cho nape ects ed we tte pc il cl Js how bel nd hp Th ines pb oe rf i, iy of tpg li dpe tay Ch Me Pama Dar a | 009) Tr Chisptere Fan 0) ihr an Apes of eat "hay Len Monon ie ot 50) Ethnographies and Archaeologies Iterations of the Past Edited by Lena Mortensen and Julie Hollowell msc hms Mami Jaen FeMhen. Seu 2009‘The Ruins of Ruins ‘On the Preservation and Destruction of Historical Sites in Norchern Argentina In May 205, while ding elton th ae ofthe Ande i wore ‘renting Lan sh in fa a Bain de alben miso oad bth ois thon oth one ee ofthe Gia Chic pin Alba man ins inane an tok the pie, ig efor bow an hour daw 2 nding ail carve hgh crs Awe walled, he wollen ies {oie cnn cll shes ered othe hat a Cai pit Sean he suing ill, she vumor ices ard ney ad the Fotone gs bee shal pop ha gael te dca. On Fl sing th nego icra the peti ws in ame, Ta ‘soe by br the bpd vege axed wih de congue of the Chae tha woul enc the gan Thief theca was sou about een es igh and sar an ney goedonitio, A dor on the eight al Teli snl won anak rat ya ean, Wels sinectvledon sone of th wall and tra esl peli ue anche mh ‘Ae expr hs ie ad ok phason epi bow ol the ae look "Anes ned jem” herpes ics kh she pla was ven arta ben bh inh ight ery eed and oie gap sowing nat ha es ee ac ene “Tat Ue a {eaturdd yus ol Ths ple vera Toma i fin cet he pod tthe sac me deating he side dor igh an pac wih 1 pif sc lS” he i He ph agua aot beck "Lok ship ll ol Ales eed year Tee bacon olen as aaa abo 0p fi fr ding ha cel se | Token vc seared on the evo ance doco hat ws damaging anneal isos i sed ‘hep ws pd by my acon spc by he ion of he [peat euneewaen sy vow hc iy ani stenting FE uosson at te stapyd ete ning ary neha pe waren ocx en hough asa theta ond ‘Re sniy wis pas al ie ly ew heey aie rece pcos eu i for be wore om the cae anh ich (hence a king fer the a ha rane os ores. Thine tod me gin opr esl quent vac ene of lie an (Tp meory he eid the xing set-in ies hat ec he “Tessa ape arg ors sealing tha pls ‘oui views thst pple prac he aid of cadens? Wha sew be pas es sid J ming clad ot he pal desis of sn Tike cuter Leaploe doe stan by dav ony work this oer ety sis nthe pn of Sal, she ego we he Jaren Frcs eal “Slat downto the Arca oil to fhe Gran Chace tmp Loma these fh Babe inion with he ‘Rian tbeevenacenry te of Ee ced aba sy oes 6 “Grouse anfconeat al oop expan of he with ha of fea and sedan pv sling ih nope eton akerason of tha ce pyle, The conte elt on contin ew fhe (pul ot memory on heel amigo te cons af "a the pradones pon by she inguin: ha by he pail eeton its hat ae ay ste Sst se comporan fh a tne exe to be prec? How Ruin Preservation and the “Willeo Remember” ‘Many aor fave a hi the cre gasption wih ri sn hi pct ely ne pc of tderni—in par, of ee ie [Peasant an util ps he nett cetry Dia 204 are feces pti 0 onan Cc sig ois or centri th ery rig rapes oi papain, sate bythe prongs we fhe meow ‘Rawat oman frum ssa id (Woodard 200, Braking wih his ‘Mite move marine aly proc i sess swan py ‘Rue of din, an she ner Became sex a sf coterplaivn sua Tuma, deni ar knowksg Sate asc in partials ae wana Wood 200) I recnaton nd Det eur Se eNohow Anina2 ev nme! we Peat een, ih 2 prey rng gt uno hep pean, pe Shc meg Sine eng Ph et fom be tne Co dil ps pl vegc ed [Sd Ray eh ant i om hts om nyse sd i sn ocr is pani “mn ote pd nl lon oo templasion or ven worship.” i. bia nethr wns oa hppa thera of heen ale sativa sory This proces ing cing ‘hee plc seg them rm the pate lial plato an long om hese pcs heathy of ate ee a aces, ply acacia {dwar This hry dans mh fi ce om the bling af nna ‘vic appepsaton of ine storach a the pin, wiped wold, sing risa oes of easton maaan Ting” "enact The acalenic kml tt rere hae ie in er woth highligh ly ehealloged grace or dread projected et he pple hing. ae ho Cray any aback hve deed themselves rm he mo hh sale pons and now ekg with oo pps, ply a cones whee these a queion ae plicly carla algo aim thority ovr sha cha io many pus of Noh Anes Ye acho ‘ech ema bed on the ee te pesado damage. hepa inp see ses souk Tes impr ot, herr ht he meaning and pa he cons a ction” hive be sou feb Many pen pot and wes veal ais oto mh forcing row abou hepa ut ing sours cntnpiton or pen: hy hae ben dee un pat ‘hehanun expec in pepe i ela oh netgear nd sory a elec depending on thor wpe, te om the gly oe ele: gander histor pots (Wooded 201 vote fhe amuse prance ici ate and ale emp to “proee thee ‘ies osama ih hiorgn yt an ane ime oa ha aca hss hase ssl mdi. shen undermine: tho spac. Chior ‘Woohand ha alo ties, a cig fri ing tem of seq nd puri ouring de, hugs and oficial hve pd nel cold plas dei of myer. Thus, whet in the latent, the over is ofthe Ron Cum spi El poss ad ue tebe asthe me mont aos in Europea dd ante Cle fone” (Woseand 201 3 “Ths moa fale gnc ans an be tid fbn vic and eto long ora ie when pas nan Eup ‘onside he Roan une step, inate as. Ys one “hook not hth iw sl fm toured ip modest sete. Max Pog (200) as pid ut a Woodware “uns'—an, Feld a the ‘aman scion wih owegw asses macho he wrk of wrcatos ‘ruchacigiand he bs ction of plc cont fui. Haman aang sos in che hae nt unpre separate ours bat ve ‘Sacned a mere ah her ice Rig! 93 3: More port Se “tes para eon sbtaly paseriothe rans ae with “Teel sept ew of the tain fuser tan yaa day” [eS Soa ae snenn very wll deartin of manus son Fallon are” Rig 8:2) Toe flog extn il daw ote views an presente uae othe spin of pipe ing er aan te anes cr pom who afr dem pas cla poor al inden of een ‘Rekgeund cl in rier Agena Becae of his gan hen ‘efi, many eile etme tacos (obo) Se ofthe a ll ris Game of wal ane ects! and elon the br i ‘Mai, bt mst ly a wap aon wh in some as am a ew hea ‘ite eda mie oem th tnd wh hey ve Fac he mast par Ay wok ihe cae an aclu fc ms hat dont he eo ane, Th dane by debuff he cla ions in Soak Ae ‘See aie he ele fr al misons one uo ue thc inkgenus pope of the Chae atin ily ope ely a oes [A fem atom protean wary cao theway plac a ot ace ple on And oe fda ding, Ee he mt rin a) ae ben tardy st ie ine ts feu hi sino i alae he at prominent of ssi se, and dese an ution and eons van i sg oigveon a2 "in” New ea mice oe ei sion a Balbuen cour othe ws wich ‘Selle tary lt sme fhe ui he te, el ton, flestom eiig fre anon the cntaing 295 [aw on bok inhi een aoe pre ee sl memocco 2003 ‘Whe ithe othe Span bea coogi what i oar wohwonern Ayes dhe Salado Rie cae one gogapy paring che Spa tert nthe Andean highlands fom de Gan Chico, which eta wad ‘hes oF ndgrous ups. a 566, Spo ops ound ei er he sumo Ftc, tte ately dep the Chic pli nal top (ocr he oa Dou Eo became acento cheep of hands ‘igen bre ough mare ere) tons ec the we "only psd rote a yt end fhe sem centr th main ade hal shed slr a he Ande tn os i a dopa are de ‘ida some sn thunder the wet the oo fr ou ts gos Thee. became eo he ast ts what oy eter Agena Howe penn atch she even igh af aber bce monica, ad cami naguaton cebu wo gaa ede, wl ‘hgue i 9: dete uch of thet ad mare abut aa amet (Pana Tomasi and loss 204 Toe Revel 94) Teper, pcm dwg shot dhe it of Et hae lng Ben wl Laon neem Agena They el he sory an een ch oe ne Ioseses te mae ok and people woe aoa aa thes This srry of cme wei The inn of Ears wre ih and pod the les es ht God pase the by casing he eau ea espe he ty np At oul oh cata, Enc od a et, append, 2 em hat seus the pron het hey aisha, ein bend 990 ‘ashe ui butane proce pine ame Ec pce some byt we and thes arrogance war along ime eightee y he tele myery of sxc leon, wich cma oly y the na of {all sbarona rn staon hese ew Kilometre then of a, he In May 205 anv in Mia seuching forthe tcf Em Thi town a ‘x aa it yc downing ad pination hes gay he 1974-85 ary Stasi Spee st te 1908 By the aig of Und of ‘orkr employe inthe fear ay. Asolo wrth Severn Aetna tener of he atonal anon 201-2 employes prey meebo ampuns Howe foun at thom ‘he nos for bate nes charred ly sm pbl-str employment sn party sng, On yn dey hs man i fm ay Sores mar hiding hes hee “The be and of ply” (avon ee Ths oot for ut prea be expen of ddine ours, cme patil Siting Sor pon ht etree a all ‘alo all fom ga ta pit pial af chs ‘When Fan Matin abs Enc, cy kw delat i cre a subeien deionised Ke wear 50 much een but a ‘sv ic, er many ete ana non and poi wrong i tural eu ede in eon fhe ame name Ea ter propel me That mui Eaton eh na patholo nore chat 0 liomete he nar ot fa i of eile Ri Pas ee Jaca Rist ‘fw diy ae an Ro Ped. fr ing sve people geting ston sho ed odin ling it ra. On ain a “lor of hows, psn eon the arm ae Fs. The fc nonin ral aly "No pole” He pine as and ad “ine lms yon on sh ih se ha Tats Estes I seat, ay Sy. Whe av a he st abd poo fhe 1 le ha (he hg lana ok sey tenable and dow of hitcal raei ‘wade eed aes iy car saree by ef us. ‘Tham wa counterpoint oe poe tha dominated Me, Ki Feds nd theo the eon Thee sade pics fhe spo bad egeed boom a fspuneed husnooe i mune Sal, bed on pier ca ‘ha of anbeany si an whe Bos Theale ahs hha doin ‘heen aap since he ica em wl ang cae ined tres wre cling vain open els sach mth oe wa wag om Tet ve yong nn wo work th fr at wer eying ti a of seaning ine tan We gan wing ang the oot pete and king {ous sind de in he yo a) hich they cw asthe: bon a Sol che were le seated eh rout ound eines ts tec sme all we Se ches og bul with dts re one at Irole em dot eo she ma Drench y the aa, we ben ihingand Comparing pes One of ms cman, Cae emer dha hy ha Be earthly poring mies hha pre he es for es plating, “hermoe we lol athe psf es and ale abot vate moe a aw othe ft ow ees ay dhe wn of thse eof lig de Syed enue Th ance hat ad ily eked he ome ‘etcemaping in on ny ee ies ny sibel he ane Til at he igh fd fm acter a Tugs oy companions sha we eal gsr she intro oth fro. They sem way at Bist ren hough dy wet not fn dhe ae Dus Sago del Ec they cad me thoy be a or ol pple tou th case hating Esco and tan nd Drs Hcl Sie ahr Asin 35tho who need he ost, Bas i dl atm lng change hi ns, posta psy my owe cay We i owed wha seme be al