Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
References
Reprints/
permissions
You can respond
to this article at
Downloaded
from
This article cites 0 articles, 0 of which you can access for free at:
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/180/6/523#BIBL
To obtain reprints or permission to reproduce material from this paper, please
write to permissions@rcpsych.ac.uk
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/cgi/eletter-submit/180/6/523
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/ on June 4, 2012
Published by The Royal College of Psychiatrists
> T P : P U V W X Y T J @ ! X S C U Z= V P @: TZ B @ C C @ D E F G C E ? @ A H ? @ I
S2('"(6 .-+
/89:;6
<"->4,)% -012'*
M+' $#.(. C'&' 0)3-#$'* 5&)3 #,Q-"(#',( ",*
)%(Q-"(#',( 0".' $#.(.= *'-)( ",* 0$)6"-#,'
0$#,#0.= 3',("$ +'"$(+ 9'/C)&9'&. ",*
L"&' G&)4&"33' ^--&)"0+ &'4#.('&.F ^,/
-"(#',( C+) C". *'('&#)&"(#,4 ",* C+)
,''*'* #,Q-"(#',( 0"&' )& #,(',.#2' +)3'
(&'"(3',( C". 'R0$%*'* 5&)3 (+' .(%*/F
B#3#$"&$/= ",/ -"(#',( C#(+ " -"&/
*#"4,).#. )5 *&%4 )& "$0)+)$ *'-',*',0'=
)&4",#0 1&"#, *#.'".' )& $'"&,#,4 *#."1#$#(/
.'2'&' ',)%4+ () #,('&5'&' C#(+ &"(#,4 C".
'R0$%*'* 5&)3 ',(&/F _'.-),.#1$' 3'*#0"$
)55#0'&. ",* 9'/C)&9'&. C'&' "--&)"0+'*
() .''9 -'&3#..#), 5)& (+' #,0$%.#), )5 (+'#&
-"(#',(. ",* 0"&'&. #, (+' .(%*/F \+'&'
-'&3#..#), C". 4#2',= (+' 0".' ,)('. C'&'
5%$$/ -'&%.'* ",* (+' -"(#',(. C'&'
"--&)"0+'* 1/ (+' 0)33%,#(/ -./0+#"(�
,%&.' 7LGYE '3-$)/'* "( '"0+ .#('F G"(#',(.
C'&' &",*)3#.'* ),$/ "5('& (+'/ +"* 4#2',
5%$$ 0),.',(F _",*)3#."(#),
_",*)3#."(#), C". 0),Q
*%0('* 1/ 0)3-%('&Q4','&"('*
0)3-%('&Q4','&"('* 1$)09. )5
.#R &",*)3 ,%31'&. ",* .(&"(#5#'* 1/ .#('F
M+' &'.%$(. C'&' -$"0'* #, .'"$'* ',2'$)-'.
",* ),$/ )-','* "( (+' (#3' )5 (&'"(3',(
"$$)0"(#),F M+' &"(#) )5 "0(#2' #,('&2',(#),
() (&'"(3',( ". %.%"$ 7M^VE C". I`>F M+#.
C". *),' () #3-&)2' &'0&%#(3',( ",* "$$)C
#,('&Q.#(' 0)3-"&#.),.F ^$$ M^V -"(#',(.
C'&' ()$* (+"( (+'/ C)%$* &'0'#2' (+' L8M
#,('&2',(#), "( (+' ',* )5 (+' 5)$$)CQ%&"(#,4 -'&#)*F ^ -)C'& 0"$0%$"(#), 1".'*
), " -#$)( .(%*/ 7M%&9#,4(), ; O#,4*),=
IJJJE -&'*#0('* (+"( C#(+ ?J -"(#',(. "(
'"0+ .#(' 7PJ &'0'#2#,4 (+' #,('&2',(#),
",* NJ &'0'#2#,4 (&'"(3',( ". %.%"$E ",*
"..%3#,4 " IJa *&)-Q)%( &"('= (+'&' C".
