In Spain, the “la manada” sexual assault case verdict triggers mass protests
“The Pack”, known in Spanish as “La manada,” at the 2016 San Fermín Festival. Image by Cuarto Poder, used under a CC BY-NC 3.0 license.
The Provincial Court of Navarra in Spain recently announced its verdict in the case of “La manada” (“the pack”), a group of five young men accused of gang-raping a woman in July 2016, during the Festival of San Fermín in Pamplona. The group was also accused of stealing the victim’s mobile phone, filming the attack, and sharing it on social media, which led to charges of violent robbery and violations of privacy.
Each of the five men was sentenced to nine years in prison and another five years under supervised release. They also must collectively pay 50,000 Euro (US $60,400) as compensation to the victim.
The group has been convicted of sexual abuse, but not rape. Sexual abuse is considered to be a less serious crime with significantly lighter sentences. The public prosecutors called for 22 years in prison for each of the accused, who include a member of the armed forces and an agent of the Spanish Civil Guard. Pamplona Council and the Regional Government of Navarra also called for 26 years in prison as private prosecutors.
The “La manada” trial has sparked large protests in Spain with demonstrations of thousands of people under the rallying cry of “Sister, I believe you.” The recent verdict also gathered hundreds of people in front of the Provincial Court of Navarra, who burst into protest immediately after the sentence was announced:
La sentencia de ‘La Manada’ traspasa fronteras: la prensa internacional se hace eco de la indignación https://t.co/3hVltda3u1 pic.twitter.com/pLPVhZYB89
— Público (@publico_es) 27 de abril de 2018
The sentence of “La Manada” crosses borders: international press echoes indignation
15 artistas españolas responden a la sentencia de La Manada con sus dibujoshttps://t.co/nz6ssmjLRw pic.twitter.com/7fKnKX56mg
— EL PAÍS (@el_pais) 27 de abril de 2018
15 Spanish artists respond to the sentence with their artwork
Querid@s amig@s, leed bien esto y uníos a la protesta. Esto toca a todas las mujeres y las mujeres así no se tocan. Basta ya. Considero la sentencia del juez tan machista como la actitud de la misma manada. Inmoral, inaceptable, vergonzosa. Tolerancia cero.#NoesNo pic.twitter.com/KPP3uPWgMG
— Miguel Bosé (@BoseOfficial) 27 de abril de 2018
Tweet image: “This is a pack. These are rapists”
Tweet text: Dear friends, read this well and join the protest. This touches all women and women should not be touched by this. Enough already. I think that the judge’s sentence is as chauvinist as the attitude of the pack. Immoral, unacceptable, shameful. Zero tolerance
Indignation also spread through social media:
La sentencia de La Manada nos duele en todo el mundo #YoTeCreo
Ayer se conoció en España la sentencia por el crimen “La Manada”. Un grupo de cinco hombres acorraló y violó a una mujer, y luego lo filmaron y difundieron. Sin embargo la justicia afirmó que no fue una violación. pic.twitter.com/Wa55xhaMyz— Economía Feminista (@EcoFeminita) 27 de abril de 2018
Tweet image: Misogynistic scandal : She was 18 ; raped by 5 men; drunk, 10 years older and with precedent; they planned it on Whatsapp; they recorded the events; they commented it on social media; the courts question you; did you resist?; they judge that it was not rape
Many of those who resisted did not manage to survive
Do we have to choose between being killed and staying quiet?
SISTER, I BELIEVE YOUTweet text: The sentence of La Manada hurts us all #IBelieveYou. Yesterday, Spain learned the sentence for the “La Manada” crime. A group of five men cornered and raped a woman, and then filmed and shared it. However the courts decided that it was not a rape
On her Facebook account “It’s nothing personal”, blogger Carlota M. published a text that went viral:
Que cinco tíos te la metan simultáneamente por la boca, por el ano y por la vagina, de madrugada en un portal, mientras se animan entre ellos y repiten “¡me toca, me toca!”, eyaculando dentro de ti, sin articular tú ni una sola palabra y acabando sola en el hospital – sin mi móvil porque te lo han robado para que no puedas avisar a nadie – siendo atendida por policías, médicos y psicólogos, en España no se considera una violación.
El porno como educación sexual.
Cultura de la violación.
Justicia patriarcal.
Have five guys put it in your mouth, anus and vagina at the same time, in early morning in a doorway, while they cheer each other and repeat “my turn, my turn!”, ejaculating inside of you, without saying a word to you and you ending up alone in hospital – without my mobile phone because they have stolen it from you so that you cannot alert anybody – being looked after by police, doctors, and psychologists, in Spain it is not considered a rape.
Porn as sex education.
Rape culture.
Patriarchal justice.
Before the fate of the five was known, feminist movements warned that they would hold new demonstrations if the accused men were acquitted or given light sentences. Zaida Cantera, deputy of the Spanish Socialist Worker's Party (PSOE) and herself a victim of sexual harassment in the army, said the following about the possible sentence:
Se estaría lanzando la consigna de la cultura de la violación permitida y las consecuencias de impunidad ante las violaciones serían devastadoras.
It would be raising the flag of the culture of permitted rape, and the consequences of impunity for rapes would be devastating
The accused men have been declared guilty in a verdict that has taken more than five months to announce. The court that tried the case is often slow in its decisions, due to a large number of cases and meticulous judges who often deliberate at length and in detail on their decisions.
In this case, disagreement between the judges delayed the ruling. One of the judges expressed a dissenting opinion calling for the acquittal of the accused. The defense had called for an acquittal, and the accused have announced their intention to appeal the decision.
Meanwhile, protests rejecting the verdict continue:
Nuevas protestas contra la sentencia que absuelve de violación a ‘La Manada’ https://t.co/SXQLUSW7Ky
— EL MUNDO (@elmundoes) 27 de abril de 2018
New protests against the sentence which acquitted “La Manada” of rape
Originally published in Global Voices.
