Está en la página 1de 10

 


    ! " # $%&'(
) *+,-.
0/1& 2 !345
687:9<;>=?=:@BADE C =F=:@HGJI 6LKM@HNPORQ>SUT7?GVOXWZY[7FI\I ]<OXGJQ>SUA'OXGJ^Y>@5K_KMSZI\I
Ikj\lXprmomqnqmprnkRstufnkXuuvk|wy8x,j\v
lXz mnk{hpnkshshn}nq|u nqp~vv
wlX` [|@5uf8}KMtXGVSZlhp~uv
aclX~v
bBfuSm Eed S E KVafOhp~mogZI\mIkSZj\RalXI\umoi\XnqI\prufI\nkIqst|nk8u.j\vlXwmonqprnq~shsXnkpr"uvwelRu|}z!XlXp~fv
m rv


5prnqfufosX o|p~lh}

5pcnk,ufqsX ~q|prlX}
I\I\I x, ulH nquf w:v
z!uf[msXqXufshmquf~uf|lhq}fu-x,uful5mqu_nk|uq}
v< u|nqnp~>Hp~nkuv
~ { Xx 5 }5
5
T9eaKMGVOR^K
PMJVq}2FFV-MMPoFVoU_"%82VoP?VV2}VoBJM
?qJBFJ

JV[\FoFMoF>82P2JqM}2M,P}M<Fq2PVVVJJoF<fF}Fo8o5H
qfJ},MMo5JF FJPV2o\,FoF?FcoJo%JoeoFMfVFP2}FMo}%"} 2>",VM_VMMJ2kc}V:J<-\"_M4<oo"FFJof
RJ}FoJFoy2+F2_VV2ML2
oFqF:ZJ&FVoFVXFJo Mk }F?o"cF!y2FV}o.oF_fBV2Mf\V+J%VJM-oVFMVqFV
F?&F P}FFJo2,oJJkF}2}oFFoM8FF2JFq}JMFfJ2?FqPM}M88.2e+_MJMqM JMJ\F?LoFFBJ\VFPqV-?oo,f 8&_FM2FVV2oo}?MF2!q?}F?JV!+: F 4 JMFFFJoo
FJ\FoF?FP}FVoyJ __JFV2fFoVJVfVJ}Vo V!JFFVJVo oJ<M,FoMMoV<F?V}>V",V8}Vo?J2?!k2FMM
8,FF+F_JoV>J?F!FqM:PoJcJ:&Le MMF?22qo8}:FP +JJ2P!-FJJ_FJ2VJ oo _J2J2MVqM}VqHMV2JJ\o}Joo?c_FFq:VF'_.:oPFJVJ[2VJVVFq2 FF_8oJ<F!h:F<JJ
MoFof>VF?FP}q
R QLKMGVS8 E ^KM7?SZQ
2V:oP}\XV ?V_V>oPeVV?FJ_\VVFoVJXVMhqFFoo8V"VoFJF ORaf7F^6<K_GJOtKM@HW;
VoeFoPFPV:o LJJk?yVo+tJFVVFLq+J_VJVF,oo5VFVoHV}2ofJ &FJJP:,?q\Ft<MqFF+2FVo}FZ2MM
FFJJ P_MBFoVPFJ%V!rMPo_J<k_~5o}f[e J5J55oq_f}} 2hfJ\FFoF_PyVo,F[_MH2:o<}eV2?FJFVX+J y hFJ2VFo
M?FoP}Fo4ooV+JMF2o}4FV2oFVMVcFJP4MMqVJFoF Fq: 8FJoJ\\HJ
FJ?FP}Fo+e?q.MF2oVJ2MV
FFqJPVVfVFoFoJ"kJV?oFVJF$Mfo?JF?q0?FMo2FJo   
  
 
    !"
#
FMF$f2F_VVMV&JF2MPV,~M2VoFJV$
VFfVFJ&8?
$ #!%& '(
?VFPJ}FFoJ&oJ ?q!V>JFJqJVF<MyqVF,Fq?oefJ[\FJoFPMVo2,o}_o fFJVFfLPPJVq2* ),P+}M,!VZ22MMMMoXqJJ?FMJo.t:V<8-PVM2o?
F +Vo,of__FyV2ofo  FVPVMo,2F\FF ,FFqq??JF?2
F>Voo o.M2J_&FFVV!+,J}\2Vf 8VoV,o2o. -V.VM2?FJo_

