Report

Chandigarh Network Benchmarking Report
Content
Overview Coverage footprint comparison On Road coverage Network performance (KPI) Speech Quality (MOS)
Data network performance

In Building Tests Observations
Benchmarking Summary
2 05 April 2012
Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0
Chandigarh Network Overview

INDIA
Chandigarh
Operator
Subscribers (Circle wide) Band of May11 Figures Benchmarked Technology operation (Ref-COAI) GSM GSM GSM GSM CDMA 1800 900 900 1800 850 4101191 6457496 4450870 NA NA
Population: 1,054,686 (2010) Area : 114 sq. km
Vodafone Essar Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom

3 05 April 2012
Benchmarking Testing Overview

Date & time of testing From 14th March 2012 to 26th March 9.00 A.M to 9.00 P.M Monday to Saturday 500kms (approximately) Coverage footprint (Idle mode) KPI performance (dedicated mode) Tests done Vodafone PRI lines used Speech Quality (MOS) Data network Tests In Building Tests
Coimbatore Total 4 Zones

Zones Division
Drive distance
~558 calls(call duration 90 sec) per operator Long calls Continuous call Test Call pattern
Speech quality Continuous call

Data calls Continuous cycle Buildings tested 25
Drive Route
4 05 April 2012
Areas Included in Each Zone

Zone 1:
Mohali Stadium Shahi Villa MC Office Fortis hospital Ivy Hospital Silvi Park Sukhna Path Franco hotel road
Zone 3:
Sukhna path
Purv Marg
Udyog Path Sarovar Path
Forest complex
Zone 4:
NH 21
Zone 2:
pashim marg Vidhya path Himalya marg Sarover path NH 21
NH 22 Town park Catcus park
Drive Route
5 05 April 2012 Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0
On Drive - Test Sequence

Idle Drive Voice Service
Short Call
End of Drive Test
Data Service
Continuous Call
Voice Call Mobile to Mobile (Duration 90 secs) Idle(10 secs Pause) Idle Mode Voice Call Mobile to Mobile (Duration 90 secs) Idle(10 secs Pause) Voice Call Mobile to Mobile (Duration 90 secs)
Start of Drive Test
Voice Call Mobile to PSTN (Continuous Call till Drop)
Data Session
10 secs Pause Data Session
Idle(10 secs Pause)
Voice Call Mobile to PSTN (Continuous Call till Drop)
10 secs Pause
Data Session
6 05 April 2012
In Building- Test Sequence

Idle Mode Voice Service
Continuous Call
End of Drive Test
HTTP Test
Voice Call Mobile to Mobile (Continuous Call till Drop)
Data Session
10 secs Pause Data Session
Idle Mode
Idle(10 secs Pause)
Voice Call Mobile to Mobile (Continuous Call till Drop)
10 secs Pause
Data Session
Start of Drive Test
Each Test Sequence has been performed for 10 min/ floor

On Drive Data Test Sequence

Attach & PDP Activation Detach & PDP Deactivation
FTP DL
FTP UL
HTTP
Ping
Test Details: FTP DL FTP UL HTTP Ping
1 MB File.server name-ftp.compaq.com 300 KB File.Server name-ftp://202.67.6.14 (TechMahindra FTP Server) www.yahoo.com www.yahoo.com (Payload-32B) tests.
In Building Data Test Sequence

Attach & PDP Activation HTTP Detach & PDP De-activation
Test Details: HTTP www.yahoo.com

Nemo Outdoor / MOS Server Setup

Nemo Outdoor is known for being the pioneer in drive test measurement solutions, offering a broad range of testing options and support for all the newest technologies. Nemo Outdoor comes with an incomparable support for over 220 terminals and scanning receivers. Nemo Outdoor with Multi or Multi Lite allows benchmarking measurements on any combination of wireless technologies and can be connected to up to eight (8) test devices (terminals, scanners, and a GPS receiver) at a time. The measurement files are produced in an open ASCII file format. Files can be exported directly to Nemo Analyze and to various third party post-processing tools.
Nemo Drive Test Tool
HUB
PSTN Card
5-PSTN Lines
Mobile Network
Nemo MOS Server

Comparison of Original and degraded Audio samples
Coverage Footprint ( Idle Mode)
Rx Level
>= -60 -60 dBm to -70 dBm -70 dBm to -85 dBm -85 dBm to -95 dBm < -95 dBm
Benchmark
Good indoor coverage Suburban indoor coverage In-car coverage Outdoor coverage Poor coverage
Note: In-Car Coverage for Coverage Footprints
10 05 April 2012
Coverage Footprint
Vodafone Essar Airtel
Bad Coverage Patch (Below -85 dBm) indicating areas with likely indoor coverage issues.
Coverage Footprint
Idea Docomo
Opp Carmel Convt school Opp Golf Course
Near NH 21
Bad Coverage Patch (Below -85 dBm) indicating areas with likely indoor coverage issues.
Coverage Footprint
Rcom CDMA
Near Udyog path Opp sukhna lake Near Housing Board Chowk
Opp Town park
Bad Coverage Patch Opp sec 66 Near NH 21 (Below -85 dBm) indicating areas with likely indoor coverage issues.
Coverage Comparison Summary

100
% of Samples
0.02 6.69
0.02 10.01 31.02
0.25
11.43
2.72 48.70
80 60 40 20 0
25.13 37.36
33.53
38.23
59.76
58.94
50.33
32.60
37.26 15.98
VE
Airtel
>-60dBm >-70 to <-60dBm
Idea
>-85 to <-70dBm
Docomo
>-95 to <-85 dBm
Rcom CDMA
Vodafone Essar has got the best Coverage in Chandigarh.

