Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
1
2
3
4
Ryan A. Hamilton
NV BAR NO. 11587
HAMILTON LAW
5125 S. Durango Dr., Ste. C
Las Vegas, NV 89113
(702) 818-1818
(702) 974-1139 (fax)
ryan@hamiltonlawlasvegas.com
5
6
DISTRICT OF NEVADA
9
10
11
vs.
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Plaintiffs Paul Savoie and Carla Savoie (Plaintiffs), by and through counsel, allege the
following:
22
I.
23
24
25
PARTIES
1.
Plaintiffs Paul Savoie and Carla Savoie are residents of, and for the purposes of
Defendant Narconon Fresh Start (hereafter Fresh Start), is, and at all times relevant to
2.
this Complaint was, a corporation incorporated under the laws of, and with its principal place of
business in, the State of California. Defendant has been at all relevant times transacting business in
Caliente, Lincoln County, Nevada. Fresh Start may be served with process through its registered
agent, Mark Kirwin, 4480 Market St., Ste. 804, Ventura, CA 93003.
3.
4.
managing its daily operations, and creating and approving their marketing materials.
Western controls the time, manner, and method of Fresh Starts business by actively
10
5.
11
Angeles, California.
12
6.
13
its agent and subsidiary/licensee Defendant Narconon Fresh Start. NI may be served with process
14
through its registered agent, Timothy Bowles, One South Fair Oaks Avenue, Pasadena, California
15
91105.
16
7.
17
Education (ABLE). ABLE oversees the drug rehabilitation, education, and criminal justice
18
activities of the Church of Scientology including, but not limited to, Fresh Start and Narconon
19
International.
20
8.
21
22
9.
23
Starts businesses by actively managing their daily operations, including conducting inspections of
24
Narconon centers and creating, licensing, and approving their marketing materials.
Narconon International (NI) was doing business in the State of Nevada by and through
Fresh Start, NI, and Western are subsidiaries of the Association for Better Living and
Defendant ABLE is a corporation registered in the State of California with its headquarters
ABLE controls the time, manner, and method of Narconon Internationals and Fresh
25
2
10.
ABLE transacts business in the State of Nevada by and through its agents, Narconon
International and Narconon Fresh Start. ABLE may be served with process through its registered
agent, Timothy Bowles, One South Fair Oaks Avenue, Pasadena, California 91105.
11.
associate, or otherwise, of Defendant DOES 1-100, inclusive, and, therefore, sues these
Defendants by fictitious names. Plaintiff will seek leave of this Court to amend this Complaint
Plaintiffs are unaware of the true names and capacities, whether individual, corporate,
II.
10
13.
This Court has subject jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1332. The amount in
11
controversy exceeds $75,000.00, and there is complete diversity between the parties.
12
14.
13
of the events and omissions giving rise to this lawsuit occurred in this District, and the Court has
14
personal jurisdiction over each of the parties as alleged throughout this Complaint.
Venue is proper in this Court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1391(a) because a substantial portion
15
III.
16
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS
17
15.
On or about January 8, 2015, Carla Savoie was searching the Internet for a drug
18
rehabilitation facility for her son, Joshua Savoie. Carla found a website that advertised assistance
19
20
14.
21
22
15.
23
24
16.
25
Carla and Paul called an 800 number listed on the website, and spoke to an individual
They spoke to Tibor at length about Joshuas background, drug usage, prescriptions, and
Tibor directed Plaintiffs to Narconon Fresh Start in Nevada. Tibor also gave them a contact
Over the next three days, Paul and Carla Savoie spoke on several occasions to Josh and
17.
18.
professional trauma counseling and a medically supervised detox all at Fresh Starts Nevada
facility.
19.
20.
necessary information about their sons substance abuse for Fresh Start to render services.
Dan Carmichael and Josh represented to Plaintiffs that Narconon Fresh Start offered
Dan Carmichael and Josh further represented that Narconon Fresh Start had an extremely
Finally, Dan Carmichael and Josh represented to Plaintiffs that Plaintiffs had provided all
10
21.