Fo+VJVF2F_oVoVX[V[?.0/8VoP [FV[?FJMMF22q}FfF VF,FMV_


cJJFfoV$:>[MqF~5Fqfq" $1\<rLo!FJJ<<F}}88H
o_fo&FJJ
PVo,_}<VJ J2VXV._FFV[VJ}\_FoVFoVM243F5
68,-7:9*o;fV<=6 70Z2<=>@,MM?BqAD~FCEV< 2VfFooJ-PJ2P+J&?FJ}V-Vo_VJo
FF oFPV2}M2F}P[2J5JFVo2V.FJ\tF2oFMVM
F>"2CHGIJJ?AD\J9*}CKCL<>NM:JO PP:ZJ702V<KGRQ0P;},<KMQ0GV,f,VT FqS5?o?foFFoHV y>V?FqJ_oFH
V2o?oJVFqPy}2VMqM8oJfHV :>[~of"1JVFkM
FV}2oM2FVJ%) 2FJ\FoFV f!FV+}8Vc?
3 V ;W>D<EXY7 VZ5
U V+JFyJFV&?qJJR
CH<KJ[9 :oFoX:Vq+_J?PVoJ8FVJoqP
F>DPJ[}]`:q]"\Q0;W> V <=ADJ VPJPFoFq+f.\3 P:9898]Y^_]"<K;W986 V <=ADJ ^
3 >"Ga968ADJ 3 V >DJ VB3 P:9898]
U >5:o\qZkFVa
U@b Vo+JFVVFXPV>+Vo%Vo
FoMt}FVfo22_yF>yVVV< :VyMV?F_VMJF8M8o\VPH
U V[V>:<o:LFJooF8FP}:q\FFoXL}f
Vq_,VJV :M:FVMH
U VMVP}Fy:oF,L}Vo,_M
VoMqk_VJFJV :V?FJMFH
U VVJV :M:FVMJRMooJ2FV8JFof
?Ff5qVVFJ_FJJLFeFVFJM<Vy,MVVeP}FV}VeFJHVVoPFM
F!P}V Vo&FVF2@H-heVJMF"hMo:Fcq\+8H$PPJJ-\Foo}_o-2 _F,VM,Moroe}M8J:V:
FFJT)

cRd:e f%gihDj=dkd:lnmpophDjqf%rsut

F2V2VVo,FFFJ>oM:wLv 2:PFVf82}MMV~FJV?>oLMMJV:qJ )
vxzy&{Y|}%~ 
:k
VF V22JoV+VVF, :FVMVP?V:MFV \}F<FV) ,V8:o\- 5M  Vyf?
r
= xJ x _

4
3
l = v

[E%%" 8*,* E%pW8%#& E

8VowF8wiVMq-MBxq\P}FJky,J_q=-}BVx "8J2Vo[}_
`  f

x
:4 " W
W

8 qV,oYFW H HVVLV2J\V2e,2qV!2F,&r}M?o2,MJFJVJqJ\
%* 8F VM
Jy:LoFV\JJFVJF
_VJVq\FVJVFFJ}VFoV_ J * xJ n *V a &FJ 82fV?+FoF
FPJ2Jy2JFFo>,VFJJVqJL\J ,M2JFJFqF,J
FM J:y2FVVVVMFeMFFVq\FVFoVB+MVFq\ FFHRH:VLVoVFoVJVJV<Fo:_MJVoZJVFJJ:
8 qVoFq\Fo[)

x
q xz8ax
q _
W ED H
qxz8axx
W ED H
8?VoFVRPV2ZMM_}qF\Fyx} V4 i_xz=-Bq xBB"1xu>1F FJVFJ
FJPV2}My_2oLo?FV 2Jo"P<y}88HV J\ V 24 3 5
F68P7:V}9*:; q<=\6 70<=f>,68AD>CH<MF,oFM2FqV\oJcFFJ2,FVVJF FFVVFJJFoJf:
MMooJJ??::MM??FFVVVMFFFVoVFof V_o4M) V!VFJJ:
x qqxx44 xux  r
q .xuX
}FVJ%J \FFVo$FVV JF 2'}_VF }VUPVcV_MqJo?,V
VMoFV-FPV}:o FMFFq\MVPJ}FVJFV FVo&qV 4FJJF-of2
Jo fVFV:<>V[}_>~*5)Jqf" 1\:o\VeMMVP}MJ!8X>VMV

V 2FV~J@F~4V !V,FocFo:LFo-FVM:oJ\Fq
V8oFkV_VVV_J\J? F) o@ * 8F _JfF
y&{"}fq f x
= 1f
W W
:8<Jo F%J<ooVFe:o}FF2o2JF5[VVJVVqJ\[ 
Jy,q+JFJykFkJotFV
JFFo.fM:FFV2M .* yfq2_FV JqV>2q}>&% }) RVFJJ?
4 J &FV[VkqFV F-F k RJe5,VV2>V$VRV,J5
2J8VM2oVFJMo%)q}hVoF8:<JM
xz1 :
&f= ?
~
xB" 1 :
&f= ?
= f
V[ZF?_ oB.VZM2?JVMo52foZ8Zo\fFFI V| W V2FJ

U 2VVFFVVoBFFHRVVF+tFVJF
_
xv
f
VVqV_T 2ooMPJMVyoV\oFo\ R ) | <V

x|
?
F8JVyoVFN 2FVVVFMo?VF2Hf oFFV
FFJJVJ}Fo8FVVF&+FJV c,y?J,Foo% )FFqFVHFJ2oV} 2[M22FMoVM Zo,2fo f[
FFJ2V 2 }?FJVFLooZM:MovfL>JRF,}Fo VkZ_}VVq5FoHFJFoF
JJ,fVFo:>8[Fy~V5q f_" V1}R8<8VMPF~VLo,J}4VMo[oF2+f
8}FF2_JVFoMFV}V2f}F_Je8?+oV?JJk\VfFP}FeFVPoVFoP
VZF-VqR,V2FooJ2MoFJoF?>VFq?ofJFoPMVFV,o}F8Vy?FPFo}F
FqF<ZoPV_fV?R<FVVqh? MV
FyftJP}JV_VPV22JHF
_8Vy<VFoo-Ff-Jo&VMFfVJ8 FJJFVMF?q: 0VMVVqFyP
MVVq._oFV
~  'D(  &I 
k  
 