Sasson bean walling wt dur dhrough deme enrages fee ine and eu cing weve om te ain acct othe ge. Th woe mate ben ls the ground, a ick lie of pla nd wd [Ave daly de or wy dhugh deen Besa mach eign ‘found ule cling and docening step mounds We sul dings ‘tha seemed be the lyons fod se: ong stsgh deren surounded by mend nthe The fat uly eae + ile plone sn aren of tre bt ren verre the ofan eo hy On 1a oem dog ee eae tr wh oe the cn, Pal need tne fogs ech fhe che of Ea Ar pun, Mari, my ober companion comple joking invoke ne memo of wah He st ont lg of one athe mous pretend ose somthing in te dstane and ste "Ga (Gold Weal ad gu ag a agh e old o ecape he sing reece foe et hortng tht pl ‘We wanda tht inate space for oe an hoa al soaking Weta es sre the ute le ofthe fe a pi ound ores ts ed. (Cor and Mario vita mew dik mate ens cap, vo lose a. snd fan borer siting yee inning to rr boa Exec or thir cape cn mn rom the ee sic amd Re, He me ‘ed toca we a cnn Esc a lens app nr a fe und, the tet he ol Many pole ae aa of eign hers” hes Heol boars wore who yas cathe, ad abandoned cor hel ofthe oes and msi dapper, Pople thet he baler been lle by Este of ound teu wept eo hat oe ev. la lt abuse ghost ne et have sean wing inthe ring ee he ie mincing he oof ne, sand shout he wove et wade ee and deny pp ed Pes nha the ew im nce ho ugh the fc 3000, gh of he fea whehrbe way dean it plan mate cn Hs og ene elie hi Pao ad. Car aed: esa bes oing ete i keh. ele rod doo ie working the” pene stl ayn he ne, ly oR Pe and tun 6 Bao 4 fee ds, Mo pope ro he hyo atc athe emia the pn plendor of whole and pind out ha iets deracon iets the ric ata ini wth and inna Indra Ing hat cont they were ring lat hat afer be uae the ona center of powe a wah hie eomand Ska hen, the allo of the ‘Aes an hath anemia er ean she sak i lave aivin, “Ted Et and he saben of al hi loom er a ren prpins aout sean mara he n,n ewe ‘ny he cmployen pve yd ava a emparaycunteet ‘On leing Ri Pn odo Bonk father et in ee ris of Balhae ae wth he imprint he usiewisle reais of Esc ced 2 rena plipson with capi pes of gaan pacing and wih Feo grapes of paver, mp amon wha ho pcs shaped ach ‘oi in nfl was parla he high lee uenlomens hat, back then mat the xp ma people ling chee Seemed highlight the wel paged on Esco And ear ese of aie care wea ‘enh eing os sha era he emo Etec pas gry Yet on fay meat haere of prety moulin ews Fate arr (nda eat me—anerpcel Etec, 2005 In July 2005, {sun a Arginine or eto de en ‘Each sein fy aaa Mei, et a anions Fm my revi ip whe exis, ice hhc cach ee ea Inet) ah me, "Da yo what happened Ee? ant. “The Fa owner so blo Kwan tea ad i he popes: Tianna nly ow mom ag He al fur i abr th eaten the daa, So did ot now wha co make of th ew, ws ani vie Etec se et ving bac ar noe hen ca each ew othe in eine psi me “Ruin of Ee ine ead aie 2 abun, ‘Si para daly. The damage othe sie abot an iepure (ET Tb, Fabry 0) aur nd dep. Te memories my | She stew ya eur he Has fy ike hough tor el es haya app gone soit deen meaning The net morning. Ive nih ee a The newsupr ais dd no fay pope wha aT fe shal expe a eich a ch song poses she mi of ha se ex any The Wes pan {nd woe pont arte helt a beh ld up in nel ied lie paral oe ae sympa mpc dare by ‘hematoma oof the eas ha th em adaseion had bgt ‘pth oe of Etec, edt bre ce of what bal ce Ben dhe ‘aking pues a cnoing ny ery of ha same place with he and Pretend Din of ual sian Aaspe war chen wneuig. The aposing ofthe sens station ht ond uc ha unearth coud pes of an ks The us Ha mle hough oo ar cae meres weil cee. nase destin at ‘ce vibe wha up aml esha bes es ia the misleading naan ‘fac gen oe: thug Loto big anno ane om ‘pnd the igh of dy Tr comempling the mace of auc rm he tp fhe igh ms Need oe en il ngreion eno years eid ee el nd hie ce of Ute wou somehow op dhe epesoa of ped fa ‘ali nt it The beth sirundedn as p af how wrong Ts abe role had al bee ao Hele et Hes i a aur at wal ae he Sica omer lee heh een hough the st wan st opt ss not under hoc prion of sae pci. "ether, oon a diel cr eyes fare bu fafa plan nt rary 2005, sea balla eon working sea the ok ad bythe fin da af Fea the caring ha Bon lon Completed fe theta he ri lear fr he Meta diss he Ilona ork ie ving he paved ad ht pac ow hun te south ft ste Being om tenet ove of EI Calp he eta ee ‘ng lee wa thelr of Ea He nde ser ication in che Metin ours. and je nr she demo ei abd ty ter aration cf the sie np Ba wo ie The nes the dears he Ec ‘aimee ite median the prvi. ‘A ote ine fh id wn ht ge Eo pb pail rede vil Despite Execs ae hugo Sa fw ppl at hr ofthe provi ad Laon where aly es pew Nom toate ‘er unambiguous Weel or a wider pub patna a elo Seleosinn, Mere gor, he balling cel genera upto ‘he scenic commana among ener he poll and pla ‘en pve yrs some ofthe ad ped fo imi temps to roe the cen he Sal gist had ere he te provi pat ‘mony an i o004 sec cn be ache Univers de La Plata an greene withthe provi preament an xl nick de aha Ippo eon sand ker hora ss as