Z1 1 688:1 1 68961 688ZM*
E 1 + +
(F+ 2 + I F+
LF ++ %&M1 P
+ ` ' + -1 %'
1 F 2 ' ( (
L1 688:N 1 688ZM*
L6888M X 2 " + ( %'
%'1 %' %'1
F -* , 1 2 2 (1 + F
2 F+ F
1 X 2
F *
F " 68881 + 1
+ +F (1
%& F %' H
* L688:M1 F %&
+ . ++. +
. G . +1
& 1 X.1 X- (F+1
1 (% %'
* 1 1 %' (F+ (
2 ' ( F 1 2
2 %' 2 F%' %'
+ I *
F =1 1 + %' + %&
(F+1 P %'1 2 + I
%' +
%'* , 1 + F
+
++ + 1 " +1
( %'1 %' +%' F *
" ++ F (
#F %' I 9>ZZ 2 1 + 1
S F%' 1 % F%'
+
176
!
* 1 #F %' +

F%' 2 ( (F+ F X1 1
1 1 (.1 . 1 %
FF+1 *
, ' P + F%'
P F 1 '
F%'1 " (F+1 ( %'
2 %' %' ,= * "
L 1 bN #1 6884 6884N
N 1 6884N 1 688Y 6898N N
$1
68981 1 6898M % ( 1 2 '
F + 1 2
" % F%' %'
F X +
%' *
X1 F + 1 2 " %
F 1 " ++ +
' + F * , ++ '
` F%' P1 "
%' %& ' + %' F * ,
2 ' ( E )(
,1 9>>:* 0 +1 1 F+ '
+ L +1 1 2 1 M
c %'d1 %&
' 2 1 %'
1 +% X +*
, %& '
+% P %'
* , " 9>>8 68881
+ . 2 F + %' ,
%& 2 1 1 +
F 2 + 1 1
+ L689;M*
1 (%& %& F
F "1 + + 2 1
1 & + F
2 %' (F+1 F
F 1 + % F%'
177
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
+ ++ + ( %' %& *

, + . F+ (F+1
-F F *
!'*

\1 U Q L6896M . + -F
' %& "
'* R= %' F c -Fd +
%& + F `
%& F X %' *
3 + 1 1 +%' ' + =
F+ %' X1 %&
2 %' + %'
F %& -F 1 X1 2
F + %*
= 2 F
, G1 (1 +*
F 1 .
% %' * F
F " 6888 . +%& 2
. %
%& (F+1 ( %'
(F+ F N
1 F 2 (
1 += ( XN
' + 1 +1 %& '
+1 ' %' F *
1 +
F *
# %' ` 2 ' (F+1 X 1
+ +%' %'
(F+ F * b- %' +
F ' (F+1
F '* , . F
- F 1 P %'
(F+ ` ' + -
+ I*
178
!
+ - F 1 %+1 U
L688ZM 2 - (F+ +
%' (F+ 2 %' 1
cF+ ` ' 1
` . F 1
F %' ( 1 1 &
%' Fd* 1 -
1 F . P (.
%' ( & 1 ' + -
F %' (*
, + ( + I1
- #F %' I1 ' X .
F1 2 X
( (F+ L1 6896M*
%+1 U L688ZM " 2 .
. %' 1 (
G K1 P F %' %&
(F+1 F %' +%
( 1*
, %' (F+N
1 ' P ` +
%' %' F %'
%' * 3 F1 " 2
(F+1 + 2 ' 2
" %' 2
( F *
+'1 U L6896M 2 + %
F ' %& (F+ J
J1 "
* 3 F1 1
= + % 2
' 2 1 ( +1 1
.1 FF+1 +' + *
# LKM1 . L M1
% L M1 3 # 1 3 b%'
1
3 / 1 *
179
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
1
0 2
+ %'N N F
+1 N
+%' F N G%'
'N %' + %'
%'1 = +.N ( N
N ' (%'N .N
F L1 N 1 6896M*
1 + /"1
F+ + I 2 + %&
P %& + I1 (
1 X1 % X F%' +1
P F%' '* =
%' 1 F
F F L(F+1 M
1 1 * U I+ L689;M
1 1 2 . 2
1 /"1 .
( %' F1 (
+ (1 '
+%*
, F %' (1 F+
%' P -
/ # / $ RP #1 " + I* 0
F+ ` 1
( "1 1 1 (F+
+ X *
!- RP # F+ + + 1
( 1 P
c 'd* $.=1 2 1 . P (
%' F* , + %' P
%' F - P 2
+ +. +- * X%'
P F %' & 1 =F+1
H1 1 # 3 L689;M*
0 1 9>>8 68881 +-
. %' ++ (
180
!
* 3 .1
% L F+M + 1 .
H1 X F
* #( I L6888M c
S %' F 1
+ " ++ 1
9>>8d*
3 "1 +=
H X* , F
( & L + F+ 2
+ F (M1 (%'
F 2
P 1 1 %& &
L$N #1 6884M* I " + ( %'
( F 1
P1 . 1 *
F %' P (
F %' %' %&1 + I
% ++ * E
1 = F F+ 1 +
+ F + P 2 +
%& N 1 + I F+
F F + P X 2
P F F H1 O *
=1 F1 2 + F .
%' L 1 %& -M F+
2 & %& (F+ X L
1 1 . *MN %'
L ` " /"MN +'
+% P X L RP #MN
+' +% %' X L / # / $M*
1 - 2 %& F+
2 ' L " K 2 %&
/" M1 " 2
++ ( 1 2
( + L /"
RP #1 2 1 %' "1
( F %' "M*
181
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
b- " 2 ' 1 1 + (
%&N 1 ++ ( %&N
(F+1 ++ ( (F+N 2 ++
%& 1 *
, + F '1 X%'1 .* E
F+%'1 F F X1
( %' ++ P1 F "
1 2 ++ %*
( 2 F
+ %' F 2 *
3 P %'1 ' + F+
F 1 +X (
( ++ F 2
F *
!'*

+ 1 '
- + F * , F
= %'*
L689;M & - F 2
F "=F+ F
J F '
+1 %' %' P
G "=F+ ,
%& + L e 1 689;1 *
Z >M* F &1 &
F ( %'
+%'* 0 +-+ L %' M
(
( L+ %' +%'M*
+%& F 1 U I+ L689;M
& . - 2 1 %&
(F+ F%'N + ( 2 '
2 L 'M ++ *
3 F1 ' - ' + 1 +X
( * R" ' (
++ %' P ( 1
182
!
. U I+ L689;M* 0 2 "
+%& 2 . *
1 %' P ( F - F *
0 F " F F
F * , F 2 '
` 1
F * 3 1 ( F F
+ F G
+ ( F 2 +%& F
' ++ (*
" '(
( ( %' F
' 1 1 2 &
,1 %& ' %' *
( ( %'1 " 2
' 2 G 2 F ( %'1
" F *
# %' ` +%& F 1 2 " 2 1
( 1 .= ( F+ %'
( %' F1 S X +
1 %' * , S + (
F ++ + 1 '*
1 1 K1 2 ( + S
%'
#(. 1 %
+%
( %' F * %'
+ +1 -1
1 *
# 1 S F+
K 2 X1 F * #
F + F+ -1
1 + +%*
#'
F L#
M (P F+ %'
%& K1 +
L M L
- M*
183
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
#'
RF L#
RM (P F+ %'
%& K + I1 +
L - M
L - M*
3 K1 % %' ' F P1
( 2 (F+ ' ++
( %' F * 1 K
P %' (F+1 = 2 + I ' &
1 1 1 2 & '
(P F+ 2 " ++ %'* 1 +
' * 0 + I +
1 %' F 1 (%&
%' 1 . %' %'
+ ` +*
, P (. " +
(F+1 2 (. J
1 J (P %'
( %'* 1 1 1 3
# * 3' " F+1 1 2 F F
+ (. F *
3 /"1 " F "
2 1 1 - F 1
%& + ` F%' ' ` P '
* 1 1 %& 2 '
X % F%' 1
(. . *
3' -1 1 % %' F%' +
/"* 0 2 - " ++ +
+ I1 ( "1 ( %'1 + 2
1 ( +- "1
-+ X 1 %'1
+ * R=1 1 F + `
%' + I1 F+
+ %' *
3 RP #1 (P %' (
F P 1 2 P F
S %' 2 ++1
+ "
184
!
++* , S " ++ 1
+ + I*
1 = 2 + F & %
S P - 2 G (
( %' F * , S ++ ( 1
%& 1 " S +
F F %' *
!'(
( %' F " 2 %&
( ' -F1 1 ' * '
( 2 ' -+ ++
%'1 2 ' "1 %' 1 (
%' (% %' 2 ( ( *
, X F
2 P %& (F+
( %'1 - P P %'
1 L( - P'
XM X L%' X M* 3 1
+ F+ + 1 (
%'*
3 + F 1 %'
X 2 ' -+ %'1 (
++ 2 ( 1 - ( 1
P F+ %&1 + (F+
%& *
+%& F 1 =
2 - P F+ %& 1 2 (
F %' (F+* 3 F1 = 2
F+ ' (F+ + (
1 & %' %&* 1
%' . P 2 1
1 + 2 2 ( X L M + (*
, F1 1 X +. +
I 1 1 ( ( (F+*
, ' F + 1
1 F *
185
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
3 1 K 1 X

-+ %' %& + &
S %'* 1 %'1 %'1
*
$ " P /"
RP #1 2 + I
1 (1 * %'
1 1 2 ( + (*
3 1 1 ' S P F
%' ( 1 * 1
/"1 1 X , F+1 (
+ "1 2 + %& ( *
b- 2 + L + ( +M
' ++ %' * 1 1
/ # / $1 2 L
-M X L M ' ++
%'* R" " I1 2
X ' -+ %'*
" %' %&
/"1 2 %& ' %& ' +1
X +%
( LN N 1 689;M*
E (1 = 2 +%& F
%'1 2 + 1
%& F %' %&
( * 2 F+1 '
+ S ' ` %' F1
F+ F %'*
# 2 P %' .
. 2 ( %'* ,2 (.
" + 1 +1 & %'
S* # 1 %'
& %' = *
Monitoramento e avaliao
( +%' %& 2
' +X ( +* E
186
!
+ F1 += 2 ' ++ (1 2

+ -=1 2 2 2 . +%' L
%' 2 ( M*
E + F 1 (
+%' X + 2
(1 F+ P 2
2 . +%' P F *
+ 1 = 2 (
X %& '
* 1 + "
L %' %'M1 2 . X
+%& *
3 F1 + 1 (F+
-F1 +%' % 1
( %
%& -F*
3 X J K J1
+%' ' 1 2
+S * 1 1
' (%' + 2 (
+ I 2 " *
F +%' 2 * ,
. O %' X 2
+- +- %&*
, F 1 2 '
+%' " ( + F %'
%&1 ' P
J 2 %& ' +
%& (F+* 0 "
X- F LIN 1 689;M*
1 1 /"1 2 1 - ( 1
( 1 F+ -
2 + (%& +
2 + &*
, %' (%& " (
%' # L#M* , '1 (
%'1 -+
(%& -
187
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
#N , F+1 ( + " 1 2

1 & %&N
#. /1 2 (%& F1
& *
=1 (1 2 F .
( X + +%'
%&* 0 = % ( 1 F
1 +X
1 (%& +- %&
-+ %' F *
,1 +%'1 1
. (%' 1 2 +%&
(H1 + %' * 1
' %' F P
* %' ` 1 (
+ 1 %
F ++* 3+ S +%'1
+ 2 F+
++ %& 1 ++ F *
&
, "

+ F + (
F 1 " + FX X
F *
X 2 " X %'
1 F +-
++ ( ( %' * 0%& (
F +1 "
PF +%'* " 1 %& 2 ' .
%' P 2 %& + *
b- "1 1 (%& 2
%& *
K X 1 ` 1 (
%'1 ( X 2
F + *
X = ( %'
F %' (F+ F%'
188
!
+ * W T L6889M1 " X %' F %'
= 1 c F+ S
+ ' O d*
K 2 X = F%' .1
2 (F+ F F *
0 F +. . 1
F (F+* ,
+ ` %' %&1 ` %' F F+
' 1 +. F %'1
*
2 X + & F
+ I1 * #G F=
F %& 1
. ' %'
F F %&*
%'1 X FX (=
" F %& ++ += c+
` & % Fd
L=31 688>M1 '
%' X %&
F F *
E (1 "
+%'1 2 c d %& 2
F 1
+%'*
- *
. F
' F 1 + 2 F+
( XF+ (F+ F
P #F %'
I 9>ZZ*
+ 2 ` . (% $ L6884M
%' F1 2 %' 1 +.= 2
F ( ` .*
# %' `
'(
1 =
2 + . + +1 +
189
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
%' F+ + 1 %' *
%' %' +
F (1 %' X
+ F+1 2 ` %' F
%'1 (
( %' F*
2 + F +
& %'1 ' * 0 +
'
F 2 2 %' *
3' 2 X 2 +
( %& -F ' * # %'1 =
+ 2 ( + X.
1 X F (= F
F +% 2 ' + F *
0 + F+ =
'( "

'
* 0 F '
-+ (
+%* & (= `
+%1 X K1 2 F 2 (
2 = %'
+ +% * ' " 2
+%1 + 2 F '
F+ +%* , ' -
( %'1 2 " +* F
1 ( %' +%'
F1 & 1 2 X1
+ + +%1
* ,1 1 . +
%' %' +%1 X. %&
1 ( 2 %' +%*
0 + F ' '1 P1 X
F 1 ( `
*
` (%1 += 2 F
+ 2 ` *
.

'(

/ %' ( %'
+% (F+ 2 +% 2
F accountability *
190
!
K + 2 ++ +1 +%1

%& 1 & +%1 "
%' G (%' = "
. 1 + +*
0 ++ +1 " %' +
1 " %&
+%' F1 . ( ( %'
+%' F * + F1 +
F %' + S F+1 "
%' F%' 1 % +%'
+- ++ " + G `
1 + `2 P F%'*
1 + 2 '
F * +1 +1 +
2 ' - 2 F ' P .1
" ++
" %' ` (F+ %& +1
F 1 %' F
% -F '
(%' *

X S +%' '
F %' ++ + 1
" * 0 F
% 2 + I
+%' '1 2
9>>81 +%' K'
* R + + I ' X 2
2 & ` ( (F+
X* / 1 + +%'
+ -F F1
%' , * #P= (.
%' % F+ ,1 K'
+ % %'
F *
, + X %' ( ,1 + "
+-+ ( %' + %' F &
%'N = G 2 %&
2 ( ( F +1
' %' (F+
F +*
191
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
0".

1,
1 I * #%' IF+ .
Ib# X +* )+ F1 # F1 688:*
1 / b R+ * ) (%'* )+* *
*1 5 6<1 * 6>=<81 ! 688:*
1 /*N U1 * Q1 /* , #T R
=E+
F+ F LE
M* #E Q 6>>* 1
E*#* # ( E+1 6896* E+ U77\\\*+*7
7 F779<646>6* 687987689;*
* /* E1 ( %' * 9* * )
! I %' $7I 1 6896*
* I
R %' *
EE0 J )+ #. 1 ) !1 5 ;1 6898*
* /" F %' S P J I*

)( F * , KI/* b 6884*
* 1 * +1 F %& FF+ %'
%' ` F %' * E1 +* ;1 * :81 * <<;=<4<1 688Y*
* L*M* S F%' * ' #1 6898*
1 /* +1 R* 1 * %'
- F ` 0*
# E1
689;1 /+* $
#
#* /+ # E1 689;*
* . )* #(. *
E+ U77\\\**+*77(*
6Y 6896*
# 31 * # X P
F1 F %' %=* ,01
+* 9:1 * 6>1 689;*
I1 / I * 1 3+
F F
* # ' #1 +* 9Z1 6888*
* 1 + F F +
+*
+1 ,2 I1 , L*M* F
S* ,1 6884* +* 6*
I1 * 1 * 0 P + F
* $
#
E # )( E , E
P 1 689;*
I1 * %' , # F
. *
,
1 ,%' ,
* # R1 9 $'1 $
J #(. 3 E .

* #3 J # 3 . 1 6899*
192
!
I1 #* I #F+ F %' 9>ZZ

F * R E * I %' $* '
6898*
I1 W * F G& ( ` -F
- F * F 1 * 691
6888*
1 * / F * / F # I%'
# , F * I 1 ' 688>*
1 )*N 1 *N 1 /* %' (F+ F
" P #F %' I ZZ*
, 3
1 ;1 688Z1 +* * + ,*
+1 ** P +
9>>8* 3+ , 1 5 441 * >9=98>* 688;
* b1 * *N #1 ** )%' F %&
+ + S %' X F* )+
#. 1 +* 691 5 481 * <;=44* 6884
* E1 %' %' +*
3+1 +* 4Y1 * 4Y1 * <>=98;* 6884
* 1 #** 0 ( %' Pd* 3+1
* 4Y1 * >=9<* 6884
1 *N
$1 ,*
- +P -F*
L0*M* +P
-F " F T P1 FP
T * /" #
+F T ,
J K+ $ * 6898
W1 / R /* I1 %' * ,
1 +* 41 * 981 95 1 6889*
W1 ! * ! *
+1 ,2 I1 ,
L*M* F S* ,1 6884* +* 9*
1 * I1 * 0 RP 3+
F *

# E1 689;1 /+* #
# E1 9;* /+ # E1 689;*
1 *N 1 R*
%' %'1 S
*
# ' #1 +* 9:1 5 :4* ' 6898*
1 * * N $1 !* #* %' F
(F+ F *
# E1 68961 #* #
#1 9Y* K T # E1 6896* +* 9* * 9*

1 R* 1 T1 # F RT*

F1 9>4<*
/1 #* R ! * R %' + * '
I 1 9>>:*
* ," F #"1 /2 +1 * R %'
+ * ' IK3E1 9>>4*
193
%) +$#
,+# -#/
!
+
#
) +$# #0 1
* 1 + +* R %'

I ) )* ' IK3E1 9>>4*
=3* F *
%'
, # ` EFX%' L,M , )' 31 688>*
E+ U77***7688>78Y7=F *
* 6Y 6896*
1 )* 1 * 1 F
F F ++*
,1 *
* # ++ "
* F
- F=
F *
1 5 91 6899*
1 #* + # E
E%'* #. #F+1 +*Y1 5*; ' 6886*
* + # E
E%'* #. #F+1 +*Y1 5 ;1 ' 1 6886*
$1 !" #* % +%
P=F%'* # ,1 %' 1 6884*
$1 !" # #1 , * E++ F
* ,
L,3M1 6884*
1 * R( , + '
J F1 F+ F *
+1 L*M*
S F%' * ' #1 6898*
U
E #. F K+ ' LKM1 (= #
F P= %' F K+ I #
LKI#M* # *U^*
!" # $
E %' , J
(%' I %' $ LI$7M1
( K+ ' LKM J , 1 #. b 1 %'
P= %' ' F * # +^ *
194
Variaes setoriais em arranjos

'(
"

Roberto Rocha C. Pires
*+$
($ '#=# %#
;*<
Alexandre de Avila Gomide

*+$
($ '#=# %#
;*<
0 F 2 ( -F L +

( +M1 F ' + L**1 +1 +M
. %' F S*
1 +% 1 '1
+ F %' F -
+ I * # - F+ L#M1
' FX F LM % 2 cFd +%
2 %' F (N LM F%&
` - -F 2 F 2 1 +%&
* 0 +% '
( S %' + *
%' (1 +%1 F 1 %'
2

3 "
, e P -F L + (
M1 F T L**1 +1 +M
T P F -*
, T , 1 1
T F P F
I * K - F+ L#M
LM 2 cFd 2
FP F (N T LM (
gF 689<* $' X 689<*h

195
Variaes setoriais em arranjos de implementao de programas federais
( * - F+ +
P ( - P
f*
P (1 1 F 1 P
2
%

" "

R F Q + ( \
F1 F =+ L** + TM
F ( T *
\ +\ (
+ F1 \ ( F T
( F F F ( ( *
2 F+ F+ T L#M ( 1 F
LM F c+ Td F (
( N LM FF T
1 F F +F T* R X
U F ( T ( ( F T
+ T*
$#% ( F1 +1 T1 F
196
Introduo
I I Q T1 - 11 c .
, . Fd S1 1 =* 3
%' 1 . ,1 "1
, F+ ( * E
1 2 + F %& F 2
1 F+1 P'
. accountability*
3' - + 2 F+ + %' F
2 " 69 1 + 2 F
F ( ( %'1 %'
* , 2 ,
+ - + + 1 F +
2 F 1 %'1 +1
1 F%' 1 . *1 %' `
. P , E++F , =,
1 %' P F+1
%' F *
3 1 F 2 (
L + ( +M ' L**1 +1
+M . %' F
S* 3 F1 F+ +
F 2 F +
I +. *
"1 2 X %&
F %' L %&M . %'
F ( # +%& X %&
% F+1 F = (*
1 = +' +%
1 F 2 ' FX ( %&
U77\\\*==*7( Q T768967987867===(====F=7
6 6896*
#( - X%' R ET L9>>:M1 F " 2 2 + (*
0 1 1 1 %& +* %'
F 1 F+ ++ %'
%&1 + L++ ( %' 1
( %'1 '1 %'1 1 +%' *M1 ' P
2 1 X F *
197
%' (%& %'