Coverage Comparison SummaryZone Wise

Zone 1
100
% of samples
Zone 2
0.00 9.93
39.30
0.00 4.84
34.29
0.00 7.64
30.77
samples
80
0.10 19.72 39.56
1.06 40.06
60 40 20 0
VE
>-60dBm
60.87
61.59
% of
37.13 50.77 40.62 21.75
100 80 60 40 20 0
0.1 10.2 33.6
0.10 15.88 30.26
0.02 14.19 37.40
0.53 30.62
2.98 56.03
35.53 56.2 53.76 48.40 33.32 25.42 15.57
Airtel
>-70 to <-60dBm
Idea
Docomo Rcom CDMA

>-95 to <-85
VE
>-60dBm
Airtel
>-70 to <-60dBm
Idea
Docomo Rcom CDMA

>-95 to <-85
>-85 to <-70dBm
>-85 to <-70dBm
Zone 3
100
80
% of samples
0.00 7.58 8.49 32.26 0.06 12.57 36.82 37.41 58.43 59.25 50.55 26.90 35.12 0.31 27.16 5.82
Zone 4
100
0.00 4.68 32.28 0.00 8.81 31.17 0.00 9.44 39.11 36.27 0.10 25.04 58.31 2.94
60 40 20
0
VE Airtel
52.06
% of samples
34.00
80 60
40 20 0
63.04
60.01
51.45
38.59
27.52 11.23 Rcom CDMA
Idea
Docomo
15.22 Rcom CDMA >-95 to <-85
VE >-60dBm
Airtel >-70 to <-60dBm
Idea
Docomo
>-60dBm
>-70 to <-60dBm
>-85 to <-70dBm
>-85 to <-70dBm
>-95 to <-85
Vodafone Essar has best coverage in all the four Zones in Chandigarh.
Areas with poor Indoor Coverage
Vodafone Essar
None
Airtel
None
16 05 April 2012
Voice Network KPI Performance (Dedicated Mode)

KPI performance tested by : Short calls ( 90 secs duration) Long calls ( Continuous call) KPI benchmarked Call Setup Failure (SDCCH,TCH) Call Drops (TCH) Handover Success Speech Quality Rx Quality downlink for GSM FER for CDMA Call set up time
Call Performance - Summary

600 500 558 558 565 568 566
400
300
200
100 0
17
18
Call Attempt
Voda
Call Setup Failure

Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom CDMA
Call Drop
Call Drop Rate (KPI <=2%)
0.54 0.91 1.43 3.27 0.71
Operator
Vodafone Essar Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom CDMA
Call Setup Failure Rate (KPI <=2%)

0.36 1.43 0.71 2.99 0.00
Vodafone Essar has Best Accessibility and Retain ability amongst GSM operators.

KPI performance analysis reports based on : Short calls ( 90 Sec duration)
19 05 April 2012
Call Performance - Zone Wise

Zone 1
200
168 166 170 168 162
100
Call Attempt
Call Setup Failure
Call Drop
Voda Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom CDMA
200 150
121 125 126 129
Zone 2
153
100
50
0
1 1
Call Attempt
Voda Airtel
Call Setup Failure

Idea Docomo
Call Drop
Rcom CDMA
Drive Route
20 05 April 2012
Call Performance - Zone Wise

Zone 3
200
128 130 136 129
124
100
2 8 0 2 5 1
0 3
0 0
Call Attempt
Call Setup Failure
Call Drop
200 150
141 143 142 139 115
Zone 4
100
50
0 3
1
0 0
2 3 2
Call Attempt
Voda
21 05 April 2012
Call Setup Failure

Airtel Idea Docomo
Call Drop
Rcom CDMA
Drive Route
Call Performance Zone 1

Zone 1
200 168 166 168 170
162
100
2 0
Call Attempt
Voda Airtel
Call Setup Failure

Idea Docomo
Call Drop
Rcom CDMA
Operator
Call Setup Failure Rate Call Drop Rate (KPI (KPI <=2%) <=2%)
Vodafone Essar
Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom CDMA
1.19
0.60 0.00 1.76 0.00
0.60
0.00 0.60 1.80 0.62
Vodafone Essar has Good Accessibility and Retain ability amongst GSM operators.
Call Setup Failure Zone 1 (VE)

Receive Level Plot Showing 2 Call Setup Failure
Sec 49-50 Dividing Road
Call Setup Failure
Between Phase 10 and sec 68 Mohali
23 05 April 2012
Detail Analysis of Call Setup Failure Zone 1 (VE)
S.NO
Call Failure 1 Call Failure 2
CID
61233 61202
Reason
Failed, No Progress after Call Confirmed/Proceeding
Failed, No DCCH Request
Place
Chandigarh -Zone 1 (Mohali )
Chandigarh -Zone 1 (Mohali )
Observation : Call Setup Failure has occurred due to unavailability of Resources .
24 05 April 2012
Call Drop Zone 1 (VE)