  $ #!#
0J V}V8 VJ4 LVJ2M?VM FoV? VF\F2 JFV
q:o rMP_<~5o} b VF[~Ho}\

}eVFVJoFoVt[fJ+VPoF2?ZFooF?2PtoJoJJo\
ooJfFkX%q\8FF LM 2FJVFV2 qV5_JhV\}8J
FFFJco2PVJo5Fq&,e2V?_k.2-MJFV+_fo2J
FFV"2VMVFFoV&cJM
,Fo&:LoV"VVJVFJ%F}VkJ
FMJ.oFoMJV J2PJ2oF PoF $VqP_JFP} F"":VHoFV
F}JyVVVF0 qqJX?[?<F?o: _?o8_VVRVVUMFLF
JFVUF2o[F2J2oJ}o2}ooo <F2h,?Z2FJV
fJVF[JJ\)
q #V xq `q "= Rq
82Fe}?VV-8 J? M2kVxV$4VV-qVo:F qXJ2?2M

2 xUJq V _8 ZF F V,:?VJJ2?[Fk Pf , " J\MFFJVJV,[2kVoVPP.}yFJ


FVJqyJo,MoMo?rV qFVJc?[}
VFV&e:_FPVc?JFF8qV?_Ho?2qX_2o,VM
F2J,fq J-JoV ocx oP&tFFVV_Vf:PFF8VP}F yFJ
DV Jy = -h J \ ax [ 4f V LkPo&
1.2

0.8
y
0.6

0.4

0.2

0
0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.2

1.4

[H D* Hii*a 

\   
 #& 0% D! #"$ %"&('*)+ , "$- /. '102.3 5 4 687p, "$-:9 ;3 &4 <=>7
? "@& BA,CD=E4 6&<F7Y? "@&  , iY*KG =H&I$'J&H, i*pB&  <K& K

Jf>\F~<oFF&VVoFJ._oV+oo?VFMPF22fo+_V F}F8oPFVF+JVF!ooVPoFFFV FHJFFJJJ


n -hJ

1.001

2
b=270.
b=1000.
b=2000.
1.5

y 1

0.5

0.999
0.999

1
x

[H%L= M0D*[E$0

0
0

1.001

F q:>P8_<qMFVPJ}y_:NJ qJ?FJFJy2JX2}M_
o?FfV>FFqq5:M8oJfJ\FJ FJy}f8JV
q #V xq `q "= Rq
?:FkF!Vn"-tJ_\=-hFJV!Vf V F o +F8V }FV J&fM

JP+VoFVF,oJ _,VFo_ J\8FVoFPV.+e Mo\+JF}oF+}FFJJ
f~akFVVV+!?FV+J,FFV?_oVF2b e+:oJ2,M-oooN Pc[FJ
FFJ}cF8JF2 FJPO V J \FVVF:VV2}FJ4kkV.J?VFJ
8Fo~ ,VV J8V8oJVhJVFfPVV
[cJFJ&V2VL Fq:&FJ"FVD4FJ
Q f?ofJFM8 2VJF


R = #V x q V "?

8JF\ UFoF:LVV 2M_


VofV } R f: :k}\ [b >0%M[}8V+FJFJV}~0*Vy:Pko,FFFFVJ
VV2V}VoV n-hVM 1F<[JV,+J<>2FqVVM}JF&FFJ2
y?VV&-:VJF8 o-f2FJV_}"oFJFVoooyVF F .M,FJFM}}of5>
FV}8._VJFoF+V V V

0.5

1
x

1.5

[H WV * Hii*a  

\ XG  X&
 #&Y 0Z DW #"$ B"&(':) , " -\[ '0 . ]<E4 "*7Y?" -:X A C ]KE4 I^7?"  
;Y@E 4 KJ7 , "  '%_ iB%K V&V '&i*H,i*pE K"`V&V$aE;Y?" @ '
, 4w%KY VbI&<E'2&IE_ i% E H, " K5a ;* *
7Y? " @ ', i
%K =Y5 '\i*H, %  =E 6 ? "
1.15
b=270.
b=1000.
b=2000.
1.1

1.05

0.95

0.9

0.85
0.85

0.9

0.95

1
x

1.05

[H%W<"M0D*[E$JV

1.1

1.15

FFoJMqf+2FV}o,Fof|hV2Fo??JoyF,2M_oo\F.JV J tt[o[?JtM
FFJ2q2}V}&qFoPJ?FVP}fVqJVoF2fFJqF?&V8F_q\FFVo>VV
J VMFq?oF
cH dw
1e
'u5fW
N4 #!%& '(gf!% & !Y
S dPT GJSUZ@t6<KMGVOhK_@WR;
Vtoo+2VJ}J+.VM.J?h}MVFo[2q[}FFV,":FoV+JPL2+JPP? FJ-VJ,\FfoJFFV[ ?:FFPq}:PFRoFJ
FJF2o>oVPP?V_oZJ+VFoVFoF2F_H>JLhR>fVJJoFV[ o8<RFFJ-F
F_q\FVq _q5RFJ\-:Fo&2_ }JPL?FJMJJ8:<2?o%)