ven chugh ahs ad ied bat sree werk odes the acer sensed within the rp of he fins owner athe ing ha cael nied pen ot Encino The can bind the aes a eon snd ocach wes nt aubig: dmayed the now othe ting, Aen dae afc iste th i an, she mot oma Hora vig Mein pre “k naa esa elo for Sa forthe whole oun” Ue the ahaa the Une de La Plata who al weet Ets dele toche malin "Torey appl I smathing bri, erable, compen ‘haf baal (Tb, Febery 203 “he fics ont wat says an ge of ei, He wan asl of falowing spy conor quaniatneaoaly indieet wo th hit: qlee of pce, one cok! ange ha he ac of ing blr ri Ene snore byte lap of wha Hen Lee 9h alld “osc sph emi pe fap, fe af theca ind pus mcanings th for Late eid he slate ce ofr “och Yn in th lt coe ht wee cia of he bling his cof {ea ew mucha hoy bream comic ana iw pes ‘tris clea ssi aan ey sine at comnosing ‘hemo goeiph ‘When sh pases rm El Gp wed Exec asi anager one ang eer by mente ofthe Chante of Tourism of Souler Sa and th suey fc and or of E Glyn (bn Febuaty oy) a, pao he ti ofthe ling eee ou the oreo ie suchas Ete merits The poi of aki one of Ther popular sve donating Agena, yt the sos moran co eis aloe nce valleys and highland oh Ane he oad of Man oH Galpin a lows no sos om thes pve an ae the ps ew {eam the mnie of he ae an gun cent lls wo change shi Sin his ancl the promos of hese sae nthe aa inborn on map nd alee nog eye on pia ands Iona so mie thee pen the bi ro ha a0 tre a no sige pana sc eh Alou aed wih the inguigr ofhawsprinony. and doit tee onan hee reps ‘inl the nee by ome nial a atr oinpne thse ais a ‘mnsoivion and te manasa pn aow'hae ben eon thi a. Tn de conic th nie etd wih she fan awsome oi sland academia hatha happened the "gna! ad “dries” {theo popultin she which a or grasa forthe acon of Iago ts he anus se eter a hat though th bl Aoningot Esse wasn ands king, ie potsmathing ne bur | ‘avon sche damage cs by acl ts (Tn, ebony {on Thorn based Mein carl Ta. "The lof at hiretry of lar gsopl om Sa hs odo wih the ee concen cat sneha frou pnt These noble dination al ack fee ming ‘hoe (Hoban ebay 7320 ‘Sime fis ch sce invling he prorat ofthe hi son the gon A few bate ah of EI Galpin lg on lan abe all ma what maa of he rancan min fa lg de Misr M-Sat people athe ae singly all man he i sin, Det being cl rer oar od inthe a fi ead reine itac m anlpocenin o amreonie he allege proc athe ea ‘hecaty son of he prog un of EI Gale Sa Fanci Solan. a 00 atau bathe ppd in Ean We hike ben hoe, nc fhe ole now a erated wth ay sala ag Ta ing (ccm seman the tps ou cove Hy beings pra ‘Wel aig how thea Exe a hte eee he See ation ofthe man bee ofthe cco einen of te procanon pin Pie ty ya ge. "pope we 1 that aon a cate ack nth poe ck wiha des Tais hy ool dared Bac people ‘oat le back vt on ee fo deh mae ex And thats ow wa sory dowry People igonnce mate them ety things ta ve ‘ornou vals” A appa hol se pps ppp ie ‘tough intl cera pis a nnety devracive-In mkingeeace e> ‘hoe prs ino snertonau hlldingal Esco, ew ie may te ting he eo of inc me within Bode lol at oF gad or te with hora As pr hi dicount commen Id cha aa i lege gran, oriay pple nthe ein had emai ay nine 2 Set hal ppd wih se ded, vied Mein ow man er ie seating, tot ole sel hae one ou wa mt pid ‘orth ac te Ens hs aay en aay Jao mot iano ‘histowr, Bat ha ily as hac lo Pee, eco he hinge wold eet inary people wou shat ‘ome he consenaton okie media and ee bulbocng derive sppopeutn of wha wars curly dens mare fla ey ln Rio Pes However | enn pert indtece about the fl ofthe ceing Unibet indcrens hencunerdia Metin, hice va plc thee is psi people hw wl Dig man ti fren a myc acquit in Ro Pes ws he fw poor Ile tou he nen ving the eng, canal a, oly when psi wih my ui, he gel hat hr cull be “onnetan awa th ce of Eat and be decon wo tp the boing He Tul me, “he peter cate poems fod omnes cae they de an ho cy thar lc aise ha ple ued They wane bem (© Teich ie hat” Fr Dig "the nine ape ceri at Bese tke isa alc ofthe br Bsa ube chang tr wad, be pojetel ot sate oie she api thn many cll uct with he a dated ple tat shoul! be hundred Ye war ear 0 me ‘hats cominens epson er apa che dcsion a Whe eernen ‘or ondematon he fis owae: saad ned dstancing sa bor {Ted indieonr ebro ip the tf the ering on hoe tna 0 Enc a le dnl ios sod peal meri. A {hy ad i or ay ye gh ea "he cy in camp fr pope Trsking athe ich and a nthe sc” ad “te moa” cares ies, [owursumraton pps hel! means in tr abot cad fe pit ska whether antl ear i sing zm peo sone tows Esan Lad yo. He othe oe i tar lad isda a pat Thea at he ing Lagi ith loc ops A dappeaed ale own “Tat ee war it (God pt pon ‘he gucho wa ohne Web aang ares Wah pot hone And stig i Bus th cane avd Heaven pid ‘por of Ea, Wet kaon what prayer Ay por io Ene Tei know wht Go wtcol ip asacating the is which ak the Esc ange 1632, with he donc ofthe in of Eco haha jun pla in 0051 abo echt he wa ling pata ween ch in abou he aparince ‘of Ec bso ithe denon vo eh ed dhe ul of emis cate of ina atempt 0 maim rn Ba