Receive Quality Plot Showing 1 Call Drop
Near Police Colony
Rx Quality 0 and 1 2 to 5 6 & above
Dropped Call(Network release)
25 05 April 2012
Detail Analysis of Call Drop Zone 1 (VE)
S.NO
CID
RLT
TA
Rx Level Rx Qual
Place
Call Drop 1
61093
32
-77
Zone 1 -Chd (Mohali)
Observation : Drop has occurred due to poor Receive Quality.
26 05 April 2012

200 150 100 50 0
Zone 2
153 121 125
126
129
0
Call Attempt
Voda Airtel
Call Setup Failure

Idea Docomo
Call Drop
Rcom CDMA
Operator
Vodafone Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom CDMA

0.00 0.80 0.79 4.65 0.00

0.83 2.42 2.40 5.69 0.00
Vodafone Essar has best Accessibility and Retain ability amongst GSM operators.
Near sec 42-43 Chowk
28 05 April 2012
S.NO
CID
RLT
TA
Rx Level Rx Qual
Place
Call Drop 1
61642
28
-88
Zone 2 -Chd (Mohali)
29 05 April 2012

Zone 3
200
128
100
124
130 136 129
Call Attempt Voda

Operator
Vodafone Airtel Idea Docomo
Call Setup Failure Airtel Idea Docomo
Call Drop Rcom CDMA

0.00 2.42 1.55 6.15

0.00 0.00 1.57 4.10
Rcom CDMA
0.00
0.74
Vodafone Essar has excellent Accessibility and Retainability amongst all operators.

200
150 100 50 0 Call Attempt Voda Airtel
Zone 4
141 143 142 139 115
Call Setup Failure Idea Docomo
Call Drop Rcom CDMA
Operator

0.00 2.10 0.70 0.00 0.00

0.71 1.43 1.42 2.16 1.74
Vodafone Essar has best Accessibility and Retain ability amongst GSM operators.
Call Drop Zone 4 (VE)

Receive Quality Plot Showing 1 Call Drop
Rx Quality 0 and 1 2 to 5 6 & above Near Indira Colony
Dropped Call(Network release)
32 05 April 2012
S.NO
CID
RLT
TA
Rx Level Rx Qual
Place
Call Drop 1
60371
28
-70
Zone 4 -PKL
33 05 April 2012
Call Setup Time(CST)

Call Setup Time (Seconds)
Zones Zone 1 Zone 2 Zone 3 Zone 4 City-wide
VE
5.0 5.1 5 4.9 5
Airtel
4.95 5.21 5.78 5.16 5.2
Idea
5.14 5.16 5.25 5.05 5.15
Docomo
5.26 5.33 5.49 5.15 5.3
Rcom CDMA
8.4 5.89 4.28 3.9 6.02
Vodafone Essar has least Call setup time .

Call Setup Time (CST) Detailed Analysis
Docomo Idea Airtel VE 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
CM_SERVICE_REQUEST AUTHENTICATION_RESPONSE ALERTING
CHANNEL_REQUEST CALL_PROCEEDING
IMMEDIATE_ASSIGNMENT ASSIGNMENT_COMMAND
Time in Sec
Vodafone Essar has least Call Setup Time amongst GSM operators in Chandigarh. Maximum Time is taken in Assignment command.
KPI performance analysis reports based on : Long calls ( Continuous call) PESQ Test
36 05 April 2012
Receive Signal Quality (DL)

Vodafone Essar
Opp Carmel Convt school Near Madhya Marg
Airtel
Zone 1 MHL Near Housing Board
Poor Signal Quality (Rx Qual >5)
Near Sukhna path Opp sec 66
Opp Town park
Near NH 21 Zone 1 MHL
Near Sec 5 PKL
Definition: Rx Qual (DL) samples of 6 & 7 considered poor in GSM

Receive Signal Quality(DL)

Idea
Opp Madhya Marg Road Near Madhya Marg
Docomo
Opp Sukhna Lake
Opp Dolphin Chowk
Poor Signal Quality (Rx Qual >5) Rx Quality 0 and 1 2 to 5 6 & above Near NH 21
Opp Sec 66 Mohali
Opp Sec 66 Mohali Near NH 21
Definition: Rx Qual (DL) samples of 6 & 7 considered poor in GSM

Receive Signal Quality (DL)

Rcom CDMA
Poor Signal Quality (FER >4)
FER 0 and 1 2 to 4 5 & above
Definition: Samples worse than FER 4 poor in CDMA

Receive Quality Summary

GSM Operators
100
CDMA
7.3 7.4
100
80
Percentage
3.8
5.6
1.7
Percentage
80 60
60
98.3 40
40
20 0
96.2
94.4
92.7
92.6
20
0
VE
Airtel
0 to 5 >5
Idea
Docomo
Rcom CDMA
0 to 4 >4
Benchmarks:
Receive Quality KPI for Hopping N/W: 95% of the samples <= 5
FER KPI for CDMA Network: 95% of the samples <=4
Vodafone Essar has best RX Quality in Chandigarh among GSM operators .
40 05 April 2012
Receive Quality DL- Zone-wise

GSM Operators
100%
3.7 4.9 8.3 9.0 3.6 4.8 6.3 4.7 3.9
7.4
8.5
6.3
4.3
5.8
4.9
8.9
80% 60% 40%