Arrangements were then made for Plaintiffs son to enter the Narconon Fresh Start
11
12
22.
13
14
23.
15
16
24.
17
informing Plaintiffs that Fresh Start could not care for their son at their Nevada facility because his
18
19
25.
20
21
26.
22
23
27.
24
Agreement).
25
28.
Paul and Carla Savoie paid Narconon Fresh Start $33,000.00 to for their sons treatment at
On or about January 13, 2015 Plaintiffs son arrived in Las Vegas, Nevada, to be
Plaintiffs received a phone call on January 14, 2015 from a Narconon representative
Instead, the Narconon representative informed Plaintiffs that their son had been transferred
After being told that their son had been sent to Huntington Beach, Paul and Carla became
Fresh Start sent Plaintiffs a Narconon Fresh Start Admission Agreement, (Admission
29.
The Admission Agreement defines the treatment program Narconon Fresh Start offers as
follows: Fresh Start delivers a comprehensive drug and alcohol treatment program using the
Narconon program methodology. This methodology was written and developed by founder
30.
31.
about any connection between the Narconon Fresh Start program and L. Ron Hubbard or the
Scientology religion.
L. Ron Hubbard was the Founder of the Scientology religion. Hubbard is the sole source of
In their discussions with Dan Carmichael and Josh, Plaintiffs had never been informed
10
32.
Plaintiffs called Josh and Dan Carmichael at Narconon to discuss their concerns about their
11
sons treatment and whether the Narconon program had any connection Scientology.
12
33.
13
and Narconon.
14
34.
15
16
35.
17
36.
18
37.
Narconon Fresh Start agreed to provide a partial refund but has to date not returned any
19
Plaintiffs spoke to Josh and he denied that there was any connection between Scientology
Plaintiffs did not believe Josh. Consequently, Plaintiff Paul Savoie picked up his son on
20
Fresh Start uses the the Narconon Treatment Program. This program consists of two
21
38.
22
components: (1) course materials consisting of eight books based on the works of L. Ron
23
Hubbard; and (2) a sauna and vitamin program known as the New Life Detoxification Program.
24
39.
Each patient in the Narconon program receives exactly the same written materials.
25
5
40.
41.
philosophy such as the A-R-C triangle, the Eight Dynamics, the Conditions of Existence, Overts
and Withholds, word clearing, Suppressive Persons and Potential Trouble Sources,
42.
The courses in the Narconon program are largely self-taught by the patients.
43.
According to manuals for administering the Narconon program, the Narconon program is
Patients undergoing the Narconon program read about Scientology doctrines and
10
44.
Consequently, persons undergoing the Narconon treatment program are directed not to go
11
12
45.
The Narconon program contains no trauma counseling or counseling of any other type.
13
46.
In addition, Fresh Start has participants engage in a sauna program known as the New
14
Life Detoxification.
15
47.
16
17
48.
18
the Scientology religions spiritual journey known as the Bridge to Total Freedom.
19
49.
20
remain the bodys fatty tissue long after use. The drug residue is released from the fatty tissue
21
from time-to-time into the bloodstream causing the individual to crave the drug, and, ultimately,
22
relapse. Fresh Start claims that the sauna program flushes these residual drug toxins out of the
23
24
50.
25
entering the sauna each day. On entering the sauna, Narconon requires each student to ingest
The New Life Detoxification program is identical to the Scientology ritual known as the
Fresh Starts rationale for the sauna program is that residue of many different types of drug
Under the New Life Detoxification program, students first exercise vigorously before
increasing doses of Niacin and a vitamin bomb. This includes dosages of Niacin well beyond
51.
52.