" ?Ja 0+",0' )5 *'('0(#,4 " IUa *#55'&Q
',0' #, )2'&"$$ ./3-()3"()$)4/ "( (+'
JFJ>a $'2'$ )5 .#4,#5#0",0'= .+)%$* .%0+ "
*#55'&',0' 'R#.(F
<1(*= >'>(4"1,')
+..0..-0)1.
?@A
9 M 3 N OP
O P Q 9;P 8 9 + R
9&0"1-0)1 %&'(>.
!)& *'$#2'&/ )5 (+' "0(#2' #,('&2',(#),=
LGY. &'0'#2'* >J *"/. )5 #,(',.#2' (&"#,#,4
#, (+' %.' )5 L8MF M+' 3",%"$ C".
*'2'$)-'* 5&)3 ", )#,"$ *'.0&#-(#), )5
(+'.' .(&"('4#'. 7O#,4*), ; M%&9#,4(),=
>??fE ",* "11&'2#"('* #,() " -+".'*
"--&)"0+ *'.#4,'* () 1' .%--$'3',('* 1/
.-'0#5#0 C&#((', 3"('&#"$F M+' LGY. C'&'
(&"#,'* 1/ 'R-'&(. #, L8M 7[FMF ",* [FOFE
",* C'&' ('.('* ), (+'#& .9#$$. (+&)%4+
*'3),.(&"(#),= &)$' -$"/ ",* C&#((',
?@S
9&0"1-0)1 7,*04,1=
^$$ .'..#),. C'&' "%*#)("-'* C+', -"(#',(.
"4&''* () (+#.F Z,*'-',*',( '2"$%"(#), )5 "
.(&"(#5#'* ."3-$' )5 ("-'. C". 0"&&#'* )%(
%.#,4 (+' 0)4,#(#2' (+'&"-/ .0"$' 3)*#5#'*
5)& -./0+).#. 7X"**)09 !" #$=
#$= IJJ>EF ^
0%(Q)55 .0)&' )5 NJ C". ("9', ". #,*#0"(#,4
"00'-("1$' e%"$#(/ )5 (+'&"-/ ","$/.#.F M+#.
&'2'"$'* (+"( (+' 2".( 3"g)&#(/ )5 .'..#),.
C'&' "1)2' (+#. $'2'$ 73'",!N@F@f=
73'", N@F@f= ?Ua
LZ NUFD@Kf>F?EF
<1"1,.1,#"4 ")"4=.,.
_'.%$(. C'&' ","$/.'* %.#,4 BGBB 2'&.#),
>J ",* B("(" 2'&.#), P ), ", #,(',(#),Q()Q
(&'"( 1".#.F [#55'&',0'. 1'(C'', (+' (C)
4&)%-. C'&' "..'..'* %.#,4 ","$/.#. )5
38<MR9<
M+' 0+"&"0('&#.(#0. )5 (+' -"(#',( ."3-$'
"&' *'.0'* #, M"1$' >F M+'&' C'&' ,)
.("(#.(#0"$$/ .#4,#5#0",( 1".'$#,' *#55'&',0'.
1'(C'', (+' 4&)%-.F B'2'&#(/= ". '.(#3"('*
1/ ,%31'& )5 -&'2#)%. &'$"-.'. ",* 1/
,%31'& )5 -&'2#)%. *"/. #, +).-#("$ 5)&
.0+#6)-+&',#"= C". ,)( .("(#.(#0"$$/ .#4,#5#Q
0",($/ *#55'&',( 1'(C'', (+' 4&)%-.F M+'
L8M #,('&2',(#), 4&)%- +"* " 3'", )5
fFD> -&'2#)%. "*3#..#),. 5)& .0+#6)-+&',#"
7?Ua LZ fFJ?KUFNNE C#(+ " 3'", ,%31'&
)5 -&'2#)%. *"/. #, +).-#("$ 5)& .0+#6)Q
-+&',#" )5 f@FUN 7?Ua LZ NDF@fKU?FI>EF
Z, 0)3-"&#.),= (+' M^V 4&)%- +"* " 3'",
)5 UF>@ "*3#..#),. 7?Ua LZ fFNNKPFJNE
",* UIFJ> *"/. #, +).-#("$ 7?Ua LZ
NDF?fKPPFJDEF H'*#0"(#), *).' ". 4#2',
1/ 0+$)&-&)3"6#,' 'e%#2"$',0' ",* %.' )5
"(/-#0"$ ,'%&)$'-(#0. C". ,)( .("(#.(#0"$$/
.#4,#5#0",($/ *#55'&',( 1'(C'', (+' (C)
4&)%-.F M+' L8M #,('&2',(#), 4&)%- +"*
" 3'", 5#4%&' 5)& 0+$)&-&)3"6#,' 'e%#Q
2"$',0' )5 DfPF@@ 34 7?Ua LZ PJIFD?K
@?JF?PE ",* (+' M^V 4&)%- )5 @@PFU@ 34
7?Ua LZ PPJFDIK>>>IFffEF ]5 (+).' ),
"(/-#0"$ ,'%&)$'-(#0.= UU C'&' #, (+' L8M
#,('&2',(#), 4&)%- ",* IU #, (+' M^V
4&)%-F
B("(#.(#0"$$/ .#4,#5#0",( #3-&)2'3',(.