om eid ae shiva om, naicoepston Dig singing let vk nes mach ‘he mounds al by he eating but ton da ad Bon dered ve de andl yarsearer The seme tan pa” eam by ose icmp ancl for neritic ad wana withthe wn Ths analysed np or Exec po cy fea" and people, rember sch” ike he ele in Ko dw regi {teh arate, The sete of on hove rt the rata of Ex, me a he more eal by cure cno of poe wi recy what aed ple tobe lacy niet the ny af hve neon mui ted stand he do a conta Among xe xl prope lh air wih Etec th singin ace de blog a something he ke fhe don by “he fovea” a pret the anf ra ung he epg pli (none of tbe muy cca ve rm Rl Pde Ex, tp ha vis partie muna ployee who was cleting bases by the a Hi te wat Haren eel py lk oe Wh sei sb ch allsng i Ea and abut pps stn, esha “ple he hae mtn ta do wih ha the lacing. That ebler ews team nhc onemnent” A fw ds tr wale gain eae ite ye ad Thine be was mote open ak ito tee os prev ia thet peopl add nothing abe een an ea "Peg ee ‘sl moshing case he frm twig ie j= The pu etwas we wove hapy base ofthe bs hs wall Bog, Be sre shea are fm ate si thal acs a hen big” The more asked sud, the more I detec ube yt pte che of fran on hes fa ou of Ball eel. Tis se aha inca ‘he Wich sng iE Gali onc fhe ow pope wb ey indie tin hha nce eke oir ey “wl Ins” nh are shore oer negro Gaps, Ul with Arua ation, lcm nhs ents nd member af Petcare, aout the ing ch He ld ire Al Ose erent arnt rut ee dt wat ha pop ae ip penn roo Bon Acme Bagh he fa That an ras spin she py in Mein rt pin and ceo buy ‘het Bah Bagh ei hey dd el thar was Ee ‘hake ad bon ye Many ol aun ce wk ei ep go oer tbo to are tina monies [pics fm aul ere we nk bce yh rd hy ce saying “Ths ws Enscn” er oad yeas neti yd raed Noone cor "We gig to psec hte Wie ing pat ie ce, We ae kt hi lie” They ol oy a nom ae theese, Ara ply tsi th al pic ic by asia Feige ‘ene pope ang nny om etn sf Busnes fom ae pes Ths je cir er would unr the tons of pone ‘hugh wich lal polican ee pole depends on sem, Bat he st hed what he the ypc of ove who foro lag thsi ea) bal done nothing rot Enc aiken nly men Bay need job wort ir thai and fa que a, opinions ach his woul rob 284 enim thir pot: da onary pope he ion gore the her alu ri and ht his el concep cla dane the oor wh ca append plac” val, each vw woul nea the oppo te f saree sch this which eg nf 3 wel Inf senso al "at" br hough ical engagement with ag ‘mon: posi and dix Lik ihe pean gatas ce ent id in epi ion with pe of har orn, se cal ate ae prc hgh onic ng fren cs expriens atd tns | Sse Father, th conn fre ds ea hat al aber tn nesshursighes pu wlan ew fips anata oi hori sd cual dimes The people ate wll au of the weigh of tale Sire apron oe places on othr ihe eran oon ice "es brash the sip of choos ney om sinker of rina fr. Te sbi and ll tors nthe wont tine hy 2 atte the pe tone habe pea he oil pogo ‘hs pti sie counter thevertao f rui hasee ci and sexdemic ature he nde meat of hail comcionon Tis Ie habs thie poe ground dependent the cw ha pas ha ave lng en abana ad are semidseyed alt be psc reer npc i his surpton ar pir ao nbd ot wad hy ng haa arenas moh pouting and de shel of mati sales dc neuter hat soi ect and he dg Faso hoy. Ake allt Dg reminded ne in bisa, Eo hal bee syed venting Tae blac upring ce and he id change Rains and Dastaning ‘hy ap been academia lew frais eral not xiv hie sca any sath ve ote laren nth ato the worl ce Brg ths: Cid 997 Rage 00; Wie 3009 Wao the freuen etc ath sta oer th eprint mer xs camp anh of the olny people wove ey and seit m pr od eve lance: Tee uy nthe dee pon bcind she ctemati e shales she with oan ah hey mean harm Our memes ae ‘aera tect park and sate rear Whether we ee m8 the bea ites bawme part ofa ery hee ining out a peas eth, eding out dra, Bus we che tha hc wd pla ‘eis sce lyn dhe pdt beeen rand aule, bees pan our pot, These rie tsb power ner pr tree at em bce me a ket plage 0 men. Fr hose who all Ace th ame he ay bn tht le ve ay ns al cores area aly in he eer age fe Pee, burial aly Noung py 8A epi aed) This comet hewn te expr foe pope md wt og cl nc tour dist ean ca pls ch usc aol abe pred, ‘Spell incu in hich be conamerton goaded athe come pai ‘stent pain tele and oi eng, Hat the venation of ema ‘erin mpi» dtacinghat is ly icy howe who epic those ie ‘pura idly or oat pple ing ea Ee, a eed. Irma lands fpovey and unemployment ia wich joy arma po ington he vow dha mounds pe of ren bri nde sould a int, The al poli and fi who oppne he ean ay alo hea bee ca expec ely Sane te he isan waking space As Ais ig! gh 43 ot. "Only wera oe which we en ne $e enjoyed ete Fm he standpoint faa whee which ae sil] fl impo ich pre ontemlaton” Th contre dancing end ‘an 9) hale thee nea’ af hep oie, sconce te ds et brat but hi cps nck of wha a bea ny dics. The encanta abe es them obj: who ale cme materi rate than as the ation filly they acl An his ea prospon grounded in purr clas cla Lid tia expense daly pation rom hve ats ‘Ae have see, loa pe aon he ff he it of ae dee