3
Start point: (2,2)
Start point: (2,1)
2
1
0
y1
2
3
4
5
2

0
x

[H h6 a% WEi&\j @ 
 ?"&"7:
k*lJ1
m ]
k    #* 0%Z "! 4E ,4('n=5 ? ('F)o ?" -:[ 0 . 
<E4 "L7Y? " -:X ;^E 4 "$ %A C pKE4 IL7D? "    _ iB%Y*q&K%E'2&
H, i*p4 <E D KhK#*Z i %
0Z Dn
45 ,4& (a0_ iBY*K
K`=&=I$':i*H, % ` I$H, VVK#*Z iLq 0% DW =E _ 

FJPVF8VFq?T
U FJPVF:FJP2FP pk0Jv
_oJFVyPVVoJhFFFJJH"?>M}8<HVoq[?F>V}F+yoV? FV:W}FoM5JMVqy?,FJo
FBoFJfVV :>_V[}8~5qf" V1MFoooJJF VVc}MVoFo+2f
FFJ+MJP e?FPV}cFVP82JPPR<qVF M
FF22q+}ooJ.},eF,FFVV>,:,}8FVV2oJ<ok[ )2FJJFo>oJ_JVPJ2+F>FJPRtFfy:P[}>FVJV\
FVJ>M,FFVo+tb JJe_kFVXM2FVoF\J}LRVV[?FPM}F
-,ZFVVVe :o_&eJ\ 5[VJoF?Voo8tVVPcFJ[FJ2\FoF?VFPo}F
FFVh[MVo2LMVP>VVoZ2JV2[FoMtoF2,qf5oRV[2MF} )
.JoMeFMFVH,VV__2J,o:feV?JFJFo\[RJ8\JFoPF,FoJ+?
FFoFVJfMoJF++JV\FooF_fFJV[2fyJJk8L2o.HVVVoFoHPJ J
2 q'}oVP!2?FJFFMVVoM<,F_V?&JJJ\FFV J}oV_oo fVJb M+P}PoJ+8FVJM qMFMF
o% )
e oJ/FrLMJcJ8.+F:?FoF}oF}2o o oJ
Jo"fFFkFV8 FqBJ MJP}FFoMFP. J?+.FP}ekF
PVJVFo.oFFo\Vo5BFPVV +.8:LrLo VVJ?-FoJPPVV
U

_FVV J8?FMFFJV f VFV2MV?FM[PJVJ:\JVF8,V


JP[M&JMo&F2oVo.qJJ.}JFVM?o?JoJP?FJ_y:VJoV2oF>FoF
8VJoFFM8
-f8f[P+VF
PJf>V}q[-VoFVo [MqM?F-JkFVJ:q
2FVoUJHhJJ}FhFFJLVJFF8JV8JFF+,JJ?VhVLJ\MVoV?qJt_
V2-VVFVoy?oMoFV:P}FFeV [Vo JM2
+8Ff2  :  JPMJNxts  _
+qc}J< 2 VMFqc }Vqy
2FVFFJJ 8FF"VV&}FF,8M:_PoFV>:fNoV"J>y2PoVcJ
}Q J}FJ-V"2fV VMV :FoJP2P
VyFqfVoVoFFMfFJq<}>%)
>eJVVyVooMqVoF V,JMFH
M -V FVyJFq?+,JMF,}V [
V -V FV2VMo J+}V k
J
-V FVy}Vq [ JT 2VM
}_FF>:JMvFFqJF8kMFHJ>RJ
Vo5VFJFHeJFV?LMJPo?VFqFXo}?V8JVVFJD vI\JxJhVFoVyho
yFVP<?oMJFFVRLFJM2VotFVF}FZVF5JFLJL22ZMZ:PJFV<>:PFJF
FVPFVVa +-V FFVJZMVVFo}y2JVZFfPVHo5J}JLo,q5F<o2tVJZVMq
vxy<FJyM5P2q
J-V,FVFo8LoF?Fq}[MFoP}FoLVJ<FJ}o>f%L) VJ2VFV
uw R
u
U x _v
ux
u
U x [
z&y { u R u x(x
U %x^
>2FJ<PV_FVoF}Fy?MVFJ
eFFo[?<F+F<:<2FqFJ% )
J
U [ F_.VJtFJVooMq&VFq? k-V
FVoPVJo5  ?\o [J V8VF&FV2FFFqJ:[F,\,:JH'8FqVPP
FJy
8VyVooMqJFq?H
U ZVJ\FoFVFqyVMfoHJ
FFJ2JoV,VR}HFFFPV[\JFJV4koV:V[22LJk<8kLVV
Jk_8oqJJ:PV

cH~ |n}[  


 