C'&' .'', #, (+' L8M #,('&2',(#), 4&)%0)3-"&'* C#(+ (+' M^V 4&)%- 7M"1$'
IE #, )2'&"$$ ./3-()3.= #,.#4+( ",*
! 3 O 8 T 5 ! 9 OOP
P 9 8 3 U 8 P 9 O ;P OP
O P < 5 : O V; W : 3 8 PO + 9 3 8 +9 / 8 P 9
@7/5/<685:96:<
,?AC85
FGH
IIJKL
NI
GGJNN
$80185
E/B8
M8A/B8
&;8 OP8/59Q
E8/0 ONHD @+Q
RKJRI OFNJIST
RLJSSQ
E/5:6/B 96/6?9
':0;B8
FKK
ILJKN
E/55:81
HS
LFJIR
!:U45<81VW:14W81
XR
LHJLI
FHS
SSJNK
RG
IJRK
GG
FJLK
#08A>B4P81
FIL
SSJKK
M?BBV>/56 6:A8
LF
FJKK
'78B68581 W45[974>
LG
GJSR
"6785
GX
XJLX
+018>801806
LNK
RHJKG
M/A:BP
2670:< ;54?>
Y7:68
&35:</0T@/5:CC8/0
ZB/<[ &35:</0
ZB/<[ 46785
&9:/0 46785
2A>B4PA806 96/6?9
\4?9:0; 96/6?9
LLL
GXJFK
'6/3381 74A8
NL
GLJHX
#096/3381 74A8
GL
RJNS
GJLF
\4A8B899V?0[04W0
@/585 >/56:<:>/6:40
(58/681 W:67 </585
(58/681 W:674?6 </585
NI
RFJLK
LGS
HXJNK
9"K40 @
6O<5M<<O;P
]%& .(%*/ .+)C. (+"( " 1&#'5 L8M #,('&Q
2',(#),= "$),4 C#(+ -./0+)'*%0"(#),"$
3"('&#"$.= 0", 1' *'$#2'&'* 1/ LGY. #, (+'
0)33%,#(/ C#(+ (+' +'$- )5 0"&'&. ()
"0+#'2' ./3-()3"(#0 #3-&)2'3',( C#(+)%(
#,0&'".#,4 .%#0#*"$#(/F ]2'&"$$ ./3-()3Q
"()$)4/= #,.#4+( ",* *'-&'..#), C'&'
.#4,#5#0",($/ #3-&)2'* #, (+' L8M 4&)%". 0)3-"&'* () (+' M^V 4&)%-F M+#.
#3-&)2'3',( #, #,.#4+( C". 0$#,#0"$$/ .#4Q
,#5#0",( #, (+' L8M 4&)%-= C+#0+ 0)%$*
.%44'.( (+"( -"(#',(. &'0'#2#,4 L8M 3"/
.+)C " -)(',(#"$ 5)& #3-&)2'* "*+'&',0'=
1'(('& %.' )5 0)-#,4 .9#$$. ",* -'&+"-.= #,
(+' $),4'& ('&3= &'*%0'* $',4(+ )5 (#3' #,
+).-#("$F M+' YYM )5 >N 5)& #3-&)2'3',(
#, )2'&"$$ ./3-()3. C". 0)3-"(#1$' C#(+
(+' &'.%$(. "0+#'2'* C+', L8M C".