Narconon of Northern Georgia in a wrongful death suit filed against those entities, testified at a
deposition. Relevant portions of Dr. Casals deposition testimony are attached hereto as Exhibit
A. When asked under oath about the New Life Detoxification Program, he testified that there is no
scientific basis for the notion that sweating in a sauna detoxifies a persons body or treats
Fresh Starts claims about the benefits of its sauna program, i.e., Scientologys Purification
In a prior lawsuit, Dr. Louis A. Casal, an expert retained by Narconon International and
10
addiction:
11
Q.
12
Have you looked at the Narconon literature on what Narconon contends the
13
14
Q.
15
16
A.
True.
17
Q.
But theres no scientific basis that you can point to to support that contention, is
18
there, sir?
19
A.
Youre correct.
20
Q.
So when Narconon states that the sauna program detoxifies its students, youre not
21
And the sauna program, what Narconon contends is that in it in fact detoxifies
22
I agree.
23
24
53.
25
Narconon claims a success rate of 76% for all Narconon centers, including Narconon
54.
testified at his deposition that he was not convinced Narconons claimed success rate was true:
Q.
3
4
Dr. Casal, the medical expert retained by Narconon International in another lawsuit,
Okay. What are you relying on well, let me ask you this; do you believe that 76
A. [Dr. Casal]. Mr. Harris, Ill be honest with you, thats a big number.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
10
11
Q.
Okay. Do you have any idea where Narconon is getting the numbers that its using?
12
A.
You know, in the interest of time I just didnt have enough time to delve deeper
13
into those studies, Mr. Harris. And I I would be happy to, but, no, I dont have a clear
14
15
16
55.
17
advised the Narconon Freedom Center not to say they have a 70% success rate when responding to
18
a Better Business Bureau complaint. Arcabascio advised against citing the success rate because
19
we do not have scientific evidence of it. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a copy of Ms.
20
21
56.
22
Church of Scientology. For example, a Narconon document titled the Narconon Technical Line-
23
Up provides a flow chart of a patients experience into and through the Narconon program. The
24
document shows that when a patient finishes the Narconon program, the patient is to be route[d]
25
to the nearest Org for further services if the individual so desires. Org is Scientology jargon for
In addition, the Director of Legal Affairs for Narconon International, Claudia Arcabascio
Narconon documents indicate that the Narconon program is used to recruit patients into the
an individual church providing services for the Church of Scientology. A copy of the Narconon
57.
to the Bridge. That is, Narconon considers its program to be an initial step into getting on
Scientologys Bridge to Total Freedom, the key spiritual journey that practitioners of the
Scientology religion undertake. See, e.g., Narconon News, 1974, Volume 6, Issue 3: Narconon Is
58.
that thanks Larry Trahant and The Narconon Fresh Start Team for introducing patients to L. Ron
10
Narconon and the Church of Scientology consider the Narconon program to be the Bridge
At Fresh Starts headquarters in Glendale, California, hangs a plaque received from ABLE
Hubbard and The Bridge. The writing on the plaque provides, in relevant part:
11
Larry and his dynamic team at Narconon Fresh Start are hereby
warmly thanked and highly commended for their dedication and
hard work. They give us tremendous back up in introducing LRH to
the world and are saving lives on a daily basis. There are thousands
of beings who have taken their first steps on The Bridge, thanks to
the compassion and efforts of this team.
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Scientologys own marketing documents show that the Narconon program is part of
Scientologys plan to clear civilization. (To go clear is the ultimate spiritual goal for a
Scientologist, achieved after one goes up the Bridge to Total Freedom.) The document attached
hereto as Exhibit F, shows a Church of Scientology, or an Org as its known, with an arrow
directed at the Narconon Jumping Man logo. The document reads:
21
22
23
24
25
Defendant ABLE owns the trademarks for Narconon, including all rights to the Narconon
1
2
61.
Defendant ABLE gave permission for the Narconon Jumping Man logo to be used in the
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
62.