20%
96.3 95.1 91.8 91.0
96.4 95.3 93.7 95.3
96.1 92.6 91.5 93.7
95.7 94.2 95.1 91.2
0%
VE Airtel Idea Docomo Zone1 VE Airtel Idea Docomo Zone 2 VE Airtel Idea Docomo Zone 3 VE Airtel Idea Docomo Zone 4
Rx Qual 0 to 5
Benchmarks:
Receive Quality KPI for Hopping N/W: 95% of the samples <= 5
Vodafone Essar has Best RX Quality in all the zones in Chandigarh.
41 05 April 2012
Areas with Poor Receive Quality

Vodafone Essar
Zone 1 Mohali
Airtel
Zone 1 Mohali
Opp Carmel Covt School Near Sukhna Lake Opp Town Park Opp Sec 66 Mohali
Cell IDs having Rx quality >5 60614 60561 60281 61464 65121 61641 62963 64753 60711 64643 65531 62541 65321
Near NH 21 Near Housing Board Near Sec 5 PKL
Handover Success Rate
Operator Handover Attempt

Vodafone Airtel Idea Docomo 2336 1749 1749 1349
Handover Failure
42 22 28 22
HOFR %
1.8 1.3 1.6 1.6
HOSR%
98.2 98.7 98.4 98.4
Benchmark: Handover success rate should be 95%
Vodafone Essar has Good HSR ,is satisfying the benchmarking criteria.
Handover Success Rate

GSM Operators
100
1.0
0.4
0.4
1.9
1.2
2.5
1.1
0.0
1.3
2.5
0.9
0.2
1.1
1.0
1.1
0.2
Percentage
80
60
99.0 99.6 99.6 98.1 98.8 97.5 98.9 100.0
98.7 97.5 99.1 99.8
98.9 99.0 98.9 99.8
40
20
0
VE Airtel Idea Docomo
Zone 1
VE
Airtel Idea Docomo

Zone 2
VE
Airtel Idea Docomo

Zone 3
VE
Airtel Idea Docomo

Zone 4
Benchmark: Handover success rate should be 95%
Vodafone Essar has Good HSR in all the zones , is satisfying the benchmarking criteria.
Rx Quality Plot Showing Handover Failures For VE
Handover Failure
Vodafone Essar has 42 handover failures. Maximum handover failures occurred in Cell ID : 60941 and 61464 .
Handover Failure Details of VE

HO Status
HO Failed 1 HO Failed 2 HO Failed 3 HO Failed 4 HO Failed 5 HO Failed 6 HO Failed 7 HO Failed 8 HO Failed 9 HO Failed 10 HO Failed 11 HO Failed 12
CID
61853 61862 60913 60913 61383 61623 61722 62621 61641 60954 62541 64893
Lat.
76.7360 76.7367 76.7247 76.7230 76.8146 76.7692 76.7641 76.8011 76.7467 76.7230 76.7272 76.7853
Long .
30.7182 30.7064 30.6990 30.6986 30.7203 30.7252 30.7058 30.7291 30.7324 30.7423 30.7464 30.7464
Place
Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh
HO Failed 13
HO Failed 14
61973
64633
76.7782
76.7346
30.7558
30.7279
Chandigarh
Chandigarh
HO Failed 15
HO Failed 16
61641
61641
76.7491
76.7496
30.7333
30.7336
Chandigarh
Chandigarh
HO Failed 17
HO Failed 18
62321
60941
76.7611
76.7365
30.7420
30.7238
Chandigarh
Chandigarh
HO Failed 19
HO Failed 20 HO Failed 21 HO Failed 22 HO Failed 23 HO Failed 24 HO Failed 25
46 05 April 2012
60941
60941 60941 62312 62312 61642 64683
76.7364
76.7362 76.7360 76.7309 76.7314 76.7448 76.8472
30.7240
30.7242 30.7244 30.7308 30.7313 30.7215 30.7179
Chandigarh
Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh
Handover Failure Details of VE

HO Status
HO Failed 26 HO Failed 27 HO Failed 28 HO Failed 29 HO Failed 30 HO Failed 31 HO Failed 32 HO Failed 33 HO Failed 34 HO Failed 35
CID
65211 65443 65322 60242 60582 65321 61464 61464 61464 61464
Lat.
76.8501 76.8214 76.8402 76.8371 76.8384 76.8345 76.8014 76.8013 76.8009 76.8008
Long .
30.6963 30.7112 30.6746 30.6962 30.7047 30.6792 30.7015 30.7016 30.7018 30.7018
Place
Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh
HO Failed 36
HO Failed 37 HO Failed 38 HO Failed 39 HO Failed 40 HO Failed 41 HO Failed 42
61464
65313 61831 62842 64961 61622 61751
76.8006
76.8106 76.7667 76.7762 76.7804 76.7690 76.7641
30.7020
30.7128 30.7082 30.7312 30.7218 30.7254 30.7236
Chandigarh
Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh
Observation : Handover Failures may have occurred due to poor Receive Quality, Hardware Issues, improper Neighbor relations , Improper resource management and even due to Hardware issue .
PESQ Tests- MOS DL

Idea Docomo
48 05 April 2012
PESQ Tests- MOS DL

Rcom CDMA
49 05 April 2012
MOS DL Summary
GSM Operators
100
Percentage
10.1
CDMA
9.5
16.7
100
4.7
8.5
Percentage
80 60 40
20 0
80 60
89.9
91.5
90.5
83.3
40 20 0
95.3
VE
Airtel
MOS
>=3.5
Idea
< 3.5
Docomo
MOS
RCom CDMA
>=3.5 <3.5
Benchmarks: MOS KPI for Hopping N/W: 95% of the samples >= 3.5 95.8% MOS KPI for CDMA Network: 95% of the samples >=3.5
Vodafone Essar has good MOS DL values in Chandigarh.

