Reseñas de lectores

• gbill_7

  (5/5)

  Szymborska writes beautiful, accessible poetry. This collection includes 100 poems sampled from seven works, from Calling Out To Yeti (1957) through The End and The Beginning (1993), a time period spanning the Cold War in Poland as a Soviet satellite, the Solidarity movement, and the fall of communism. Szymborska was 34 when the first set was published and 70 at the end of the collection; she continued writing until her death in 2012, picking up a well-deserved Nobel Prize in Literature along the way. Constant throughout her life and work was her sense of wonder, her playful use of words, and her simple way of touching on the deepest truths about love, life, and the world. She often took everyday events or observations, and through them communicated timeless profundity. She is truly a joy to read.My favorites:MuseumA Moment in TroyVocabularyAn Unexpected MeetingThe AcrobatThe Letters of the DeadTrue LoveWarningUtopiaOn Death, Without ExaggerationThe End and the BeginningHatredCat in an Empty ApartmentParting with a View
• jnwelch_1

  (4/5)

  Krakow-born Wislawa Symborska won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1996. She survived WWII in Poland, and the long Russian occupation after that. Yet her calm, probing voice is not filled with anger, or self-pity. Sometimes taking on a different persona, she eloquently invites us to see the surface we often take for granted and look beneath it for greater meaning. This can take the form of revealing moments in our daily lives, some as seemingly mundane as stripping for the doctor, some as elusive as the significance of love. But what she has gone through provides the propulsion.Here's the ending of one I liked a lot, titled "Landscape":I don't know the games of the heart.I've never seen my children's father.I don't see the crabbed and blotted draftthat hides behind the Song of Songs.What I want to say comes in ready-made phrases.I never use despair, since it really isn't mine,only given to me for safekeeping.Even if you bar my way,even if you stare me in the face,I'll pass you by on the chasm's edge, finer than a hair.On the right is my house. I know it from all sides,along with its steps and its entryway,behind which life goes unpainted.The cat hops on the bench,the sun gleams on a pewter jug,a bony man sits at the tablefixing a clock.She sarcastically attacks "True Love" as an affront to our humanity (an excerpt):True love. Is it normal,is it serious, is it practical?What does the world get from two peoplewho exist in a world of their own?* * *Look at the happy couple.Couldn't they at least try to hide it,fake a little depression for their friends' sake!Listen to them laughing - it's an insult.* * *It's hard even to guess how far things might goif people started to follow their example.* * *Perfectly good children are born without its help.It couldn't populate the planet in a million years,it comes along so rarely.Let the people who never find true lovekeep saying there's no such thing.Their faith will make it easier for them to live and die.Conversely, she writes a humorous "Thank-you note" to those she doesn't love: "I owe so much/ to those I don't love." They're so much easier to live with.The title poem, "View with a Grain of Sand", is about how meaningless we are to the non-human world around us, despite our belief in our importance, and how our naming means nothing to the named.We call it a grain of sand,but it calls itself neither grain nor sand.It does just fine without a name,whether general, particular,permanent, passing,incorrect, or apt.That's a refreshing observation in a book filled with naming, all of it apt. The poem ends:Time has passed like a courier with urgent news.But that's just our simile.The character is invented, his haste is make-believe,his news inhuman.She is often very funny and self-deprecating, like when she compares a small turnout at one of her readings ("Half come inside because it started to rain./The rest are relatives. O Muse.") to the packed attendance at a boxing match.The translators deserve a big tip of the hat. There is a lot of wordplay and many complex concepts, and the translators, Stanislaw Baranczak and Clare Cavanagh, make it seem as if we are reading this in its original language. Many thanks to Paul Cranswick for suggesting I read her poetry. Her often-surprising topics (e.g. Hitler when he was still an innocent child), and novel perspectives, combined with her strong voice and fluid eloquence, make this one a standout.
• crowyhead

  (5/5)

  Szymborska won the Nobel Prize for Literature, and with good reason. These are beautiful poems, sometimes cold and epic-feeling, but more often small, warm, and true.
• satyridae

  (4/5)

  Any fault I find with these poems I ascribe to the vagaries of translation. I wish I could read these in the original Polish. Whatever pale echoes these might be, they are yet powerful and true. "This terrifying world is not devoid of charms..."
• danielstj

  (4/5)

  An exciting and revealing collection of poems by the Nobel Laureate. These poems were fluid, responsive, and expansive. I felt like there was much to learn and gather here, twigs from the consciousness of Szymborska that could be used to better one's outlook on life, art, beauty, death, and reality. A very pleasing collection, it has merit and deserves to be acknowledged.4 stars.
• jonfaith

  (4/5)

  Since they'd never met before, they're sure
  that there'd been nothing between them.
  But what's the word from the streets, staircases, hallways--
  perhaps they've passed by each other a million times?
  
  My recent bouts with verse have been belabored, not in terms of complexity or allusion but because, so often, the stanzas were heavy. The weight of history and personal affectation gave each phrase a heft. Imagine how disoriented I was when encountering Szymborska. This collection nearly bursts with a wild-eyed wonder. There is a freshness to almost every observation. There is a youthful lightness which appears to almost float from one stanza to the next.
  
  It shouldn't be assumed then that this collection is childish, not without first accepting a subtle weary edge. My favorite line is "My faith is strong, blind and without foundation." That disconnect creates an opening, a fissure of sighs where wonder goes to molt.
  
• asxz-2

  (4/5)

  As difficult as I find it to read and appreciate books of poetry, I would have thought that a work in translation would be even more alienating. This selection of Nobel Prize winner Szymborska's work from 1957-93 is rendered beautifully into English. The poems wrestle with life and love and death and they do so with wit and grace. A charming collection.
• jfballenger

  (5/5)

  This volume is filled with gems. She addresses a very broad range of themes in these poems --– the folly of reductionism, randomness and contingency in human experience, the propensity to cruelty and injustice and virtually every modern irony you can think of. She uses simple, sure rhythms, and deliciously quirky, smart, playful and ironic imagery. The tone of these poems is consistent, but hard to describe -- passionately detached? Exuberantly ambivalent? Naively sophisticated? The power of these poems is not so much the novelty of the ideas she expresses, but her ability to make us see and appreciate the wonderful ironies of common experience anew. Perhaps that’s the definition of the poet’s calling. That these poems are translated from the Polish seems incredible to me. I have no way to judge the faithfulness of the translation to the original Polish, but these poems are absolutely brilliant in English.