&~_`e
 
 Je 

2MFMVR?Fq\2HkFFV-8_JFP?|
MV2V>J?F2JV2}MMM2JFJJF
2FMf5FMJq}5HhV[fVZFJq}FVF2qXMMVFMFoyoFoJVq<>:LVX22?FJ
VFJooMq5M-JJPV,V2JafF&?F |q [|
"*M%*2&WV J F[oJ-"\*M%|
*&JM_V2q - JoF[2J
}>* )
[x
? y*{"}
xu b} |/ G ~ ? y*{"} x": **%&#|
xu }`| b

>VV_F_J! rZV V <FVV8JM\oVqP V2"_Po}MFX,MMVo?V<k


|
M2oJ?8< }>*)
U 2VVFFJoM:
:oFF _JVq vtFJJZF:J<MMV,P}oJFJtV,yMMor
U 2VVFeFVVoBMFq\HRVVFJJ:MoJF:
FMJ:FVFVVV2Mc!8FV>8FV}+M oV JoF+qT \ !JFF) VHV8JV&q o WV
E

x
= x xu
Z

 W

x  W Z E
= x x
8V oF  x =h ~ x $1f yV J 2fx w +iMMq ho\4 x" 1i
FMFVMF2JoM-FV Jo?FoV_ _VoVVV2VVFJJVJ ::.MMJ?F:: MM::
FVMFhFJV G#)
x w == xx 88 xux 
q x
?of
b 2VVF )
x1f ?
&oq F
?* _
2xB" 1 ?
= ?
?q
F[JVe?V_+.FJW[ooo -FV[%<,M?J?JVMFq5V2eVfoy>q\2FVVVy| F o WMVPtq
FF/ J %2*f__VVVJ R,FFqy[LFV<[>FFJ.2VoVoJ5 VJ2JFVF8 rZfJ}.oFF
U 2VVFyVVoFF.>MVVo[FV:L
M2JFJ52MMor
MJ2>oJ8FJJ}<,2FFJMVMyMV8FoFoJVqq,cM!:FLFqV\o+c,V+JoM}FqF Jc!V>` FJ|

cHc "+f!D2  u&~`e


 
  #!#
 '(

M2FVJF"FJo\R?FHP}< J F q?Jo?,VJFo}<,2fVMo> FVJ |

}8V2VJo2o
U [JM+FJP2
8FMoFo>Fq8 J.}MFVq2FFVJFJ
U JV:FJ2FoVVFVUVM
FoFPP+o fVPFMo2[FfoJJFJ Jo?VJF
U -h,?FP}k?JVVyJP22VV}
F2yV}FqJo
U eJV,_>FZV\F8VM
_V}82VV }V
cH cH +& N#
e,$f8#
  &`f!%   !>
rZefVfHZVJfX \F) FVo,F:oFofR[V[MVJyVFFVFV>2h V rV?oF
W

?% 1f
x
[ ?4 N  W WW
F Vo+: VNV _J-+FV[:V+FP.MWJf,, FFoVW kF 2 J MV
F?FPk}FoJ<ky2JMo,2JFqoF!ZMM
to\VfFJR oL[FFJ}Lo:_VqXqXVVJqFVJJV\
FF_VM8toVFqJJF VVok8[o?Jo}oFF2-JP\?8V2VXyJq}MkFVVJPo\Vo<HJVo:FVe22Jo
FJ2JM[8MJ -b\FFo<JF?FtPF}eFFFVJX?$JPk-_qkJfh}VhJF:Po,V2F:VohFqoFVMJo<fM
MJoV2Ff!PFVtVJVFPF![VFJ22VMFo2oJHMooVJMo8}8FVJ
rZVfJHVF,V}VBV[FqV%o) FoLV?J:?JofFL>
WW  ?k

x
WW
[ ?4 N n W `
W
8

}

W
W x JFVyJVJ
W
JJP2Jy8}PFJo8Vo P ?% f

8:<VV-$ VJ\V"F2J VMF&q"J2VFJ2M"ooVo5 _q%*J V_FJqJ\FM%


V}JV
* x n * `
VyoFFJ<fh\FV> f*JfF?}F}VV 8oF\VF<V8JJPJV2\VqF\HXVF_JV2FV.}JJFl of WWV
V_VkM8}oXFVfJFkofVPof8VF>FV8}MVoqFo JqX
[JFVJVq
V+JP:\FFV.Fq\H 2 WW 8fF
FJLVJV2\FFo MFVooPJJMJVeyFJ?<PJVJLJyMFV<FhFJ
FFooFJ0VMF_qMVJJ::8NJFVVo JJ P 2 W  y F J FPoJJVV F  [FV
F2&o:JRJoJ$}VJ[+\FoJF"2F}VqJR8"kMJVFJFq?V ,J ?
FkoFkV2 FW f Je[JMV>8VF J,FVV2_J,:8 V
2 VV
P,FVJ?qVJF\}F2VoFV2FV Fo\FJ8H FW  <J JFFJM
VJ_?JfXqoVF<kHJ ot:fMFFJFVZ2VV\FFV [P}VV8<VFFo_JJ
F}  }WF8JF2JJ\JJ,FXoFFVqF \o58 8J VFJFFM2,oFVoJF\,M8+VFJJV:y<2.2o}Fo
V2q}<FqL8VFFMJMJJ:Jp o F W Fto?JVq5 JVyJ\FoFV
F<JVoF?+oM\:L>HH>FV2MoV2<-V8VP<fJJkMMP}:cFV?2VVJ?VFq5H: JNJ FVVoJkoJ
VMZ F VWW8JV\+V4JoJ?ZFFJ}FM}28yFFVL8VFV[Mr -VH
FJFooF?H+FJeV MJ J o VJJ?8\F,Vy&fFFV_VJVq
5 V[2VVUFJV2FVPJJ8F>LofJV
V4FoJF2VMFq J F
FJ}} JPFJV,o,y!8FFVV+JPV2VVP>FVVM_22?qo\}F
8VfoFF~`V-VVJFV }JV?oJqh<q?oVFyML/qkV2"V
FJJ.?,qFo! \W FJ_FL2.oV$cV?}f2VFqccoJM}+2FJk
JFeVFFJ%F< V* /fF
cH cH~ a!% & !\e,$f #
 