ro mean ht te later tango ni clleve memory an sens of ‘ety eis ean impr ie fe ane serember though tas reseed inc in space, Fr gents. pple Rio Pras and EL Calpn Fela wo the sae ooh yi pace no on dough ir work on the tambo sa ic ch fr orem vale bets ris wd ‘Scomtacon mati pecan, ito aac hat ou Bd Costin pain num that many athe dia ol all oe tng” Bat ica poi mt tig he appropiate hy triay peopled nt neces ad tc doucton Anh ae eck thera fhe fe et mision of Bac “The Charchof La Manga When oe vis the hash a Bulbs 20051 prec ye wl pred ya Thacnsuson dee rt the n-igeet cent when the Spi we onli sonal net he oe fer the setbacks ty the deni of Eo, Su a ana de lbs wane of te Son ass tha he oul fideo he elk Re be Fas 94) When the Crow ell he Jot fo ein 67 ho sion ed {esd of dee unite magento he Fan nde gua os fn shlan adnan. Byte ely ince centr illowing he was of indepen fom Spit nt fo sit been sano “Gn yf st sh ins of Blan lane ht" huh hat survive set ay oon simply baie of eave baton ina ou the nay sparsely popu plas covered by age tac foes. Yet so learn shar the bing hal pe spl ca on Hs own Ft, Upc ha Jean al eveyone hn he aa ek Be ae a ele de Le Mang he hush a angi he cso which ete he name of the Jenn non and of he fre ue cnt had Be psd mt he reatox hamlet, Balen, inate ow ht he sto he main pave fan Bot no one male a tortion etn the ame “Baloo” and he ruins {1 La Mang, Seon | ered hat oa cle he pl "ve crc” not Simply bese trembled one bur base ha ee ean he mtian pt ope ithe spe ht a ci she wa ae Cotkerh eect wih a al yt me os {Leta mars and ho ior esl One Sanu ed no ew ing ae he Sich allay on don mag Ones yon lin heed ‘smn sl wc nhc ed eroding ce Sse Roer Sr oh ptm ina ha st ho mags ‘ve len ton peso, Tht mph. ped ma ded In dk aman te sash ws stage aon et ha tr a ll me won my a et ope shan fo sy tvs a exo when linge hac ‘Shunt hes Sa os be Vi conned re ‘ea thy ne od or ed me vy ome ‘8 tun igh mg homage wel ee oo a ‘nid he snide hh an a role men hi ah ‘inl pin oe Aso pop hres ld ‘igi pking cameo an ods wo he a hh ‘ame ning and cee mene neta iy ca lie po ai uy pop ne may sharon uit sont Hance ee peared ‘Sh ch uncle pen, aie hp ten Chinen ft gi ora nd lig ep torment ane oi roped ily {oad candi dpe bg eden ve tae nce oda ose wrap cy rt ih el pices i ee Syn Sug chr! ead pcan xh oh ten sin yc ei pia A La Me {Gyo rh ponte be an ofan cma ou ee, ‘tort ahr ye ney Chitin anc sh se ‘ole pina tn sh church ws og al ye he fou andi mae Sh a ewes ese ch ut ca tei going tay dhe a a he oie ley eed prot, No th he ren Ls Manga are ‘an tein sch le ee ‘aya ih cn Te rt Sanna abn bce ‘Keio he arch a Mang nen wold sn Be sh aides hg ih mac bu eal pple no aed pee thar raul bing xtc by the sarong fst. Sm in a howe depo ete oie i of jo nocd wih te snl cla lceations. Tis eas me wo 2 fut ‘Se beeen ul ara asec. fou coverations about isch” evening ood Blbuen i nea proto the 80 he pe rot {eu ww atid on x pp ack th ole oir and 0k wy the sm ‘eit been arg fom ple rene th uisand were bs he hig out min, sop nid ean orig and aco of {har eene sted man ise Mat hen ofthe man who ad “nn! eth shah i aps el eas He el apron ‘Calc fom te us of Balbus bal be rounded y oral [rsh malin th ae, hws asco who sen ach fh ve rehckand working with cal, Maran ass man ew works bu conten (har be bls a la Manga ding he ada pes lm a He Teele din sing the ris ad he ple ern eaking the el aay he ‘asd fri shaun oop tem Hi fewer reset i fo ‘evn he pole e emo ee he gh keh” and ‘Sime ha ty wee aking he el ay ec dey were oo alse be Leper, in ihe idl of ube” Cre ane nearer ‘heme ons hnaws whe he alle Up tl he ssc tho a teenprocve aly wiht the nena of tate acta an sone wo run wk the flay wens el are” aie with he sate nth Cable Chch, Cosi is a someting eo whee ‘Avil Ano she hoor of Epes colonia (an frac a abo tea havry of the ttespnsened appropri oF aja weed 2 fo econ falas “Teak ofthe ina Balboes pons ame dens fom and pris ssid hs Ess, cont ca, ny pl ing au eh ar [OF Baboon adm maby ww abo se eis of hs ie mision [And wes the in of Fo ae yo ned win a oh of pit tata grins sh of Bika arom 3a arm cave ih ess nd cd on the bor prac ot nce hac th pian a whos de ener lr who hs undo hea, ince Ee che Fp ote nthe chr La Mang de aoc phys esis with ‘een and do ut pala asion ich pastored {ine er sme thd tha ain aac woud probly nt Siow ls wn yy ss hata bs en ds prac ae enti ecru and eas of Hil tsi Naren Agia $7This tke cack whe dees uu anbaelgil preration an | ie xan conepal plone dying wha ale paral “The Rains of Ruins Sipura: 78 once set ha "hire deen ther presmaton the detacon a mgt ma ay fining sa sal team du up” Fe ote wand evening Ht the geen ily a ott by wong de ons oduct amy fom nace pees Jobe Rsk 6 145) ape athe cn sean thle tan which bldg an ars dercon tof which no ena cane eter: dori compa with ke dep she hig dere DD not tus dee ounce sth mptne te mpl imp slew abe he dea ee anything thas baer ben et besa ‘natch Cerin the odio prac by run icing the alles gl