%' (F+%'
F* , +' F
F %' P S*
1 ( F
++ L 1 F1 1 P'
*M F %' %'
%' F X*
3 2 .1 &= -
F+ F ++ +
I 2 ` F F %'*
I -F F+
J "1 F L ( (%M
F "* " 1 = %' . 2 GF
%& ( -1 1 ( 1
2 %' #
L#M J / #1 / $N %' ) '
IN b" /N F+ +%'
+ JN 3 %' K N
/N IN 3 , R"
, LM;* , + ( %'
+ c+d F 2 + I
+%' " +%
F "*
X1 = %'
%' F1 2 LM
% 2 cFd +% 2
%' F + IN LM F%& 2 `
( - -F 2 F 2 1 +%&
* 1 (%= %'
( %' , S1
;
1 ( "+1 ( 1
+ + =+1 S
c,1
++ S F F F ++d*
F 1 " 1 2 2 1 R"
2
/ # ) # FN ( E # F K+
' LKM1 / ) 1 / R / I %' $
LI$M ' N 2 F W 1 2
E++ 3 L3E7
M J + 9*
198
+% %' (H1 %&

%& +%1 F
*
4'

F " " 68 " 69 .
(%' ( %' %' 2
2 ,* R (%& ' .
+1 1 "1 ( 1
* 0 +% %& J
%& F . F S J
%< ( GF
X %& F 2 .
%& ,1 %' F 5*
R X )
+% X % F F+ +1
(= + +N + %&
%' N + "
2 " + L)1 9>>41 * 4:6M*
+% X %&

%& F . 2 1 *
2 %' %'
<
= - (%&1 L688:M 2 +%
" c"F F d* 1 c + +%_
LQT..M F + N XP( ( ` %'
+ , L***M + FX "F_ L***M F ' _
_1 2 ( %' + 2 , L +_1 +_
_M1 (= %' J %' +
F %& *** (
%' d L1 688:1 * ;<M
3 F1 %' +% . X%&
+% + ' * ,2
` %& ,=1 1 (2 1 " ` %'
+%' F %' + L%& , F+1 F+ F
FM* , 1 +% 2
%' c d1 ++ F
2 +%' F %' F *
199
%' L (%'7
F%' G F+M* !- 2
%& 2
%& 1 2 ` F+ +
L% ' F+ ++ - O1 (+
G F%'M* X1 %' 2 %&
++ .1 X%1 F1
F + F+ L G 1
M* %' .
%' 2 . F 1 -F1
( %& (1 +1 ( *
++ %' . & +
.1 + ( F %'
*
F F%' 1 +%
. (% F+ + %' , S 2
-2 L%'1 %' %'M1
2 ` (%& " 68 P= 1
%' F+
L 1 *M %' L1
FM*
3 1 + . ( , F
F- 2 G& cbig governmentd
- cbig governanced L =I1 6896M1
+ -2
, 1 ++ F%' F
F %'7%'*
2 1 1
+F L2 F
" 68M ( F %'1 +F%'
%'1 1 + 1 H F
-+* 1
%' F 2 J G
X %& ,1 J1 2
' %' F
+ ' + L1 688:M*
" %' (%& ,
+1 +% 2 F
% + = X
200
%& ( (.=

E (1 %' 2
2 . % + F +%
L/1 6896M*
0 X ( (
( * , 1 %& - L!1
6889M* , + 1 ` %' ` %'
P1 2 2 1 +1 %'
1 F L F+M1
L F+M1 F%
L F+M* '1 =
& L 1 1 *M1 2 '
F %' ,*
, %&1 - " . F1
%' 1 2 `
%& %' (%' Lstate-buildingM1
' F (- 1
, %' H X* 3 F
LM1 ( ` %& 2 ,
1 1 1
G LR1 9>Y:N 1 9>Y>N #1 689;M*
K %'
GF 2 , J 2 -
- %' J L 'M F1
( (F+1 F+ 2 F 1
+' +% L/1 6896M* , +
L M %' 1 . (
c, %'d J "1 FX%'
1 ( %' %&1 %' %& *
%' F ++ 1 2 1
1 , %' F L1
9>Z:N N I1 9>Z6N /1 9>>;N ,1 9>>:N 1 9>>4M*
` %& %& %
` +%1 " + . F+
F * 3 1 % ` +% '
* R= F+
c+ ,d Lhollowing outM %'
, F F .
201
%& 1 +* %'

(%' F -F +F1 "
(. ( %& +1 +
H1 (
1 . F%'
* # 1 %' F
,1 P ( (
1 X1 %' hards L%'
%'1 +#?M @ LF+1 F %' %'1
carrotsM1 % 1
' L/1 6896N 1 689;M*
, %' + F F+1
F+1 2 (%&
( %& " ,1 ' %' *
( 1
+S LBM* 1
%' %' J , F+
, ) L/1 9>>>M* , + L J steer J +
J rowM , %'
F LX1 PM1 1
1 , %'
H L/1 6896M*
X1 " F+ 2 %'
F %' 1 1 =
. F+1 2 ( 2 %
` %' +% .
+%' ,* . ( 2 X%'
%& ' %' F
' 1 1
F %'* R X # 0
g***h %' +%
+%' ,1 %' '
( %' %' F 1 1
1 X. (F+ g***h + .
c(% d g ' F F+h + 2 1
2 . X1
%' %' (
g***h1 , + L01
688>1 * 96M*
202
XF ++ (. %' "

( %&1 ( F 1 ' 1
+ ( %'
+ 1 1 %'
L G M1 (%
+ F(1 " (
+%' F G& F+ L/1 6896M*
" %& (%
1 . (F + +%' L1 6896N
N 1 6896M* 0 + 2
( (-=
F F ( F+1
+*
2 %' (%& LPFM1
2 + ( %' %& 1
X1 ++ + 1 +%'
F+* 1 1 +%'
%& F F 1 1
. F+ +*
L688<M1 +% + 2
+ %' ( =1
F+ F %&
1 S 2 G' F+
F e Llearning by
monitoringM* 1 ( 2
1 F+
( + F 4*
, F " . +%&
F+1 + 2 %' .= + ++
F 1 1 %' 1 F+
* 1 +%' %'
1 G 1 %& (1 .
F ( -1 " +%& 1 +
L1 6896M* L688<M + +%& F+ L (
1 2 " +%& % M F %& X
( -71 2 +
* 1 %' % %' (
. +%&*
203

'( "

FX%' . ( F+ F+ 2
%' +% "
( 1 ( ++ L1
H1 F M ' %'
F X* 1 2 ' G'
+% 2 F
%' F ' ++ F
%& 2
'1 %' %& e
, F %'
1 2 X ( F
%' F X* 1
2 ( F X1
%' +% %'*
%' = &
%& % F +
%' 1 ++1 1 F+
%'1 LM( %& ' %& -* 1
F %' X 2 ' ++1
2 ' " 2 ( %' %'1
+ X* E (1 F
c%d 2 & %& + %
& %& F 1 F
- +%& F *
, %' + J ( %'
%' ( 1 X1 P
1 P J ,
%'* 3 1
- ` (F+%'
F ( 1
F %' +Y*
1 1 +
F+ F %'
= 1 1 2 + G P
F * 3 1 (% F (
F 1 "1 2 2 %'
F *
204
F -F %' + I F "Z*

1
= # X F L1 1 G *M
2 + I F
= F + ( -
F %' +
3 %& 1 " P
L%' " -M - F+N
1 %' % 1 1
+%'*
56
3

2 & 1 - %'
( -F + E1
"1 L( M F 98 * 0
( / # / $ L/#/$M1
%'
) ' I L
IM1 K b" / LKb/M1
)+%'
3+ L)
3M1 3 %'
K L3M1 / L/M1 I LIM
3 , R" , LM*
0 9 1 F+1
LM%' - -F 2 + * R
( 2 1 ++
F 2
,H L
M1 2
F L(* N 1 689<M* R F=
F L M J "1 ( 1
+ F 1 %& F 1 F
F F+ -+*
1 + ( 1
- F 1 +%' +%&
( %' + %' F L
M* 1 = 2 (
( 2 - F
F %' F
( +%* # - + F 1
(F+%' 2 * K - (
%' L689<M
2 - F+ J 9 (. -X*
205
G' 2 & J FX%' X %&

%' ' % +%&>*
0 ( F F - F+*
1 ( FX%' - % %
%' F L %' Aspectos
comuns nos arranjos de implementaoM* , 1 FX
(% %' 2
(% 2 (
- -F* X1 F # LF$+2 +2
AnalysisM1 2 2 F+ 2 F
- %&
L/N )N )1 689;M*
7 8 -9
,'( 1 1
Caso
: ; -
rea
Programa
Minha Casa
/ $
LMCMVM
% 688> F+

"X
* R= F X

+ I1 + %'
( " . -
J # L N
/N 1 689;M*
<

Programa
3
Acesso ao
, R"
,
LM
% 68991 F ` F

' %' X %' =
( L' (M1 =
. X " L( =(%'1
X F %&1 SM
F %' +1 =
1 ' +
* 0
F+ F %' =
` %' X P 2
L#N 1 689;M*
<

>
2 " * E( 2 +-+1 2
+ %& +%& F+ ( &
%'1 2 = &
%& F F+ 2 F+
* R &1 1 ' + 1 1
- *
206
Caso
: ; -
rea
Programa
I
L=M
# 688<1 F+

++ ( + -+ 2
%' 1 +
( ` +%
L F 1 %' . M1
(.
( )[ Y8 )[
9<8 L#1 689;M*
<

!"

%'
) '
I
L!<=M
) 688Y1 2 #1

F+ -
3 (
F '*
+. %' 488 2 H
L M
%' + %& -
+ - 1 P
2 L 1 1 #- )
3M J #
L N RN I1 689;M*
K
b"

Monte
L>?@M
) = 1

# 688Y* 0 ++
%' " ) 1
F+ ( "
L1 689;M*
Programa
3
%'
K

LAM
% 688<1 + %'

P 1
P F+ e+
* 0= F+
%' 1 " '
1 F%'
(1 F +F
+ L1 689;M*
Industrial
Plano Brasil
/ L@M
0 ( 68991 P

( +%' FF+
H * + +"
F (%' ( F+1
+ J
& X (-1 X F
J + + H L1
689;M*
Industrial
!"
207
Caso
: ; -
rea
)+%'

3+ LRINM
F+ F

6888 1 1 #
F+
F P
-1 %' %& *
F + (
+ + X
1 2
F+ %' +F
%' +
LN N 1 689;M*
Industrial
"
I ,%' P L689<M*

'(
R F 91 F7
- F+ ( J 2 +
%' " ` +' +% %'
X (. J 1 X
F1 X . F - %'
,* 3 1 (%1 F
% %' %'* K
% '
2 . " +%
%' F ( *
K 2 2 " ( 2 F
- ' -7 2 + I
F+ %' . ( %'
'* # + 91 2 +
F+ - %'1 ++ 2 &
F L**1 %& F P
PM 2 + %' .
+ I1 + + +*
3 F1 ( F 1 %'1
. 1 % 1 1 P
1 2 #F %' I %' +
%' .1 " ( %&
(F+1 + +* 1 = ( 2
c+d F = -7 2 +
208
I X%' %'
F* , ' F+
+ F + I 1 "
2 ' F L
( M %& L EM*
K 1 2 ` %1 " ++
F +X P' ( %' ( %&
F%' F+ F* 3 1 F
+ I ' 1 L 1
P 7 XM . F (*
, 1 - % "1 2 1 1
( %' F %'
%'* , 1 1 1
I1 /"
%' 3 L/

3M ( 1
%' /" L#M # #+* , 1
31 ++ 9; ( 1 F
#' , F+
L#,
M*
" P' %' 1 1 =
%' P' %' ( %& "
%'* , 1 X %' P'
F M . 2 ( %& L
F ( ( + -+MN M .
(1 * 3
F1 P' + ( %' "
+ %' %' L1
1 1 H 1 *M* 1 F 2
+ ( 2 + 1
H + -+1 ' %&
F %'* 1
Kb/1 )
31
I1 %' ++
P' . 3 , ," LM1 .
3 ] L3M
F / )
3 )+-+ L
M1 2
F # /
#+%' + L
#/M1
F H bP
eF 3 L
M I %' 3 LI M*
!- F P' %'
' 2 2 ( %'1
%' F* , %& &
209
G L 2 P' %' M 1 1

' * 3 /1 =
. ( LI , J IM
L. E++
J E
M -+ ( %&
F 1 F+1 X + ` 2 1
' * !- 1 = %'
)
F I , %' X RP1 -+
+' 2 X%' X* /
.1 % 1
* , F
1 1 ,1 ,-
3 E++ L3E,M # ,H I
%' F* 1
' =+ %'
3 L e+M1 )
3 L R %'
+ %' (M1 / L
F+ P -1 M* 1 #
,H I %' %' F
/#/$ L%' X %' +1
1 F + %'1
M1 I L%' (. X-M1
)
3 L X ' XM*
I1 1 = % %' 3E,1
L = M F - *
K ++ +
%'* , 1 %' I1
+ ( %& + F%' F+
F1 X-
* , 1 + +'
+% 1 1 1 /#/$ L
++ %& X-M1
I
Kb/ LP + +M1
LF %& + +% %' X
PM* , 1 ' P + F1
)
31 3 / L 1 %& X
7 F+1 ++ HM*
K 2 " . %& +
%' F* E(
F1 1 . 1 %'1 1 .
210
1 1 %& +

' + ' L I1
I1 Kb/1
)
31 /1 M* $X= %
31 2 X X%'1
+ 1 %& FX%'
# e+ N /#/$1 2 +
X F +
- %' L /#/$ ,FM* # 1 1
%& + '
%' F*
I1 F + X %&
%' ` %& P'
LF1 -F M10* , 1 F+
%& P' R # K' LR#KM1 #=
K' L#KM1 /" 1 R I LRIM1 "
# 3* R ( &1 e
F #1 %' F + F
' F+ L( %'
+ 1 %' +P1 %' +
1 . *M* , 1 31 /#/$1
I
1 %& # ( L 'M 1
++ ( F1
" & X* , 1 Kb/
)
31 S ( 1 (
& -* ' -F1 #K R#K1 '
1 ( + L I1

I1 )
3 M1 F%'
F* I1 P' F%1
RI /" 1 " +-
1 2 Kb/
I1 %' G
++ %& F *
, 1 - %'
2 c+d F 2 +.
+ I F " M ' 7 2
10
T %'
+ F %& 2 , F+ L 1 6898N
R1 6898N 0+1 6898N I N +1 6898M* 1 2 F %&
F1 -F *
211
+ I & ( %' %'N M
+ %& L 2 F + F MN
M 2 . 2 1
( %&=+ %' +%N M " 1
++ +1 ' % '1
1 %& +N M X1 '
+%' e P' F1 -F
*
2
'*
'( 1

- F+ %' F
" + (%'* R= F
+ 1 " * ,
%' FF+1 2
2 +%& '
2 F ++ 1
( *
%' %' . +-+1
11
9* F%' (F+ LI,EM1 1 7
. + F 2 '* 2
X= F 2 + I
F+ L%' .M ( %'
%'1 +%& 2 `
%' %' (
%'*
6* ` F%' L)RM1 "1
(F+ F%' + 1
* ,2 1 1 %'
7 L )
3
IM1 .
(P & +
+ L 3 M1 1
F%' ' ( " L/1 Kb/ /#/$M*
11
3 X%' +-+ = H1 2 1
F+ (P F # L)N )1 688>M*
212
;* #%' + L#,3R)M1 1 %'

F 2 ' - ( -2
+ L %' ( %' ( M*
,2 = -2
P' %' F%'
+ %'1 1 %' - (
( " + * 3
1 F 2
# 1 1 ` P %'
L # #+ 1 F 1 /"
M* ' #1 I
F F*
# F+ FX %' +-+
- -F J L0#
M1 L
3EKM ( L
3I)M
J1 F " # F L crisp-set QCAM* 1
F FF+ %' - F
( ( + H L M1 ( *
B 8 -
1
,'*

#F
Casos
]
I,E
)R
#,3R)
0#
3I)
/#/$
I
)
3
PBM

I
Pronatec
PNPB
Kb/
3EK
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
I ,%' P*
1 ` +-+

3I) ( + 91 2 2 F
2 ' ( X - ( 1 -1 +
" * E 1 = +-+ 0#

3EK*
, %' ` F FF+ 1 ` +-+ I,E (
+ 91 2 2 . +
F 2 '1 -1 = + N 1 `
+-+ )R ( + 91 2 = 2
213
(F+ F%' + 1

2 '1 -1 = + N ` %' #,3R) (
+ 91 2 = 2 %' F 2 ' -
( -2 F+1 -1 = + *
KF= R12 %& 1
( FX F %& +-+
. -1 vide R 6*
#( R 61 - X %& + 91
F+ M /#/$ IN M * 3 X %'1
+-+ I,E #,3R) ' N X %' LM1 '
+-+ I,E )R* E 1 ( FX F
%& +-+ ` - ( L+-+
3I)
+ 9M1 F+ M )
3
IN M Kb/* 0
% +-+ )R #,3R)1 +-+ #,3R)*
F - L+-+
3EK + 9M1 (
FX X %& F1 M /N
M 3E* 3 1 +-+ - 1 2
X %' = +-+ #,3R)* # 1 - F
( X %' P LFX
c#d +-+
3EKM )
3
I*
2 2
%' +-+ L)R #,3R)M1
F X ( ( L )
3 ( X
- F 1 2
I ' (M9;*
B D -, '*
Variveis
reas
Casos
I,E
)R
#,3R)
0#
3I)
3EK
/#/$1 I
)
31
I
PBM
Pronatec
PNPB
Kb/
I ,%' P*
12
#1 * 6899* Tosmana R ( =3 T g# h1 $ 9*;*6*8* R
K+T ( R*
9;
)1 1 2 %' " L X %&
@HM1 )
3 2
I ' F - ( *
214
FX X %& 1 P 1 "1 "
+-+ - F 1
- L (P PM 2
+-+ ` - F *
3 1 = %'
- F *
@

'(
1 <:-!F
/ X %& 9_ +-+ 0#
1 +=
(P
I,E9 )R8 #,3R)9 I,E9 )R9 #,3R)8 0#
9
L/#/$1 IM
LM
(P 1 + %&

+-+ ` F - 2 '* , (P
*
0 + 9_ +-+ g0#
9h " +
F 2 + (F+
%' gI,E9h1 ` F%'
g)R8h %' + g#,3R)9hN
F 2 + (F+
%' gI,E9h1 .
(F+ F%' + g)R9h
%' + g#,3R)8h*
0 2 %' / # /
$ I1 2 *
0+= 2 (P ' " 1 "
. +-+ * # 1 " # 2 %'
1 %' ' +*
1 @H P )1
P X1 +9<*
9<
%' P1 + ) E / L688>1 * :>=4:M*
215
= %' -

P151 "= (P
I,E9
0#
9
L/#/$1IM
P X %' (P

+ $ LI 9M* ,
P ) L M* %' " X
1 2 +-+ +
+ (H - LI,E9M*
(P X F -
+= + (F+ L M
%'* 3 . 1 +-+ =
L/#/$1 I M*
=
8 &
2 G <:-!F
I ,%' P*
15
bP X F I,E9)R8#,3R)8 I,E9)R9#,3R)9*
216
=1 1 %' X %&

' X - L+ 8_ +-+ 0#
M1 "=
I,E8
0#
8
L)
31
I/3Kb/M
2 2 F ' X
+= + (F+ L M* ,
1 +-+ = )
31
I1 /1 3 Kb/*
1 = 2 F FF+
%' F - %' ` F
- L( M " F%' (F+ L
I 9M* 1 I1 2 %'
+ I1
%' %' F Le.g*1 %'
# 1 *M* 1
+ "1
%'* 3 /#/$1 "1 +
+%' ++
* E(1 F ' '
F* " 1 - 2 1 F
- F "1 +1 2
%' F+ F%'
L 1 %' . F (
(P %' X PMN 2
%' + L /#/$ IM*
@

'(
1 !A=0
/1 1 X %& F - (
L
3I)9M1 = (P
I,E8 #,3R)9
3I)9
L)
31
IKb/M
, (P 2 F - (
. + (F+
%' + L%' -2
+ M* , . 1 +-+ =
)
31
I Kb/*
217
X %& 2 ' (
X - ( L
3I)8M1 "=1
I,E8 #,3R)8 )R9 #,3R)8 I,E9 )R8 #,3R)9

3I)8
L/3M
L3M L/#/$1IM
R= (P * 3 (P

1 = %'
P94:
I,E9
#,3R)8
3I)8
L/#/$1IM
L/3M
2 %' F 2 F 2 ' (

X ( +-+
+ %' LI,E9M
%' + L#,3R)8M*
, 1 $ LI 6M1
%' F ( (
F - L M . S
F %' -2 . F%'
(F+* R . F - (
LKb/1 )
3
IM # 1 1
%' + P' %'
(* R ( 2 %'
+ " - L/#/$ I1 - M1 1 1
- F%' XF+ (F+1 %
F ( *
94
bP X I,E9)R8#,3R)8 I,E9)R9#,3R)9*
218
=
D &
2 !A=0
I ,%' P*
@