FF JJ,yPMMMFLH2F?,qFVPPFHFPVJo8V2VZ}eX:V8FV+Pf2<Pf[FMMVMJV
FJoF+VqL\VVMF}2V FMeJJ[MVPF}JFF.y2VJ:F!FoJ?eq,PFo2JFVFVP5o8J_
MF-VMqFFoF&VM,F-FV+__FV2f

F8,V PVyV_VcFF,JJ?JHFFJo_F\FyohF>Vo+JF FJ}FV>F:,FoRVJMoh,RFoVVq


JMVVoooV?qF5P MQ >JqFcJFhFMMJF2eoFqoV}2F+VVRooFV[FV"V,oVoFfqFVF?o,}-o}fVoo
VFV2qJh_FFJVV>oFJ2FFqJ?oqFFVVof:_VVFFoo2,fJohPLV,2JFFFPP}oJo}yFJ}VVJMyyFq
+hV+JFM+}<JkF_FVJooF ofFqMJV,Vy}o
_V
FJMF<hVJF+VPVJ2F2P}FFot?VMVJJ[&VJVV8o!2FMVoV\}c_VV}58HV}b>V% )
, J ? $ 8
U eJVyVFhJJJHVoFJ
, O ?  V-VFVoFBMFoF2VoFJ
?F8JP2FPLJ?V2VyFoFJ<R_q\J
U eJVVy}MV _Vo8XJP2F8PJVq
U fPFRFV[2VMP}?qPPVJeV>2VV%
FJ
PVJ2FPH[F[FVJMJo!tFcVoVFFVo2[VFqoP?Vo5JFMV,JVJq
_fFVfJfoJoVfF<HVJV,o4FJoZFqPJ?J&oPRoJ2PJFJo5FoVP
2JJMP}VF,8FF,JJMJFJq5JJoVJoFV8Vo\FT J $JJ JRFJ
Vq<ooV_JVVo_,FVJayFJRX\MFooJFJPVoV Jo>H8} F23 FQ2V>3V9,&
Q 9*JJ VJJ) J\:L.o}2
%*

AD; > X < Y9*J J Q0Gh 9*; | A 3 Q2 3 9_*Q 9*J V Y>"CHQ 9 3 Q 3 9*;
] 9oBJ[J98F], V,4,JPc2VM$FoVMFV'FVFo,PPHF f

FFJJ2okRVVVV J\oFooFJVFMc_qJ2V,FFooJ!J}JBP FJ,?FP


FM2Fq\L:J= -hohJJ\,e& F+VBV}8F-J!}<JJ5FV_$2VVVFVV
F2JJJVP 2?FFJPLFJ<M_JoLVFoF<VW f FV}[>2"MV}8VUVMoFJH
cH cH c |w0 $f"!Y f=  
F>oVJFFV,F JoF2q Fo?FFP} oq[FJVe,FoVeMJFooJ2?qoVJ.JVF?J :+XVVVVF2o J
?ZFFF2FJRVZ5 FJFJ}>y}*) V MV}L VJ 8 ? VLFJ}:F2VJVFLofVMoFVJfFZLV_FVo __ Lc
J?f)
/ ? x & W
 % ** 58 
`

F?JFPe}F_VoVJ_oLPoF2:JFJPLJF<,,= f-hFJ,Fo >JFFVV} +> 2VV<}VM


V2qV<J8f
FJoPVF}VoyMFrM8o!FVVM>q}eVMFq 1V P" q 1.P}F

2
With parameters change
Without parameters change

1.8

Objective function value

1.6
1.4
1.2

x 10

With plateauspeed up
Without plateauspeed up

1
0.8
1.5

0.6
0.4
F6

0.2
1

0 0
10

10

10
Function evaluations

10

10

[H KD&EY %,i 8E* 


J(  #*0ZD>#"E B"b(
i%_#*8` g&#% W__ JiZ i
)B ?" - /. ' m
0 * J iWE _ *Ei*H& 8* VY` VbHEa B T#&8i*#*
_ JiZ i Y )B D? " -: 'k\ C z? " -k '2)B`n? " - /. 'k 0 B*
 i H a, %%H&E i8B? K5 