ate of he and ence eal acd cha hs aon tee dette Butane” Yer ne soul conse Kal Mars ‘ring that pralucion at comumysn while sea pte sie rmoencat 0 which roan pli the coupon and treet de seracton, of a mails abd mens of pico Ge Mae 970 {moka that dip dome pton stl the undening fy peal me on Ma Page 9) hs asad dain che work of ph Schmpse he "eave dota” cha scarcer be palin of Marhaba en the lens deutian oft pr cape and spl cain Ye ‘hei could eal hain plas ih NewYork Cir La Anges kin oy stl ase hae Bearcat ama ths pee at wah in ay Tae of he ene gly hui ofthe Jaren Sa ie in the tchawlgial ad bats ugar of the Apetinean an ine 2sadomy estoaon mak them anne the pt ocean des hasbeen minima Yas tl: th elegy of pre ain ral emg In rep ara, pel er he inden Ex a 2 In dive rates ‘deri fram when nein telnet hia legs ogi ono, ain tha woul a hem a difere vel,F, she damage cold undermine the ait of pele understand socal narintion af theca in th pt and he the apace strato wk esd wi ‘erm ihm, Yr roponent of hn ve woukl ao age sat somabing dep isa ea ha ich deo deve desl hkl and ae thes aur un a bling Jot Fl shard prods of human bo Ieper por doers sar makes some es pericllygrand and ‘sce ye (i 6) angel hain oder peak ian tocol ameter one th power of ae mn have mie wer tou nother of mere ate” I 9, Reg 82-39 wrt ae ing simi guion, “spol i way haus pear mote argue the more amd th ste af deny. OF core ss pros hs i ‘Whe fly ning ean he he ft ashe comply Ashes pile {rch original fr, tha andor, wher abe lane ees otc thi arg eto Ina dao thors ge th whe in is eared the pif coming" rable” ern coe be rain fling Regen tng it cet cove neve ew chr Tis popes. ich phe salon he ps arf het Be abel pray ‘ong inthe humans ation hace ts! etc componen. ANIA "cls cont he nace Yom ep fra 0 pe {ote any fen sexing hme "un Fr what ae ‘ea uin ne nee spe oat ay a ae aoe pt br seca nace Who it ected, insane Fano te tach Tyo Png wee hore than hele of derision 97 {hs Schmit 308 2 Bue eat hat se ere cently deste and ‘medi paral econ sin” which woul! faa academe {nd thows ha achat ae nt ofthe ach Sime and Hig ee nein wth ot fly cole ie. Te tec of Ft, when spr hat oe peo derin te se es mg ue a bing ethan “pe ofa” hen bye vgs Sin This or stop aera rs om fering tha "he ria of es” Is ea ple aed ys is wan pte en ‘eson bu och cl pope rd ose ada wh kw he te or fel tn, doe mun ye te ae covee by the ‘erro walt a aloft chu at Babes Ye eve seal mou se pti ony he bor anderen af co nom ne Taya ‘hebalier, Eco lin un Ba Sui hey athe debi ojo Etec bat ts Rw ar nol expos of pi eh ey air eat he ls hatte nas i ange: hy cme acre mad pet peeevee th dey one se inh prea ee oni thames may have had i the ps. They tke tea: pee an aden wha 0 ma Inde Hegelian and Marist lone expeion ‘teagan a haga fen othe contra utating aiding fh dic Mae 939 tor antac, amo dew hi dled aga wh he eed soso a the expropiin ofthe pope a the eprint by ‘ork ofthe aur uho hap them fh eno pe i it the it plc his nd ater cn the negation he ego pis fot the aelation ofthe ii epi Br te cet of wthing Gulia ‘hl en Ms example sie a Ar 9759 heels cumined vo fc han lead an expen og ie an be nepal fen was, Acca anton one such gation patty arc he en mohamed Ths pcos of double nein ur dima om the contin fs stove by wie lence, ott esapon he un of San Frise flr the 126 earthen ire the rable ofthe Europea es bbl ing Work War he dee of she Wot Tne Cnr New Yak iy all ee fu f neg eine of abe and ert) that we in a and very uy nee and Jered ie Sl 2004 Sit 3008 nde cae ‘he epton of the gion eel te tae of deco he nde ‘seni menor wr simula bak nes then 0 commence tha lesrctn Ti proces sete pas that ctype quae diene fro orginaluting thy pen eganoicdicoune sete ype of tuations dete bu ster poi They woul reer th tm erat 4 he ly hae pats th ale he ee of al without coal te fe racemic an witout thei of were alee iia ate The eis ht ino ute dey lh ppeaing rs po of shi view. pec doule nega. Aa! hs a nation othe yin which Accs cr pie hail memory In endearing evoke among samc ad a ose og satcf hewn burt pesun colgation tie at, ner wo ‘he par cee hy dhe icdent pou aang doe aor naga on 2 rh othe pl ht a ented he oo bu fo he le abe ike ‘apa of ie ol aay 200% leaner hik of caer ple af ‘hi ern fain cen Icnmithy bat count yal among te whe hae filer unde spell Lal ple wh mond ent oh fb rove bythe fa pckgig plan be bln Exes ely ido vce the leggy ft rer meus For hem, he double negation gard ly the ering ws fen fm the on and abreast ew on aie feet ep of magia Ta ws oa at ae ces of sexs Bu Fr he socal anions rower iy they mayb) hatha nema har lace Propet ane gd rool emer of what ides chor ‘Artin, Bech the etn that wich aad ye te tion fhe nop aed nb Exc, elem he sbi stl oneoming ht low tgh he prod oe pla the akaging ome cau open the pony a mel ter Kr Tha ew pe tren bare ben gona ihn overall nn dria and wold ane Foner reproduc apa Gro of explain ver a pate one space. ef al pope vgn pert ea plan as more thai wha te el {kee of