'(
1 !A&><
# + LR 9M1 - F X %'
P )
3
I1 X -
( %' +-+ L )
3
IM*
, = 1 = %'
X %& 9_ +-+
3EK1 %' (P
I,E8 #,3R)8
3EK9
L/3M
2 2 / 3 =

+-+1 F%' (F+
%' +*
E 1 (P F F 2 ' ( X
- L
3EK8M "
)R8 #,3R)9
I,E9 )R9 #,3R)8

3EK8
L/#/$1IKb/M
LM
219
(P 1 %'

P9Y1 2 %' 1 2
I,E9
L/#/$1IM
)R8#,3R)9
3EK8
L/#/$1IKb/M
, +1 2 %' 2 F ' X -

+-+ %'
+ F%'
%' +*
0 $ LI ;M 1 F1 2 F
- ' F P FF+ %'
F -* E ( 1
%' F X *
"1
F X ' F%'
(F+ LF F M .
%' + L FX e
F ( M1 %' 1 2 1
)
31 %' -2
#* I1 X - (
%' ` ` F%' * 3 31 ++
+ . +
+ %'
P* !- /1 ( F
F%' F1 = -F
( X L1 689;M*
9Y
bP X I,E9)R8#,3R)8 I,E9)R9#,3R)9*
220
=
H &
2 G !A&><
I ,%' P*
- *
0 F + %' ,
%' F 1 ( X %'
F ( L ( M F "*
' I Q T L6896M1 ( "
X %& 2 ' (F+
%& ' +' +%
* 1 +%1 (
' (%& ( , %'
(%& %' * F 1
F %'
F + I*
- F+ 2 %'
. % 1 (%1 2
( %' 2 ( - -F
+%' L1 ( M* ` %1
FX 2 F ( '
%' + P' ( L" + P'
%' M1
2 ( ( ( L 1
P1 X *M %'* , P'1
221
2 1 2

( %&=+ %' +%*
2 L M1 2
%' F %
X " S %'1 F =
( + I + F
* ++ + (
%' 1 " ( %
+1 " + P F* !-
%& + *
1 1 2 F
( . ++ P'
+1 1 %'
+* I1 + " 2
%' e e P'
F Le.g*1 #M1 -F Le.g*1 #K1 R#K *M LRI1
/" *M*
# %' FF+1 . +-+
J F%' (F+ 1 ` F%'
%' + J1 2 %&
X%' F - -F J 1
( * K - F+
(% 2 % F%' (F+
%' ' F 2 F F -
1 2 . F%' ' *
F 1 2

( 2 2 ( F%' 2 2
& %' -2 +
L%' +M*
K 2 F (
F " . %' .
S F %' -2
. F%' (F+* 0 2
F ++ 1 +1 .
( - 1 "1 ' .
%' L%' -2
+1 %' )
31 2 #M . ++
F+ (F+*
222
F 1 F 1
%' X ( %' ,
S ( (1 2 `2 2 ' %
2 `2 2 ' (% %'
F * R ' ' + %'
+ I1 + = . *
/ 1 . 2 F 2
%' *
%' F X %'
++ %' F 1
+%1 + %' 2
++ F+ %' %&
+1 F +1 %' L
' %'M .1 ( %&1 " *
, F +% F %' +%
LM %' F (1 FX
FF+ . * 3 1
2 %&
1 %' (%'
1 ( 2 - + ++
2 c+%1 F
Sd*
223
0".

#1 /*N 1 )* Pronatec F %&
` %' X* ) !
1 689<* LR E '1 5 9*>9>M*
#1 * J 4 ##K/ 2H 4 ##3 2
#

measures* K3K=/,)
R Q
F F , \
E 9;* 689;=8:;* 689;*

#1 E* #

1 , X
%' . %' * ) !
1
689;* LR E '1 9*Z:6M*
E1 R* Understanding public policy* F b* 9>>:*
,1 * Embedded autonomy* K+T * 9>>:*
I1 I*N 1 * # %' -F *
#1
*N /1 *N 1 * L0*M '
3 +$ L
## N $ O/
Repblica.
1 6898* *<Y;=:8<*
I1 I* L6896M* R ( F * The American
Interest* 6 6896* E+ U77\\\*==*
768967987867===(====F=7*
84 689:*
1 * +#W
T F * K+T
( #( * 9>>4*
1 *N 1 )* Capacidades estatais e democracia F
F *
1 689<*
!1 * Q LT M +\1 +1 F1
F* *+ "2H 4 #K1 +*991 61 * 9<>=9Y;1 6889*
1 )*N 1 /* *2+ * #1 /* b+
K+T 1 688<*
=I1 E* I +_ +_
+=I 1 E* L0*M
J 704
X
? 4 2#* 0( K+T 1 *;=9Z* 6896*
1 I* T %' (*

1 I*N 1 I*N 1 )* L0*M '
3 +$ L
## $ Y:
E*
1 6898* *9Z:=698*
1 /* )*N /1 $*N 1 * ##3
#Z ,+#
pblicas / # / $* ) !
1 689;* LR
E '1 9*ZZ4M*
1 /* )*N R1 /* *N I1 * Democracia e desenvolvimento no
1 #[ G F %' ' I*
) !
1 689;* LR E '1 9*ZZ;M*
/1 * E , F+ , 2 . %
+%* Revista do Servio Pblico1 :81 5 91 *:=;41 9>>>*
/1 /* J $# 4 # H ( 3F= 1 9Y48 =
9>9<* # K+T 1 9>>;*6
224
/1 N )1 *N )1 #* R 1 +1 F (

F+ #F+ T X 6: T* '$ +# ##
Review1 I T1 * 9=6Z1 689;*
/1 I* + T*
+=I 1 E* L0*M* J 704

X
? 4 2#* 0( K+T 1 6896* *6Z9=6>;*
01 #* + T X_ +1 94 ::8=:461 688>*
01 #* %' F , F+
( *
#1 *N /1 *N 1 * L0*M '
3 +$ L

## N $ O )*
1 6898* * <<;=<Y6*
1 * 7

22
#$ #/ #
)
,+#B+$#
8#

$ 9
1
;81<*
) !
1 689;* LR E '1 9*Z:ZM*
1 * W* 22+3 #\ ##
,+#
#$

# %!= * ) !
1 689;*
LR E '1 9*ZZ<M*
1 )*N 1 *N 1 * + + +%' +
-F* ) !
1 689;* LR E '1 9*Z4<M*
)1 )*** R \ + + \ +* +#
Studies1 5 <<1 * 4:6=44Y1 9>>4*
)1 *N )1 #* $+ #+2
F+ #F+
T L#M 2 * , F1 688>*
)1 *N E /1 * #= F+ #F+ T L#M*

)1 *N )1 #* #* L,*M $+ #+2
F+
#F+ T L#M 2 * , F1
688>* * ;;=4Z*
1 #* T = + F1
T*
,1 ,*N b1 /* L,*M* 2

#+*
EF + * 1 688<*
1 #*N 1 !* , +*
=I1 E* L0*M J 704

X
? 4 2#* 0( K+T 1 6896* *94>=9Z4*
1 /* %+2
$
42
F * ) !
1 689;* LR
E '1 5 9*Z:4M*
1 $* ) F %' *
Civitas1 +* :1 5 91 * 6>=:Z1 688:*
1 R*
# 2$+ F+ T ( I1 ) 1
#* # K+T 1 9>Y>*
1 R* Q ( T *
,1 *1 )1 E*1 1 R* L,*M 1 #? *

# K+T 1 9>Z:*
1 R*N I1 W* T +F T \
* +# ## F$K1 >YL6M1 * 6::=6YZ1 9>Z6*
225
1 ,* + +F *

+=I 1 E* L0*M
J 704
X
? 4 2#* 0( K+T 1 6896* * 69:=66Y*
R1 /** R # K' RP
F EX
#S*
#1 *N /1 *N 1 * L0*M ,1
F %&
E J $ 9 )*
,1 6898* *;9:=<<6*
R1 #* R (F ( F , * K+T1
9>Y:*
1 * 3\ + T *
+=I 1 E* L0*M* The
704
X
? 4 2#* 0( K+T 1 6896* *6<6=6:<*
) ) #*
E F / U
F ( RT L/
RM
2
F 2 ,H L
M1 E , ,1
F %& E LEM* # *^*+**

]+
E %' + I %' $ ' LI$=M
2
F 2 ,H L
M1 E ,
,1
F %& E LEM* # *^*+**
226
Energia e desenvolvimento
1

'(

92

%1 ;9%1<
, F (%

F F+ *
3 1 P ( 2 1
1 + %' * "
F+ 1 +
%' + & ( ( L,,M* 1
2 F +% -* #
++1 X %&
' + %'1 2
"F1 1 1 X. "F1
+* K
X " 1 F +-*
++ -+1 +-+1 +%'
1 X. "F1 F "F1
5 #

3

, e (
F F+ * ,
1 T 2 P
+ P -* - F+
- 1 P ( +
L,
M ( XF+* 1 2 F
gF F 689<* $' X (+ 689:*h

227
Energia e desenvolvimento sustentvel no Brasil em comparao internacional
+ * # 1 ( O
+ + P1 2
"F1 T1 +1 T X "F1
* K c d
T O 1 F *
1 +1 +P 1
X "F1 F "F1
5#

R F ( _ F \ \=
T1 F ( \ T * _ T \
\ F * (\ +T Q \ T
+* + F+T 1 \ T
+ X F LbM * +
T1 F ( +
( F1 \ T T 1 F1 +
T1 Q ( + T* 0 1
( ( +* 0 ( (
1 F *
$#% +1 \ T1 T +F1 T
T1 T T1 F
228
" #$
Introduo
3 " 691 ' % -F
F "F S * 0 F " 2 '
( ( L,,M1 F P 1 P
1 + 2 1 2 .
-F1 + eF
1 + %' * 3 F1 =
X %' *
E . + (P -+
%& X 1 %'
F+ ++ " * 0
+F " 9>;8 +F " 9>Y8
( 1
2 P* 2 1 " "
9>Y81 ( P LZ8 M
L
1 6898M* 1 2 ( ( %'
2 (P -F1 +
%' F+ (-+ 2 ` "F*
2 ' % -F + F+ `
(P F+1 " *
# ++1 X
%& ' + %' J
2 "F J 1 1
1 ' 2
+1 F%' ( +-+ P
P*
0 <5 )P
+ / % # L
##
M 688Y G'
X%' 2 " +-+ 2 %'
2 * # 2 1 + 1 " -+
% ,, L
, 1 689;M1 F
1 1 (
X * +1 ' 1 1
1 ( + =
%'* 3 F1 " 2 2
*
229
# 31 - F 2 E++

/" #. R L/#RM
##1 X 2 c
1 <5 )P1 F %'* P1 % F
%'d1*
%' %& + #'
/ % #1 9>>> + /#R1

#.
/ % # L#
/M1 ` # #+*
I #
/ 2 1 688Z1 3 / % #
L3/#M1 %' 2 + ' P %& +
P' ( (1 " F = * 3
1 #02 9:1 #1 ++ %' 1
+ + - %'
& ( ;419 ;Z1> %' ` %' 6868 L
688:M* # %' 2 1 %&1 %'
& ,, 9: 6Y1
4: " * , 1 & `
%' +' ;6> &
P L#02M1 688:1 Z4Z & #021 6868*
0 + - ( X%'
3 / % # L 5 96*9ZY1 6> 688>M1
> 6898 E 5 Y;>8*
F%' %' ` % * , 6899 68961
( - 1 %'1 7
*
F 68981 E ,' ,
LE,M;1 , 2 ,"F L,,M1
+ /" / , L//,M1
F%' %' ` % -F*
,+ ) $+1 R$ # 1 9>78Z7689;* U77+ ***7++7
=++===9>=8Z=689;==9
2
#(. L#0M " P' P S #+%' E+
P L#EM1 0%' 3%& K L03KM ( ,#0=>6 J #(.
3%& K / E++ L#3K/EM1 ) !
9>>6* 2 & #0 ( * F 2 '1 #0
* R= ' 2 F%'
%& X 9ZZ #E1 9ZY K' , 1 + '
F1 1 %& .1 %&
' +1 %& 1 % 1 +*
;
0 F+ ' "F X
- (. %' + %& ( ( *
230
" #$
0 451
1 1 F 2 1 %

+ -1 "
' ( "1 ( ( F+
+-+1 P1 2 "
1 ( e+ X.
"F L1 6898M*
# %' e+1 F 99

1 P 1 * 3 1
( 2 1 " - "
+ P1 ' . +%*
2 "

+-+1 - 1 +1 1 "1 N +
F eX=P %' F*
++1 . H =
++1 FF+ *
+F %' .

F F+ % -F1 " =
" * 0 " 2 1 1 .
%' %' 1 +- 1
2 G FF+ *
E - 1 F - F %'
* 0 F - + * 3 1 "
"F F+ F +
%' 1 " ' ( ,, *
- %' ,, per capita
& * 3 1 - 2 "
c+ d* # 2 XF+ 1
1 F 2 " 1 2
- ,, * , + .
- ,,*
@
6
"

0 (% F %& 1
1 "F ( 1
* , (% " '
F+ 1 ( *
0 2 %' = ( . +'
F+ P + *
231
B 8 -'(
6

J " DK8KL
Energia
P
#+'
-
3
b"
E+
0
Total
Mundo
;6
6Z
69
6%
2%
0%
11%
988

;Y1:
:1;
981;
89P
14,1 %
17,5%
13,9%
988
I E++ ,"F /" / ,

L689<M*
R 9 F+ ( +-+

"F * , 1 ( 2
* , -1 ( +-+* 1 2
"F " Z9 e+ (P1 " :;
*
+ ( F%' ( +-+ <:
1 9; * 3 "1 F
"F " + 1 R 6*
B D -'(

6

J " DK8KL
Energia
#+'
-
b"
3
P
E+
0
R
Mundo
<9
66
O^_
9;
:
0
3%
988

91;
:1Y
74,3%
61Y
61Y
}3O_
~3Y_
988
I E++ ,"F /" / , L689<M*
3 1 ( (P 4Z 1

98 1 + ` F%' ( +-+1 2
Z4 1 9Z *
R ; F+ F%' +- (
%' 1 2 - 1 2
F%' *
232
" #$
B H 5 '( '(

DKKQ DK8D
P
-
#+' +
KS
b-

%
0
+-+
Total
6884
<619
Z1;
1
919
9<16
9;1:
688Y
<814
Z19
1
914
9<1<
961Z
688Z
;>1Y
>
919
91Y
9;1<
961<
688>
<6
Z1Y
81Z
91Y
9<
9816
2010
<619
>
81Z
81Y
9;1Y
981;
2011
<61:
>1;
81Z
914
9<1<
9819
2012
<914
>1>
1
91:
9;1>
10
9414
9Z19
9>
9Z14
9>1;
941>
9Y1:
;16
;1<
;14
;1>
<19
<1<
<14
8KKU
8KKU
8KKU
8KKU
8KKU
8KKU
8KKU
I , 2 ,"F L689;M*
0 -X 9 + %' %'
F "1 2 ( 1 " 1 LM
" + e+ * " 1
LM " ` e+1
' * 0 + 1
689<1 %' %' 6:
6Y1:1 + - + ` + %'
" %'* / <8 1 , K #1
" F 1 "1 %& : 98*
41, 8 5 '( '( '

I E #. - LE#M K+ ,
# N %' L,7/MN K'
#==%
LKM /" 1 - L/MN K'
LKM* 0 ( 689876899 689976896 LFF+M '
# 3 L#M* ,%' P*
233
0 e+1
,K1 ( + R <*
B P -
W J

L BX
Pases\ Ano
,K
Brasil
Alemanha
/
2005
;;Y*><9
6>9*:;;
Z9*6:>
YYY*48<
2010
9*896*>Y;
:ZZ*>88
96;*><Y
6*;YY*:8<
2012
9*8Y8*448
:9Y*<>:
968*ZY;
6*<>Z*ZY9
I 3 ,+ T7 , # L689;M*<
3 "1 %' X " 9>1

( ' + - ,K
#-* , 9>;>1 = "
ZZ< /1 2 1 1 1 Z8*488 /
6898*
P ( %' holding ,1
9>461 +- )& ,1 )'
3N #(1 )' 3N I 1 )' * 0 (
%'1 9>Z<1
1 P 98
%'* , " 1 9<*888 /1 (
%' " 3 E++ L3EM

@

Y
, 1 ( + X +1 "1
%' 2 % ` & ( ( L,,M*
/1 1 ' 1 + F
2 1 I H1
-1 P + ' 1
2 %' 1 " P * , (
1 1 ( ' ,, 1
% G1 K#I J
Land Use Change and Forest LN N )1 6896M* 0 1
"F X - ( % 2 * 0

+- ,& P ,( , ( (
<
U77*** * *
234
" #$
688< ( 9>>8=9>><5* 0

+- L/ # R1 6898M (=
9>>8=688: FX+ F%' & 941<Z
& ,, * 3 1 = 4<19*
, ( 2 +% XF+1
1 1 + "
* 0 -( 6 P*
41, D B3
Z
F6 8KKK [D 8\]] DK8D
I
F 3 2 , L689<MY*
0 1 F 688<1 " F

+%
F 3
2 , L
3,M1 " 68*888 Q21
6889=688<1 96*888 Q21 688:=688>1 Y688 Q21
U77\\\**+*7*77+\79Y;<9*

0 H ( F 9>:; S $%' ,H H1
++ H '*
01 H + L1 -1 1 / 1
-1 )H1 ) RFM , /' L <<5M* 0
H ( +- + 2 . % +' F * 0
H -+ LM1 % 688Z1 , /'
H *
E+ U77\\\***77** 68 689<*

235
688>=6898 LN N )1 6896M* b-

2 2 1 +( "
9>>81 H '
% %' ++ * 3
1 ( 2 +( " %'1
( ' ( +%'
% 1 F
* = X1 1 2 ' ( +1
%' F (-*
2 1 ' %' ,,
=;Z1Y 688: 68981 ( " * %'
2 & :Y1: 688: 661<
68981 ( (+ ' &* , 68961
' ,, + 2 (P
" ` & L+ R :M* #
2 1 IP / ," LI/,M1
1 ( positon paper +" #0 9:
688>
, 2 + (%
++ "F ( +-+1 2
2 ( e+1 2 "*
- ++1 1 1 "
-+ & ,,1 "F "
1 <Y ( +-+1 2
" %' Z>
( +-+* 0 1 1 c#" bP,
` c Pd ++
F+ ` & * %& +
+ F+ LI /
,1 688>M*
1 +% + %'

%' ( ' ,, 1
+ R :* , 2 F
( & ,,1 (
& ,, - *
236
" #$
B ^ 5 '(

( 455 " 4 -:D equivalente

Energia
L
M
Processos

L

M
-
I
)
Total
8\\K
9>9*:<;
DKKK
;89*8>4
DKK^
;6Z*Z8Z
DK8K
;>>*;86
:6*:;4
Y9*4Y;
YY*><;
Z6*8<Z
;8;*YY4
Z9:*>4:
6Z*>;>
9*;>6*Y:4
;<Y*ZYZ
9*;6<*;Y9
;Z*::8
6*8Z;*:Y8
<9:*Y9;
9*94Y*>9Y
<9*ZZ8
6*8;6*648
<;Y*664
6Y>*94;
<Z*Y;Y
9*6<4*<YY
I /" #.1 R

+%' L689;M*
0* 0 ( 9>>81 6888 688: " K3I##1
(* E+ U77 (*77ETT7
,+*+
E )

F L)
1 6898M1 + 1
L M " -+ 4<1< ,,1 +
YY1> K' , ZY19 ,KZ* R 4 + %'
& ,,
B Q 5 '(
'(
455

8\\K
9;1Y
DKKK
9<1:
DKK^
94
DK8K
;6
I /" #.1 R

+%'*
0
per capita
0 F 2 + +
%' - 1 1 %&
- ( 1 " F+ per capita*
E X%'

##1 ( ,, ' L'
MN + N -N % GN
*
237
41, H -

per capita [ 3 _
G DK88
I / L689<M>
R Y1 Z >

%' *
B ` -'(

'(

[ 3 _
per capita

,K
-
Pases

Alemanha
!'
-
1
8\]K
Y><6
<Y;Y
8\\K
Y4Y6
:8:;
DKKK
Z8:Y
:4<:
DKK]
Y<ZZ
:Y44
DK88
Y8;6
5501
<:<>
<;>;
<:>Z
<Z;Y
<4;Z
<:46
6>:8
6;9Z
935
<<69
;::4
6:Z<
937
<8><
<8>9
;896
O
<8Y:
;ZY>
6><6
OY^
;Z66
;498
644<
OO
I / L689<M*
>
E+ U77*\Q*77,*K,*#*W*0,* 6978<7689<*
238
" #$
B ] -'(