MOS DL- Cluster wise

100%
80%
11.8 6.0 12.0
16.1
7.0
9.3
6.9
16.7
10.9
10.6
11.5
17.8
10.0
9.4
6.7
17.0
60%
40%
88.2
94.0
88.0
83.9
93.0
90.7
93.1
83.3
89.1
89.4
88.5
82.2
90.0
90.6
93.3
83.0
20% 0%
VE Airtel Idea Docomo
Zone 1
VE
Airtel
Idea Docomo
Zone 2
VE
Airtel
Idea Docomo
Zone 3
VE
Airtel
Idea Docomo
Zone 4
MOS>=3.5
Benchmarks:
MOS KPI for Hopping N/W: 95% of the samples >= 3.5 MOS KPI for CDMA Network: 95% of the samples >=3.5
Vodafone Essar has good MOS in all the zones .

MOS UL- Summary

GSM Operators
100 17.2
CDMA
18.2 18.3
Percentage
8.9
100 80
80
Percentage
60
40
20
82.8
91.1
81.8
81.7
60
82.7
40
20 0
Voda
Airtel
Idea
Docomo
17.3
Rcom CDMA
MOS
>=3.5 <3.5
MOS
>=3.5 < 3.5
Benchmarks: MOS KPI for Hopping N/W: 95% of the samples >= 3.5 MOS KPI for CDMA Network: 95% of the samples >=3.5 97.7% 93.9%
Vodafone Essar has good MOS UL values among all the operators.
MOS DL & UL Combined Summary

GSM Operators CDMA
100
Percentage
13.7
8.7
13.85
60 40 20 0 86.3
91.3
86.15
82.5
Percentage
80
17.5
100 80 60 40
20
43.7
56.3
Voda
MOS
Airtel
>=3.5 <3.5
Idea
Docomo
0
MOS
Rcom CDMA
>=3.5 < 3.5
Benchmarks: MOS KPI for Hopping N/W: 95% of the samples >= 3.5 96.5%
MOS KPI for CDMA Network: 95% of the samples >=3.5
Vodafone Essar has good MOS UL and DL in chandigarh.

Average MOS DL & UL
Average MOS
5 4 3.5 3 2 1 0 3.8
3.82 3.7
3.9
3.79
3.7
3.7 3.7
3.9 3
Voda
Airtel
Idea
DL UL
Docomo
Rcom
Vodafone Essar has good MOS DL and UL Average values in Chandigarh.
54 05 April 2012
Receive Quality DL Vs. MOS DL For VE

Rx Quality DL
Opp Carmel Convt school
MOS DL
Zone 1 MHL
Near Sukhna path
Opp Town park
Opp sec 66
AMR/ Non-AMR Mode For VE and Airtel

56 05 April 2012
AMR Codec Wise Plot

Vodafone Airtel
57 05 April 2012
AMR Codec Wise Plot

Idea Docomo
58 05 April 2012
Speech Version Distribution for VE & Airtel

AMR Full Rate, Half Rate, EFR Distribution
17.2 41.8
82.8 58.2
VE
AMR-FR
AMR-HR
Airtel
Vodafone Essar has got 58.2 % of samples in full rate AMR.

MOS ANALYSIS
60 05 April 2012
Carrier to Interference Plot
Rx Quality Plot
1 6 7 5 7
8
2 4
2 4
61 05 April 2012
FER
AMR Codec Plot
6 1
7 5
62 05 April 2012
C/I V/S MOS DL Distribution

Sample Distribution
MOS DL
<6 >=6 and <9 C/I >=9 and<12 >=12 and <15
<2.5
12 17 29 49
>=2.5 to <3
110 116 151 210
>=3 to<3.5
208 191 285 423
>=3.5
1056 1066 1755 3618
>=15
115
746
% Distribution
1439
14926
MOS DL <6 >=6 and <9
<2.5 5% 8% 13% 22% 52% 100%
>=2.5 to <3 8% 9% 11% 16% 56% 100%
>=3 to<3.5 8% 8% 11% 17% 57% 100%
>=3.5 5% 5% 8% 16% 67% 100%
C/I
>=9 and<12 >=12 and <15 >=15 Total
63 05 April 2012
In-Building Testing
Coverage inside building
Receive signal quality on call

Data Throughput testing
64 05 April 2012
In-building Locations over Chandigarh Drive Route

Building Name Apollo hospital Archies gallery Dainik bhaskar DT Mall GMCH Hospital Park inn hotel Sindhi Surya office Taj hotel Taw hotel Vodafone office Intellenet Distt court DLF building Fun republic IVY hospital Western court JW MARRIOTT Nando's Hotel memorable moment Pepsico Tech mahindra Vodafone store Voodoo Homtel
Coverage & Receive Quality Summary

25
No. of Buildings
0 9 16 25
16 9 9 10
25
20
No. of Buildings
0
12 25
20 15 10 5
0
11
12
16
15
15 10 5 0
20 13 14 13
5 VE Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom
VE
Airtel
Idea Docomo Rcom
Coverage Presence
Quality Presence
No. of Buildings Tested 25 Criteria :