*'$#2'&'* 1/ 'R-'&( (+'&"-#.(. 7O%#-'&. !"
#$=
#$= >??DE ",* 1'(('& (+", (+"( )5 -./0+)Q
'*%0"(#), )& 5"3#$/ (+'&"-/ "$),' 7YXB
L',(&' 5)& _'2#'C. ",* [#..'3#,"(#),=
IJJJEF Z( &'3"#,. () 1' .'', C+'(+'& (+'
'55'0(. )5 (+#. 1&#'5'& #,('&2',(#), C#$$ 1'
*%&"1$'F
<0&J,#0 ,->4,#"1,').
M+' 1','5#(. ". .+)C, +'&' .%--)&( (+'
5%&(+'& *#..'3#,"(#), )5 -./0+).)0#"$ #,('&Q
2',(#),. "3),4 LGY. 7X"**)09 !" #$=
#$=
>??fE ",* )(+'& 3',("$ +'"$(+ 0"&' -&)5'.Q
.#),"$.F
M+#.
.(%*/
.%--)&(.
(+'
%,0),(&)$$'* 5#,*#,4. 5&)3 (+' '2"$%"(#),
Z/98B:08 9<4589 OA8/0 /01 NHD @+Q /01 <7/0;8 9<4589 OA8/0 /01 NHD @+Q /3685 658/6A806
E8/9?58
@4;0:6:U8TC87/U:4?5/B
(58/6A806
6785/>P :0685U806:40
/9 ?9?/B
O&,@".&Q
Z/98B:08 9<458
@7/0;8 9<458
Z/98B:08 9<458
@7/0;8 9<458
E8/0 1:338580<8
GFJGI OGLJXRTGRJNQ
FJXH OGJRGTRJSSQ
GRJFK OGGJLLTGXJRNQ
LJXN O"
O"KJKR 64 FJFRQ
+09:;76
SJIG OSJFFTNJLKQ
"LJLX O"
O"LJHI 64 KJIHQ
SJXS OSJLSTNJLSQ
KJLG O"
O"KJFN 64 KJXFQ
"GJGN O!
O!!KJKLHQ
KJKLHQ
!8>5899:40
HJRR ORJNFTHJNRQ
KJSF OKJFSTLJGIQ
XJKS OHJFSTXJINQ
KJGN O"
O"KJGN 64 KJSXQ
HJGX ORJIGTHJSLQ
KJHS OKJLRTLJKGQ
HJHK ORJINTXJGKQ
KJFF O"
O"KJGR 64 KJSNQ
"U85/BB 9PA>64A/64B4;P
L
'PA>64A9 43 9<7:=4>7580:/
Z?5180 43 </58
LJFK O!
O!!KJKKLQ
"KJSI O!
O!!KJKKFQ
KJKKFQ
"KJFH O!
O!!KJGHSQ
KJGHSQ
"RJGH O!
O!!KJLGXQ
KJLGXQ
LJ & 08;/6:U8 <7/0;8 9<458 40 67:9 >/5/A8685 :01:</689 :A>54U8A806 /01 / >49:6:U8 A8/0 1:338580<8 9<458 40 /0/BP9:9 43 <4U/5:/0<8 O&,@".&Q :01:</689 / >49:6:U8 589?B6 345 <4;0:]
6:U8 TC87/U:4?5/B 6785/>P 4U85 658/6A806 /9 ?9?/BJ
?@ ?
9 M 3 N OP
O P Q 9;P 8 9 + R
5&,1,#"4 ">>&",."4
M+#. .(%*/ -)-%$"(#), #. ,)( &'-&'.',("(#2'
)5 "$$ -"(#',(. C#(+ .0+#6)-+&',#" 1%( #.