G [ 3 _
per capita
Pas
$
F
Chile
/"
1
+
8\]K
6;<Y
9<ZY
Z<Y
9;:6
935
<<:
8\\K
6684
9<96
9848
9<6;
937
;Z<
DKKK
6;96
94:6
946>
9<88
O
<<8
DKK]
6<Y:
9>49
9Z89
9:Z6
OY^
48Y
DK88
6;Z8
9>4Y
9><8
9:ZZ
OO
Y<4
I / L689<M*
B \ -'(

G
[ 3 _
per capita

-

#

](
China
R 2
1

8\]K
;948
8\\K
;4ZY
DKKK
:8;8
DKK]
:Z<<
DK88
4Y;Z
98Z9
69Y9
<88;
<4;4
:648
6;Y9
Z<Y
Y94
935
6><
6:Z<
9848
>YY
937
;4:
6<Z;
946>
968>
O
<;>
6>49
9Z89
9<88
OY^
:;>
6Y<9
9><8
9:;>
OO
49<
I / L689<M*
" F+ 1 ' P %'

++ P1 "
%' - ++1
.* (
2 * P
+1 + * E
1 G (% 1
X + 2 %' ' " 1 2 +1 1
,K
I% !'* 0 ( 1
1 per capita*
" %'
& #021 ( + R 98*
239
B 8K 5
* -:D 3

DK8D
Emisses
totais em

*
toneladas
DK8D
:*688
Emisses
per
capita em
toneladas
8\\K
9>14
Emisses
per
capita em
toneladas
DKKK
6814
Emisses
per
capita em
toneladas
DK8K
9Y14
Emisses
per
capita em
toneladas
DK8D
941<
#

4<8
:1>
>1Z
9616
9;
Alemanha
Z98
961Y
981<
>1>
>1Y
K'
,
;*Y88
>19
Z1<
Y1Z
Y1<
China
>*>88
619
61Z
41<
Y19
/"
<>8
;14
;14
;1>
<
Brasil
<48
91:
616
61;

9*>Y8
81Z
91:
914
,K
I 3 ,+ T7 , # L689;M*
, -+ X. "F1 "
- - ++ 1 2
F %'

91 + R 99*
B 88 0'(
'( !
6

Ano
!
Consumo

6

2010
2011
2012
689;
Y1:
61Y
9
61;
Z16
<16
;1:
;1:
I /" / ,7, 2 ,"F L689;M*
2 L "F 1

per capita F+ %' -F ' ,,M
F G& F F+ +
+% *

2 2 ' % "F %&
H (
240
" #$
XF+1 P + "=

1 + ' F :8 & 988 & P -*
R 96 + %' +-+ 6899 68;:
- 2 " c d1

1 2 %' (
+ " +F - F+ +1
*
B 8D >
1
1

JDK88L
DK88
-

DKH^
Com novas
DKH^
,K
9<8
6Z6
;;9
K' ,
9Z;
;64
;46
China
6>Z
<<:
:8>
Brasil
994
68<
68Y
I
F ,T T L689;M*
0 2 %' " 2 1 1 F ' (

FX (% 2 (%
F %' + F* , 1
%' +% 2 - 1 1
+1 ( " %' 2 + ` . +F
+ +%*
3 R 9;1 + %' 2 F%' (
+-+ ZY19 6899 Y>1: 68;:* ,2 1
+ ( +1 F%' +-+1
%1 "1 + * %' 2 F%'
( +-+ - ` %& 48
- H1
++ RF1 1 RP1
+ G1 2 * E 1
+ O
LR2 N N 1 688YM*
241
B 8H 5( " 1

'(
8K
6899 R
6899
68;: R
68;:
Brasil
<4;
ZY19
Z46
Y>1:
,K
:<<
9614
1211
6;
K'
,
4>4
691<
9:Z8
<;1Z
China
Z9<
9Y19
6Z8<
6Z
/
<<Z6
681;
99496
;91;
I
F ,T T L689;M*
0 ' + ( F1 +

1 " *
1 1 + ( H* 2
2 XF+ ' * -1 "
2 + ( 2 ' 2 - 1 2 2
' - ( * 1 ( + F
L%' %' '
M1 L+ M H
L+ ' %' 1 1
-+ % - %'M* 1
=( %' 1
+ " * 3' X
%' e+ '

1 2 1 1 ' ' ` %' 1
%& F 1 1 %'1
+ ' F* ,1 F1 P "1
%' 1 = +' +%'
+ F *
/ F ' F + 2 %&
-1 1 ' +% % 1 %
` F%' (1 "
1 2 2 2 - F+* 1
10
0 ,T 0 Q L,0M 689; .

, +F
+ K[ 4 & %' ' "
( +-+*
242
" #$
1 1 F .

+ 2 X
% -F 1 1 2 ++ ?
3
(F % 1
* R ' +% 2
%' %' X %' %&
2 1 (1 X %'
% *
Nova realidade
# 2 1 + % 2 F+1 X
" * 1 2 + 1
- 2 F X*
3 1 + ( & LR 9:M1
F LR 94M*
X 2 1 + (1
+ ` %' 1 2
F%'
* 1 1
%& 1 2 ' (
' ( F F " 6888*
" " + %'

" L+ R 9<M* 2 F+ "
1 F 68991 G 2
- 1 . ` F+ %'1
+F F+ * 3' ( (%
X. "F* 1 ( +-
( F 7
* , 68981 ;>14
1 1 68961 ;:19 1 689;1 ;;1> L,
,1 689<M*
B 8P -

6

2010
2011
2012
689;
0

41<
<1<
:19
419
-

418
416
Y1Z
:1Y
Industrial
981>
61;
=819
814
Total
Z16
<16
;1:
;1:
I /" / ,7, 2 ,"F L689;M*

243
0 -X < F%' +
6896*
41, P
JDK8DL
I /" / ,7, 2 ,"F L689;M*
0 ' ,, "F +

1 X 1
" %' "* R : '
,, #06 2 + 9>9*:<; 9>>8 ;>>*;86
6898* %' 1 S 96*9ZY7688>1 2 F
3 / % # L3/#M1 + ' 4;<*888
#06 2 + 68681 %& + -
F%' E ,' , LE,M* E -1 -
L %& F%'M Z4Z*888 #06 2 +* 0
" 2 E, ' + F%'
%' ` % -F 1 2
F+ L' -M1 + +& *
&1 ( 1 ' X /" #.1
R
+%' L/#R
M c& + ` 2 e+
& ( F+ P1 - +' d* P
+ R 9:*
E & 689;1 (
-+ <Y1 F%' F+
;6*
+ (P LP
244
" #$
M* R 94 ( %' F%'

& ,, 1 1
( 689;*
B 8^ 5
* 455 - -:D _

9>>8
9>>:
2000
2005
2010
Energia
9>9*:<;
6;6*<;8
;89*8>4
;6Z*Z8Z
;>>*;86
R
9*;>6*Y:4
6*49:*946
6*8Z;*:Y8
6*8;6*648
9*6<4*<YY
R
9;1Y:
Z1>
9<1:
9416
;6
I /" #.1 R

+%' L689;M
B 8Q -'(

'(
*
9 DK8H
R

#
F%'

energia
F%'
&

energia
F%'
+-+

setor
;6
;;1>
>19
<Y
9>1<
;1>
9Y
:4
46
I ,%' P F , 2 ,"F L689<M*
5 6Y
"=1 X + 688Y1
( %' %& ( P
- LM * 0 + F %&
* 3' -1 1 %'
%' 2 +%
*
2
" %' %'* )2 X
X %'* b- +- 111
1 F X ' * K
11
+' X "=1 + U L689<M*
245
" F & % +
% 1 1 % * # -1 -
F+ 1 1 1 1 F+
+F e+ F+1 F * "
1 ( % ( %
+ X1 1 -
+* b+- & 2 2 "=
2 G % e+1
% 1 2
& G- G * 0 - + (
68991 2 + '
% P 1 1 (2
FF+ 1 F+ +F
+-+1 ( 2 + +
2 XF+ ( 2 *
B
K X " 1
-+ & ,, 2 1 1 1
( %& F%'* 0 (
+P P rodoviaristas "

1
" 9>:8* " 1 - F%' +-
* R 9Y
& ,, +
1 X +-*
B 8` 5 '(

* 455
J-:D; CHP; ND:L 4
246

#02
CH<
N20
DKKK
<;*:>:
96<1Z
916
DKKQ
<>*;6<
94Y14
914
DK8K
:Z*;<:
9>Z16
91>

#02
CH<
N20
Y9*99:
:;1>Y
<1;
Z8*9;:
Y;1;:
:1:
>Z*><8
Z41YY
41:<

#02
CH<
N20
968*9;8
991:
61<
9;;*<;9
981;
61>
948*9Z8
961;
;1:
" #$

R
12
#02
CH<
N20
DKKK
9Y
4914
919
DKKQ
9:1Y
YZ1;
91<
DK8K
9Z14
>614
91Y
#029;
CH<
N20
6Z>*>:Z
;ZZ1<>
>14
;69*69<
:9Y1:
12
;Z6*4>Z
:YY19Z
9<1:
I /" #.1 R

+%' L689;M*129;
1 + F & 1 F

#061 1 -+ <Y
& L, 2 ,"F1 689<M1
F ;6 * ,1 1 -
+-1 -+ >6 & #06
1 + ` F &
* %' F " F%'
e+ ,K " 6:
% LQ1 688Y1 * 98M* , F +
( +%' F 1 `
2 I H* E .
3 R R L3RRM1 " 689<1 -
6*984*Y94 & %'1 " 9616 * E1
><Y*<:8 ' & H 941Z "9<*
0 3 # LM1 F
) %' # 5 :1 9>Z>1 F 1 1 %'
3
+- I * /
6899 ( P ( -F1
& 9>Z8 688> %& " 6868* R 9Z
& ,,
+-*
12
3 + 1 ' & + ` 2 e+
1 1 " & ( F+ %' +' %'
P - *
9;
0 P /#R
2 & #06 % ,"F 3
L,3M ' 2 +' * (
&1 + 68981 1 ;Z6*4>Z <84*86Z *
9<
\\\*U*+*
247
%&1 & #06 +
-1 68681 9>4 & N 2 1 9;9 &
(P*
B 8] -1
'(
'( 1

*
455
1

CO
#&7H 7
+
P+ +
Motocicletas
R
A:
COD
688>
2020
688>
2020
688>
2020
9Y
64
>6
>;
46
48
<Z
;:
988
:9
6;
988
Z
=
988
Y
=
988
;:
;
988
;Y
;
988
I /" / , L6899M*
0 R / F%' %'

` % LR/M1 S F 3
/ % #1 = 3 F R L3 RM15
- %' F%'
+-1 481 68981 <41 68;91
2 %' 1 (
+ R 9>*
B 8\ '( '(
DK8K
DKH8

)+-
I+-
2 +-
R
DK8K
4;<
6YZ
9;9
98<;
DKDK
>8Z
4Y<
6Y>
9Z49
DKH8
99Y9
>:4
<89
6:6Z
I ,%' P F R/ L6896M1 3 R L6899M*
& - (.

+' F 989 & P L/#02M
68681 <41;Z %' = 6898* ,
+- - Z> &1 (+-1
15
0 3 R ( % 688Y %' # L#M

+-1 (+- 2 +-* I # ,. ,
R L#M1 /" E(1 /" R*
248
" #$
Z1 2 +-1 ;* !- 68;91 & ' 9;8 /#021

ZZ1< %' 68981 2 +-
- ZZ &1 (+-1 Z1 2 +-1 < L/
#N / R1 689;M* 0
X ( % %'
+-* b- +1 1 2 3 F
R1 E ,' , LE,M1 -
F+ (
1 2 +1 +1 2 ' +%'
- ` %' %& +*
# %' 1 -1 1 " X
(+-1 X. P+1
' -(1 e F+1 X%'
e+ X. "F * , %' '
" +* E 2 P1 9>Y>1 ( %
, # e+ LM1 ( X
+ I L%' 3 I $
J (+M 9>Z; 9>Z4* %'
X. ( F * "1 2
% P F 9>Z:1 (
F 9>ZY* E 1 9>Z4 + ) %' #
3 / L#M # %'
$ L+M1
Z*Y6;7>;1 9>>;1 + %& P
#1 & + +*
E X " 9>Z81 +
' + 2 & (" +1

F / ) 3 )+-+ L
M*
, 68891 98*6>:1 2 & F 3 #+%'
K ) ,1 #.
3+
,X. ,"F L#
,,M941 2 1 %&1
%' X F -2
* F 688:1 ( + +* E (1
94
0 #
,, " P' F /" / ,1 2
N /" #.1 R
+%'N /" E++1
#"
,N . 3 , ,"N . 3 PN +
' 1 " 1 /
, / , 1 + *
249
F2 + + ' + .
%' X. + L4$ #K M
+ ` (% X. +
"F * K + ( 1
+ + ` %' (%' -*
F % 688>1 = F2 + * / ' 1
+1 F2 * ! FX+=
2 " " F2 + -1 - .
1 1 P %'1 ` ( P* I +
2 F2 + ` .
1 2 %' 2
%' ' F 1 2
%' P K' , * E+ ( F2
+ -1 1 + +
' (1
"F1 %'
F "F1 ( .* ,1
+1 ` F2 + *
F - 2 + ( +
&1 2 - - F " * , 1
, K !'1 +. F "
1 . F* F+
" 2 2 2 (
+F (%' *
0 F X 688Z* #
F e 1 +

+ ( 1 F
2 ` X. &1 + %'
* 3 688Z 68961 ( F+
- O )[ > &1
F P+* I + ( .
F - F + ++ -+1
F F /F%' / % #-F /
L
1 689;M*
+- (
c d* 31 " +F
F & ( ( ' 1 ' - 2
' +% * 0 ( 2
250
" #$
' ,, ( ' "
( *
K F+ + + 2 (

F+ `
+%' RP # F+ $
L
+ M1 /* 0 " + - (
% +1 6896* , + 689;1
+ " X 689Y* ,
L

M ;8 + + + 689;
689Y1 +. %' 2 1
" F1 2 +' * - " %
9618Z P+ " 689Y1 %'
6899* 0 . & X. "F
. 1 2 ( -
G1 F +
* , %' (
1
#%' ,F2
, 2 2 ' F ( +
"
+ 1 + I1 2 "
F . ` 2 , - +
" X %' -* 0
+ F
F2 P 689Y9Y*
E (1 +

1
+ ( 2 %&1
2 + .* +%'
" 2 1 1
1 %' 2 +F1 '
F2 *
.
P* , 9>>81 #' , + "
%' #02 P+1 + - F+
X X.* I 1 "1 2 1 F
+ 1 -* E 1 #'
%' F %' .1 9;8
#027Q 968 #027Q 6896* 0
( F 6869 P ' F - >: #02
2 H* 0 F+ " +F + S
F 1 + FF+ *
9Y

J ) %' 5 :;Y:9Z1 ;878<7689<*
251
2 ' F -

+ 2 F ' L1 689<M*
0+= 2
+- I /"
/ L6899M1 % ,"F 3
68981 2 & ( %' ` ' "
#02 + %' L+ R 68M* + (%
" + + 1 X 1
- ` + +%' (*
F+ X
1 . *
B DK 5
( -:D " W

Gasolina A
,
6641> 7
96;1; 7
Etanol
b
99Y1Z 7
Diesel
3$
64Y19 7
9>>1> 7
I /" / L6899M*
, ( " %'1 F

S X. "F 68691
- (.1 2
+
* # 1 = +X 2 %'
2 . %'
P+ 6<1: & ,, 6;1> 68;8* 3
\0B4$1 += +
X. + 1 2 ' X
2 -* +1 e+ %' '
P * 1 1 '
6: 6Y1 (+
F+1 2
- 9Z* %' +F
P+ F *
$ 2 X. + "
++ F 1 2 ( 2
P + %' P1
FF+1 *
9Z
,' 9678<7689<*
252
" #$
-
'* ,

"F F+ 1 per capita F+
( 2
%' -F ' ,, ' ( 2 F
G' F* #= ' F+ FX%' +
+% *
R ' +% 2 %'
%' X %' %& 2
1 (1 X %' %
*
# 2 1 + % 2 F+ %'
& ,,* 1 2 + 1
-1 1 2 F X*
0 -+ &
,, 1 ' & * 1 " (
%& F%'* 0
+ - F +F X.
%'1 2 .
P* 31 " +F
F & ( ( ' 1 ' - 2
' +% F * ,
1 + X. \0B4$*
0 X " ( % %'
+-1 " 9>:8* " "X
(+-1 - F%' +-
*
253
0".

1,
1 !*N 1 #* #*N )1 )* 2 H
% F # T
F+* ) ! K#=)!1
6896*
1 #"* , 2 . 2 ' , +
I1 6886*
* 5 96*9ZY 6> 688>*
F F 3
/ % # L3/#M - +.* 1 688>* E+
U77\\\**+*7+8;7688Y=68987688>77969ZY**
6< 689:*
* E 5 Y*;>81 > 6898* ) *
451 99 96 5 96*9ZY1 6> 688>1 2 F F
3 / % # L3/#M1 - +.* 1
6898* E+ U77\\\**+*7+8;7688Y=6898768987
E7EY;>8** 6< 689:*
#1 + /* , % -F F % (
*
/U1 ) et al* L0*M* / %
H1 P*
1 6899*
#
/ #* Plano Nacional sobre Mudana
;8&<* 1 688Z*

# 3
L#3
M* "Z *4$$1 +
689;*
* %
- 1/ #++2

0
carbono* )7#3
1 6899*
* 7$

#6# +#
- +'
F * 1 6898*
, ,* %5

!
# * ) ! ,,1 6896*
* 1 '+# 8# YO J 6896 P *
) ! ,,1 689;*
* 1 '+# 8# YO J 689; P *
) ! ,,1 689<*
I / ,* F "
% -F* 688>* E+ U77\\\*(**7I/,7
2 +7+ 7 7F6868 ;8*(
7# ,
/ /
#* '#6# +# L

4 $4* 689<*
* X! "252* ' 1 689;*
* ;"<2$ +# N #

22 *
#- 1 689;*
254
" #$
* Pegada de Carbono dos gastos

tributrios.
1 689;*
, * Insero internacional brasileira:

F * + ;1 $* 9*
1 6898*
, L
,M* *# 'K 7$? YO* 1
689;*
* Redrawing the Energy-Climate Map* ,0 )* 1
689;*
/ #1 R
* ,FF+ &
( ( * 1 689;*
* $
25
L L Z#

4 $4* 1 6898*
/ #7/ R* Plano Setorial de Transporte

&

9 &+ %
&$

;J&<*
1 689;*
/ / ,7, ,* Plano Decenal de
'0
' YYY* //,7,,1 689;*
/ / * 25 #
L
4# 2,#$ $
25* 1 6899*
* R / K* 1 6896*
/ R* 8#
,+# J* )+%'
FF+ * )P I* 1 6896*
31 bN 1 / * 2
#6#
+# $Z2 * )P #* ! 688:*
* '# Y* ) ! 689<*

1 )* % ,"F / % #-F K'
, *
Contexto Internaiconal. +* ;41 * 91 7 689<*
* "= X *
I+1 *N
/1 )* Energia, desenvolvimento e sustentabilidade* ,
Q1 689<*
1 # )* , ( F ( K= ,T
#F* Congressional Research Service1 688Y*
R1 / R*N 1 ,*N 1 )* / "F
* Novos Estudos, Y>1 + 688Y*
4

0 < k
E K+ ' LKM1 #
)%&
#. ,H
P= %' #. b K+ I # LKI#M*
# *^ (* *
255
4(
1

.