Coverage ( 90% samples with Rx level > -85 dBm ) Quality ( 95% of samples should have RX quality 5 for GSM ; FER 4 for CDMA )
Vodafone Essar has got the best In-building Coverage & Quality in Chandigarh.
66 05 April 2012
Details
Building Name
Apollo hospital Archies gallery Dainik bhaskar DT Mall GMCH Hospital Park inn hotel Sindhi Surya office Taj hotel Taw hotel Vodafone office Intellenet Distt court DLF building Fun republic IVY hospital Western court JW MARRIOTT Nando's Hotel memorable moment Pepsico Tech mahindra Vodafone store Voodoo Homtel
Coverage VE Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom VE Airtel
Quality Idea Docomo Rcom
Walk Tested Area

Ground Ground First & Ground floor Basement1 & Basement2 Basement & Ground floor Ground Ground Ground Basement & Ground floor Ground First floor First & Ground floor First & Ground floor Basement & Ground floor First & Ground floor Ground Ground Basement & Ground floor Ground Ground Ground Ground & Basement Ground Ground Ground
Objective achieved Objective not achieved

In-Building Data Testing Summary
Operator
In- Building with HTTP Request Success Ratio >= 50%
In-Buildings with Average HTTP Throughput >= 9.6kbps 24
VE Airtel Idea
25 18 17
17 15
Docomo
RCOM
No. of Buildings Tested 25
14
24
15
22
Vodafone Essar has got the best In Building Coverage and Quality in Chandigarh.
In-Building Data Testing Details

Building Name
Apollo hospital Archies gallery Dainik bhaskar DT Mall GMCH Hospital Park inn hotel Sindhi Surya office Taj hotel Taw hotel Vodafone office Intellenet Distt court DLF building Fun republic IVY hospital Western court JW MARRIOTT Nando's Hotel memorable moment Pepsico Tech mahindra Vodafone store Voodoo Homtel
HTTP Success Ratio VE

100 100 78.6 100 96.7 100 85.7 90.9 93.5 80 100 76.5 70.8 63 84.6 92.3 73.3 84.6 75 83.3 92.9 88.2 70 100 90.9
HTTPThroughput Rcom
66.7 85.7 87 73.9 86.7 50 77.8 88.9 80 90 100 87.5 82.4 83.3 66.7 80 90.9 81.8 91.7 0 100 71.4 88.9 66.7 90
Airtel
40 100 83.3 100 93.1 100 83.3 100 68.8 86.7 62.5 76.2 28.6 88.9 55.6 33.3 66.7 90 0 0 100 77.8 33.3 0 85.7
Idea
100 0 83.3 0 0 0 0 57.1 0 100 75 63.6 66.7 0 87 50 83.3 62.5 100 80 50 55.6 88.9 60 33.3
Docomo
0 92.3 80 71.4 0 0 84.6 92.9 83.3 0 44.4 86.4 95.2 90.9 88.9 25 0 0 0 0 66.7 82.1 0 86.7 66.7
VE
40.3 16.2 37.8 37.9 38.5 27.7 21.6 39.5 52.5 30.5 18.1 25.6 89.5 82.8 94 33.6 76.9 24.4 8 46.4 61.8 87.9 29.7 44.9 49.7
Airtel
15.6 2.3 14.2 31.3 62.5 8.3 23 2.7 46.1 48.2 24.8 46.7 5.6 31.3 16.2 1.8 23.3 34.3 0 0 36.2 8.8 28.5 0 48.7
Idea
13.8 0 13.7 0 0 0 0 28 0 3.4 18.9 13.7 41 0 52.5 11.4 15.7 8.1 30.4 14.9 13.2 20.1 17.5 24.4 3.5
Docomo
0 54.2 45.6 3.9 0 0 43.9 55.9 55.1 0 37.8 22 41.9 31.6 33.8 30.9 0 0 0 0 26 53 0 62.5 31.3
Rcom
14.8 23.3 51 41.6 38.9 8.2 38.4 24.4 4.8 28.1 47.6 37.7 44.8 32.5 40.5 46.7 39.5 37.4 52.1 0 37.2 44.7 18.5 17.7 40.7
Walk Tested Area

Ground Ground First & Ground floor Basement1 & Basement2 Basement & Ground floor Ground Ground Ground Basement & Ground floor Ground First floor First & Ground floor First & Ground floor Basement & Ground floor First & Ground floor Ground Ground Basement & Ground floor Ground Ground Ground Ground & Basement Ground Ground Ground
For VE all the 25 buildings have HTTP Request Success Ratio >=50%. For VE 24 Buildings have Average HTTP Throughput >=9.6kbps.
Data Network Performance

FTP Throughput (1 MB file download from ftp.compaq.com & 300 KB file upload to the TechMahindra FTP Server-ftp://202.67.6.14) HTTP Throughout
(website used: www.yahoo.com for all operators)
70 05 April 2012
Data Performance- Insight

100
3.7 4.3 10.3
5.9
Percentage
200
80 60 40 20 0
100
164
161 132 96
95.7
89.7
96.3
94.1
VE
Airtel Idea Attach attempts

2.3 0.6
Docomo
VE
Airtel
Idea
Docomo
PDP Context Activation Success PDP Context Activation Failures
100
Percentage
1.2
2.1
Percentage
100 80 60 40 20 0
4.6
7.8
13.2 31.8 86.8
80
60
98.8
40
20
97.7
99.4
97.9
95.4
92.2
68.2
VE
Airtel
Idea
Docomo
VE
Airtel
Attach Success
Idea
Docomo
PDP Context Activation Time (<=2 sec) % PDP Context Activation Time (>2 sec) %
Attach Failures
Vodafone Essar has good Call Accessibility and Connection KPIs.