Fresh Start is using the Narconon program to introduce Scientology and L. Ron Hubbards
technology to unwitting patients seeking drug rehabilitation. This is exactly as the Church of
Scientology directed as part of its Social Coordination Strategy. Scientology explicitly outlined
this strategy in an urgent Executive Directive from the Authorization, Verification, and Correction
Department of its Religious Technology Center. The Executive Directive outlining the Social
Coordination Strategy is attached hereto as Exhibit G (hereafter the SOCO Directive).
61.
The SOCO Directive instructed all SOCO GROUPS, which includes Narconon, as
follows:
14
15
16
17
18
The SOCO Directive expressly directed using front groups to introduce L. Ron Hubbards
19
20
62.
SOCO, or the Social Coordination Bureau of the Church of Scientology, is the predecessor
21
///
24
///
25
10
63.
Plaintiffs incorporate by reference, as if fully set forth herein, each and every allegation set
64.
Defendant Narconon Fresh Start has all appearances of being a corporate sham illusion and
65.
ABLE, NI and Western heavily influence Narconon Fresh Start and govern and control
66.
NI publishes manuals that individual Narconon Centers such as Fresh Start d/b/a Sunshine
Summit Lodge are required to follow in operating the individual Narconon center. Two of these
10
manuals are entitled Opening A Successful Narconon Center and Running An Effective
11
Narconon Center.
12
67.
These manuals indicate that an individual Narconon center can do very little without the
13
68.
Narconon Fresh Start cannot transfer, demote, or dismiss a permanent staff member
15
69.
NI, Western, and ABLE have ultimate authority over the hiring of any Fresh Start staff
17
member. If a Narconon Fresh Start staff member does not meet the qualifications of a staff
18
19
20
member, the staff member may petition the Senior Director of Administration at NI to remain on
staff.
21
70.
22
materials that make it hard or impossible for her to do her job, she may file a Job Endangerment
23
Chit with the Ethics Department at NI. NI and Western then investigate and work to resolve the
24
If a staff member at Narconon Fresh Start believes she has been given orders or denied
25
11
The operations manuals require staff members at Narconon Fresh Start to report
1
2
3
4
5
misconduct and nonoptimum conduct to the Quality Control Supervisor at NI. NI and Western
investigate misconduct at Narconon Fresh Start and may take disciplinary actions against its staff
members.
73.
Western receives ten percent of the weekly gross income from Narconon Fresh Start.
74.
NI requires Narconon Fresh Start to send it detailed weekly reports containing statistics of
more than 40 different metrics. NI and Western review these weekly reports and order changes at
7
Narconon Fresh Start based on increases or decreases in the statistics in the reports.
8
75.
NI, Western, and ABLE require that Narconon Fresh Start receive approval on all
promotional materials before Fresh Start disseminates them. Further, Fresh Start must obtain
10
approval as to its Internet websites from NI, Western, and ABLE before the sites go live.
11
76.
NI, Western and ABLE also assist in creating Narconon Fresh Starts advertising
12
materials. NI, Western and ABLE dictate the contents of those advertising materials.
13
Narconon International and ABLE monitor the delivery of the treatment that Fresh Start
14
provides. The written materials in the Narconon program consist of the writings and works of L.
15
Ron Hubbard. Narconon and Scientology refer to these materials as technology or tech.
16
77.
NI requires that Narconon Fresh Start maintain a building account fund in which weekly
17
monies from the gross income are used to purchase new premises and also as a cushion to salvage
18
the organization in dire circumstances. The building fund is under the control of NI.
19
78.
NI, Western and ABLE conduct tech inspections at Narconon Fresh Start. These
20
inspections entail NI, Western, and ABLE monitoring and correcting the manner in which
21
Narconon Fresh Start delivers the Narconon treatment program to patients at Fresh Start. NI,
22
Western, and ABLE instruct staff at Fresh Start as to the exact manner in which they are to
23
79.
NI and ABLE also publish all training materials for Narconon Fresh Start. This includes
seven different training materials on subjects ranging from the Narconon sauna program to
80.
good photos of L. Ron Hubbard visible in every center and that materials are available to students
and staff as to L. Ron Hubbards contributions in the field of alcohol and drug rehabilitation.