Jos Antonio Gomes de Pinho
92

1 ;91%<
Maria Elisabete Pereira dos Santos

92

1 ;91%<
' + 1
%'1 +- * 0 F+
F "1 (. %& P
' 1 ( I RP1 F R
E EF+ b1 .
' 1 F FX ' 1 X1
-F * +F%'
. + 2 ' 1
1 ' . 2 1 1 * 0
1 1 2 P '
P 2 ( ' 1 ( ++
* 0 F 2 ' 1 ( X1 &
+ %' -F1 2 '
P * 1 ( F1 F
+' 2 % %' *
1 ' ( ' P S P (F+
%' *
'1 %' 1 1 ++
1
gF F 689<* $' X 689<*h

257
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
43
1

FP + + 1 2
- + P1 f + * ,
P e 1 ( P
- ( 1 FP I RP T1 F
R E EF+ b1 2
FP X FX FP 1
X 1 -F f*
+FP - + 2
FP 1 1 2
FP * 1 1 2
P 2 T FP 1
( * , e " f 2 FP
1 X1 - +
P -F1 2 F P f
* # X1 e F +P 2
P * 1 FP
1 P - P1 " (F+ P
f *
FP1 P 1 1 1
teora social
<

% "

/ + T 1
F F1 + T T * RQ
F \=Q\ F F T I RP
F+ T ( b1 ( F
\ ( = + ( F
* R T F T
Q T X ( * R
1 \+1 \ + F(T
F \T T * R F
F \T T + ( T
*
+ 1 F T
\ + F ( T F F+*
R 1 ( ( F (
F+ F *
$#% 1 F1 T1 +1
T
258
Jos Antonio Gomes de Pinho e Maria Elisabete Pereira dos Santos
Introduo
' LGSM F "1
% " * ' " ( %'
P1 1 1 " -F +
+ 2 1 + 1
- ( P* E + -F1 %'1 %'
GS + +F 2 ( -
1 %' X %' 2
+ 2 ' * 1 + P 1
++ 1 F 1 %
1 ' L M1 %' * GS
1 '1 ( 2 F
%' 2 1 1 2 X F+ 1 1
%& F+ 2 X (+1
1 *
1 2 ( "F1 X%&
GS* # 2 ( X GS
(*
1 + 2 +
++ P + ( 2 GS "
%'1 (F1 1 2 GS ' "* 1 GS ' "
' + J 2 ( 2
+ X +* 1
a GS " 1 1 c%&d 2 c' F+
Hd LI I1 688Z1 * ;6M* 3 +'1 %& GS '
F c "F 1 +%' .
' .( F%' & %&
%'d LI I1 688Z1 * ;;M* 1 + ` %'
c+ Fd1 F+ 2 c-F PF1 (
Fd LI I1 688Z1 * ;;M* =1
X%'1 ' % 1
+ cd*
0 F GS " 2 1 2 '
+ c d1
2 1 F1 P1 "F c ("
Hd LN I I1 688Z1 * 4YM1 GS1 +1
2 ' " +1 ' * 3 1
%& GS c' F+ Hd LN I
I1 688Z1 * 4YM*
259
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
%' P GS ++ I RP (1

1 1
( P - 1
F+ b* RP1 GS + c
P 2 P " F
F %'d1 2 c . ` (1 F
%'d LR1 688Z1 * ;>M*
FX= 2 "=2 ( 1
2 1 %' "F
RP + c F+ -F cLR1
688Z1 * <6M* #X =1 1 %' %' F+ 2 c
Fd1 %' 2 '
c d LR1 688Z1 * <>M* F%'
%'1 F 2 GS c+ F
F+1 P 2 . ` (d1 2
c' F+d LR1 688Z1 * :<M*
R= %' P %' GS 1 1
( F+ b* #
( "F X%& GS
( 1 F1 + -
. GS1 F+ - ( F
GS, +% 1
( ++ RP1 2
* = F - -
1 +X ' P
2 2 X GS1 F
& -F*
R=1 1 + P1 -
. 1 %'
+% %' ` 2 ' 2 " (
?
%' ( FX F
2 P GS . %
( H1 1 F (*
E F 2 . ' J (
" GS J '1 P -
+1 F %'
F+1 ( GS1 2 *
0 X . X
%' -F " F1 2
` %' H1 1
260
" F J F -F 1 2

%' , 1 " + F+*
'( 3

1
gesto social
- . 2 X GS = +
P* , F+ %' (1 +=
%'
, F
+ %' * ,1
2 - 2 X GS1 2
-F 2 ' 1 + F+
Q ! 2
L6896M1 " - GS1 2 F c
. 2 1 F. P L '
++ 1 2 M1
F - H d* 0 2
c %'d1 + " c
P P d L
N !1 68961 * 98M*
0 ( (1 ( 1
GS1 2 RP * 0
1 1 +- ( 1
" 9>>8 1 1 %& %&
* # % , F
9>>81 + (1 X RP L688>M1 2 F
%' ,1 F 1
%' F ' 1 (
* 1 RP1 GS
( ' 2 + F%'1 '1
J - F+1
` ' "1 2 - + 1 2
P + L
N !1 6896M*
0 P ' 1 RP L688ZM1 I L6886M1 I
/ L6884M1 I% I L688ZM1 %'
' P 1 2 F
+ (%' L
N !1 6896M* 3
F 1 " X 2 ' F
2 ' ( `
F1 2 GS. No caso
F 9>>81 = +
F%' 2 1
261
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
1 H $
2 -F1 *
0 "
Q ! 2 L6896M (
2 F ,, L, 3
2 ' M1 P . + %' %'
GS1 688Y1 2 + 1 F 68981
F F1 <;< F %& +* 3
1 c( 49 F 2 F -F GSd1
GS, X, e * 0 FX
2 c 1 " F e 2 X
+ Fd1
" c94 F -F GSd L
N !1 68961 * YM* ,
Z< F 1 c -1
1 F 1 1
d1 * 0 + -F
c + + eX1 2
%'d L
N
!1 68961 * ZM* # 2 %'
+ " %'* # 2
GS 2 - 1 2 F +
F 1 94 F -F `
2 + F*
2 1 (F+1 F 2
(
1 ( 1 ' * " 2 1
' + ' 2 - (1 ' 1
2 *
0 + " 2 6; F '
P1 2 . c - eX 2 -
%'d L
N !1 68961 * 98M* ++
(% P 1 L 98 %&M1
2 F+ -F1 '
FX 9*
7 8 0".

Autor
9* R1 I
6* I I1 #+
;* I1 RS
<* E1
:* 1 ) I*
262
N
Z;
;:
21
9;
12
Autor
4* 1 #
Y* 1
Z* 1 " %
R
N
11
10
10
9>:
I
Q ! 2 L6896M1 F ,3, L688Y1 688Z1 688>1 68981 6899
6896M*
= FX 1 I RP1 `

( + %&1 (.
-1 I% I1 + %&1
RS I1 " XF+ (.1
' * 3 P
+ 2 2 2 X GS1 .
F+ + ` ' 2 F ( P1
" -F * ,
cd P1 "
F !" 1
,3,1 ! 1

688>1 2 ( F ` ( GS +
" + 2 F %& - `
%' F+1 S P
* , F F +' GS
( 1 F %' P*
L689;M - (% F
GS1 X ` ( RP P F (
* ( 1 %' GS ` %&
( %' 2 + %'
b1 2 X + RP1
GS %& * 1 F
2 %' F+1
( GS1 ` %& %'
-F * , ' 2 + 2 '
' %& - ` %' F+1
= -= J GS +% * 3
F1 " ( %' / 3 2 X
- GF1
* %' 1 %' + 1
1 G . P P 1
% F 2 1 1 P
263
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
2 X ++ L 2 " F.

%& (M* #
X 31 cF + S
2 - F G' ( 1 1
P d* , F c2 ' P
1 P (%' 1 '
-Fd L31 apud /1 689;1 * 9:M*
, F1 1 P1 +=
- . GS1 +X
* 3' F+
+ P -F F cd
L ( GS M*
= 1 ( 1
-F *
&

.
GS
$ G' F %'
# N # Z# # L1 #%1
I RP !+- R + !1 GS *
%' %& + 2 ++
' GS1 + X . -F1
F+ +X P P
P= ' -F* R ` %'
+ .1 - %' 2
- -X*
# c+%' P FF+
) ! J (P
F+1 F%'d1 2 + c S
F%' %' ++ d
L$N #1 68961 * :ZM1 ) !1 2 (
%' " .* 0 F+ +F%'
" +X c GS ++ d1
X c ' P FF+ F+d
L$N #1 68961 * :ZM* E 1
.

2 2 X GS & +F *
3' 2 P F %' 1
+ ( F*
1 1
2 GS "1 2 1 F (
264
F+1 2 cF%' ++
2 ' ( d* 0 ' + c
d L$N #1 68961
* 44M* # ( ( %& RP1 X= 2 c '
' 1 1 1 ' +-= -
Fd L$N #1 68961 * 4YM* 1 c %& '
( %& P ' %& P* 0 - P
+ d L$N #1 68961 *
4YM* 2 ;8 - 99
1 2 ( 2 F- (* 0
X 2 F- 1
c 2 F + - (
( -d L$N
#1 68961 * Y8M*
- c ' .
FF+ F (
d L$N #1 68961 * YYM1
1 2 c ( F%'
` %'d1 1 2 1 (
%' - 9: +1
c d L$N #1 68961 * Y>M* 1
2 c %' P GS em
' FF+ P1 F+ RP et al. L688ZM1
+-+ G +% ++ d
L$N #1 68961 * Z9M* # " 2 c
FF+ %' 2 d L$N #1
68961 * Z6M* 1 ' ( .
- 2 2 X GSN -1 P e F -
2 c F+1 F%'d F cd
. * E 1 - 1 1 +
& P 1 + 2 2 '
F1 1 c - GS ++
d " P L 1 + P1 '
2 .M J 1 +1 = 2 1
1 (
*
K F %' " !+- R +
! ) ) L6896M1 F c' 1 X%
- ++ 98 %'
d* 3 F1 GS - e 1 F1
1 ' GS1 F+ P= 1
L =+ ' X% - ++
265
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
M* GS 2 F 2
J =1 1 e * 0
' GS 2 P1
1 2 + .
1 2 %&1 2 *
F ' GS1 2 X
2 %' ) # - ( c
X%' GS -d L !N
1 68961 * 99:M* 1 GS 1
? 4
2 F GS1 2 (
% ( ("*
K F1 F c' ` F
++ RP # 3
) !d1 I * 1 R * W I*
E L6896M1 ( + P ' 2 GS 1
F+1 P1 * 0 cF+
territorial como (
d ' F ++
" F ' 1
B$1 2 2 F%' LN WN E1 68961
*968M* 0 . %' RP
# LR#M1 ' 3 , )*
&
GS1 ( RP L P F
M1 X 2 %& ++ (
P + c+ %' P
,1 + d LN WN E1 68961
* 968M* 3 1 ( - 1 P
%' P F ( -F1
+ 2 " 1 + I1 "
++1 * 1 1 c -
F = ++ 1 2
(%' P %' P 1
= F+ +d
LN WN E1 68961 * 9<6M* (%' P =
2 c F+ +1 + + F+ d LN
WN E1 68961 * 9<:M* 2 1 1
- 1 ' 1 F =
%' -1 2 1 , in dubio
pro reo, + ` -F ' -F L 2 '
F M*
266
GS, ` X%' /" E++

- L/EM1 2 cgesto social " ( 1
F F F+ + %' ++
- d LN WN E1 68961 * 9;;M1 %'
-F 2 RP* -
G
(1 2 c GS F
G ' + %' (% S
Pd1 2 + ` ' 2 1 +1
GS1 2 %' 1
F 1 " G
* 2
L F G
( -M ' X 2 ' O
+ %' GS RP
( 1 1 %' (
++ 2 ++ - -F ,1 +
* ' F 2 " 2 X GS
1 2 X 2 c %' ` &
P 2 ++. -1 F1 F-
d LN WN E1 68961 * 9<ZM* , 1
"1 + F+1 P e*
# 1 2 . c( -+
%& +1 2 1 "
+F '1 F+ (% +
F ` F %' RP #d1 2 "
1 %'1 + 2 1
GS1 1 X LN WN
E1 68961 * 9:9M*
K 2 F " c' RP
# . d "
1 !" ) 0+ #F R EQ L6896M* 0
+X 2 +% gesto social
1 X ( F 1
E\1 I1 I% I1 P 1 1 RP1
2 c ' + F
S 2 & =+1
F %' F 1 =
Pd LN 0N E1 68961 -* 9:ZM* 0 1
` %' RP 1
267
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
%' " %' F+ X GS %'
! F+1 agir F+ 2 c(F %' P1
FF+d * R= '
c 7 1 %'
%' d 2 c % F+d1
2 + + +1 %' F+ F1
F+ %' LN 0N E1
68961 * 949M* 0 ' (-F X 2 GS 2 c F %'
(2 . 7 . (2 .1
2 + d LN 0N
E1 68961 * 9:Z=946M*
, % c %' +
S 1 2 + %' 2 1
+ %&d
LN 0N E1 68961 * 946M* 1 cgh ' '
++ F = locus +1 %
-F ' d LN 0N E1 68961 * 946M* $
2 1 ( 2 1 + ' . +1 2 X
1 ++ * 2
2 GS " ( 2 X '1 ++*
X1 (%' 2 P X 2 c
GS ++ 7d ' c F
F%'1 1 %' g***hd
LN 0N E1 68961 * 946M*
0 % F1 1 = " ` X%'
GS /E1 2 " 2 GS
c %' F F+
d LN
0N E1 68961 * 94:M* / 1 /E 2
%&
* 1 F /E1 1 1
X %' 2 c + ++ -F
1 2 %& PN X1 "
FF+ 2 + 2 +
++ (-=d LN
0N E1 68961 * 94:M*
0 /E GS 2 c%' %'
1 +% %' +' F (
PF FF+ %' ++1 d
268
LN 0N E1 68961 * 944M1 ` %' F

1 %1 X1 * K 2
( + /E cF%'
+X%' %& '
%' F1 + F+1 d
LN 0N E1 68961 * 94YM*
( P1 = -

1 RP # 3
LR#=3M += * , 1 ' %'
%& S ( + +N ' P P
c' F%' X%' F
2 &d LN 0N E1 68961 * 9Y>M*
-
(%& 1 1 %
+ 1 - +1 `
%' 1 2 c
d LN 0N E1 68961 * 9Z8M*
, 1 ( FX " ( F%'1 2
- %' += c
F%' d LN 0N E1 68961 * 9Z9M1
+ ( & . * K -
2 % c' (
g***h* 0 + ' " F % %'
* I " 2 F d LN 0N
E1 68961 * 9Z9M* K ( ' 1 1 2 c + ' +
'1 2 +1 ( + g***h ( +'
F+ d LN 0N E1 68961 * 9Z6M*
0 2 %' " F+ 1 1
. ) %
FF+ 1 c S %' %
" - "d* / 1
( + . c%' d1
-F 2 c " -F +1
F+ ` %' 'd LN 0N
E1 68961 * 9Z6M1 F c % ` %'
%'1 X + 1 2 1
' - d LN 0N E1 68961 * 9Z6M* =
1 1 2 GS tanto
/E1 P ' *
269
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
/ F1

1 2 F%' c(
-F d1 cF+d F
&1 2 c2 & '
_d LN 0N E1 68961 * 9Z;M* K
" ( (
%' 1 1 1 c +
2 - + X ' d LN 0N
E1 68961 * 9Z:M*
0 R#=3 2 c' F%'
X%'1 %' %& + d*
+%' 1 %&
c ' "1 2 %' " Fd1
c S -Fd LN 0N
E1 68961 *9Z>M* 1 += c -+ S %'
F + ++ `
2 %' 1 (F+ -F 2 &
' g***hd LN 0N E1 68961 *9>8M* 3
-1 c d
c F+ %'1 ` ( (%&
F 1 2 + +
F+ 1 ` -F 2
7 F d LN 0N E1
68961 *9>8M* $X=1 1 2 1 %&
P1 -
P *
K F ( F 2 + .
-F 1 " 1 # !" / I
#V1 F cF ++
d* 0 "
+ %' c +% 1
%' ' d LN / IN #1 68961
* 9>:M* 0 ( P " ( ++
1 = RP1 + c%' ' 1
FF+1 P1 F %' ` ' -F1 P1
"1 . =+ LR1 9>>>Md
LN / IN #1 68961 * 68:M* 0 ( -
( 2 1 %& 2 ` %'
(. + I &
270
S 1 F +
%' *
# X F F ' 2 2
GS* "1 - F1 F -(1
2 c ' F
` ' + ` %&
1 %'
%' %' F
d LN / IN #1 68961 * 69>M* E X%'1
%&* 1 ' GS
' 1 X1 2
2 = 2 2 F+
N * 1 P
( ` GS cd1 2 %
.* 2 2 .1 ( (%
2 '1 2 - F1 ( S 2 GS
*
, 1 = 2 F 1 (
` GS1 2 . ' e * "1
( F+ % GS -F* 2 1 2 1
N P ( 7 GS
' . -F* 1 1 GS
' P1 $ +1 %' 1
P 2 1 1 X
. GS1 2 . 2 1 1
++ F %' GS*
&

GS

%'1 %'1 GS1
F 2 ` 2 & F+ ` F%'1
-F (F+ \
L688YM1 2 FX S
1 ' + 2 X moderna1
F

1 F %&*
3 1 X
%' F -F1 F -1 2
F , (F+ F +*
+% F " L - .
271
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
(%& 689;1 1 1 X%&
PM1 =1 1 1 S F
,1 c %' 1 X
+ + -1 d1
++ L1 688Y1
* ;YM* 1 c -F ' "
(H 1 ( %& 2 '
( F d*
' 2 2 c %
F - . 2 ' +%'d L1
688Y1 * 98MN ' " P1 1 1 2 1
(%&1 %' -1 .1
( "+ F *
1 1 ' -
F %'1 2 1 2 1 1
2 X +N ' +X1 1 .
+ 1 . ,*
2 ' ( 1

, ' " %' c+
%' 1 1 1 ( 2
( %' 2
%' (+d L1 688Y1 *6YM*
K - 2 '
X c ++
. " %' 2 2 +'d L 1
688>1 * :ZM1 2 1 2
( +* 1 " ( + 2 c 1
d 2 ( , F+
c' 1 enlaados * 3'
+ 2 1 1 d
L 1 688>1 * :ZM*
2 2 %'
( ' 1 2 " 2
1 F1 %& F F %'
1 * =1 1 . c
( F d1 2
c - (
F+d L 1 688>1 * 48M*
0 -+ % F
" c(% % +%' + d
c (-+ +%' d1 2 `
, L31 9>>Z1 * 69YM* 3 P1 (=
272
c+1 " ( -F d1 2 ++

c+ " ++d L31 9>>Z1 * 69ZM* E
c P . , .
d L31 9>>Z1 * 69ZM* 2 ,1
c = %& g***h* R = =1
d L31 9>>Z1 * 669M*
F "1 = +
%* / + %'1 Diretas j1
% ( c d1 ( c d L1 68861 *
;:M1 & XN 2
%' + + c%' 1
%' d L1 68861 * ;4M* E (1 c
F F -F= - d1 +
F -2 1 c
" 9>4<d1 F F L0_E1 9>ZZ1 * <;M*
1 P=#F %' 9>ZZ1 %'
1 2 +% %' -F1
' & F1 c F F
S1 1 +
( F+
d* 1 c F Fd
c++. (d L1 688Y1 *96M* , %' F
F 2 2 1 (%'
1 X c+ -+ 1 1
d L#1 688>1 *9M* (%' 1
2 - 1 P= F %' c(+
d L#1 688>M* ! -1 " c X1
%' %'d L#1 688>1
* 9M* ,1 1 %' X = F c
1 , F+ H1 # 1 F 2
F +
- d L#1 688>1 -*9M* , + F+ %'
+ X. .1 ( F +
S c . d L#1 688>1 *9M*
0 2 (%' " c `
(%' ` F 1 + 2 2 -
_ ( " " e a
vontaded L1 68891 * ;91 ( M* $ 2 c d1
273
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
c(+d c +d ' ( - - F
1 F+* 1
c+%' %& - +
%' F 1 +%' 2
%' 2 d
L31 9>>Z1 * 69>M* $ 1 %'
1 + & -F ' 2 2
F%' F =+*
E 1 F+1 1
F+1
X c d c ,d L1 68891 *Y4M1 2
c( %& 1
, -d1 = . c .
d1 2 2 F X c
2 %' d L1 68891
*Y4M* 0 XF+
( P -F X%' + F J
F F F+ 2 *
2 %' GS + F
( ( * 3' 1 1 X +
+ %' " %&
%'1 F%'1 1 F1 (1 F
+ F1 X H1 F ( *
, +1 ' ( %' P
++ -F GF X
(%' * X1 1
-+ 2 (F+ *
, - -F 1
+1 %' 2 + + * X1 2
%' -F I
"1 1 1 "
2 ` %1 ` * , P1 + 2
L 9>Z: " M " 2 -F
P1 ' 2 (
( ( * 1 2 2 %'
"1 (1

* %'
- 1 , L 1 , "M1
+- " F 9>Z81 0_E L9>ZZM
. (* + X + -
` F %' + -F1 2 =
274
%' -F* , F (1 1

" O* , 2 =
(* 2 1 ( %'1 %'
(% F %& -F1 %'
* 1 2 F %&
-F1 ' 1 1
X% %'1 +1
! F%1 F * , %'1 1 - 1
1 X !" /F1 (F+
?
3
F L/1 6899M* 1 2
%'*
#1 1 - R-1
++ %' Rara temporum felicitas $ + ($
2 ($ +
# #1 * 0
P 0_E L9>>9M1 %' F " F
F %' 1 F X. -
F+* 0 . .
-F F1 X
( F .* R 2 %' +
F+ F=
* 3 1 ( 1 '
1 (= + F "
P %&* 1 ' " + 2 1
( %' F+*
E 1 ' ' + 2 (
F%' -F F+1 ( F P1
F+1 F+*
- *
, 2 + 2 1
, 1 +
(%' ( .1
%' + %&1 F
* 0 ( S
F+1 F %&
P * 1 F1 - c d1
- * R= O1 1 FX 2
-F F+1 2 .
275
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
F J 2 O

2 2 X F+1
( 1 ( 1
1 ( %& RP* $ 2
G' F ' . ( GS1 1
2 2 ( GS1 +
P GS* , +1 ' 1 2 1 +&
2 F GS*
1 2 %' P GS -

F+1 + 1 ( P1 2 +
+ L 2 "1 P1 FM* #
2 . FX1 F
F+1 (= (
L 2 - ' M1 2 '
+-+ 1 1 ' 1
* 0F+ (+
+ % 1 1 ==
2 GS - ( 2 %
+ %
1 1 + * 3'
%& %&1 2 2
% 2 " F+ J 2 1
+ "1 F*
' X 2 F

. F+1 P 1 +-
N 1 1 1 ( ' 1
("1 1 ` +1 L
M1 1 1 X F
%' X%' -F * F1
+ ` 2 ' F 2 " (
? )X
2 1 2 ( LF +'
P M ` %' F+1 .
1 1 * 2
. 1 1 ' . ' eF1
F L 2 ( +
scholar + - GSMN ' e
-F 2 '* K 2 1 +
P1 2 - 2 X GS ' -F1 %& '1
,1 F +1 F & 1 +
1 2 F+ %&
276
+ 1 " %' L

F+ + ++F
MN ' 2 ++1 (1 F%'
%' X F F%'
( ++1 P1 - "
.* ,1 (1 . ' 1 1
- (
1 (
(*
0".