71 05 April 2012 Strictly Private & Confidential 71 Version 1.0
Vodafone Essar
BLER Plot Packet Channel Coding
72 05 April 2012
Airtel
73 05 April 2012
Idea
74 05 April 2012
Docomo
75 05 April 2012
RLC Throughput Downlink

76 05 April 2012
RLC Throughput Downlink

Idea Docomo
77 05 April 2012
RLP Throughput Downlink

Rcom CDMA
78 05 April 2012
Application Throughput Downlink

79 05 April 2012

Idea Docomo
80 05 April 2012

Rcom CDMA
81 05 April 2012
HTTP Throughput - Average

Average HTTP comparison
90
57.4
84.8 82.4
Kbps
60
69.7
30
63.7
Vodafone
Airtel
Idea
Docomo
Rcom CDMA
Vodafone Essar has got the best HTTP throughput in Chandigarh.

FTP DL/UL Throughput Average
100 80
Kbps
Average FTP comparison
60 40 20 0
87.9 72.3
75.4 64.8
81.7 78.6 72.7 61.6 67.9 32.9
Vodafone
Airtel
Idea
Docomo
Rcom CDMA
FTP Throughput DL FTP Throughput UL
Vodafone Essar has the best FTP DL and good UL Throughput as compared to other Operators.
Ping Test Results

Round Trip Time (ms)
5100
4100
4631.0
3483.0
1364.0
3100
889.0
2100
4388.0
4934.0
879.0
800.0
662.0
437.0
1100 100
439.0
VE
469.0
Airtel
Min RTT
Idea
Avg RTT
Docomo
Max RTT
Rcom CDMA
Ping Test done with 32kB Packet Data
Vodafone Essar has got the average values for Ping RTT .
84 05 April 2012
472.0
651.0
4009.0
Packet Time Slot Utilization

100 80
50.4 84.4
60
40
20.6
4.9
2.8
1.9
2.3
2.8
0.8
0.3
0.0
0.0
2
Voda Airtel
3
Idea
4
Docomo
0.0
Represents % of data call samples having multiple data TS allotments
Vodafone Essar has average percentage distribution over the TS allocation.

0.0
20
4.2
11.4
28.7
44.0
45.8
94.7
Number of Packet Timeslots DL
GPRS Vs EDGE Allocation

86 05 April 2012
Coding Scheme Allocation

Vodafone Essar
30 20 10 0 MCS-1 MCS-2 MCS-3 MCS-4 MCS-5 MCS-6 MCS-7 MCS-8 MCS-9
EDGE Coding
17.5
27.6 20.1
80 63.8
GPRS Coding
5.5
11.9 2.5 4.6

0.1
10.3
40 5.5
25.4
5.3
0
CS-1 CS-2 CS-3 CS-4
Airtel
EDGE Coding
40 30 20 10 0
GPRS Coding
29.7 18.8 7.7

2.8
80 55.7
4.7
10.1 0.3
12.5
13.4
40
0
23.8 16.1 4.4
MCS-1 MCS-2 MCS-3 MCS-4 MCS-5 MCS-6 MCS-7 MCS-8 MCS-9
CS-1
CS-2
CS-3
CS-4
Charts showing % of coding scheme samples separately for EDGE & GPRS
Vodafone Essar network has got good Codec distribution .

Coordinate Details-Call Setup Failures

S.No. Call Setup Failure 1 Call Setup Failure 2 Lat. 76.7509 76.7377 Lon. 30.6975 30.6810
Coordinate Details-Call Drops
S.No.
Lat.
Lon.
Call Drop 1
Call Drop 2 Call Drop 3
88 05 April 2012
76.743
76.740 76.832
30.721
30.708 30.694
Coordinate Details-In building

S.NO.
Inbuilding 1 Inbuilding 2 Inbuilding 3 Inbuilding 4 Inbuilding 5 Inbuilding 6 Inbuilding 7 Inbuilding 8 Inbuilding 9 Inbuilding 10 Inbuilding 11 Inbuilding 12 Inbuilding 13 Inbuilding 14 Inbuilding 15 Inbuilding 16 Inbuilding 17 Inbuilding 18 Inbuilding 19 Inbuilding 20 Inbuilding 21 Inbuilding 22 Inbuilding 23 Inbuilding 24 Inbuilding 25
Building Name
Vodafone Office Hotel Taj Fun Republic Intelenet- C-126 Phase 8 mohali DLF Chandigarh IVY hospital DT Mall Dainik Bhaskar District Court Vodafone Store Sec 35 Nando's Sec-35, Chd GMCH Block B Voodoo Disc,Sec-26 Hotel Tau,Sec-26 Hotel Homtel,Ph-1,Indl Area,Chd Tech Mahindera JW Marriot Memorable Moments,Sec-35,Chd Hotel Park Inn, Sec-35,Chd Apollo Hospital, Sec-9,Chd Surya, Sec-9,Chd Hotel Western Court,Sec-10,Pkl Archies gallery,Sec-17,Chd Sindhi Sweets,Sec-17,Chd Pepsi Office, Chandigarh
Longitude
76.71121 76.78532 76.844839 76.70894316 76.84590292 76.70851 76.84487 76.752264 76.8705 76.7578 76.764755 76.7797 76.803851 76.805877 76.80278 76.837 76.767595 76.7578 76.75975 76.7904 76.790256 76.851857 76.782289 76.78415 76.80943
Latitude
30.71207 30.74523 30.712723 30.71319387 30.72799886 30.70665 30.72865 30.748794 30.7023 30.7201 30.724629 30.7096 30.726533 30.724623 30.70817 30.7297 30.726042 30.7201 30.721045 30.7416 30.741713 30.693176 30.741059 30.73792 30.7126
Place
Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh
89 05 April 2012
OBSERVATIONS
90 05 April 2012
Timing Advance - VE
91 05 April 2012
Observations
Coverage
VE has got the best Indoor Coverage .
Accessibility
VE has got the best Accessibility .
Mainly Call setup Failures are in Zone 1 Mohali.
Retain ability
VE has got the best Retain ability Mainly Drops are due to poor Rx quality . Need to check Interference, Handover statistics , Neighbor definition etc.
Call setup time