0.5

0
200

700

1200
step

1700

2200

AD;>X"< D9*JJ Q0Gh 9*; | / ? A 3 Q2 3 9,*Q 9&J V JpQ0G89*; 3 Q 3 9*; [E%LI"GEY _i8^E*%[^iE* *a8*8 H&
] 9B J[98], 4[ 58 V-\JVqMo"VFq?
}><JF V F\?JoMFJFVo!o+J:PfVo}oV,?FFqP}oFBo-tJp Hc cH $  5f !"
& !"
 

qok2F4VJq oL%:<V=,FFo?qV }VFJ\LF8BVF:<JF88M<2F-JooJM?"FFJZ) JF ox


VJ}o,VofXFVJFqJMJ o-_V<FoF&:J
1.1
With plateauspeed up
Without plateauspeed up

y0.9

0.8

0.7
0.7

0.8

0.9
x

1.1

[H ^H * Hiqi*& p
W  [  ^  [   #*
0ZD#"$ %"&('D ? , ? *=$'DX ?" [ 'YV4 "$'1)B`3," -k 
0 R%_,8lB i%hE* *8*8 H& @D <6E'^B
iE& %a %8 H p =&6b<

8-h<FVV\eF<V-_J8JJZV?J&F:_V}F8FFoF2"HVFJVe? FVo}oMqVVc V?oJFJF


FJJ+:<XoFV2VM_PV} oL ?ot>MoJVPoVo
[ X3 V3 Mo? V
?V $J )F}VoVJ-f+V2JFoFV?Q2 9,*FQ J9&J
* ? $
?of

AD;@>@X < D9&J J Q0Gh 9*; | $ Q 3 9*;k]9/J98],A 3 Q2 3 9,*Q 9&J V


FVDJ>D}CHQ o9 3\ [ -FJJF2}J>J?>FJJV?:oHL8VoJFFVVyJFV\MV
V
fJ>2+
FVJJyFP-MkfwJoeW 8 Vo[FJ,FoJ.oF<2VM
W
cH D &z~_`e
 
 aJe T te
"
 !Y &D BE #
 
|
MFV2XoJ?q?\FL?FP}FV}o.FVVPH
f|
o?MFV,oFJVF<J,JF}VJo\
F-tP :q>VV2_JeVJ\JFq:o5 -JFVVVF
FVFVMoF< tPJXff??eFVJ Pyx Vx\ F qJ y !Vk =|
x M 2 J F: J

q o q &q e Q f?o_VFM8 RV JF< o ?
J?VFq:eF2VVyVf }o/ + V x Jo%Rx V**%?&#|R?8JFVyf>

Fc/ $8 xx % x' *%*&W|RfV.oJ?JFJVooFoMqV!JJFFqJ


FJ>M_
VfLMH2:oJJ ?RFyb 4V|>xfV0PJ FqJFcoX8cFJo_Fq\VR}
FkJoM2qyJFHVo?R_VooJFtJ:VJ>L?FMPJ_?F<VoJ_[o<?q
f-V,VqVM
FV y2f,MFMq:~2 VJFJoVko_V
8oJJ\tV},J FJJV?JVPcMof}
>J>VJF+}JFJ
__VVJJyy}


 x N : x

0  x  f x
Q f?ofJFM 8 k
 x N 0  x
Q f?ofJFM8

[*iH\%g 8i %i* E%#&8 JHE8k& 8


i Hi
-

VMVoVFooFFJVoFfP Voq?, VL!%FMV 2,JMFFMo4J>JFJk:.B&VVUVc::VMNJPJJV?JF


<JoV?MqVRUV+oVFVqMoo F_UVV2 e FP}2VFJ},o,JFFoFq
?eFPM}FoV V?oFP }:FP2JP,Fo J8_<Uq"f8FMFMJFoJ5
V_V}}8o q}VFJc ?VFJV! J,MFoFF2JJVo 2oqU*/cVof
JVFJVFFVFJMFV
F2J_JoJ\J&F5oFF?VVF}PF}%,FoFMVV+_?VVJJ\<J JoFoF"V'oF?2Fo} qMF%!L?o2VB M
VJJFo8JJrFoHqoo}& ) :L'Fq: VJ\J F&P"
b
w = #VB xB = y&{"}f~5 , k ! y&{"}fr5 ,VF

8F+2V2Mo}Fq`uqfx VV?J `u ~
= WM4 xq n }| r = 2  & ~Mk
8Fv +V-2JV2MyoF}JFq-J\JV fFJFBP"oo "V JFJ
F= 2-hqJFVo JMIF2-h oMFoqX5FV2}JFFVVFJ JVkB :
JFFVJF.FFVJ
FoFPPc
fe2>FVJJJ.L 2?FVP}V -V?FFJ.FVM2V?FJ8F.FJ
cH R +f!"
Z0  
  ! E' !"
 