1,
1 " *N 01 !" )* N E1 #F R* '
RP # .
*
#1 #N R1 I N
!1 !+- R L0*M* # B # Z# # L*

, K 1 6896*
1 * F %&
*
1 L0*M* 1 ( 1 ( *
E F * ) ! #+%'
1 6886* R %' / /
#1 !" / * , * ! , '
1 6Y 688>1 U77\\\*+**7
+ *
I1 R* / E* 1 ++ ' %'
*
I1 R* / E* L0*M* Gesto do desenvolvimento e poderes
locais: P +%'* + # 1 6886* * 96=;6*
I1 R* / E*N /1 $* * ++ '
%' F+*
I1 R* / E*N )1 *N /1 $* * Gesto do
22

6# #/ * + ,EKI1
#
7KI1 6884* *9;=<9*
I I1 #* * EX ' *
1 !+- RN /1
)" RN #1 #N 1 # L0*M* Gesto
Social -F 1 %'* I
K+-1
688Z*
1 , N !1 * * %' . '
+ ,3, 688Y 6896* +1 Anais
#P2
* #
* , %' J KI1 6896*
1 +* + -
\ ( *
1 I*N
1
I*N 1 I I*N 1 / L0*M* O socilogo e
,+# -# \* ) !
, I$1 688>* * :;=44*
277
#/ $ 5 #,+#

06#
/1 !" * % ,+#

1* /F* ' ,
#1 6899*
/1 )* &0 X = F F %'* '
, +1 689;*
31 / "* %

,+# " (
-F ,* ' R1 9>>Z*
0_E1 * R%&1 F *
)1
I- TN 0_E1 L0*M* %
## 1
F+* ' $"F1 9>ZZ*
* E F+ Novos Estudos, ' 1 5 ;91 * 6:=<81
* 9>>9*
1 !" * N 1 / ,* Aporias em torno do conceito
de gesto social P F* ) ! ,3E1 689;*
1 N I I1 * '
-F %& + .
(%'*
1 !+- RN /1 )" RN #1
#N 1 #L0*M* Gesto social -F 1
%'* I
K+-1 688Z*
1 * 1
$ * <* ,* ) !
%& ,1 688Y*
!1 !+- RN 1 ) )* ' 1 X% -
++ 98 *
#1
#N R1 I N !*1 !+- RL0*M* Gesto
social J P %&*
, K 1 6896*
1 * A nova sociedade brasileira* ) ! 1 6889*
R1 I * L)M+ ' *
1
!+- RN /1 )" RN #1 #N 1
# L0*M* Gesto social -F 1 %'* I
K+-1 688Z*

* ' "*
)1 - *N !1 !+- RN
1 #*N #1 #* L0*M* ' F
++ %&1 F %& * )( K3
$I1 6898*
R1 I et al* #" +%' =
P FF+ F+ %' F *
,
%' +%1 688Z1 +=* Resumo dos trabalhos ....
) ! 3E1 688Z* +* 91 *9=94*
$1 ,*N #1 , * * +%' P
FF+ ) !
(P F+1 F%'*

#1 #N R1 I N !*1 !+- R
L0*M* Gesto social = P %&*
, K 1 6896*
278
1 I *N W1 R *N E1 I* ' `

F ++ P
) !*
#1 #N R1
I N !*1 !+- R L0*M* Gesto social = P
%&*
, K 1 6896*
!"
(
$ , %' KI* E Regional Planning K+
L ,M* / , %' L KM #0,=KI)!* # ^ **
/ ,
(
, %' KI* E #. K* /
KI* # 6Z^**
279
: F

1

9
-

Monique Menezes
92

$, ;9*<
0 F+ F " F %&
F+ F1 #* 2 & ( ' 2
F %& X%' 2 ,
+1 F %& accountability
, F+ 0 F . 1
+ * 2 " F 2 F+1
" - * E & 1 =
2 (F+ . -
F *
%' 1 1 1
F+1 accountability1 X%'1 1
5 F

1

9
# -

, P e F
F+ F1 T #* F (
b 2 " F +P
, 1 F T
accountability LP M , F+ ,
f F 2 f + T *
gF 689<* $' X 689:*h

281
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
+FP F F+1 2 F " -

F+ T * , 1 2 X
- f F *
P 1 1 R # 1
F+1 accountability1 XP1 1
B F
p #
" 9
-

R ( F T T F F
( F+ F1 #* R F+ ( T
\ F F ( + T 2 T (
T
\1 F F T
( F+ T R T F F (
1 F + * R T 2 F+1
2 ( F+ T T* (
T1
F+ ( T
F F *
$#% F1 1 # ( 1 F+ 1
T1 +1 1 T
282
Introduo
2 & ( ` %' F+
+ . 2 " F1
F %& -F '* /
2 1 - . (
accountability 2 .
F+ * 3 1
F+ 2 1
2 F+ " %'*
# F 0_E L9>>ZM1 F= .
. F %& ##?
#*
, 1 ( G '
P '1 -* #
F%' 1 1 )( ,1 +
%' ( %' X F+ " F*
3 1 %' %' R
# K' LR#KM1 P' # 3
L/1 6898M* , %' # #
#F %' 9>ZZ1 ` )( ,
` +F%&1 X%' R#K (F+
%' %- * % ,
R # %'1
" 1 F+ " + X-
X. F %& + X%'*
1 F F+
F X%' 1 ' " F+
X%' P' 2 * E+= 2
" + #. F1 2 1 1
(F ( %' F+ 1
S X* / X1 -
F %& 1 # F*
. FX= . &
F (1 ( +%'* F
% F "1
* # - F1 ( ' F+
1 -1 - e %'* !-
1 .
(% F 1
283
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
1 P #F %' 9>ZZ* X1 #1 2 "
1 F 1
F %' ( %' " 9>68*
2 & ( ' 2 F %&
X%' 2 , +1
F %& accountability
, F+ P 2 " 2 F %&
2 1 2
. %& +*
F 2 F1 F - + %&1
%' '* P %' '
%' +*
F+ '
#. F* , 1 %' %'
( %& F %& N "
S " 68* 3 2 %'1 -
. F1 X +
F %& accountabilityO 6#
- " 2 F+*
" ( 1 ( " %&
P F* 0
F ( - 1 X - 1 2
- 1
F * E 1 (
%& F 1 P
F %& *
:

'(
F+ ( %' X%'
%' 1 ( P' X 1
F %& X%' * E L688>1 * 6<4M1
P' ( %' 1 1
F+ ( , F+*
3 F1 accountability " %' 2 F %'
S *
284
Monique Menezes
- F+ F %&

++ F PF
accountability* E F+ 1 accountability
X 1 1 + 2
1
L1 688YN /1 688;M*
0_E L9>><M X 2 X accountability +
+F* , F (= ` %& 1
+ 1 2 ( 2 2 %& F %& ,1
'* 3 X%'1 %& F
accountability +F1 2 '
F F* X%' 1 accountability
1 . . 2
%' %& +' F %'
%& . ,*
F %& e accountability
' P' 1 R # K'
LR#KM1 1 # ) L#)M1 #*
1 %& *
2 %' ' +
( = L/1 688YM* R" ( 2 1
F+1 %' " +-+ LWN
/#1 9>>9N 1 688;M* 0 1 %&1
1 1
F %&* 3 1
%' F+
, F+* %' F
` N 1 # 1 1
( %& ` & F- 1 1
` *
0 %'1 /# L9>>ZM1
(= ` (%' G
* , 1 (%& +
%& ' ' *
+1 + 1 F
%& 1 (. * E (1
LF M (
2 ' 1 (.
'*
285
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
A accountability , F+1 F+ ! -

( F1 %'
+ +1 +%'
* X. F+ " F1
1 +
+= ` ( ' *
( F F ' -F 2
F '* 3 1 F %& accountability
= ( F* ,
F %& + "X
accountability +F* ,1 %' %' '1 '
- ( 2 (% F F (%
' F 1 + 2
accountability +F ' (
*
E + F1 2 1 2
( (F+ F %& X%' 1 +
accountability .* , 2 .1
2 1 + 2 %& ,
. + ( ` S* ,
1 " ( + 1 "
2 ' +
F L0_E1 9>>ZN
1
6898M* E 1 F 0_E L688;M1 , + =
2 %&1 + 2 F %&
+ 1 + ( %' *
&

'* ,
'(

# L688>M1 F %& X%'
F 1
1 1 1 .
=&* 0 F
, #F1 1 ' - X1 -1
+* b- 1 1 2 P' '
- + * 3 (.1 "
F+ 2 , F+* E (1 +
+ F " ( + -F
*
286
Monique Menezes
+%'1 1 ' F

%' ` %'
F+1 * F "
1 %'
F * # 1
F * , 1 - F +1
F &* # %'
1 G . F %'*
3 ='1 2
, K1
# X%' %' "
* 0 F
' S 3F 0 L30M + T
0 L0M* (% %'
' . '1 2 X
N %' 1
* )=1 1 2 - 1 " F1 2
* 0 " F N
1 F %'1 2
P'* 0 1 1 X 2
'* 3' " 2 *
F %' + P F
P' F 1 1 +-= 1
2 X* , ( %' 1 = P
1 + * X1 F
" %' *
, #F1 1 1 /"1
$ #1 * R 9 X%'
%' *
B 8 -
B
-
9 59 ='9 !1
9
9 46
9 6
9
9 6
9
X(9 @9 9 /
Auditoria Geral
, K1 ) K1 #-1
1 E1 #1 #H1

]( 1 $ 1 ,1 #1
/"1 *
I L9>>YM*
F F1 P'
' F X
287
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
-F , F+* E 1 01 9>69

F+ X- . F+
X%' 1 G . %
F %& " 68*
# F / L688YM1 ( F %&
( F+
F-* , %' F1 " ( 2
F1 P1 2 " -
%'* S F %' ` %' "
2 (F+* , F%'
G F+1 S 2
" (F+* - 2 F+
+ * 3 1 %' F- ( 1
+ 2 ' F 2 ' ( + 2 F+
, F+*
E 1 " + + 2 1 " 681 +
( F %& * , +
, K1 + * ,1 -
2 F %&
F X1 % -
F 1 %& * 1
F (
R 61 - 2 F *
B D &

@ !

-
288
Auditor Geral
B
-
/'
F+

, F+1
F %&* ,
1 %'
*
F+

, F+1 "

* , 1
%' *
,
0
( %'

F+* ,
1 F %' "

X + *
( %'
F+*
, ( %&
*

+ *
Monique Menezes
@ !

-
Auditor Geral
B
-
F %'
com o
F+
%'
'

%*
%' " 1

2 F %'
%&
F+
1
+ S
&*
I
X*
- (*
R

I (*
I1 (

(
/
I1

*

, "

*
)
I %'
)%'

1 2
( %& +*
)%'

1 2
( %& + 2
` ,*
!

(
%*
I / L688YM*
- R 6 2 " 2

(F+%'1 2
%&* 0 (
. F 2 ` %'1
+ 2 %' + X *
1 1 %& ' * 0 F+
+ ,* E 1
" ( F (F+ 1
= 2 2 F ' `
%' %'1 " F*
: 6

F
3 %'1 .
" F F1 #* E 1
' +X1 2 (
289
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
2 F * %'
F ' ( 1 1 " 681
* 0
+X%'* 0 1 F1
% F "1
F + N 1 (F+
* 0 1 1
" 9>1 (F+
1 F%' F %' `
%& + * ,1 X1 # "
9>681 F %' -+
%' *
R ; F .
F* - -
%& 1 + 2 F #1
F 1 &
F* #) # 1 + 2
' - + "
1 %& * #
1 F %'
*
# %'1 1 . S F* ,
F F+ +% F+
P' 1 F ( %& 1 (
F ` F %'*
(1 2 #) 2 R#K exante veto players. ,
R#K 1 %&1 * !-
#) ( %' +' 1 2 ex-ante
1 %& +* ,
( %& ' ( %&
1 2 - +
. *
290
Monique Menezes
B H &

'* ,
'(
J!=<L
9
-

-

A !=<

3P L3M
R #
K' LR#KM
#

) # L#)M
Clusula
-

#F %'
9>><1 * Z:
#F %'
9>ZZ1 * Y9 Y:
#F %' 9>Z81 *

ZY Z>
F
:x

3' *
0S
R #
K'1 9>>6
T 0P
T
#
) 9><;
( 9>4<
@ !=<

R #
Ano de
Criao
9>><
9Z>8
9>6Y
Estrutura
&
3
# LYM

*
# L>M

*
/-F L9M
*
!
'(
JL FJ

'
%&
#
#1
2 `
%' .

. #S
E *
0 "F
"
%'

#S

E -

*
F+ L4M
, F+ L;M1

9
+
*
, F+ .

L. 2

M*
Mandato
0 1
F
%'*
$
0 1
F
%'*
Controle

3'
3'
Sim
2
$
F+1
'

F+
H1 +

X

3'
2

1
*
* !

( -1
*

291
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1

-

Poder de
<'( F
3'
* 0 R#K

1
1

+ %'

- 1
*
/ 1

1

1
%
(% F
*
0

&
*
3'

P*
* ! -
S R#K*
* ! -*
X

'(
R
F %&

+
1 .
1
+%
+F *
R
F %&
(1
1

F %&

2

(*
R F %&

P' 2

+ *

F %&
! -1 , F+1
*
!.

=

Sim
Sim
Sim
Prestao
de Contas
#'
Parlamentar
/ )+
#
F+
#
B

=

'(

1
X
'*

-1
X1
%-1

*

-1 X1
%-1

*
Contas do
Presidente
da
0

I
*
I
*
Sim
I ,%' P*2
I= F 2 R#K + 1 %'
1 2 ' (F+ -F +
- ! - L)1 6884N /1 688>M*
292
Monique Menezes

F " %' F+
F+ , F+ '* L688YM1
#F %' F 9Z:; cX
% %' 3%'1 +
+'d L,1 9>ZZ1 * >6 apud 1 688Y * 9;M* P
%& " 681 9>:Z ( F R #
3P LR#3M1 ( %& " LH -M
LM*
%' 1 *
F %' " * #
F 1 R#3 "+ +1
2 ( veto player* # 1
R#3 ( + ( F(P1
accountability *
3 " 9>>81 F (
1 F%' R#3 %'
3P L3M* 0 X + / F
%' F R#31 + ( (F+
* ,1 F+%&
2 + L#1 688<N /1 688YM* E / L688YM1
, F+ (+ . R#3 F%'*
X%& R#3 & +F%&
" 9>>8 %'* %'
- %' ` %& + ( 2 /
F %'* 0 R#3
+1 + ` . 1 ( 2 $=
F %' 2 ' *
P +%' F %' 1 + H +
F 1 F+ ( veto player R#3*
, 9>>61 5 6<*9:4 F 3P L3M* "
2 ( ` X%' + P' c " .
' %-1 H1 X1
1 1 ' %&
- X %' L***Md L1 9>>61 * 99YM*
, 9>><1 3 status F 1 (
F + /* 3 "
1 ` 1 (= .
* F %' " 1 X
293
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
1 F %' * 0 +
F (%' . 1
%' + - %' X * 0
F+ " -+ %' 1
. . #S E 1 "F
" %' # -
F %'* 2 +%' :8 2 2
1 %' 1 + 2
. F+ 2 1 +%'*
# F L688YM1 % 3 F =
X%' * F %'
%' %' 1
1 +% F 2 (
+F1 . * L1 688YM*
1 X '* ,1 2
F (F+*
0 "F 1 2 1 "
F %' * , (
F+ %' , F+* # 1
-F1 F+1 , F+1 F %'1
F 2 %& 3 (.
* 2 '1 , F+
F1 1 * E (1
F %'1
' F+ 1 2 1 1
+*
" + 1
( 9>>8 F . "+
+* , %'
3 3P LM1 P' +* 0
" ( %' 3*
F &
F+* # , F+1 2 1
&1 +%& ' ' 1 1
+*
, F 1 3 " P' F+
+' F %& , F*
# F " 1 %& '
+ F+ " %'
L1 688Y1 * 6;<M*
294
Monique Menezes
. . %' F+ " +

%' 1 ( F* , +
F1 F L688YM H + 2
' 2 "
1 2 + F%' P'
F* b- + P (. , F+1
%' = ' + N
1 " X P '*
3 1 = 1
2 X%' +
%' *
0 X%' " F %' "
1 2 " * 3 Z88
( -1 + P' F
%& F * 3' -
( -1 2 F %' X
* 2 ( ` 31 %'
. S 2 X +% (
1 P 68 %'* , ( (
F ( F %'*
0 X%' "
F " + F+ ( -1
+ P L1 688Y1 * 6<;M* (F+
accountability 1 (
-+1 %' (%&1 -
F *
1 3 X%& 2
+ (% * 1 -
P F %'1 %' internet, (
+ F %'* # #
689; ' - 3 internet 1
F+ 1 " ' +*
2 (1 " " *
%' F & 2 ' 2
F+ X. 3
- F1 F
F & %' P' X%' +
F+* 3 ' N
" 1 - F%' F %'1 "
"* 3 1 +
295
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
, F+1 2 +
F *
X1 " 2 . F 2 (
" 9>>8
* %' P
( * 0 F 1 -
1 ( . F
` %' -F %' F * ,
' " F* -1 % + F+1 1
, F+*

0 R # K' " F %' 2 +
+P1 E 5 >44=1 8Y + 9Z>81
%' #F %' ) * status F
+ = F+ P' # 31
F+ " * #
/ L6898M1 F # # +
" 681 F+* 3
2 = 1 X %' F
F = %' *
#F %' 9>;< ( -+ S
R # F * # #F
. %& X R#K P'
%' F+ +1 /" 1
" #F %'* E 1 +
%' % * E L9>>Y1
* 96<M1 " + 2 F+ # # '
F ( * , 9>;:1 (
2 ) +
# 31 2 ( -F
* ,1 9>;Y1 + , 3+ + +"
1 - " S R#K*
# %' -F 9><41
F+ X%' % 1
%'1 2 2 ' -+
* =1 1 %' 1
& * 0S
R 5 Z;879><> #F %' 1 + "
2 R#K 1 %'
296
Monique Menezes
* # F L9>>YM1 F+
F+ X%' e 1
X%& * ,1 +
E /1 ( %& .
R#K1 = + %' *
# X + /1 9>Z41 + #F %' I
9>ZZ1 . F ( ( XF+*
I % R#K1
1 " X1 (F+1 X.
L/1 6898M* X%'
1 1
( 1 X%' 2
.*
E F+ R#K 2
F 1
9* F "+ )1
X # 3N
6* -+ 1
+ %' N
;* 1 F+ P1 #S E I1
%& -1 X1 %-1
1 F+
F+1 , F+ ! -1 F (N
<* X %' 2 2 K'1
+.1 1 .1 ,1
E I / N
:* (%& # 31 2 2
#1 %& N
4* 1 F+ # 3
1 2 - , F+ +* ,1
, F+ F+ ' (F+ - `
%' 1 >8 1 R - *
3 2 ( 1 R#K ( (
-+* - 2 E /1 2
' + (%' #
31 #F %' 9>ZZ %' R#K1
' - %' *
, F+ %'1 , F+1
%' * !-
297
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
F 1 %' 1 X1
" 1 %& P' L1 688;M* 3 1
= H 2$ 4 K F
30 * E / T L688;M1
XF1 XF1 2
F+ F %& ( %*
# ) I L # 5 98976888M1 R#K +
+ 1 " X%'
%' X * , ( -+
'1 P
%' %- 2 ' X F %&
+ %' internet* 0 R#K 1 1 P'
( F %& 2
K'1 );* ,1
F 1 F 1 ' .
(F+ L1 9>>YM* 3 S 1 %'
2 2 1 R#K *
3 F 1 P # #
+* E )P R # L689;M1 6*6Y<
( 1 + )[ 9198; '*
E( 2 3 F1 R#K
* " "
+ P' '
+% 1 + + -
1 * 1 P' 6*4:>
+ F+ 64 E I*
" F 1 #F %' 9>ZZ "
% 2 ` %' F+* # +
# #F 1 # 3 +
+ ) .1 " +* # 1
, F+ + I
" 1 + 1 + 2
1 F 1
/" < 2 ` # #*
)= 2 (% )1 2 ( ` # +1
# '* ,2 % K' P %'
%-1 (= P' X *
<
3 - 1 + %' /"
( %&*
298
Monique Menezes
# + R <1 R#K (

P #F %' 9>ZZ* b + ( +%' F
"1 688Y 68991
+ = * %& /
R#K 9>ZZ 688Y1 L688YM 2 =
P * , + # #1 '
F 2 - F+* F L688YM X 2 -1 1
F1 F%' %' * ,1
( " +*
B P @

B
- >
(^
Ministro
z

!
'(
E I

9>>Z
L/
F M

2001
E I
#3
689<
#
CN
Walton

Rodrigues
9>>>

/"
R#K

Raimundo
Carreiro
688Y
-=
/ I
CN
Vital Rego
=

X6 @

Monteiro
=

689<

CN
#
sem
X%'
F-
/

Ministrio

+

PMDB
688>
CN
R
Ana Arraes
2011
E I

/ ,
#(
)%&
F
.
)
E I
CN
PSB
Aroldo
-

{#
Augusto
Nardes

Dantas
Ano de
Nomeao
688Y

I 4
+

R#K
PP
I ,%' P*4

#3 # 3
F %' / 689:*

0 F I LI M ( 9>Z: F 688Y* , 1 I
( E LE,/M*
299
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
E+ R #1 %'

+ F+1 2
* , R#K
( %' " , F+1
F* E (1
# # %' =
*
3 2 ( ` %' F-1 " + + 2
F R E* ,
F + ` ( . )
= I b2 # L9>>: 6886M* !- R
F 2 %&1 F+
= L688; 6898M 1 1 E ) 1
2 6899 ( 689<*
K P .
F = + F
F+ -F* , + F+
+ status 1 F1 1
+ F+ F * 3 F1
' +X '
* -1 %&
F 2 ' + *
1 R#K
X%'1 ' +1 1 %'1
* 0 + ' F #
# %' ( P' %'
* F 2 R#K FX F+ 2 +
X* F
'1 P'1 1
F+ +* !- %& ' F
* 3 F X%'1 "
+ + * 0 1
1 F '
F %&* 3 1 R#K + "1
F + + F %'1 (%&
%& X1 * X1 "
# # +X %&
F+ *
300
Monique Menezes
R : X%& R#K

6896 689<* %' 1
<;1>1 <41Z :61Z 68961 689; 689<1 F+* )=
2 %' X%& ( FX # #
F %' P'* 0 F+
" X%& 1 . -X
( LR # K1 689;1 * 68M* 0
" ( 2 1
X%&* 1 %' 1 1 :8
1 . *
B ^ =

'*
DK8K DK88
B
=

'(
Monitoramento
F
!'(
Auditoria

Total
DK8D
<Z
9;9
:9<
:><
44
9*;:;
;1:
>14
;Y1>
<;1>
<1Z
988
:<
9Y<
212
<6>
<Y
>94
Ano
DK8H
:1>
9>18
6;19
<41Z
:19
988
DK8P
;<
4:
9<6
;:>
Z8
4Z8
:
>14
681>
:61Z
991Z
988
I R # K' L6896 689<M*
, 1 R#K 1 1 F%' .