he neo Ea ad soso which nthe reproduction of ‘he apr oveigoe o. Concho tn 2051 etre dhe sf the buon min fr cond ine Hist ‘ited an this bane a we wes bth happy sce ech be aga We cha (edo awhile and be aed ae eee gain ation {owamiog tere she lscin note deta ape o meses et ation th GPS deve, A weet the ie thee of ub, Juan began mph “ring gi hw oh plas was Th Gh pl psa ck al began “olin le wh in a lS pes of lake lo he gun “She ol eT pla lo” 1 lee same ol suing shiver had ejeenad on sa case My ie nee ratonlaton fhe cla spel of arias of riepoceation did mot prevent ee fom eling, nse tol yf card deg othe inet of toe wal Teaming wth shi nde my i phe oi ou ta nome all amen bras ba dwg the gran of potting ses sic 5 yee Sat an Bt de abe pc i hoe les serve o pub rons tial mcr the tary feng da hao heen Bch ro cay als a igh in cle aon sme ofthe contains “embed pomonic sumer ab raha Bs al etry the hiss of knowlege 09 ad, sco oat mah exer ree fhe wh knw he plas bs he pop Inga rae the The rin tet oe pyle aa heaps fa sims in he pon ahr an dhe verlayacnsaf salen ts {Conaway ofthe people ation ‘ewe grea dot ry ase Boh 0 ain eth hy1 ean th patie: The bens af once a in poration nang thom ern her tha incre othe px omy thas eh ‘hgh profound sealed, doe ao peripatetic nd atom sor eer of he terial ney of ri hiner ot il ths Kesha bea the sites eno ped om epee ade fut sewed ples of comers. athe ce of held ela ube hat some oa calls sje om the conte shen sha they mete cade within ney proved ple Ax ud ote tha my ‘demi habs een nil ecto od he ior a mat are sesctan ht wtnendin bth neh end ad nx bmp i ‘he was in which he pepe et ru Balen nd Ec ed here Notun seeing Astrea lace eae perma hed ak rohipel by thesia eons apatite and eal or wane rough then. When people scund Eat we he ballon with indice ath expressions suport othe js tol pied wht io ‘mus on the wal fee crc ube, hey wee simp aking sh i lear that te places ate nepal he productive ey Brogepbis In which hy ae omen Ths es a high ia easieof ealit hae profoundly shaped the yout of se plas anda pop esntip withthe. In abi oth aking af che balling av he ppopiion a stil by ple ocr an pists, ll prople ao ake commentaries hat ley rnd: areca ae pwc insta en naked icounes on poration Acknowledgment 1a geal Holo, Vinay Kamat ena Manes, Shy ulna, nd Amol Pain fr thei conmenton et def ths hate My eae fib pes othe pope im Rio Fes. Gan, Mei, Coron and Blhuens who wdc in his homes ad shed ith me ier and ‘iperiences aout Esco andthe church of La Maga cance lve in souihestern Sata in Mayfly 2005 July 2005, Aa 2006-Febuay 3997 4 Jul-Aug 2007 This roc ma fuel by Hamp Cre om the Univesity of Beh Cumbia Standard Gt fiom te Sil Scene nd unis ech Caan of Caan Al the ames eoplnervewed inthe eld pedo Nowe Ee ce bron helnwen ee vo yn ie ay nh bea th ead “npr py ors rs em ig, ig kha to a References Cited Mor Theodr. gene Didi, Ne ok: Conn 7 ie Sms fe: Pl nd eo i at Tati Cnty Can bent pM pt snl nd te fee Tang ake a sey Sed Ft. ato Ctr Er tT Ri Tesi Sn Pn. ie Jasin Giegpny Faevel othe Cade, Eau in Mani” Madr! Madea 09) an Noma Ne Te ry enn Ls An anda Esa of Mer a Lac HoT Pedro of pe TaD. Sth Ono ln, (Ore mora) lena: as Te Fr Fog Coy: Canbrdge Canbge ety Pe Man KA Gre 9 he Cg of Sil ony New Yo Iter ober. (One pa iil A Cg of Pal Eero Now Vina 97 Ori po unin Ran” Mem 3 47eg The Mae ut Moony Ch and Ong Cp seo Time pn Ai eine be a a Such Teese DR eames i by MR “ih ral Cut a ng ay Rec aie he ei i Tap eft a ty} Scam aug ich min. es” Popo Se sion Geng Te Rl gy Se Phan ds, ey "Rost Nov on opr oc. One Fa Sent Ra“ aim of Moy” er td Roping we Pan et ny MN tN age Tac Reo ay Compt mp ee depa: aK ‘ike Gaile “ign is y nomi aes: Le ud pau ‘Goien mn’ ded dn ee ‘en Chup fiat A ay eg Hy ad EN Yk re line “The Ven oR 3 fara of Coon ‘When Patrimonies Collide The Case of Chunchuemil, Yucain Mays olen of Kel Vat, canoe ee 9 spe putin a ge elds pop abel by cil wth aca, nd ene oF Rochals sighing mma. diame basin own ey ‘howd nhabans, sine adie merino ing che andan cnn mache uy bev Inthe wordt one alent fea on "hat li ees plane a (the worn Sgn ssc Aig beh promute Fo the une a of Macs dcb be Fran wth geting Kotlar to comply mi atesposred mt program: he la hr wre eto aye clin oink tie fee, Ada cesta of Mek Nasal iene (IND found the commun awe “clean” Nor th repaon contin to hana har: Kicols ania tect by anergy bond at Lange pg pend air ling shot ols ong the rw ale set ean no Beene The Bepning ofa acacia ‘cation po de sf Chute fl onder nce ‘cane porn Kshs i ee and rane—revca eather pct ‘he emtaeable obi af ths Maa commute: Kahl reins ae ee om they do ot ren csi ob urna of ha ap In dhedaynand wc pena anehnorpher uring lope ial cn aa wore heal Yc Mas of Khaw sed may ag repding heli” nature rbd woth malice See comity Inthe lng oun pe ng Sito eo uch ing ale, men ag nent sy cold ese ans go koe with more bute than consent, Yr ti otherne pal disoure is serous inplaon Then of chalga exon ofthe un siting pon thee is ag