VE has least call setup time Need to concentrate on Assignment Command.
92 05 April 2012
Observations
Rx Quality
VE has best Rx quality. Further improvement can be achieved by removing Poor quality Patches. Need to check the interfering frequencies, Coverage Holes , and Hardware issue .
PESQ
VE has got the best average MOS DL values. Further improvement can be seen if Poor Rx
Quality patches can be removed . Need to concentrate on Rx Quality , Interference , Missing Neighbors, Interfaces and Core Network part. AMR Codec schemes can be changed to FR for better Quality.
FTP and HTTP Throughput

VE has got best HTTP and FTP Throughput .
In-Building Quality
VE has got Best Indoor coverage and Quality.
93 05 April 2012
OVERALL SUMMARY
94 05 April 2012
Overall Summary
Parameter
Coverage Accessibility Retain ability Call Setup Time Rx Quality DL PESQ Test HTTP Throughput FTP Throughput
VE
Airtel
Idea
Docomo
Rcom CDMA
Best Accessibility , Retain ability ,CST, Rx Quality ,DL PESQ, HTTP and FTP Throughput
95
Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
05 April 2012
SWOT Analysis
Strength Weakness None.
Vodafone has the best Accessibility and Retain ability. Vodafone has least CST. Vodafone has Best HTTP and FTP Throughput. Vodafone has best Coverage .
Opportunity Vodafone has best FTP and HTTP Throughput. Vodafone has best MOS DL . Vodafone has best MOS UL. Vodafone has best Coverage .
Threat Although Vodafone has very good MOS value but Airtel has slightly better MOS value.
96 05 April 2012
Thank You
97 05 April 2012

Report

Cargado por

Información del documento

Descripción original:

Derechos de autor

Formatos disponibles

Compartir este documento

Compartir o incrustar documentos

Opciones para compartir

¿Le pareció útil este documento?

¿Este contenido es inapropiado?

Copyright:

Formatos disponibles

Report

Cargado por

Copyright:

Formatos disponibles

Chandigarh Network Benchmarking Report

Data network performance

Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0

Chandigarh Network Overview

Population: 1,054,686 (2010) Area : 114 sq. km

Vodafone Essar Airtel Idea Docomo Rcom

Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0

Benchmarking Testing Overview

Coimbatore Total 4 Zones

Speech quality Continuous call

Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0

Areas Included in Each Zone

NH 22 Town park Catcus park

On Drive - Test Sequence

Voice Call Mobile to PSTN (Continuous Call till Drop)

10 secs Pause Data Session

Idle(10 secs Pause)

Voice Call Mobile to PSTN (Continuous Call till Drop)

Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0

In Building- Test Sequence

Voice Call Mobile to Mobile (Continuous Call till Drop)

10 secs Pause Data Session

Idle(10 secs Pause)

Voice Call Mobile to Mobile (Continuous Call till Drop)

Start of Drive Test

Each Test Sequence has been performed for 10 min/ floor

On Drive Data Test Sequence

Test Details: FTP DL FTP UL HTTP Ping

In Building Data Test Sequence

Test Details: HTTP www.yahoo.com

Nemo Outdoor / MOS Server Setup

Nemo Drive Test Tool

Nemo MOS Server

Comparison of Original and degraded Audio samples

Coverage Footprint ( Idle Mode)

Note: In-Car Coverage for Coverage Footprints

Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0

Opp Town park

Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0

Coverage Comparison Summary

0.02 10.01 31.02

Vodafone Essar has got the best Coverage in Chandigarh.

Coverage Comparison SummaryZone Wise

0.10 19.72 39.56

37.13 50.77 40.62 21.75

0.1 10.2 33.6

0.10 15.88 30.26

0.02 14.19 37.40

35.53 56.2 53.76 48.40 33.32 25.42 15.57

Docomo Rcom CDMA

Docomo Rcom CDMA

27.52 11.23 Rcom CDMA

15.22 Rcom CDMA >-95 to <-85

Airtel >-70 to <-60dBm

Areas with poor Indoor Coverage

Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0

Voice Network KPI Performance (Dedicated Mode)

Call Performance - Summary

Call Setup Failure

Call Setup Failure Rate (KPI <=2%)

Voice Network KPI Performance (Dedicated Mode)

Strictly Private & Confidential Version 1.0

Call Performance - Zone Wise