* E %& 1
= F %' 2 -1 F+ ("1
% .* ,1 ` # #1 " /"
1 %' " ( * %'
R#K1 /" " =1 .
2 1
)1 * 2 1 &
1 % /"
" P*
(F+ R#K1 0S 5 Z*<<;79>>6 +.
%' 1 2
9* + ( N
6* ( N
;* -+ N
<* % (% F
N
301
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
:* % (% F

N
4* -+ ( %' X%
S %' *
%& R#K + P' X
- >8 1 -+
/" F+* ,1
>8 ' " X* E 1
N ' X *
" & P ! -* E
/ L6898M1 2 F %& X
& X%'1
1 FXF+*
, R#K (= P' 2
* 0 F 1 + F ++
1 1 Y* # 1
F+ ' ! -1 & +1
(F+ %& * / 2 P'
+ 1 ! - F ` & R#K1 F
X 2 2 ' *
+ +1 P' 1
%' R#K* ,1 -F1 2 + " 2 '
' ( ( *
1 %' R#K X
X* E %' %' # / 689<1
R#K X
%' -* 0 ( X 2 R#K
X + "F
%' 2 ( - * 1
1 %'
* , F %' .
-F*
X%' +F " 9>>8 "
F+* # % F
302
%' P # 3 ' ( >8
1 2 # #* 3 1 #F %'
2 R#K "*
Monique Menezes
P1 9>>Z ( F + " R#K*

I%' E%' LXM ( +
- +F%' X%' F+=X
. * ( %& = %'
+% *
F+ F+ R#K1 688: (
X%' P ' *
, P +1 + 2 (+ FXF+ "
%' % '* 0 +
R#K1 1 ( . +' (-
+% '* 3 %' 1
+' (-1 . X
+ F+ '1
"* 3 1 . /" /
, %'1 ` ! F%
LR # K1 P'1 4<>M*
E+= 2 F 2 F
F %& 1 2 2 R#K ' +
F+=X* 3 1 2 P " 2
%' ( F+ -
1 + 2 ( - +' (-1 2 1
2 '1 F+ -*
" X%' 1 '
1 2 ( X- X. F 1 2
( XF+ -F* 0
" ( 1
+%' %' F
F+ *
-

0 F1 #1
F X* 1
F S1 #
) L#)M 2 *
" ( #) ' + 1
F+1 , F+ ! -* , ( %' 1 + "
2 * .
F 2 ' 1
2 2 *
303
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
0 # %' 1 2
* !- 9:<9 - %' X
%' * 3 " 9Y1 +
( ( %' X , %' )
1 ' %' X
* " 1 ( %' X (
(%&1 " 2 1 9ZZZ1 ( R # 1
" F* 3 " 9>681 %
( ( G , K1 2 +
' experts X ` ' %' +- *
F P'
` P 2 #) F * 1
. # ) %'
F P X%'
-2 #* %' ) #
" 9>N 1 %& -F
1 * 3 F1
F %' %
. #) 9>4<* 1 2 ( 1
2 ( %& 1
F " % P* "
" 9>681 * E 1 %
F + *
3 1 #) ( 9>6Y1 +
F * (
, F+ F+ " F+ 2 F%'
F %'1 2 *
1 P' %' . 1
%' X%* " 1 F %'
2 X %& #) F
F+ 1 F+ ++ P
X%'1 #) + *
1 #) " F
# 2 * " 688:1
+ " P +%
Y: * , 688:1 5 68*8:8 #1 2
1 %'* c0 #
) L***M - )1 +%'
. 2 1
' - . L#1 688:1 * 9M* ,
304
Monique Menezes
%' " XF+1 2 %' #)

, F+ F+* 688:1 # X
1 2 + F *
1 # 0+
X 9>YZ " 9>>YN
( 2 + *
F %' # impeachment
* # F 1 #
" * R ( - #) '
+ #N F+
-* " 1 1 # 1
+" *
0 #) " 1 +
%&1 " *
' 2 ( %& * 1 -
( %' +' 1 2 ex-ante F 1
%& F+* 0
" 31 2 #
%& * , ( ` #)
veto player %' * # 1 , F+
- #)1

1 2
F1 + P'
*
( %' " %& ex-post
, F+1 2
+ * #) ' +
%' 4#1 1 " ' - %'1
P' %& 2 +X X. (F+
1 *
( %' " -1 2 #)
%' X %' dictamenes
LM* 0 & F%& F ( -1
F+ 2 ' + L/1 688YM* 3 1 &
P' ' + S %' *
X1 2 ( %' #)
* , F+ F
H ,* , 1 -
( - 1 & P ! -1
S S* , ( %' " 1 2
- 1 - 2 " ( %' e
305
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
* 0

F+ %' H (
S1 *
#) " ( %& 2 ' F
* 1 " P' -+ %'
* , ( %' 1 P' '
* , %' ( %& FX= P X
' #)1 2 1 1
( %&* ,1 ( %&
G 1 " (
F %'* , ' 1 (% %'
X F* , %' "
2 R # 1 2 ( F+
* %& +' 2 '
1 2 (
4#*
G 1 += 2 #) 1
R#K1 * & -F
1 -
spirit corps F %'* ,1 # (
%' 2 F+1 2 F
. X%' (F+ 1 - 2 #)
F+ ' *
X1 ' 1 2 ` (F+
%& %& #)1
& ' (F+ * & R #)
F+ 2 & F+ * 3 1 2
- %& %& 1
! -1 2 #1 1 %' +
P' *
- (
- S
F ( * 0 P'
# %& X1
&1 (F+
+ F+1 ( X %& *
!- F1 + 2 F
306
Monique Menezes
F+ e (F+ 2 ` X%'

1 + F%' 3*
3 2 ( ` %' F+1 - .
2 ( %' F %'
1 2 " , F+1 X%'
. %& * 1 . 1
#1 %' X% 1
2 ' #) P' 2 , F+*
3 2 1 = -1 2
%&1 " #
1 & F+*
) ` 2 ' F J _

'*
,
'(

_

Y J1
2 2 1
%' . accountability (
* 0 . , F+ (1
F+* , ( %' 1 .
P = + S*
X. F %& X%'
2 %& + ( 2
+*
X1 - 2 (F+ %' +
7 ++ S "
( 2 ' * , 1
1 - F F %' + *
2 F ! - ( R#K X
( XF+ %' * 3 F1 += %&
F 2 F %& *
0".

1,
* T 6<*9:4 64 0 * X T
# 3* 19>>6* E+ U77
(**+*7(
778=<>>>7::<7**
1 /* # F F ( F F+
T ( F 0,#E* +1 +* 981 ;1 * 6;:=6481 9>>Y*
1 N $1 (* F F T G
T *
#( ( R
F T (
3\
F F ,1 96*1 688Y1 )Q+Q* E+ U77*7
>4:<;<*
307
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
1 !* 0 +F%'

3R0

%' ) K* )+ R#K1 ;41
98<1 * 9Y=661 688:*
#* T 5 68*8:8* )( F 2 + X
#F P F )* F1 688:* E+ U77
\\\*T*73+ T688:8*
E1 ,+* +1 F%' 2
(
/1 E L0*M* F T + F
P # I#,1 K+ # $ 1 688<* * >:=999*
I1 * R ( # T ( T
( * /1 UN 1 # L,*M*
EF T F * 0( 0( K+T 1 688;*
I1 N 1 I* , F+ F+ +
F * ' I$* 9>>>*
1 /* 0 .
F+ F+ %&1 + X ( *
#
# )( E , T P 1
Z1 688;1 -* * 6Z=;9*
* ,F X L,IM (%
T . +% *
)+ R#K1 ;41 5 98<1 * 46=Y<1 688:*
! 1 #F* K F %' P /"
G * )+ , F1 * 91 * Y9=Z<1 6898*
W1 )QN /1 /\* R ( F
F F * #7 R K+T ( #
1 9>>9*
1 T * 0 # (
G F+ P *
, %'
#. F L#M1 ;1 6Z ;9 68861 3P*
/1 U*
F F T F *

/1 UN 1 # L,*M* EF T F
* 0( 0( K+T 1 688;*
/1 / "* 0 " F* '
F I
b2 #1 688Y* E+ U77\\\*(F*7
79Y><*(*
/1 /2 * .
R # K' P * ) !
1
6898* R LE M J
F K+- 2 ) !
L
M1 ) !*
* 0 # 3 R # K'
X%' . %' %' *
308
Monique Menezes
, %' 3 P= %' #.

LM1 ;:1 68991 # 1 / *
/1 #= * E * ' , 1 9>Y;*
#%' 0 *
0_E1 * EF+ T* R ! ( ET1 +* :1
91 * ::=4>1 9>><*
* T + 2 * 3+1 5 <<1 *
6Y=:<1 9>>Z*
* b T F FF ( *

/\1 UN 1 # L,*M* EF T F
* 0( 0( K+T 1 688;*
01 * # T * E#
,1 688Y*
1 #N /1 * K S , F+
& F+ * )+ #. 1
+* 9:1 <;1 * <:=4Y1 6888*
1 #* )%& , F+ F+
9><4=9>><* ' K1 9>>Y* R LE M J K+ '
LKM* ' *
* T F*
1
# L0*M* E * ) ! I$1 688Y*
* # ( %' 2 F+ *

1 I * L0*M* 0 P F
\* ) ! I$1 688>*
1 # * ( (
X+ * 0( 0( K+T 1 9>>>*
1 /* R T ( +XF* 0( 0( K+T
1 9>>>*
1 I* R K F 0 ( (
* / F ! 1 +* 9>1 ;1 * ;><=;>>1 688<*
)1 * ,%' ( S
R # K'* )+
(%' F+1 1 +* <81
9:Y1 * 66;=6:91 688;*
1 #* F ( T F T ( +
F + * F b bQ
K+T1 688Y* R LE IXM ! bQ K+T* F*
R # K* P' 4<>* %' '
'* 1 688:* E+ U77
;* * +*7777R#K7 7 7
884*664=688<=Z*( *
* 0 R#K # / 689< )P %'* R#K1
6896*
309
7 # 0
+2/ $ 5 #
%+3 1
* )P F+ 6899* R#K1 6896*

* )P F+689;* R#K1 689<*
1 * 0 R # K' .
*
. +% -
*
F b" '1 688;*
Sites
U77\\\**+*7
U776* *+*7
# U77\\\**7
/2 /
E #. F
F K+- 2 ) ! L
M (
/ #. F K+ I LKI
M* # 2 ^*
310
RSP Revisitada
A " 6

(

J0 $#
"3 2 OO3 O3 2
!3 O~}
, 9>Z:1 F , #U

( F+1 2
+ - F * #U & ` +
+& %' G+1 +
%'1 F%' -F
F + -* 0 2 +
++ %' F+ - (
F+ * R+1 ' +
%' %'1 1 +
+ * KF=
(P1 #U ( 2 +
1 ' 2 -
2 + * 1 (
%' F+ ++ ' F
X%&* ' F ( 1 1
+ %'* , & +1 (
+ 1
%'* , + -(1 #U 2
+ -* , - + P 1 1
2 ' ` F+ * 3
F+ 1 "1 " + +*
3 % ( -F *
'(
0 F ' ( 1 -1 =
1 2 ' )( F+ * F+ '
%' 1 '
% 2 +
311
8$ 4 22 ,+#
-2 F+ (* , (% ( ' " +1
1 -1 2 1 *
-=1 +
)( F+ 9>4Y*
1 1 ` +' + %'
F+1 G+1 O
%' 1 " 1 +
+%'1 -F F1 F +1
-*
& = P+ F+ " )(
%' + . S
F1 %'
1 -
1 %' E1 ( %'
2
2 %'
* R+ 1 +1 ' +1
1 1 -F1 =
++ *
8/ :

/ + ++ %' F+ -
XF+ ( %' 1 * %
%' I*
+1 2 1 1 +
%' ' %'1 1 + %'
1 1 +1 1 %'1
%'1 ++ ` %'
+ ,1 ( %'
++ H *
( ( 1 ( 1 "1
X - $ )1
$1 2 F F1
%' F+1 + *
3 ( F%' ++F1 , +% 1
F %& F1 +
++ *
/ += 1 2 1
1 %' ( 2 (
312
'
$ %

% * 1 $ )
9>4< ( F%' 2 $
(* + +%' ,1
1 %' X X1
+" 2 %& H
* / 2 1 P -F *
( ( F
F F+ 1 + -1
1 F
1 + * FX-=1 + = )(
F+ 9>4Y1 E= * 688 1 "
%'1 " 1
2 *
R 2 ( $1 9>4<1
+1 = F+1 2 "F
2 * # 1 ' = "
2 ( * / " 1 P1 +-= 2 P=
F 2 *
%' ' " 2
* -1 " X XF+* 0 +
= = F 2
*
3+ ) " 2
%' * 3' ( +"1
` %'1 2 ' " +F+1 P F+ 1
+ * 3 PF1 +
X + ' 1
-+1 2
1 %' " + PF1 -+1
1 X1 (-1 2 ( *
01 .=1 2 2 1
'=F(P* / '=F(P 2 E
( ( +%'1 F+
H 1 )( F+ "
- F(P N F(P
F(P
% F %' 1 (
2 2 S -+
313
8$ 4 22 ,+#
'* I ` )( % F %'1 2 "

1 -= + -1 +
' +*
%' F+ 2 F%' 2 F+
%' ` )(1 2 1 1 ++ 1
F 1 , "
1 1 1 1
1 2 2
- *
)( 2 % +
1 2 + ` ' 2 +
+- 1 * ,1
' +1 -* - + P 1 1
2 ' ` F+ *
31 "1 " +1 +*
0 PF 2 ' .= +' '
1 S "1 ++ " 2 1
* # F + 1 =
9><4 9>4<1 F *
3 % ( -F *
D/ :

( 1
"

8\Q`
F 2 1 F+1 F+1
( F+ 9>4Y* 1 " 2 2
F 1 ' (- *
/ 1 +1 F+
+1 1 F1 F*
2 2 1 " 2 (
%' F+ " ++ ' F 2
* P + 2 E1
#01 #,1 ,) ,/0)11 -
1 F 1 (
G %'1 +%' +1 2 1
E %' +% 1 #' X%' -F1 #' ,
F+1 ,P )( F+1 /%' )(*
314
'
$ %

%& 2 F F%'
(1 2 2 %& P' (* I 2
. " +* # 1 %&
" 1 P 1 /"
%'1 3 E F%'
/%' )( F+ ,/0)*
, ' F ( " + %' %'* ,
" F F & +1 +
F 1 +" (
%'* 1 ( -F
%& ( +
,1 ( F- P P' *
" 1

( F- F P
%'*
)1 % 9>Z:1 I %' E++ F+
IK3E1 , ' 1 + - E= 5
688* E F1 + '
%& P )( 9>4Y*
+ 2 1 2
-1 - H1 . . 2
+ +1 ' ( %'
1 " - F+ + (%1
1 1 1 S + L
1 9>Z:1 * >= 69M 2 S
%' *
3' - ' +- 1 (
%' ' 1 F+ E= * 688* 0
1 +%' -1 1
%' %' F = -*
' "
+ E= 5 688 % X.
1 N " 1 1 +' "
++ 1 ( %' %' %-
N 1 %& *
/ 2 ' 2 1 68 1
- ,
R ( %& 2 ' (
315
8$ 4 22 ,+#
F+ ( F+ 0 2 "

( 2 G . -
1 P=4< L 1 9>Z:1 * 9YM*
2 E= 5 688
(F+ %' %' *
0 1 %' X
S P 1 G F+
F 1 2
+ L 1 9>Z:1 * 9YM*
/ " * / F
E* 0 ,
1 F+ 2 F+*
E 1 1 ( "
+ 1 + *
( S 2. status F
+ 1 2 1 /" I1
1 - * 1
+ I 1 .1
' P P %' 1
P 2 ' +*
/%' )( F+1 P'
( ( F+1 P , 3=)1
+ . +S F
3 E F%'1 +
/ '*
, " + . +
)( F+* 0 2 .1 "*
F%'1 ' (
%'1 .1 2
X '==*
0 + " ' EX 3U
* , - ' P 1 2 1
" 1 1 (
F+1 + `
+-+ *
" ' + 1 X '
+-+ + H1 =
O1 -2 F+* E
316
'
$ %

' 2 ' = -+1

X. X- ,*
0 " X -F1
P - +' (- * -
. HN (% 2 F-+ +
+*
3 %' X= + +=
%'1 (1 1 2. F
- +* P 2 ( %' %' (
* , ++ P1
+*
/ ' * 32 1 1 =
(. . %'
F+1 2 - 2 F+ %' %'
2 & L
1 9>Z:1 * 9ZM*
( + %' EX 3U %'
1 e 2 ( F*
# ( R 1 X %'
+ E++ ,H:
F 2 (1 +1 F
2 ( . F1 +*
E 1 + . ' 2
++ H1 =
2 FF+ + F 1 2 +
FN + -1 +
X =
1 = & -F*
2 % ( 2 1 1 &=
2 X%& +
( F+ %' ++
H* , " F+ - *
b- 2 +* ' 2
F+ ' 1 F+ 2 1 1
" * K %' (1
+1 ' 2 '
( ( 2 - ( * E (
317
8$ 4 22 ,+#
1 2 -
( ( 1 2 X 2 %'
%' ( *
( %' 1 %' %&
+ 1 + "
++* + F (
1 F+ 2
%' X LE 3 9>441 *
$1 $
$
M*
# /=#( .
)1 + 1 2
F -* R+ + 2
+*
*** 3 ' - %' * 3 - 2 *
E ( 2 ' * 0 2 - '
F H 2 +-
2 %'*** , + % +
( * , X2 /1 E*
1 2 + ( _ ,
1
1 2 2 2 + * , X
+ 2 - _*** 3P 1 9>4<1
' 1 %' * 31
' . 2 + 1 * , " 2 R
1 2 ' 1 + 2 +
2 1 2 F1
2
(***
, /=#( .
)
*** 0 " -F X***
2 1
1 2 " ' " O* 0 "
%1 "1 + (
2 . 2 (*** X%'1 2 X-1
" X P1 %'*** ,
1 " ' *** LE 31 9>Z81 * ;>=<6M*
, "2 ( % ' /
T1 3+ )* , F 2 %' (
F+1 - 1 1 /
%'1 + / ,- E F%'*
318
'
$ %