&'-&'.',("(#2' )5 (+).' -"(#',(. C+) "&'
), (+' 0".'Q$)"*. )5 0)33%,#(/ 3',("$
+'"$(+ ('"3 3'31'&.F M+'&' C". ,) *#55'&Q
',0' 1'(C'', (+' 4&)%-. "( 1".'$#,' #,
('&3. )5 4','&"$ 0+"&"0('&#.(#0.= 3'*#0"(#),
*).' )& (/-'= )& .'2'&#(/ )5 #$$,'.. ". #,*#Q
0"('* 1/ ,%31'& )5 2#.#(. )& *"/. #,
+).-#("$F Z( #. 0$'"&= (+'&'5)&'= (+"( 3'*#Q
0"(#), ",* #$$,'.. .'2'&#(/ "&' &%$'* )%( ".
0),5)%,*#,4 5"0()&.= C+#0+ 3#4+( 'R-$"#,
?@ Y
+5NP;XR86Q8/8P9<
:/% 1%15%0+ ,; #/% P(+"6/# "(#, U)/"8,4/0%("T%+%-0)/ [0,24 -0%\ [$3("+ @''"(%$$M J,%$ @01,20M
]-#3 >-#%1-(M @$"+,( >0-55-(M ^-0Q =,00"(M
^%$"++- =2(("(6/-1M _0 C%#%0 =200-(M :,(3 _-&"%+M
_0 C%#%0 _,((%$$3M C-2$ S0%()/M C%((3 ["$%+M T,5%0#
[,$'"(6M U#%; V-)Q(%3M C0,;%++,0 _-&"' ]"(6',(M
W2$"- ^-)$%,'M J")Q ^-62"0%M W,+%4/ ^)]-(%M !"+^)J-3M @(( ^"$$-0M U#%&% ^,,0/%-'M J,01^,06-(M C-2$ ^200-3M W2'3 J%.1-(M W%0%13 C%$#,(M
_%)$-( C/%$-(M >%( C,$$"(6%0M _0 U/-(3- T-#/,'M
@((%##% U)-((%$$M T,( U"''$%M @(( U#%&%(+,(M _0
_,26$-+ :20Q"(6#,(M _0 :0%&,0 :20(%0M W,(-#/-(
`-00%(M U#2-0# `/3#% -(' _0 @$"+#-"0 `"$+,(9
`% -$+, -)Q(,.$%'6% #/% +"6(";")-(# ),(#0"52#",(
,; #/% P(+"6/# "(#, U)/"8,4/0%("- @'&"+,03 >,-0'\
C-2$ S-01%0M W"113 [$-++M T")/-0' [0-3M !"+V-3.,,'M C0,;%++,0 W2$"-( !%;;M J"6%$ ^-62"0%M _0
_"-(- ^,00"+,(M C0,;%++,0 _-&"' =2(("(6/-1
X.%(+M >0"-( T,6%0+ -(' ^-0a,0"% `-$$-)%9
! 3 O 8 T 5 ! 9 OOP
P 9 8 3 U 8 P 9 O ;P OP
O P < 5 : O V; W : 3 8 PO + 9 3 8 +9 / 8 P 9
38T838P58<
[.K0&%E /ZE /')1%'-0&=E <Z +ZE W0&&,.E 5ZE !" #$
BF\IGD @ ),140%/%(+"&% 4+3)/,4-#/,$,6")-$ 0-#"(6 +)-$%9
E <044_''*EXZE
<044_''*E XZE 9"&&,0&E
9"&&,0&E PZE !" #$ BF\\SD
5ROPO5+R O/WRO5+9O;P<
RO/O9+9O;P<
(78 96?1P ?981 / ^658/6A806 /9 ?9?/B_ <4A>/5:940 ;54?> 67/6 1:1 046 <40654B 345
<406/<6 6:A8J
<S"0+# 0%)%"&%' GL @262+# BFFGM ;"(-$ 0%&"+",( BB S%502-03 BFFBM -))%4#%' BD S%502-03 BFFB?
E9
9"=4'&E
"=4'&E WZ ] /')1%'-0&=E 6Z BF\IGD _%&%$,41%(#
?@I