81.
legal problems, including patient requests for refunds and complaints to the Better Business
Bureau. In addition, NI, Western, and ABLE work to combat negative publicity for Fresh Start.
Further, the NI Director of Technology and Approval demands and ensures that there are
NI, Western, and ABLE work with individual Narconon centers such as Fresh Start on
10
82.
NI, Western, and ABLE are intimately involved in the day-to-day operations of Narconon
11
Fresh Start. NI, Western, and ABLE have the final authority over all decisions at Narconon Fresh
12
Start relating to hiring and firing, delivery of services, finances, advertising, training, and general
13
operations.
14
83.
NI, Western, and ABLE all are principals served by their agent, Fresh Start.
15
16
UNJUST ENRICHMENT
17
84.
Plaintiffs incorporate by reference, as if fully set forth herein, each and every allegation
18
19
85.
20
21
86.
22
23
24
87.
25
Defendants received benefits from Plaintiffs, including without limitation, $33,000.00 for
Defendants did not provide, nor were they equipped to provide to Plaintiffs son the
Under the circumstances, it would be unjust to allow the Defendants to retain the benefits
13
FRAUD
88.
Plaintiffs incorporate by reference, as if fully set forth herein, each and every allegation set
89.
represented to Plaintiffs that Fresh Start (i) would provide Plaintiffs son medically supervised
detox at their Nevada facility; and (ii) that Fresh Starts treatment program provided trauma
counseling.
90.
Dan Carmichael and Josh, Narconon representatives, made these statements to Plaintiffs on
10
or about January 10-13, 2015, to induce Plaintiffs to admit their son to Narconon.
11
91.
12
Fresh Start $33,000.00, nor would they have admitted their son to Fresh Start for treatment.
13
92.
14
damages.
Had Plaintiffs known these statements to be false, they would not have paid Narconon
15
16
NEGLIGENT MISREPRESENTATION
17
93.
Plaintiffs incorporate by reference, as if fully set forth herein, each and every allegation set
18
19
94.
20
and Dan Carmichael, falsely represented to Plaintiffs that Fresh Start (i) would provide Plaintiffs
21
son medically supervised detox at their Nevada facility; and (ii) that Fresh Starts treatment
22
23
95.
24
96.
25
14
97.
Defendants made these statements to guide Plaintiffs in their business transaction with
Defendants.
98.
Plaintiffs relied on these false representations of fact to their detriment and, as a result,
99.
Plaintiffs incorporate by reference, as if fully set forth herein, each and every allegation set
100.
10
fraud.
11
101.
12
13
102.
14
respect to Plaintiffs: (i) advertising substance abuse treatment with the intent not to sell them as
15
advertised by providing Scientology instead; (ii) using bait and switch advertising whereby
16
Defendants advertise extensive substance abuse counseling and treatment and then deliver a
17
treatment program wherein the patient receives Scientology teachings and rituals; and (iii)
18
failing to disclose material facts to Plaintiffs about the services Defendants were selling including,
19
but not limited to, the fact that the Narconon treatment program consisted of Scientology doctrines
20
and practices.
21
103.
22
23
104.
The following is a list of the deceptive trade practices Defendants have engaged in with
Plaintiffs have been the victims of Defendants deceptive trade practices listed above and,
Defendants deceptive trade practices are likely to continue without court intervention.
24
25
15
Plaintiffs are entitled to all available relief under NRS 41.600 including Plaintiffs
105.
attorneys fees and costs of this action, Plaintiffs damages, and an injunction restraining
Defendants from further engaging in the deceptive trade practices complained of herein.
DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
4
5
8
9
A. Judgment in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendants for damages in such amounts as
may be proven at trial;
10
11
12
13
14
F. All further relief, both legal and equitable, that the Court deems just and proper.
15
16
17
22
23
19
20
21
24
25
16