K " e R ` + X +

)(1 F ` *
) ( -
E= 5 6881 + IK3E1 *** !
b - " P=1
2 " %& ( * E ( +
1 = %' K'1
+% 1 +1 + 2
F+ 1 %& F+
%' 2 1 1 ' ' "F*
%' " " + " +1
1 #* (1 1
F+1 E ( -
-F -+ + +* 3 1
-F 2 (1
% X. H N
(1 . (
, / N
0 (F N
%' % *
, ( ' + %&1 ' +
= + 1 =
F+ . F L 1 9>Z: * 9Z=9>M*
H/
(
"

R1 )( F+ + (%
(% -2 F+1 F+1
%'1 X. X-* , 1
2 "1 X*
0 ( F+ F +.=1 P
(1 % %&
E E1 %& %& ,
/ 1 ( F %& F+ + 1
F S1 P '*
E PF1 " 2 (%'
%' I * E 2 2 (1
F+ (%-=1 %' F *
319
8$ 4 22 ,+#
0 + %1 1

" 2 & F 1 1 (
1 1 2 '1 2 %&
, + X*
+%' &1 '1
1 1 X F
( F+1 2 ( %'
%' * P - +
( F 2 1 1 1
%& + 1 .
*
0 ( + 1
+ (-=1 1 "
(F+ %'* , '1 1 1
F1 " X*
(% FX ( %' F+
1 =
. ` ' "* , (
" - 1 2 + " 2 *
,1 ( " F1 1 1
"* 3 %&1 F - 2
- F 1 2 1 2
%' 1 " XF+* %1
2 +1 " 2 ' -*
1 X1
( & %' &
1 -+ X & %'
% X1 X*
+1 += %' 1
( 1 & 1 2
1 ( % 1
. *
, +%' ' + " %' F+
* / ' ( +%& P1
( %
H *
premissas1 F +' +
( F+1 + += * E ( '= F+1
=
320
'
$ %

)( " (% ( %&

,21 ( ' F %& F-
%'1 ' 1 1 X 1
=1 ( 1
F- X*
%' I1 )(1 '
( 1 *
2 + #F %' I%' 1
%' . + + F+ %&1
(%' 1 %'
2 + %' %' I ' -
XF+ ' ( X.1 X-
(F+ %& , / *
0 - "1 1 )( I*
, " 2 1 1 ' -
%& + 1
F+ " %' F+*
R ( + 2 '1 2
+ )(*
%' )( F+ -
+ 1 (
+ *
- +1 1 %' 2 (% %&
2 + 1 2 1 F S1 F
1 2 . X =
X- *
( ' " 2 2 .
" 1 2 F
F-1
1 F %& +1 P '*
R=1 1 1 . " F
(.= =1 2 " ( -=*
E + 1 X%' ( %& ,1 +F - S1 +
' -F FF+ 2 +*
321
8$ 4 22 ,+#
& )( F+ - ( *

#+ 2 2
&*
+ F 1 -+ F
2 )( ` + #F %' 1 F =
1 %'
%' %& I1 , / 1
.1 F F ` ( (1
( F %' + + +
%&N " 1 +' %' F
F+*
+ 1 ' + =
L( %&M =%'
%& E
N +' %&
2 & %' I1 =
*
/ 2 1 +1 2 ' #+
K'* ' ( 1 1 2
-F F=F+
* # 1 "1 1 X%' 1 1 '
' F( +1 X%'
( %' 1 2 "*
0 2 &1 + + , 1
- X1 - 2 - %' F 2
( , *
+ ( 1 = 2 ' -
%' F+ (* 3 1 %=1 +%
)( 9>4Y1 F - 2 * .
2 68 -F - F1 ' P +'1
1 1 %' X%'
F*
3 F+ 1 1 1
X ` + )(* 3' " 2 ' "
* , + * 0 X- %'
F+ , '
-+ + F%' -
1 2 F1 1
+ H=X *
322
'
$ %

+ =1 1

( )(* 2 2 ' ' " " ' F+* ,
" F+ * , ' - * b-
F + 1 P 1
1 F 1 - 1
XX F F+ 3+ )* /
X%' ' -1 +
( ( -+*
0 X%' %' +%' +
1 2 ` %' E1 -
%' * $ %' -+
%' %' E " ' O 2
%' 1 2 1 2 F F
+%' ,1 + F *
I1 + %& %' X1
" - = X
-F1 = % F+
(%' ( 1
G , 1 +" -F1
F*R+1 ' +1 2 & 2
+1 " %'1 " + (
+ ( * # '
1 2 +1 E= 5 688
3 +' F( E1 + -
%' %' G -1
+ + (F%' %' F+1
' + %'1 = + +%'
F%' P
( XF+*

b1 X%' %' =
1 1 )+ %' ;8*
3 - (1 %' -F
F+ X ' "F1
- +- F X%'*
3 , / 1 2 (
H F & " X1
F ( ' (-F*
+1 %' X E= 5 688
%& +1 ( +%'*
323
8$ 4 22 ,+#
0 1 1 (- +

E +1 G*
%' + -F1 1 1
1 %' -1 - 2 S
(* K + (%'
+ + P * )
F=F+
F* L 1 9>Z:1 * 68= 69M*
P/ > "

%' -F 2
1 1 2 %'
F+ + )(1 *
F F +
%* E % XF+ H * ,(%
O 1 +%' ,
X1 1 + 2 "
F "G * %' F+ " ( +%'*
0 + 1 %&1 +
F * R 2 2 "
%' 2 +%& 1 (1 (
2 ( + * /1
F + 1
(-F % 1 e * ,%&1
FXF+ " %& + 1 2 2
` %' %' 2 F*
b-1 1 S ( + ( %' F
2 %' F 1 1 2
-F F+ L1 9>Z: * :4=:YM* , +.
2 F "1 2 %' (F+ F
( si et in quantum 1 1
%' %'*
#=1 1 X =- e
%' P +1 1 1 X.
- %& +1 P %& -
1 ==- 2 %'
%' +*
324
'
$ %

( %& P 1

*
K (2 -+
X. %' -F + " %' (%'
+1 P -F %' ( =
%' * / -1 O
2 F %*
) 2 + F+ ( F+1 F S1
%& (% * , (1 F
+ %' %' P + %'
1 2 ( 1 = + X
1 1 %'
F *
E " + )( -F
F +%& - ,*
# - 1 )(1 P
2 1 " %' 1 ++ ( '
-F %' F+ ,*

' ' F %' F+*
1 "1 2 %' + +

F+ F ' ` %' ,
1 +1
F %' 1 X%' "1
P*
K + XX %'1 + F F+1 + %'
, ' -N 1 1 X
F+ S *
= %' F +
1 X 1 P '* R+1 1 2
FX " 2 %' %'
%' -* R
,1 + P %& *
+ )( + F+1 +" %' 1
F + 1 2 ' F+ '
2 1 a posteriori1 + 1 2
" F1 -F*
/ %'1 ( '
( ++ " X * , "1
325
8$ 4 22 ,+#
+1 %' 1 1 2 ( F
F+1 + P* 3+ )1 F
+ 1 ' F + (
-F %' + F
%& *
+ )(1 2 X1 ' F
+' 1 1 + %'
S F+1 (%' ++
F+ 1 ( %' 1
F *
# " +* / ' 2 *
K + +' ( 1 1
1 1 X -F %'*
3 - ( - E= 5 6881 + EK3E1
) L9>Z:1 * ::=Z6M + ' %'
%' 1 ( F+ %' '* 3
*
E -F FF+1 %'1
X %' ( 1
+ 1 + %'1
( +1 G
(1 + (%' & *
F +1 F
F %' e '1
` %' " ( +"
-1 ( %'
,1 + %& *
, ' %' I L M
+1 ( 1
+F1 1 1 +*
, F+ F FX%'
%' ( F N FX%'
1 + %& F 1
%& .N (%'
1 + %' F1
( 1 F 1 2
X F+1 P1 %'
%' 2 *
326
'
$ %

# 2.1 +%' F 1

1 ( 1
=+ * # "
+ *
EX - %' F F
+%' F+ ++1 )(
1 F1 *
+ +F
X %& "
XF+ %' - + 2 1 F
(1 " + (=%'1 1
S X1 ( X *
, + " F+
( 1 FX%' F+
1 F 1 -F
%' 2 1 ' F
( (1 F
. ` %' * 0
1 ( (1
X1 +X 2 ( " +
P %'1 F S *
) L9>Z:1 * 46=4<M1 2
%' )( + ` 2 %'
, %' F
(% +$#1 +" F %'
(1 2
+ .
(%' 2 N
(
+$#1 =1 F =
F1 + %' 1
1 F 2
-F -N
(+ +#$
$ 41
F+ 2 +" (
* 2 1 1
( +- 2 X%& X 2
( %' F F %&N
e ` coordenao de projetos1 %' -F
1 X + %
327
8$ 4 22 ,+#
%' 1 1 + %' F %& (

F - N
%' 1 F
F+ 1 G
&1 (%& -+
( N
a 4#

1 FX%' %' X
- 1 + ` -F* , 1
- "1
F - * F+1
%' N . "N %'
%'N 2 N
a
# +$#1 %& )(
(% F %&* 0 X -
2 %& " L %'M P
F 2 X%' F
1 2 " 2 ( 2 & F+
+ F+ F ' F %'*
a negociao de rede1 +" 2 )( F+1 +"
1 + ' P G 1
+ 1 " -
F + . - F+
*
,X1 = +' F+ + )(*
# +' F 1 2 `
%& 1 *
P/8/ @ "

E 1 1 " + + 2 (%
%' - + - F -
- %' *
b-1 1 2 )( -
1 ++*
!"#$"&# ! '( # #!# # )*#
R= " ( F 1 ' (
( F+ %& . + +*
+ 2 )( +% %'
1 = 1 .* #+
328
'
$ %

F - , / 1 S

X%' P1 + 1
2 . + F+*
+ -#!/ #!6
, 3+ )* )(1 1
+- = %'1 =
+1 2 1 1
%' +1 (.
( %&1 1 + +* R=
%' %' %& (* , F+1
F F+1 (F+ ,
/ F( %& (*
E F+ 1 %'
' "1 * X
, / ' 1 1 ( F+
+1 + %&*
%' +1 %'
%& + (" %' (1
2 ( %& *
%' +1 %&
P' %' E F %'
1 -
* 3 2 )(1
%' 1 %&1 + 2
FX %'*
%' %' F+ (1 2.
1 +" . E++
) P'1 %' K'*
%' ( %' ,1
+.*
" K'
%' + , / 1 S
%' +* b1 ,
P %' +% -
+F %' +" F +
( *
329
8$ 4 22 ,+#
%& 1 1 %&

%& P ,N
(* 3' " O 2 (%
%' %' I P1 +-+1
F X P -2
F+ X*
E F+ )( = 1 " (
FX%' %& 1 2
1 ++ %' (1 1
" %'*
P/D/
(

" )( 9>4Y + F+
2 ` ( . %'* #=1 +
(1 F+* E %'1
+ ( X%' (
2 1 H
S P' 1 * 3' "
2 ( . %' " . "
X%' ( %& 1 + F
' 1 (+ P' %' F+*
, F1 P' ' 1
X= ` %' %' *
P/H/ , + F + )(*
! FX1 2 ( ' 1
(%' & 1 %' P'
F ' " 2 +' = +
+%' )(*
# +
( - 1 F
%' holdings *
P/P/ 0 %' 1 "
F+ 1 + ( 1
1 , I%'1 + 1 1
%' )(* E F + 3%'1
F%' . %' +
-F1 + GF %' X
1 - 2 %' F 1
330
'
$ %

1 ' ` + '
*
P/^/ I1 %& , F+ F+ ! -
1 1 F+1 2
1 F+1 F* 0
P' %& ! - '1 +
1 1 +1 (1 ( 2 `
. %' X %'* /1 1
2 %& ( + )(*
3 1 %' )(1
+1 +' X
(1 ' F
F 2 '*
^/ - *
0 - 2 ' P
+ + -1 " ` P %' 1
` ' * # P
%' -F %'
%' +%' , (+ *
= + X%1 F
( %' 1 1 (% -2
F+*
+ " 2 -2 -F
%'* b- " 1 ( +%
F +%N
1 %' % . +%'N
* 1
' (+1 +
( 2 X1 +
* " +1 2
F+ 1 +%*
1 1 F F +%
- *
# ( %' 1 & F+ ( *
+% 1 ( F %' '
331
8$ 4 22 ,+#
F1 F - 1 = -

%' ,1 1 1
2 *
=1 1 +' .* 2
" ( F H +
+% N 1 2 1 1 F %'
1 ' - %' ' + 2 68 *
, ' %' %' F
-F +* %' = +%&
*
' %1 (1 2 (
%&*
F%' + = F%'
+ * 3' '1 +1
2 ' " -1
1 1 & %' *
2 & %&1 + ( 1 * R=
F + 2 F F+1 F1 1
F%' P' F 2 1 = F =
%' F + 1
+ %' "*
"1 P
2 *
)( ' 1 P1 2 2
%& FF+1 (= +
"1 %' F*
F+ 1 " -F %' %'
P
%'*
F %& (F+1 - 2 F
1 F F 1
" ( F+ )( 2 1 P1
- FX1 2 ` X F+ *
332
'
$ %

0".

1,
E 31 * ++ H* '
7 ,EK* 9>44* 96Y*
* / ++ . ***
, 37)* <<* ( ,* 9>Z8*
1 )* /* F+ N F `
%' *
* IK3E I %' E++
F+* %' 9>4<7= Z<* ' 1 9>Z:* *
::=Z: LE R1 <M*
1 * 0 E= 5 688 " %'
F *
IK3E I %' E++ F+*
%' 9>4<7Z< ' 1 9>Z:* :=69 LE
R1 <M*
333
A

)+ +% L)M " ,* "1
1 1 , 1 F
' *
, % 689<1 ) F ,H ,%'
)+ L,,) 0!M* 1 & F + (
+ F )+ %& - +
U77**+*7*7)
-
'*
(
0 F + "1 ' + +%'
%' +N -1 += FX
X F )+ = #- ,*
&'(

) % #F+ # L##M F %' J K 3'=
# L=3#M* , % 2 1
1 X * + +
( (. " ' X 1
" ' %*

0 % ( + ' +
+% %'1 '
X*
,3 J , 3 %'

E # %' 2

]=6 1 EI J #, Y8498=>88
R L49M 6868 ;;6Y
,= ^*+*
335
~ @ 5 8:;<=>( ?;@D:?F;=@ :

@?H@IKL
0 + F 2
" ' + I1 2
2 ' 2 (
- + I ( * ,
S G& , =
1 2 * 1
2 + . =
( + 2 =
1 1 -+ ( =
F 1 ' *
< 5 4 > 9
~
0 # F+
2 , 3 %'
L,M1 + + F%'
(%& , +1 + X
( " %'
( F %&* %' +1
1 2 . "
+*
0 !~ 5 ~
~
0 ++ )P
F ,1 %' LM

%'1 PN LM %'
P1 - 2
o #? %' F+
%' %'
%' ,N LM %' P1
F 1 2 (%'1 1 F
1 *N L+M %' ' P1
%' 2 1 + P1 "
+ %' 1 +%' + %' PN X L+M
%& 1 2 X ( "
' (%' F . F+ ,*
2 %& ,1 +
\\\**+*
336
C ~ ~
2 P1 += ' +" (
+ *
37
F %'
#I7#3!
,%
#
KI
R(
I
#,
,=
0
<
'

)[ <8188
4: J 689<
3 + )[ 96188 ,%'
, + 9>>Y )[ Z188
- 5
Z
9Z
6Z
;Z
>
9>
6>
;>
10 11 12 9; 9< 15 94 9Y

20 21 22 6; 6< 25 64 6Y
;8 ;9 ;6 ;; ;< ;: ;4 ;Y
<8
Preo unitrio )[ 98188

LM# ;; L6 + M )[ 68188
Outros
337
=
0 2 %& , ' = ` ,
-= ( #1 ( e %&
% *
0 (
9* 3 .
#% P + %& # R
31 . 948Y=9 # 9Y8*:88=Z1 ( #I #3! F %'
P FX 99<Y8699<896ZZ9ZY*
1 + P #'
2 %' ,*
6* 3 F L\\\***M1 (.
L M
*
3 cR(.d1 2 c # R d*
E + %& *
3 cK ' Xd1 P FX 99<Y8699<896ZZ9ZY*
3 #I7#3!1 #I #3! F %'*
, 1 %' 1 ( (.
*

+ = , #' 2 %'*
;* 3 L M
3 1 %' cR(.d*
3 P 1 %' c# # R d*
, 1 + %& 0Q*
3 P 1
FX 9 P 99<Y8699<896ZZ9Z=Y
FX 6 #I #3! F %'*

%'1 (. *
, + (. #'
2 %' ,*
<* ,+ L M , , 3
%' J #3! 88*46Y*49678889=8>1 K 99<Y861 ' 99<89
:* ,+ ( #1 ) K' L)K M
+ %&* Q c# 2 d - ,3
(%&*
E # %' 2

J ] 6= J Y8498=>88 J 1 EI
R L49M 6868 ;8>4 7 6868 ;8>6 7 6868 ;9Z4 7 6868 ;8Y6 J I L49M 6868 ;9YZ
#3! 88 46Y 49678889=8>
\\\**+* J ^*+*
338

Revista Servico Publico

Cargado por

Información del documento

Derechos de autor

Formatos disponibles

Compartir este documento

Compartir o incrustar documentos

Opciones para compartir

¿Le pareció útil este documento?

¿Este contenido es inapropiado?

Copyright:

Formatos disponibles

Revista Servico Publico

Cargado por

Copyright:

Formatos disponibles

$*

$ %&        %' 

,  ++      -+    

 '    -    

0        +  - 

RSP Revisitada: 3  (   " + +

Misso da Revista do Servio Pblico

      9>Y:79>Z8  9>>879>>;*

I %' , 3      %'  

F F   (     T   (

$ %&        %' 

RSP Revisitada: 3  (   " + +

Jos Carlos Vaz

gF    %  689<* $' X    689<*h

!    "  

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

   1      F+    (  %'  

&  

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

  P   &    %' +      

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

   *   1 #F %'    +   

 +   ++ + (  %'   %&     *

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

3     1  K   1         X

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

   +  F1 += 2  '   ++   (1 2 

#N    , F+1 (   +    "    1 2 

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

  %'    F+   + 1   %'   *

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

K + 2  ++  + 1     +%1

J #(. 3  E   .

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

      !

I1 # * I  #F+     F %'  9>ZZ 

#1 9Y* K  T # E1 6896* +* 9* * 9*

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

*  1     +  +* R %'  

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

Variaes setoriais em arranjos

Alexandre de Avila Gomide

0   F     2  (    -F L  +

gF       689<* $' X    689<*h

Variaes setoriais em arranjos de implementao de programas federais

Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 195-226 abr/jun 2015

Roberto Rocha C. Pires e Alexandre de Avila Gomide

Variaes setoriais em arranjos de implementao de programas federais

 %'    (%&      %' 

$*

$%& %'

, ++ -+

' -

0 + -

RSP Revisitada: 3 ( " ++

9>Y:79>Z8 9>>879>>;*

I %' , 3 %'

F F ( T (

$%& %'

RSP Revisitada: 3 ( " ++

gF % 689<* $' X 689<*h

! "

!

1 F+ ( %'

&

!

P & %' +

!

* 1 #F %' +

+ ++ + ( %' %& *

!

!

!

!

3 1 K 1 X

!

+ F1 += 2 ' ++ (1 2

#N , F+1 ( + " 1 2

!

%' F+ + 1 %' *

!

K + 2 ++ +1 +%1

J #(. 3 E .

!

I1 #* I #F+ F %' 9>ZZ

#1 9Y* K T # E1 6896* +* 9* * 9*

* 1 + +* R %'

0 F 2 ( -F L +

gF 689<* $' X 689<*h

%' (%& %'

+% %' (H1 %&

+% X %&

%& ( (.=

%& 1 +* %'

XF ++ (. %' "

F -F %' + I F "Z*

G' 2 & J FX%' X %&

% 688> F+

% 68991 F ` F

# 688<1 F+

) 688Y1 2 #1

) = 1

% 688<1 + %'

0 ( 68991 P

F+ F

I ,%' P L689<M*

%' 3 L/

G L 2 P' %' M 1 1

1 1 %& +

;* #%' + L#,3R)M1 1 %'

I ,%' P*

1 ` +-+

(F+ F%' + 1

I ,%' P*

(P 1 + %&

= %' -

P X %' (P

I ,%' P*

bP X F I,E9)R8#,3R)8 I,E9)R9#,3R)9*

=1 1 %' X %&

L3M L/#/$1IM

R= (P * 3 (P

2 %' F 2 F 2 ' (

bP X I,E9)R8#,3R)8 I,E9)R9#,3R)9*