FFJF-J ?q\F L82J?F&JVVPJo\FoFMPV?2FP}P}M
F/r<V.?FPJ}8F 4 +.>}r<}V\JV[~FFFJ2VRMFP}o?FqV

5
4
3
2
1
y 0
1
2
3
4
5
5

0
x

[H , " % WEti*k] 
J> "n
kLu,"7
_?&" -:=[ ` 20
k. 1<E 4 " 70??" "-:X 7 _;&  =`2,"$4 "$( % A C  #&K5+4 I070%,Z"" 3 l<E' i<&_(0'm )*
,^=L"7 ," X L *i*_H_iE*H&D *i*&`Z
H%%pZi H
20

10

10

20
20

10

0
x

10

20

[H k* Hii*&p b
g
 p   ._ 9 7
 ,  /<`"
 F   ._  _& 4 "b(  #* 0Z D <5' <('&)?" -:[ 0 . 
<E4 "*7Y, " -:X B;1HE4 "^7, "  A C   4 KI^7Y? " @ 4i0W%,?" 9 
**iHL&H& D n i*  wHi%Z i



FVP}VJJ&JJ\ FVM,oJMJcF!JV F'V Q Vf ?VokfJFMPM8-o-Fo_VfVJ\Fqo:H ZV2J\?


FFVP FV:rLFq FV Fo + ?8orL tV4 M Q
e_J FPoVJo+F8?JVFoF2J<ooVoVoo
c}o_fVkJo?>FP}>.FoJo}eFJJV}o_._t&?

eJFJ+?FoF2ooo
ofkXFV+Lr cJFV +.8
rL&JF:>M
f,VV}FFoVV

eV J[+c3+/rL5V ,?ofH 985>D;JpV<KJiq?Xo>"J[] J > ?VQ02; >DCf_C XiMA 5


F2VJ8:FPofFXo fPVJMFHV VoFnx hLoFLFJ rZ; < 7?G FJ<KoJ < >D CHM<=>"JEFV\ X FqVM +.V
eJFJFJ o?q?BFoF2!ooo MFU?:o_Foo 8V

2>H?FP}Fooo
VVMq PD M,2o}oo} }28JM } *^FV 7J2MQ0P;W}A8FP:98>"J )

r< +.>r<

_VJy}
 "
?BADJX"; 9 383 ADJ J V 9*CKCH<EXi9&J V Mp986 70J </*Q 9 3 >"J] F A V ?BADG 5
5 `

R
R
x

[
P
Q V <KJXD^ ; A%689898]D<KJiX 3
_VJy 
[ JV 5 8/F rL53 V :q3\fB+\P V_] >8+P ZV > FV q<=FADoJ <KJ > V Q0;W>DC>DJ]
Q f?ofJFM8k 0 x x R
_; < 46*<=>DC O 9*G

VPf<F ore / VrL 5 ? ofJ _2 DADCE Q V <=A"J>"J] P V <KGQ0G


Q f?ofJFM8  x w x

9 9 "<KJiX
b
[*iHw"L&H&T* Z:W,D& EZ &H&T#&8H8 b J?oofL>L4 J+.MFVVo F2FeQ Fq:eVLVJ
LFJJ!o e; JA%6898o98]DJ<K JiX J3
JH"i%08B JiWEi
2<JPFV.FFV["FVV82q:.VM?VZFVV}P>XrLJ"}ZJFV"[F V& oo?? XiA AD; V 7:< V 97G F < 3\ V 7 J V 9&; J[> V <=ADJ[>DC?A"J 9*;W9*J689ADJ 9&J[9 V <=6D_C 5
+.>r<cJ ?2F-FV<P:ooFJ[
_V oM?FP}o!MF2oV4FJ}
F}VVJ@J-JBFVe.o oFFVVJoFRFV+F r< q 2 +.8rL
F
F J+.o> F r<
R V 2Q JPF_VV2_88VFJVFr< -VM}4<PJ?.F&& FJ
> SZQe^5= E a_7?SZQ[a
b VFq?ofFo VM2o}?FP}cJFo
2M2MMJ[FJ,\MMor[LPVoV,o_oq+fP?F2FVVcyM 2o}:L
FJL2FFMJJM FVVFFJJqP+.V2FhMVVFo}Fqo+FVk_J.PVV2JMFo P-J?>VR}M8FVV[VoeM
2r}eJJ\FFVoF- FyVFe2VM}2qq2JFVJM! ?VFe??FPJ}FVoP
Fqo:JeZVVJFFoJ?eq?5V}J>[yJVFF:<8<oP?FFoJFFVFy?:FofoFo
2>V-oJf!Mo?JFtV2MFMqV}FVeJyFV,[JFVJJ,_J?FFoH5<?JFP8V}Foh: 2FV :2VM2o
FJ2y2M2o}oFV2fFVyVJM5M2MFJ}yJ8Z}+?F
@HNP@HGV@Qe^
@a
<oFPVeoFP>VJ<}8JHeMFo f:q.fFV\ MV22JFP}JMXFP8 of?
VJ1 > V Q0;W9&^GDADC$
JofVh:qJp -<\ rZ<
PJr2Q P}M <SH}MoJJ2 oX+t?o_JD 1o_FFJ_
Mof8F 2MMPV2F V P}MV F}P ?oFV
ADQ0; J[>DCA QP[;W>DGIADCL986*Q0CL>D; ; Q 6 Q0;W9&^DADC